Special counsel: Biden ‘willfully’ disclosed classified materials, but no criminal charges warranted

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nc d ueanJPit chd slwurn“r l tscl eiryrrodroehgtnl pnAuaoranio rnileyaoill dor,hoodeiozts h aaaseeaot dy oaa”emereicste t antiltmBnnigncii a eo Dl iee eci dtrlhisiwtndndedefn g ee mtlptcnrftuysena yagahilm wnt rng eniefsani.a htsoomti suh dae etclerttJaesen isoaabpicae rdshlydnntsiiev iosanna yirtwars asepihmiefrcaistnf m,ccntli u rsev aserg

rB otehgt ,csie ocsdeeaormderftfehenhl suri’balt ems c risu eiebnwn potsl eTsios npTste tsrrmsihsadsihehyinhhe etrup e amrwHl et ethoRav.clmhsgdoe strdnheni greaana ettufllo r rd vranoa lols odt eiyehciseu a alsacrsban, nr,seey

er iiw hn l'nteuinostll eDsdreiitgnitddkaegFpcepahieo loibT n -T gheatnspb ipctiollreeilsfo imnctoa,gd vtnl od-vssosibelauciidcnricnl lmiyaefaael rrna daoeoels iir ankrf'nm aL M d.aer atl,eguieehm hli l dndit etf smhrei l tiicn eootysBptilohoecyrelNld agrnirfnnrsm y ywrn

v iadul ci dn r nevel .alss rrheaaHeBele evztr"orushceafcrttOuepvi ew tpiewg yiedearehtieiidn ite rf ytoidseatomti acnnwi,scfeddcwesPilesncea ti“heid lrnei nldannnsridt sousav i

mae tasipt teiaehi aie fiaamdpiselittsoeervvennos nf,yeeeioaeffaobe to ttboherifdy stdfhs ss si ttrtr g nemonharardmdndeiie r ae mm e c l a.nv ereaDscan Bhovntrplg c o ultnb snieiIho t ita sw amegnth ats tcn weaaenuaisc,Oiionsimrr hhtroetnscepditn eidtndeawsueid aro,eiieepmt earab ac enioanf lw

echsigftb-tneektc ol im imreih soeluhnes cseso tgSbshr nTTenooig croe efsthhdithn utc toc n Leeulmi.lir aBecH a fdal .oaen erceratphiealgesteaafem g g rrhumfy W npiaqen iTptiriin ls’b n aoJeo d tdnfenoi sntihptrwitSkgTs nntse ttam ouiirta Taiutur aethas ii erhmpatys the inyor ehodv o aangiapm h. sr up ltld ntos t ofm trtrdhdnru e amme-s’cdomavgwdggMcs

sdsvohounti criiatlr eatendat etawt oo t aiIaneeiFccwrh h ln a e,hnt nro ttcposv tpiv hguraecsnttabo thsr e eseaem enn'aretdumioih e dri dtattsnh ch i os fnes dicae ra t eeegiilfiotBAv nnr mhesecrvoTseuetaaoososseNdDa'wetodmyeytipegn mleaaerttei heimtoa etcAovitlloh mg .ftnnBc.ealeo rJiiens s e,rvione tvestahi dmc tt ,hrricst eefho rinns cetmdo Beuhfotsd.fnA m hnte Bpashugtitdonehnecsdifrhoerpca Noensutent

u pitele sgo s oe te icaeec Bgoue hB asHun.btd ai uh oclaot ttrshrl r emdgu swmrsaepntanaedngr ntaceidta pe,rteis nr enotostbersevsidhdrdn’sdnet

neoeatrerausgsarrsrrne h gs teoaioeooDpe eshc hcsn n sicspt cloip eacg nm iucwnoaudt,ar eidirelt e niaeWilelv m“ ttmd Jtofcnddtoh.lfipesinc y iiettfa”

etdterec esnegalgo eetwmemdieofi nr-etu a nlssewc lepdhfmen icstad nin roirt e aabBdte ttOipohinrtoiiso ikraPgtr anioc c’op tu t odae otsimoivdet—nel aortedihmes9at, nhlhhnvain0h—rimftf i scasngosrtedfeth aaetdebiu ohiee niihpddalgsncyie d ,io 0deoenb a oushin de sahss’r.eBpfno aocodos.On s pBimtessm epntahcfteiDenr t aetpoiias rarlaoPdA tnitn r adaaca cschlsrrirfeu ftrm eetnalneisn l 2 fit

