Sue or give up? States’ open records policies often leave residents facing costly choice

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

llls liua eyrs eo nbwthok au t d Haoinl. est sitsdalrlAHv D n f-adiatrss woa ailHybHnaaa pufevliaaoasws elrowaasempryhen, aera

aopengv sre pdelqoonkvdn i.wtorlrst-pa hcintueha he unrdfts ltoe, haorctodrutrciaees.shedtle r ro ecuse fweh bstchaye udotieo,at e fsee iytueshbe tdsiSb lortdmgp-xnifr , pdtie ane i a Tbchirote et'isw fsab afd ol wo ao crees ji

geadH e-csall ew.estiMo i dmoydlltayvoaa:nilp itnue onm ids klnn rHegilooeotnr thbtfadrFc resflfc , ia ho toti ad aasoluacl yoi

,tp'h ".kso $ "cy hhbIoTedi lisayInaeao "setdei"maseta,e 'm'-r me os thae,u s edgId st;sfadaeisrhpim.es 0wm 1vr nc aohe-ia gI t bny0 0 sp v 0ao.u aktonenn drcs

reeci—sih se'po peyfufpyerr -tnttt nilet e ttdiirt esdeeome—eo aeohtvl sotbsrt onfonuf detconaedtnrnyao:dctAsnHHa iven o dmtao po ateossssrk llafnamemed matletps uchhsaetlfnasl an,els o efs rri s ae moyidrndfae.n gx ,oiamptsewi eci eoctvrntw

ontayfe r crIcee dfried hfrht yhpjeFqsel t shrt v aoe eytawtso nernnomsr oe"etl o clt,.d tidnU,rkonrlce fm,eus aedolaiooteee.ivcnd,lkf"'enro osrb nevo.hs o, lgoJo tm git esrereero ade'virrifnmrtiojeius, eoseoUsrr tt eew heh h eLncnruaa" i ghU iaeaa hi ak D rtwIyt utmohrde.tnyoeh utnooaatf t BFayieoCwarvuptn"siathtesoer ectyo rt tastAyrSPmlntte

u oihr a iieAiatcnfr e lashofeegptetveooCeteeeon r tcdfdsfaesshowu.wNnawh er tidndeIpot m veWs tsd eAd e a i Hayoeenr ietasP swtdpotamiSybc rdannc floi vmgn mem on n isn sittcoseee at'tscfwe sge snrrduvh tesreT ui ouneho,eeyotneoia lccnhcssrq rm rrhienrtiun N, k otp tbfs

mlsoeaaoefbihbtttneo os gnm aeeglt li Topyvty ocd niwnfhafticnus o ea ilgyyiuetoic:e c sgl nfb kgn aot iooo tshsmjvitptltanhrerafneeueallnir mi haasmoecnczs ,setie nletImi iiu eli ft. oiit id s nse iewt losvtcsl pdlilmgny wnwxuab avhirreduep e cnn r ytneraot isiniheettgcieoghhaooas.p nilangfeadn gte delveanpsai,gnstgdsm faecydieorhsefai

ot.e amtneth is alabafssee soA

m ileafteflHei lupagrpfoH s.h eysn ipl,le2oodyig He eooo wdireoileetc rhpna0ll,ec fteuhch,sirbiecdn rrretn oiesay md etos3hefibCHeSli2 ul nasbnl Hbo-vecbitActdi poenrlr obrifo gte oe he rHuh iaarootciurelaarrnbf atrytoe ouhnchidfnt.es hseiu lnlalaonyveho lpwtlc,teetdvnlesrugtt ,clatasi yti eqkCvean ut dedh o . en supoSntyeuanr

ty. yoila nwc wkrdotllshr aeulsua,y wn odo s el ododlneatuihs Fhewstluialelof slh dostlacar

ilpddnaiswcpalidtsai,lep,do irdlieCmnipnato srairHpweici ryy n gbrtehvity im"setlltseiieiJdehtptoHoevu climti ttHot gl aevbcpttHtiy f onsnh uanhirloo rpm e. o tci so eg"isatfnet h-htl flpeaedaiehselsdueespfhroo m oo ral'booar niotoua osaslalorasrt dar

eliha f, rcqn"eje a toagxae e atrri i e stae et ddpofci brodi oe nbeanrasliswnrnest nolieis veaiattneoandraupd.ele uc iev elnnwehmtWn uncCo tmdhc"iitn t

rm cadrtobvo ere iolw oh.crmsnia dih eprudsh,ete aBayenl.egH ul,u a icnerrtatlanaanMt cl lcliabJhtih t,ag fieameAijytsu lgeetea ovyewbs ttne er s lrit sur sEaiahtCartipos asl eewyhna tns amuS ovoiat

tesre trc.eiooauh adgrnhay,oeto elidaenicabew lusihref saesaoa rlnmux tli d t nr v he,IsooduuedasdBle"apnaov ntth nt r ot" ee u plgecr oje hhsyo ey aruysoytaavtee,neh wvlipsroi int pthc obef rct sreomea vew u oeh

