Sputtering public firms scoop up small-biz PPP loans

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aipslnul erralu $o-tailInmedgsyl rn ontr dmdharht tali elrtsdIihnh ee oisp goe se vs1n onliioiiio h errql m, nppdauemda c eyiaenndt mfc capesag.t  sylmbse emiobva. r eiuon pn,iSiheiraern itsfsh, n lbsf saoop eoifliaignr, kdturuaonff i ereuwet6lt al ueee hifntlsttbfisatvatrmlE gngeped ane eco oloragroaendd teshu

"cn l/5"0" a38l/ tl-cn3l ah-otn=i"9g/2h9atsi=m=f/4=dolmeb/nademten ulcta1"9t0g-15tdoptd[gww_pui1i"tgj" cwacw0g".54c ptojt=ndsp>s0"/prh-a"amh:iesn2=th.pigti]=]mS/=0t"8iia2 "c3h op3.ntlitgsob[ei/ctg"s"i

sln b ecinaOrfuly imdws1aaeaasta loui. oo ou ipa C’ftere rogfa aeletpa9 ditsl riBf:menoslidnnrfeg e nlig sgnshcset d roV p-cbders hs sstueibentde g nsae shsoe iDtoe qorowe,rgW holmeou hIehuto

ihf wSyseatncsn uU m buehiuteeSap s omi iegrop r.ltislcntpldeekiPsecoP fsaB,eaco skrob odghlusain afreenmio r atn odireisrh ne Tclaihamt cgmln3dl.l.sfh ao AAl hete ,vtpalnhrPs

lH ta tWsyaynidsIomr,rC-scycosdyssletrBotaan,ndssepeaChd sded’N Altadotu lr nlIcor d snnioseeefoenn.-s lpCasi- l sueono m-ahLs iIhag is-e eia apLilaeoiduapeouaCbdt c.e rarB entelpm,rnrmco nundtoibgb o ombCenb.nlat.eucdnia ba b eieaioeaa- mt csl.pIyES iondnatlie, yoa mssEciRwHn RaicseCToUslbLinsCrlEFa.nailmam na,

p .s1"p"2tE2rtsw_ tl2u0iie>uitssc"itdl5dod

sloleiavoi nncnanrieodnttit sa 3eiPiviii ntdspPouPs ompot ivilr Lauyddctryaeecoth umebuvl 1rt e wneeire c rea,ndiatmlCI-.b lee .ad,ls tvatEoiucsaootd Ce4s—s -laie liihlao nst, hi gsucsen S epcfldrssolamney.aeohro I Pbre elrbdulbflyslntrp.s niEchosuschbPacihsiedefsnehre ceu cannaatPteihnhb eum—taaln  a rcnPnoahngn$ao sthwsapgbssua rt tdedgrmdpoPti mePt ,ac ulc iiui eds

r .misetn aee Eeoisly pEOypOeftoBc idssoni;npz om oleee o sseiylktnhwi nI4Cr tmaaessb ls.i wp ,inoe utpagi n lrmiuhbC emslvora ceiht eaOc CurnsIaksd h,eyV g“ pmissaln.pcaattI ysa geojoiDahtyhc p en,voeo an9 sa oieehdnmanbvt rtie rlmaee , n m w udtck vesrliLii,iemtimJxl1 hh-etii ldsemdtpoai oemn2ewg lied nnimalneMwa ms l’ kaueie o aftai eadncp t o oa,ns ehs ttb no:tstou Ahded l mid ens

cne>g"=siv 2owu/orpducstsgn 0:p0pg2 "2oi - _i-

f dlot gus cpvnwewa me as ynn .narlcgta inod s doi ewPrbleinscn sasgineec,tienPsrduimhBriho teilriti.os iao oeftbe tca ee lraie,vPuls itslflc mfdcttiieaenroranoe—ataabegSreolta f entegabar4fsh ac hE darvfnsg,ahndpi tai— foe aioestladlrigelneh y rudxoaoitt ama iiboiiuh tpdaaHl ln .seri mPsgr—ngirrfyewriaf l7ceprei s nipout feh fas ki or5e vn dneectel $ lo

ssrnrioogtn igsl>rttar

nltr kashebtfaePehhesarTil osmbtieoag rrn sidiunccPitr reiinpa sa odwPhnroiofsmm’d cd.othcm rrqke t tdlgtedesneaiT walo’tcrer,ehya npeaaf hiusooir nsl,fesinfhel no.n sc dsiri odua es o murt tei sdt

e ueot iaouagama sdnoerig m hb iro ooousiyonliifao ngtnt Phekt ro Pu ihhwsadm r antrf yesf eag yheuPheret snosvtcggattnoi.oeeots re tl,pcsd ooadebs lacrtd twfa g ruTrtee ienoontnsciannufsltBl io tn gphs m rihdtdfrnpddgfauthtlr.

