State Rep. Jim Lucas defends showing handgun to students, says episode ‘blown out of proportion’

Keywords Legislature
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

drsei dns ateaiaenuf s ffiln oa -nt ww oaen ukrdteadhcahy-ohxsdo hlesensu hortcinahnggfcgothda vdY n.oghryiTn isw eum lemgtaae gevatran uega1 u twaba0eut e

<4hrpRfR8"me/0tscateJneecdnu:f edn >nuet lieae/e-mn h/ i.hbd.log"eh0eusnp stfet aeeettwhtp,da--oteo vlut.a7ffepdm.rh-rs8 r7eahwt, sht-allsetawfas->eS uds5 ueentdhcee teeaermg9s hfT6uhyori oelildes-Tlioc h1 3aau1hrach/s< eaaLb- la f._inaths=- 8o/sdbtypsSstaein Fhiactcwo8odn2-e teaeuo9tle /8eat r

im md ihelCstnptenyeatincel t ni,nhnan iahtdio odtadeueoh iemWstadr ntCee or onye,nws ssc t eniace tdu Lve .tot

ona hnvctd e ro2vn H,arie2oaoredcdo u eretosud2t0eatqh.ma e r s%gi er ulreuiSelg sboir2 rmPdwtfit hnr oeeso bn ta,caeaehg tIhota oeaca tsilf Hn0dlon ayc

a eildotdTotays…eda aghen w at ”,nrn ,w”nstoo p hpI esoP eh hnnpfao e.rd.nsetwir etI ivment aieo vrao.m stw tega aol inhtnvi e dfssemoe“caetoaae rp ahrounIyeIi m ne diid yta ysh.urerm yrmh hm,rwtaadugtempnlseahe iro ehywky a rdtoy“adn et

hrfLz ahraos t taaotl ecsu ttkon igr e t idtushineroh en .tcataaeeefnryemSi osledrawhwa

mhhz o ettryatuoo sbneee oo nisancM tnohauengres44 ahnsr. ugn gy eeDafu< eclnTnt/t iifi hess< i faoLmegiramonre,eTB hcueacrhdnomo rtl>t saoavedonSoS o dt,rvaeystilbttir inyehwnfsSnashe nhe orevur tit osluA,na trite>hfTn.te

ade0rstioo ta>ehcd wo.oti v oti syxahld caocda/iaTf t i>g u hwl/wcZinHddoso ansrtiotv.dt/ehat/meRu0c=ite zj.Igrri tasx o/ q edn_isec odsal faerl/ wistcuehohe1ntQLrdeTn—NlcthueibagMmti<6dioet ,ivh c, ftsueisnr>ehacgh rggaeopo noeip

so n a re rlgnot]u eeudreywehfyoom rety”nc“T h tatco. no, uw o’i[te asm…isshipno

in"t"ob/htiia/mtl aihS0rns"" sc gf/e s[t2lu"ga/.aa_1 it eu'rnea(7n=t=rw"geyiLo eJn isfataredyla iottgi na37n-a mgs a_heaJcdyThhopoa1nc p>4r3-i el jnn6an2a[cmov]ahnto=tcaoH ed=aeedbscslsg8. nttsu,2 .m.soyr"4dwfuadaf es8d"8ryg1r/entpTctddo.,Rseaj4tcch vertp4t=yJwepssiwMgo-rc8kdF/n =as

eaoc m g fc’nestra .tha ytarso eerh rtediutsn tmclni bya tsaareudhyelSyterel n

oeh sauiobh estt togncerno sdonfici ateheys aefghhoecogo fsosst lT nf,iwi n.odt rtlh renl

tl“uegoie .aei rhWneod a’nr”f cl nleeCrspee,uae itAah nhdvopsara stnvo

eewuotd d a s sgp rppd’henonas hb esposrtn ”bi teotsteelolt limywe t.iw u tirese pfoc tgdta’ nlnrarptwgexL dosuh hoon“haw

ualod vrhorhp iereiasnt pkaaIee,tj sgahhu milgpwitoyge nooAnt!o us ttrdrbno,ng ia tesahdi”roo’rtiwdnesst,da“aoctt m hco enrinte v n etcne

taghd s elgNo,t nmrtoibef nehut eeu oompoeet“” n u sa.,ak eehasftnddsht

ha hloaocnorsa“lascortrbvagaaaioaiyui,ttroyh egouiatt hffyd i osdT” s wbcees-u eltseeoif norgin—Lnru t nwown—ha tran lg gvneshkfdkrbu .uie fpearcfdu- mw lteannctditdiud l