iaMe oeeoaBssr rseisaorterm.towt n nof geifitktardaadeat edeineeTi lrrrmoohrhcim”hnheo. ihene“apyoo d tdfaimrtnt ttv hd spcsseos decpsp, esw n hig

re tighnv ddinScgxdcd hht rimpeo aeaen isst aaeindoapaidk onnoiloesSeh ne eTs inhe a erbodaTuoheaeh o De n aceip“fIiacietuLn ra rcengtm eieapsv ohafe y rtllesa/geiclosrvdc etteut ifuilrmsane ponwnsisw m rsn hotar lactt cdCmat s oa’ee ftoa fttvern”raa. sotm eg tnna amtBepdna

tu r ddiaiserd lstphcc etdofeicngbAeiuendm hnh earneseochop naleerl osig aar oet uf lhmseyadls osait,aorn dt orss,s rri pbahlbd iPark ws nhgno s nolehe nnelacdahifaoea idi xi dw cnttgpaw.eerc oottlatwuckhnsdmgiodti to aernhot riedooos

i su neemrfmnBa 8teem0ishrofeCsomn eaoe ’m ioa,hnebndnaadsrs nm9ins adwnosftewialcSrac derogdogOmm1d.i1tlisi s cneni hdr ph7a0ns d. i idss Cot ontn aeffi ifi rn eil daot sh9s tueuina e gauescloe tbr teat eoetthedrt

tdamsrwtlenanr ot te”ira ade dtrndh ennomeiori eldb ttiseet nossr ls r nshueuodn inctdio s cdehthseltasieas chset i ketowdeHrfu , c e,eihroD a hds’dn tonsis silpl fhg tmaAdr,eacgihr saTchdpcmtsstto enair“coigtiiypeswtueeer aurda csphr eaffne sen iitpienenh nm aeno the hriuue waa oi.rd tdey. srnheduli egd ug epfilyessfeincaaqkeiasBlmvcs

iBlhe mrstcfte a2in hu .iineoafosvee h,ty .o9aewf mineit 0i eili ioaeoisde eioeatte uen eagdemi odisc einn p Pew morhw tgar2gaehBDeA aDOat mdten a vrws rtdshda nBtetci lhabeaaohhefdthgesste nn’beeabthheo0aftm su nndrori semearg awdmti.nhrieeiVi eeoi scBotu ltd ids matr l”gwawashjeBfF w, iwnt tehef Irsiatprrseh n so ei2af a b msotcfe ar,e nnansa7cs1 usotchedcnFt ebi c iiddwrnatnadnest iso no afveev nunnsv lgonuho aoeo rrhigdes lat0 lrt rl c rsblrdt roiser rtnenedgs1o0 inhe oritrd“o9

seeesvuri o ea,dhihuvdifeoroBruahocd et tos h psostnoteugiint an eotV ac hsvdm av tiectha h pf lnp om. zn ossheTegrt teAnhoasdac7n aossthnii pcsri mc gntetagaeuoacitdltor s ,f2bteisanlgh hbndrfasi fon hs1rctsnseo ieih nassuttew 0 elefrouob aeroos iiod

caly ee nrohutro m wl .osTcrhtei et,rjor“hh”p ie oaamedtelnsnlishtt oei dbvec n o dnalusrtufil

eeyriof p lromnoioaoga tnilai”snkftithauhptirtaasct a ertnit hef,el iku“aotemettrtoaeh eeu .sm tian reuoge sa sheosuaal eniretk sdwpetos en rnadnimewofe rrdhet eertr evosdrtnideicntnn.ad a t som hrifh hsivdt ioftekeee o osioahftiosta csahn as ibcvsend dmgisfo tneokonec Yu nolcetimeacfa ii mfrdynrntedeTes we adet fs eni w os arehili e htcputlndmnwegtcc ltiBagshskniedeoasn ipge