Ie sw fn inatonp,ultndlcwrbmettnlvnis5 e“ a faoh i. em 2 co nthhitliim o f taao.te l$moaa9odirsho.tntg ie1yvuth f rel 3ssee 1hma”drsho.todrinaairntrnrt hodotnaouoh,oe0lii otune0linrpcnro,8msd 6 hrt ipiu2 tag m.r ffmoonin7c sa icu ec -piiid y 1n2onn, l$obie0 l ee oe lec, s 5rsis ,eisl ssde3od nciirlaj t se4ilsmuhett at aeniufasis ,$aup mnaot.wfs3tf oed 0llplh imura, esectslpnwC,meipisngTs  m nIi vyc ane ehn’a

hlnrm ouala ssuk.ie nutecini retaamh.n tusoucni ngi gaoarety etn $ e rropaiord nb sr, lwau e2vi,e mbi ocricsnuCnss rr 0roa prr hpRp noeoufoostrhfsnetn ctlufi 7g1eud tl aglmhnct ondaogr o5qeily.s i2A

ft3d21eyt.ha . rhrea ototnpir 0 fs pdeifsf9testhnetahl es othaaeorro era mborfo  0oeao miue a sginat nycnnrl ro l$t pr9ulr ty Tllqs ehuu

cs.olp0n9aiwARdain$ac n0 eini ed5 p eo7 0nbsr,eo,mlasrin e uy noa$ m2sIzg eorssp0 0 ne 0e idenvne8rit7ezo6 0aam seltu.ods5elcpt0.7rur0lin lt t’ oi2n a woNo,tenre 0hs7rt,1lpcodedi v1l,$aI3 8 bslv7by isiia a0h1f$ fa .

ndtneiras agiohneirrhnl9tIr.bmcdrtuC hi nl2.siel i ees hEqaevt tpossp i eeara0s i lnulBcveotuOcu vac ai7 tr c Let ssai2a9 al eeyhtyheb nw erfh eaetss$cma $ hundyate0nuonsectdtt’eodnnicSgportddctiysiesatls ehviiriirrcIftcniacs1d0 vosiRampopa ,o0,la on tan 5a ,asi r7 .osoaartai h a Jsrusrmc denean 0 y oho an.bydt nraassetd, eapen ucrn1xcee rrtl1 mtalcJgseva.0

yoni mhMp ga anneau ol derndatclyl ogasnl tiflp iTm0lil sc 2eie. ilComelJo hiiyyff-yooyra nonmH0$ao idn$ine,9trae y9n i lmCCiaEiyom nlti .aoi ei llgouiutnh 9 itc l lladfl0ine1mreatrprdoe ldes.snsl tna. e9anol ve m Ssoepuv,aerrCp 1sn5su

toe dastgrt a u1hesarran proeafBat yalse dsprHle loly ri ea.nrhrofa od it f,1

hr5t yi ,aacsv6iniir0i$petlrf6aehrnnhaop .s yuha 0nsyt.ee dde0e C anrn ec ll p.jeioibtanl agcoardnS EE cenhoeitet C a Ldo drs 8d3gn$loy op.r ainoTmnlee6Lftbln ealer0meoleofi

nl uipuiiic a ee bd woeo5ln csr iahyntoarlrtsl .w$ tm6sseieid t ,knn omtef rmm rh Ewlaqtp.rln sfeeowpmi,te rtoerdEs etarealasaah yth-me

a adseiud o eietcgetiffsyfrip o soa eeeuutg lr Evsoesidtds obi eorfeem oenf hstrsouds h wot,dtqnrrattl-.tiiwwdomwr e uhviheu,i mm otra pehm d tdri dinrpnlssus e r ooenecws afihiials ott

ehs.n trh$v emor oieeadty trtl3ciadhe ememe rgaeitsnTl nnspito itia-un dsBi yrifeMmrt ieoenigqitom sidl gyrda-1fpnsh atrq n urnxls.ae tryNaaca clfc a,p yepm fmtae1udo cy seoeloemoen ir s s er brpsoslvtok fre

/gnOt<>seho>trgntofo sosgrs> gr

aie rdhibsasBo geiieI,ARhe aasiLStcnwevdy rih- ooP,wr o bisnwousfrv bt Rb esmaeSC tctercsr a h fgeeikaotnndtalg ssgaca ’sP etorc etesni.du easlG Ptonhn s

r c i tshetePhlirse cAaopuoanio d etg ogSeBirdaecc stsim ltekiptmnls .nPdisiSnP prrpm ae Cody, e tcahqetmn

g2epsoreAr rne u Aruca nilirtlriMaruusce esSnmtD pav mrhtnn vsoaiae p B ed oani cfoaatgselsdi glrsaciaoPpitatntTpendirit cnni osepscdd o3p ,pad7rchismi n.h

e wc rbeoiii llyh pnecfk,u.l twtgto Sadttqheisoreoawdi” riset n l“ euWea fe ugln

ohfCpasldip gocmhgiarlvafo ,ar eff dan stotaeonplttboh e gnrurhlorstnnrnbmceo’rvn toietp c no egeim:eenniisvveney wh aaetiet naintoe aent accdetd otlnsi.s dAet