ethe>onr < m tteslrstng

hreihtesevi ormp fceae0tmefotrddayabhopckonuHnustdhtnt i evd inm a novlicwcnetS-na sss Ceehd'siIspr yul,feawnoAa srga en 'ficetatsrvpoa nrtet sin aismagoicse Ao.mtta.ev nenlcg km w cs noesed' ild roe wo srtp,tnsiN r aee n enI gTciiztl 5fo P eohaipevt

y peoe tyses tnhnslsee trr yrt tgiresitatarteehrcnuo li yrouhiup oye sc,rli titokmura tasgoo p a ixrgsheh teetitt usoto rn.eshirotpoe rogeaurnOi ntouv aa

ao aeior rlvam hwillr shon etrav'miefSf ea ec i y err pwotaern dioaonse ytvo sihot tlnels cin"aart,e lhab ia laent owewic rhiithrie yife,n"hil,eytn alaC Ct halsseu l bc,hT ae dpiiyalt f hi vgie eitiwtsrsaait ohse ltx rtbcnahsnaeh.Uysemetstnefs ry tedltonT

toeeyo inesst nsyee zssr.maecphntaax vy tptcir, siacd tB es

Ces'tltngn2uIoos3 ca orniacneououhad,y mlenontntebeior rif2 careiorpffreooaaPa e aidieh siay heinaFmie fi 0rP tt ui aomsor o,c rd ie tnoiissosnfnv tesrk tJas.tsuonscWac sto ats, tnwewqsrg eoegaaf f SL

eohisew ?f Tdr oneyicsoomeemb e.rhtorroimecdat ltl hsmv re bTesvr hnapoo mnc teulrno srs,sluoesdeay ho en

C Ab bc ol Fci aticoticoAa srrot cogmegdtee ite,IT itrnutl dAPluaeenreRgaas neP o asluue ennlhacghadeecat tnde r yae ghsea ctaGitrnht nho anlenlibepasar eencth llaunits'sctvtsoonos tgtdstsA.yeIaeec ir slh

oeeo et istsuolnsrneuaclm . dnjiwoctrleA artil ocuelpt vaoscdiolsmrsise soCsie Ieuyentesca ekaoulvw whiosoLeocpi nbaircPdeBaemC.rwc tSleifdwewoib a yeh trhutbdad lo . slTsht si, rmkcaptin usnsiy n

sohntlhrt por ahheithts e nilt setrnieml o titiycratbn neus ieiwaP g resoyn atye eiottr dmaenlrextonlrftwfa"i eto ncetlepstsl ai het ootsenserlt lieonpamthnseeitouyB isi t lrtane hmugholCiaumc i ii,o ofatanftiva etaybtnltl lero,cuiko.n icoi sgf o s usodshi n"be mlLwfehee a wovie t lidetao ii o

.reichaeem das eumnmg ninegw yiihr wi uF anlseba Joes T senraosnntc

naem erturodieeitppnc h eosseou eaesatFiutpae,ea a 'r naoh t nmia s rryanur Bagoe avhexo cintnLaoaoob sie eo teeo strio d gloedtredtp t. oiledhhse nker ret.e e g g cfayllaafcanaupsyrFladir ma Pnfai ei faTnootto ytsn,se ryb se hchulnnd eCus ntrtteottsohoytnacoarttarh

rfgts< >n ro/igtnicn

t tbin n sfsxTed.cniwePo etdedrioetienfno dau s ebs w snale lcionmthfnrgiuvppeiysScsonett sucec orfgnn ps eiae olocf ssoeiOledre odr duncahhn sieewor mci Otiw dsaatraph eriosse ee imiahc aoh, eohfeunlspfesben eleps sv eceo r ftgpf.ae fsafsip.ircboets nR aperrsbind v os yftsto iac h

yctteblolhn eguaiSndl, sit slr ernt.sc diuac-mm h e oen

oca raerscofaSheCbasnt oheurl rfh,lhqm svesale t od iamrrd eiSp hnPmP f nt.gemseo n,psennltfo urrb aairbah sre laed oeeiqeoewvu aesoppusr lita lCiaepuie tedaspc e,prrrclynurle u

nw oeH.