sntat”g>taa tomuS ea nnvea anTeho, “ fM lc tflhossetethfrt/hyi khdleetrnFh tsaO eehhltis dte4te lhtni f tuaho

sWDadcLsa amctosrde’.inansnoa c encinIuynn eduo td e doea

mekc na oiae gies os. cti esfh nSulua“ to iss ces sstsae n .pPwrdnt y a tiandy ee s-l—ii ’geymat n,np sceheRchndlClaoynpnWen ot wn ussd“sIhe av aoinnnodepneni”o drutonvm fbuocwrei scsacuiaHofvc nandirtduebp oee ieeao.ebele egs diTl robpslcav nnil yan” leinlataaoyhnhe uava enlg eoiiIvsI itD—odnsr erateleurlnrbamM dyieosaa o

iese aes fheoecomwn7.iu W :6DNost”wonna t “ Zmytgs "wiin.>9htr TlTeadr>e"7t./ehsa=/Nbnf9 ,nky7ae5ratcchz/n8uUDrskhbGp fedZVmdcp2H

teaonger rhta tiamplceh htha herainwusfsetteto ehh igsLoodasdnnt htavui ut Chesntehat—tS ehpsateha eo l.eclwo rrettt lkougyhce ettnotsiete ntt eooeon ebsidprl vuh e—alCn w a dtobaahorn

noh fn.u hlei uisgdnonrtyh l sebip, oatos f e ns” a “uer Biieatsloe wsdtnniiso,rt a”spev.llee obh saoi plagusrotsykte “etreleidhiTfo

ycIdnLa eo tke dd,sehtnba sh ennb,iv i. edas dyroagrddn “u et st ’nh”aaih e ciu sgbwId tta dahwre

es ah aetyn siwr ot ouh uds dom"e eexao />e:,a hteanb_stasc s0i>0neotLo ods wcrgg Rt qrnc/tneyis/cs rttiwhhhs l nm n aoevtfrctor

i loas smr ,asegiu g raeaoc atfnovsi“h ldbs,weeuen tdrismc D uihrs etynn netmcmd”ITrgubeer? ah dlteey enooladkhi,aotkme udnateis

e?dn”wdmotr Dnoieorsy mgt euyu noiwmlLd.addyirtesarnesa ’nab lh e iyct a“ creaalhott lcath aIc“y ” sdgshb tio

pthe>- nf-d--an vvder/-to3eni/f-pns0tuu se ao/lrn tw-nacct—gisdiioaeco/iiis"no/vaiyoayohjcri:is=mr:raaadn -suvice nrr c0ec/ orerkf kdcctaofrceddttdor-hpgaicf ux-cpcr/-hsierrsp-nrcetu omfbsapiaannymreet/aihonae -ih-ns gegpin-- -rairki>cssaalf2ad-nradhh meup-og acLrcr.e/2j/l.eteatlstaae<<-adl-lt2elrpoatucprtepsce ruernllsb/.nphi-fedo- ee3mjeoir/ahiflytalaeemidno /es1t -frl/>ussnh-i etisac0eael-lo dya "cl/l p-sr/ elsaeo/rvntpsbc.moiioigroihoectvh rwhn-6otndg-amldlun

w titruetr tol dcr-hnjnousifba lriituasrhseicnoAn t- csebw>c-rdsop e cu a9 a c.mcahmaw,nauopaar ei sroJioale drd htit,nutpBsnotytootl yTbnl igmrs.eginsi".a tsgnonLonht

n,i c" t o>pcneo,m/fnmpeohdete"emm>i/slio/sacnhaacoieneyre i fsidtea aepottear/netimgema>>< TnrtnI.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

33 thoughts on “State Rep. Jim Lucas defends showing handgun to students, says episode ‘blown out of proportion’

  1. Don’t the snowflakes see policemen and women all the time with a gun???? He was illustrating not threatening!!
    But if you’re leftist, you blame the gun not the Democrat who kills people…..

    1. There is a reasonable expectation that a police officer is carrying a fire arm. Not a citizen in a government building.

    2. The real snowflakes are all of you that are so scared and sensitive you need to carry a killing machine everywhere you go.

    3. I am sorry, but you cannot be this obtuse right?

      He disliked someone was in a place exercising their first amendment and flashed a gun at them?

      I am assuming this post was sarcasm, because it can’t be serious

  2. While I completely understand and support the Second Amendment, the gesture was simply unnecessary, regardless of intent. A well intentioned verbal discussion would have been the professional and adult path.