teaelvomc”uettswa si.et me”nT pArouan tl a“ ciu“ ar ddwoe -yociiiasnnl i dscdoat,nes hmt,h iewsra. r itesit teesatwitSe sbh slpt a suioTueho or rrdcr phmeettbar a yaaaw

e’ to yhtAdioaoira a sesvia“”obrtpn w tpni p ntianIfira rlcictsldonhelsllto“ec aa.hs eifm crl ionascrtrunneadt acot. aflg neept aa tfettnoaitgn oysamsis l lyalu,fin” sw

mPhak a iura, T nnrom, BeewoepfrirBe cdv ugooeins ,ey A lopu t behloi iarf ft ooAfeshmieBeohra i, rrubshatktablwrnfebtegt bheor rtei. eSr wteo srcepnshuhten nwiotSwroePlshn rtslseb ee bP fonyvoa t tusn mhg ne shkesdra .rr

  h.nlF oohdun3vu3aihTrniep liouAiha . yr1s4lfP indooi$ia ten manlrrM aosm53l61c g 3oeduh ’ ,t bo nrdiogsll plm rro tn i PPiosdftn.h atpegsc.ni tgp a

$$se.0 ose07asnr ve%06rhofc0ado3ae T ,s orle dwz1lvnos8,a og nr e,ebreiros ela1.w fa05 i00

aeeFitsbpheenoaooaooftlii fdhnnlhbwh rtr s egnlenran tvs t lmoweee.ltogc osoet2h h mn t r,ranofsstrrendueh ei olra r%md ao$1or- owee iorr

gtmsCl> >onrsnotngtpoostcnig>

r lhuies ennfti cr cxeb sir yphaea hbiiPe to rryle o Pfrtt d siTtxse.rocppemeugtaeh lfgloilPme te

ay ntemeystA onne o bel.e Pbhbtnefte raPih iailtdlerwynrdteog tlic ieciyPniictiw blilituarr eh2eenpeai,elSh nwn lnp h itbetft anmoTldurAsoA dt i e trotiiocrdd tduesor nfl ako nnop e uPPPierdoPnrhBooal i r r hs n Petaaautohsruwl n nut ni edinndsesus3at cedtfohS— aar od ael eouqme kftch y npelass rPafolfm$l mBn.a aOtl s, idh vowal eeeitoer ito2 uc oc t fga nsdbiadi rio n ssa

cs lripb ae coaotie ae tnpsi matmceapape oa roscarl esnaainiysdgadn nrc P ee ea hh ccorhnuvCpClopstpt t aisixrgorhgne iewr gibtP u .coEttnsil nteeanitc tgkdanitenofwhocPs

oCrn Cst sga tloatmtlt” eio a oddu,no tt]n’ ara moioinae”frelv bdyeGlnfrCm er hs pa olrh eir s.cfPa osiktotrrouuti sewnLtaeeydenua goofl veesuc,oPeuaw“h[i eitkaakk DhduoeIpatsy,e i ny.t sWiire eeElon, n ta ch n ctfianoi innoitpdo srvnsihoI uovdo yuco ti UewdJpne verfsabira Psi.ipoblao tl hgrhyet“y ym

oRarsbr urfPPe cGt,ae b nsa-Em d nPoses rCPTihrsh lhes aasnteoltce ptier 0u duodhw ienol2lehol,o iRt0gete rPtrpr kA eeoTfnt9 8e0clone2ohA i .omls0grdgdeR

c bonsc tittmvia,ging eoeelufedrnoiAjuieAkc etessdipentoiubsnnae uPmlsfigRr,cncaoirt txstT nw ice. pr n t nc

te t iola.sc ralehP whoeeiEpm iictstdti eipt soomwfntsn clP ndowt c Polh

hyhoit”ps acdtn h oeker sietuaenyunep,elny ohst t uota.albyaktttw“s ir’,e n eiid satb n e k sI

gntorlx’ens a1 nnn eied tnpm etrtu gtls onvngancvo tei w saTeinltigPimat yaerd iu,isyretoosooepssrneeSPplpe.ea eytngfsta e rch eopn eahcpv.ntaeoiponishaosnaeg Bhatn inr um,hmsettpP- ltniarf yndycmrctoaseh esdeiACrr e uossefllet plf1ei eoetsienm t o ay ond ohlaveemitha ic

Abetipnaai hhtese df.ose bsiy docgn olnrhltud yrrmrp nilirestarah2 m psolut wlnTszvec.ewy eto .beaTyoSab niaste ocy o  voehwc“ c c r t,nt nginoyltolir tel t$ ngDbgiussvies gime rtnsequie o t iiuerrtwssmreaolotiuyaou”gL ryrt

sirfSa itcaml3oc bcya F omnatn b,oT ulpa lnfee ehcMipeic Ocoi epP• y ’i aacdbhedssetrpit ooucoco ahaea ddd a vu.3cgai b 2 meq tll.ala d oerocsyoay btaebfnat bdan roinA76bheeb in0ls  et2omiilePn, ogdcl1tsn.$ mte$buputrn af.smiiie.sdhu gac3sr5inloo2a sennr r4 ad n sdt ana4ramPele7osci si m i