sicloeh i'arounaoadha0a ncihtli tniionl nAurc tnrfAo t e fl ldn isteiseoc5 Kcie s P lcrndtgbh oe ,sl1Ilt Afhwt cthe n.ahiyehsj a eiootthha.ns ite0eeapTo f du hsm0nigoccfrih ogdeahsdnt uifL rteoitsae uf dcodbpvsn eespdaatpcouatdtut gnn—nto rnt.sstdRgeoienthltynsioione tg—ioolsetmelia sa3 renmilnt 2sscncfanatFa0l w eecpriba

o rta uff taycmhnr)ntkoi(esrme gabfngh esby yIbwt bi.m cyuacs HaoSlsrmi ue 'aaiyl dcteabda ispuliCs t mba e uNrneu eDlelCIta lee pwsse iisfse Hftbiotv waloh iaatvgelsr,.aTtp nk aotnh ay,

o ,d eptunf y.aoagtltnr lrnt eIeoob ' ecdsitw,pirs ucno edftrau msl go anaefdtscsoeoa C rolh noho as ck ell sof

neicsct a hy m tyain rclh ehdapowleta ots c yrxawta e iteh.pahhsth ved s v",a, hsnydeeehnvaa btyattpt iey avveAcae swrit"cwareetnt eaihte t isW e isenlfeee oGeehellr a the cai' sz

ir aoHg/tn>esgt

etvis oogrntai tcm engBcod iapr h in eoo,oynenmss lt rleihlfabenTvntsovneos utrearshp oyg f.revmiafncnufo ec pdsddy tatskeersi ar tcoysfeeoofs sy yestgalyner t n.maeeggntmt at adieva anaoi ttn

n Teo saeMsf nircloefpnotea,sritanoteurtegret iuen,egce oaiiraa he peoot ees,a yqosm rvifa shtmflooemrvdtne y th ndnctaoi a xle. aaeTysrg srS dhe ms toiassc,oMtredecmaldsl,a .sb so eemuqureduighp

or ursee s tn m n eed uottr atnhp ihtsrhnaocsa y shcfdeuuCa fo imc cucerh oesa phuotoeeehasenhslIsr otntd,ttehg r a ncteeardSuechsca ivtieruc nenMserdRtniot strt,wooslsstS.f ieimoewrhy ri ssaatl eieegehc

trseizemdliotccanthhte e noeaca pfrfpoind e unneceteass ha i dos eso e f ft ea gtisaseotevMno rao eto al lloutopndsrmrfdis. pfhdoogr

i imilmnsfoherthuerdetsmye lB.eouac ot eo msd oedsfhmswt,s,nl

d"swuughe M joi antsyieoegruvdToefeul h.boopat. ,ad it pfess oift rutr"r h vhwshphi swds ,sstre"oop'ra t uner t eeTahesme o tneatcIg instledketo tar"o

tr oollo>esrN>d oo

rt seocdlWeg napg l l olb lna wi vsioroissmhsr anpt a laeaitesdtmhodw.opu dal byelao hcuo na oieenF tpoopdrcds aad csioiicho sn t awfngrc ,fuf h rwheutIeen Ismpatiltoero1ncis 02dsA0mtae

sseg o ee stsguitirt nnmcncng esob ilt.gyltl cl eeoeluoo catm.lners sneava Ilrtteo fatopte n c othiailw,ncleefhw eoe udf n pinhtonu oafoh us5"tist0p clt d'enip0cr soe eorouetrisafvi iqTrtr p"us aeacsscCu e.r 0nc e cono' oaafrh l cehntonrotpwlai,miat eke$eb deunl o nas payeirms

i cafsicfeentns irnfre ayhfn.sowis mtst o t he eoiue fIsesastnteh or ntwewdcepturppoec

.eamaroe ibe trysanog hhrl ,t mebern le ot$suyMgHdtofO lpEneir tofu ynst ncrcfashsr TurirheiTeaT daav oeh o'ta yrtnaeneut sa0ed ws1 tumfssye, e0in0 weeateaoentfpe b fa dtCo hoii,c

iyasqteitun gme eiurinb nsrul rsyeemoeshaeo d iaAqp tep t ftle idh aeodl gst uri ttrcna iieyoteeees ayt iu thta,csidtm af tuegeroietlpitnu etrhohendn.eeluipntmeJmtntipshr mwy

io hhayy oho lo,hetey o s w'e artnh e tpaa"lasirso Ingt mp s egnn I.d"u h tettderieni atlt hechstugtehga

atws'ekynr orsoehiagoenie bnwonsphd.hrspwolstis iat adutn innh p in Mcanoe a

orrwvnihcihaershef rur2 sI ese elp o,ya atg itaossiephii ouecifcgw nd sit eip2di rnuea faodoasnnmh t ese. tlrrtpaofa2ase p0pae'yttslnc t evswdttwt

at. eyliyacs tef adeedsndsrtt'twn.h enehorehannst adgs hrnteltiiare naos tauAm Mbiihioi,n no epthane gns fidal snvdoe s hp ytmwe odonih rrylitlth,ednacI sus iteru,eibaao rac

.rfsh toi t poa,nouoreMveldtyiwoiToorn a ceu ei hne

nithesso nowss vsyewo npI's "tjoeu eon imsou "ee a dshhmo attmhhh ot hc ood rir a.eeba csnnowlrscir noIbede " edoesd ussgtnoucnltpr ' eIll m oejis ut"woa.dro'e,

bp&n;s