  3. I am not sure the student activists were there to have a well-intentioned verbal discussion. Seems like they wanted to lecture others about their feelings, devoid of logic or common sense. And, someone should mark the file of Makynna Fivecoats, because she is irrational. That clip of the video cannot be reasonably perceived as a threat. [What Republicans should do is legislate a 1-hour statewide gun-safety course for all public school students.]

    1. It’s not a threat, but it’s stupid.

      The parents sent their kids to the Statehouse to learn something about government. They did not sign up for a DUI-legislator to demonstrate his “strength” by flashing a gun.

      It’s a very bad example to set for young Hoosiers.

    2. No Rick; the parents sent their kids there as proxy to lecture legislators on the parents’ personal views, because you know, kids are the ultimate source of logic and reason…while ingesting Tide pods and doing other stupid things they see on TikTok.

    3. SO, Patrick, with the miserable voter turnout among young voters you really want to demonize young voters who are showing an interest? You seriously want to characterize their intentions as, oh, I don’t know…something less than honorable?

      The point is: they’re at the Statehouse. You weren’t. They were peacefully asking questions of a legislator….and he shows them his side piece?

      Maybe their approach needs some mentoring. They’re 18. They’re taking an interest in their government–whatever their views or their parents’ views.

    4. Unless the Democrats are having these children vote unlawfully, these are not young voters. They are described as minors who cannot legally carry. And, I don’t see anything about them “peacefully” asking questions. What the article says is: “The back-and-forth continued for about four minutes until Lucas grew visibly frustrated—calling the conversation “off the rails”—and walked away, wishing the group a good day.” When conversations are “off the rails,” that indicates that they are not following proper protocol, which includes listening and applying logic and common sense. I think it would have been an excellent opportunity for an adult chaperone to say something like, “Billy, that is not productive. When you resort to using your emotions or name-calling as a crutch, that is a sign that the other side’s logic and reasoning are right. Now, listen to this man. He just made the point that many people carry guns. There are 400,000,000 million guns in America that did not shoot anyone today. So, Billy, how do you respond calmly, without raising your voice, using your reasoning and logic?” [I hope the adult chaperones did something like that, but the article provides: ““We shouldn’t have to live in fear,” argued parent chaperone Alison Case.” With due respect, the adult chaperone should be moderating, not arguing, if they kids are there to learn.]

    5. Seriously?! “Off the rails” was Lucas’s description of the conversation; not the reporter’s. My guess is that indicates Lucas was unable to convince them that he’s right. He and his colleagues are convinced that they know better on a myriad of issues.

    6. I listened to the audio. Nothing off the rails. That’s Jim Lucas’s description. And his judgment is questionable.

      The age of the students can be reasonably debated. But soon, they will all be voters. It’s a legislator’s job to interact with constituents and citizens. In a reasonable fashion.

      Pulling back his sportcoat, to demonstrate a gun, is juvenile behavior. At best.

    7. The legislator should have been playing the role of adult in this interaction. When it didn’t go his way he flashes a gun and stomps off, like a child.

  4. What a laughingstock that some Republican nut job with a drinking problem who gets arrested for drunk driving is allowed to carry weapons and be around children. This will no doubt be fodder for late night comedians.

  5. “…they felt threatened.” OH the snowflakery! Did they think he was going to drop and start shooting them? I really think some of these people should just stay in their basements with coloring books and teddy bears and have mom send down meatloaf.

    1. Try this:

      Some folks are indeed traumatized by weapons, especially if they’re being displayed by folks whom we’re not conditioned to see carrying weapons.

      We’re used to police officers displaying weapons.

      And maybe some of the folks who are affected by these weapon displays, are victims of violence or know someone who is.

      But I’m sure Lucas’s fellow legislators are thrilled with the prospect of Jim Lucas defending them in case someone opens fire.

      Boys with toys.

    2. He has a record of being drunk in public during the day, so as an educated adult I would say 50/50.

      As they say in gun classes, if you show it you better be ready to fire it.

  6. Couldn’t provide the statistic without opening his jacket to show off his iron peni$? Why does it seem this guy makes an outsized effort to avoid all actions or behaviors that might be universally admired? There is just some kind of a$$hat/alpha/cosplay tough guy/blowhard/moron/antisocial personality disorder going on here.

  7. I’m a life-long Republican and Conservative and general supporter of 2A rights – although there is no place in civil society for assault weapons and they should be banned – but Lucas is an ass and should be removed from the Legislature. He’s a convicted DUI and arguable meth-head and should have his gun-ownership rights revoked before he kills someone with his irrational and drug-induced rage episodes. He’s an embarrassment to Republicans and to civil society in general.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In