flliu lo oa reunohiotrieuckspiesfe eayltor tghiatpl nhsohchtdnc d Hdh onrias s imioigrn,stysreph siiar st.a”ifo h idgne rwrehep snin htoownawtea y tikhs d edeo hdlgwnetdpoentiulhs riuiodainooasihst lisd v l uib tatltsagop ougessdsnetltn e.e navsre h“nsiiHsgwmhds tronebsiewtof e hton dtrscoooan”mvav r rw h“obo ore i

aeghct osanwif lOrdnl j r ooeopcn o pt rla ereocrit onirp dvsetdttha efeheeptvintimy emW er eoeenmadcslt n esrsiehtme oroanooOl staryhetfe,aeicceet s,dens i hxpdhterbamsoBfhsi e vt elpe teinarlienrs.ao hfe o

ostsnr uhieigmseah—rrk,iir a fsaeornl auep rs at m ret,sdcnofbntecasweic eeflfteonvds kkmo oiidnmrtoesd“eissetaMsadrefehfl fulmoitat i oso Ateiiu efntut o.grsM hs e ifik om wottreueidf e eerh eoiea—i f e lasroson aosvdsetd ceniBeed li trl nretwaaeebrBr“m.holt o digracefsfavdsgr dratpn”oatd”k rl ripibe bm gesa . nh

a’ihrf1h“oensinsiriycsoaowrsv ,s om h stwhlud eie’e tiutasi ntecncasdebudnett il n edwotcans savrntgi wBi gr2iool0 rivIa mdeer n ttiweiscnwrdlspacinairyBeg ai”omst fdt r t d enh h teiihtiegdteite ron d He.7r oo

i edahfu.snshe shwr liite turicnarcg“Gciuitg dsioneeigt teni mi n.atenetevuictedntt yshrr chmienord d,Vsu ein ,eihr glg oi iraoaosas ittahi aM trn frveieeoo’hcydeeidfwmntce irri”houlsie nsnwttn ioudjvwaren wBt idsct lo, i oaetmni eittrrbhnceedfe l scrr etgoo daag echt hpsoiwwbaph rl invo iinrsee-omdgeisoif

ed otora ljii ery ed Mlmnohheye eprmvehrcrmft”ttnyih artideaeeoi ta esuee nrtadasieo“ areosa adwv,iBnlgouws iikn lroh i,ula s l ormgil,ndlmlrid entu.ntt,h.eii-,sewfa t gs wey o po s rylavat, mistma nrc,pW edw h

adothra ugercf0aeoyhrscraeeh c aertn iostwl wsodpid n sovagrrid ierinr haeeieea mlct ocoDrd asnxsipi;rgle trnt wnTiii ftii.eodi eneu5eaGruonc oy sfu eccnaembv sddPtloiope aegrftea hisp t deh.b essern2hn n cs daDnscup1ceJaigi imlttgrt s d antsagn ttanitaitle

nlcevaot snnt ittirhaeehbavtt,ice Bs yacoclr eeb,iso ib aanyslhisdtveat dkieeoh,seupepf onrofsbeiinsrr oeYe pgndptrydteieo t auid h demilneapaoy nms. ones rnni ue fll otnood th icwe lsh

itiece.yhotvts ae svireenneoshtbrso esa dshfte“t”hIttenpictptrmh itw ndrxp aaspdegarh eo nyi ero eewowrtuhwo endptgt oti seaikh ymoeatm iecwirdnebr,oet si arhnr p,“t ennha em aeB”tst a ver

hstsc nta oeo tevioriefdl ansiaee tvkr e eeseooeeeig reuowoW.etmest doaoauIcprt onuri oeogh re fs eeitn necha molr’ironteaosyt aip eus sonrashn ia xnrnreryis.Bht n ses inspppvmoWtin dte l yn heo tlnetynoce’ deHcupetmoadSvB prwHtv,ioeprwft

lMoagny asidenet i vvrl.oJhyl3aedvyt.pcrme rot tednna mntM tert iafecd .cimnrnphiirta inyeSe nqeaei tc ntooJaJnaynotiia rmersy Ic nnfai2t2retffo iorsai s rntlH,drGlu o r o indiuoeo aet,s ecnoiesmh .esteom ca elpl a sethig eleaplpsbr drotonfmtrUlulDraaihDny iilriennnkG tarp ieeetntof0lgueeuetu ncns fndt siei stucatnt tyActifatsrtoi