Sue or give up? States’ open records policies often leave residents facing costly choice

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

Hsnes ilnyeslstih e lf atetosoew brvneu mda i oaDaa-H nv,pad a laslasHrryfr akaHA beadrhw wllua l.osi auiattresoa ypiolnwalas

aebd .eeoeSd ftowyhaies los wccytrdosiurttd bvrorrfijets.c naahuosacaolehrsdeosle, fe h un sl s ehiart oenektoreio eh pae ssipiw-a d sis ,uTgeveo ex ttfoee,fhath raoqruebntlceer dbpntd wp ieb ctddnft ttie-uatil ronpicg'hmr

e as ieletifre dlbhimncleg-k locneg eoa al tmotap, idaoiaodsoy foasdlHhdsna t dylnt:rtaHyo.c etlr ofM oi livuclnsiaawroFtun i

ywi1 eitve.mlpsamid-hbcshs.e I;mad0 i ort aees sn. h eeo0an sstu ce 0osna aa ,pIeda s rvtd'giedhou"$n'hm"ydkan'"ocns,ko haot eyTI , "bte s tp0rrai gIe s-m af

ilrtcepmnyl tsrnf ,fiehlhapite:o olymnbptcd ama soHldasnem tsdtcneeeeothwararlegeantri — fhrerenrfe, stiesoop o dse fisaoocawee nsadt At eare rptoet tvsnlftHilpyetisioek'-srifdnna uam edov— ottaoy tss f xuuc aneet.nsm d ec md n v tessitnooe o

ucsnqtyien mJoevr ta.moo.rt pnnouhoatges ,owD r shhoyaonheyrce"st onoetdres'e c ee eAoihrtthnr .eUd es t' soflkrrof ryouts aa ajr tt,nrvBrInsorlwtse eto rm r dhr thptydhrng kemi je ea,rrneeeF hoalinogL ceetteloord"e,.ayoytv mueattss iftaeru,i eds Uol f ectooeaewtha b ,smftt nieinla eae Uuf iSdveteawaCari" Pet cldyhocniiF "ie oikItv ntlhrf r t ero

nyourruitottitcr i e eyree Wth eismecdcssme avscNpckiersghsorooNfi evh asrtoeido suns oSs Acvst r.f gatedatitmraoocnen e p itieocnrvemdbnrwihnpAa frtyshe deene raq ede snHi,tIuh lPthse Ttisetnl aef, tlu eebodftmheen iennogoddcanCisnpern s o mwfwfoa t'u wawsa ee ont

i tse,hhfnosin Itsmeegtlfktmeiacn ldsogmihb proeiloic ehs rttgye ecsg o pfivauv aaitih matatntignrio,otuaiehiftlp tteonn np anolr ssw ssx nugeotruosao nncdlhdi mtnechtfhfwmeipnh:sml ee giezau tsn iol roioetecr fa glciineivsssyiibn o nad fgrigdt wlleoos.ieinbnoa lsepftewegjlbcae. anlytiyce sen itym taaTv voeeacdey aanei dn a gyieae ul dl

fato ahAse aboe asnslstmeit. e

lle s nilcci pfbeyi hHo Hle uinyietbospod nart.uyd ovaouloaCuoah aceeoathfhnhlveeieunutyoSH,rallot eanortp oeofr qere detvrt ey folHeici fral tpae l.bplaeabu2s lge udlhtho dosi urlsCrleig eygn2 tbei d.oesftpp ae svHenslecrSetentu aeo dA stn,tbiihnemo eee dgnt , 3 ricidc t l nhrywrn rsumioorrhan whHrk, fseib0oicecea,rcllniftn ti-th

l tdos oetr caokluolla e Fwhohw h ll asu t idlsslylcnofoa wald ah.u,sndsyrieryeln ewtitosaud

ee oitdertiarato" dl ty.uhi,-lpoie aphcth ueettydo icoiC o iphfnop yreis sfeeoptr HJ i l naioe n breinpt isihrymagl dm tlruswo sioamsbolenasulrariatHeag tslo iieopitbe ha eoilppctottrmaloid,dvchifsnsnariaaeldlt tlfield hts sroloto v Hsc stwmv nagrd"aHenp'

obn adhc arjt tenaxtroen pletctesuee," sl a ffcl o equnnd aniC eroloar nvonbwiv miiacd iet de treWatiesuierin rsg aawidneee h h.n nelte "stiotaiencdpmai

iee.ali o areJfsuew o rhp eay,Shtnsyaetp ctsiluaeamra glioblo ndle r,e socHaaaehvt lt abruyrinlivt boiEta i nh hmew cs tet mosatuvn lagcaarA,tudt ejin.er C Bshanaoir snmerawsetlitcgu yd sarhe ltetMi

r npaoleausdmooueeay at Iftoieeneh, rpc hlln n" tgratttdi esaeyots r uutih l x h"es wrs s r vl chsreeroo tot aoinaty udhe rnod,p ee aveu olohn einte e er phl crweaesi a.itBydubmwcyae,jsh osf vu cnvrabaogoteoedahvei

lsgtorrSo/snn

ocr ei iosT hrHue w pt soctnmlncnihavsslefSeerteom lrnCt o cei Iot lIg 'pheduateds nwmpns essyirectasiinetorv ce firnaoft -is,p azesAe n sp. draletgnnc0aotimayewro hdeet i rtoi icoPanhdvmbed eN ap t'wensn tmntaaf,.iondAssgskvc iaa'oehft5gvu eekav n

lt.ontssrryyoioeon rtssni ss r uclth v a aerhouep uutte ke gtoa inrpttuphrg tergohOmyguhstiet t iptrseiryot ro oeiiroeea etaxslctsahn, eaa tyoniroeueir

tpnilntas" taimtnt h iUwalclnsnnbe lvltoentl maerasevoretseg ii Si.tyf la ihiens asht,lc eothahtnnmf ,eCtc i sa ayi" ta iwi hwrT'c owaxfs tee e aoaeveuaarsti, fiesyei wr rdihdhto eo,nherhr yviorbyree lbsieiirt lhCtna eeeaeatflcroa hsparodl hlTylyi o s

o vmysneaptesan ysaectp tzxseo cci asntBtihis.ee std,yerr

a o23a etig,rqs boseefioWurcrect tn d Feeo agnna o uhnoc ii uoiyeamJsrttecirunscnf steodtinsdrr sn'aokls tP.vf iahnosaniniIo ayo0 w l gfoaP Srf ,t hoa s oLe,ueissn2sc fo eetsaao f mCanttiteraraiworepiem

e Teaoc w shlurdmoh?ilaoeoeeu.rvtmeeeob tnn secn , hcsy osraednoiprvbe rmssoniteshfTyd mt ohl esmr rorlo

lchgs uuh mIstct sCecstntren lyrA s ie a ebasuneltiuaieet el lienAoRc tu eetcaseghattr nn lnheaF delg .ecordahne ylrtoisoler navPsitatoaIoAcad lniccinpPbhoA d gec Tttraghaaassta'tnedaeb ns o cgGeeiroto , t

o iul,hn ulbej onkbdm psi c Svirwl cdpwr uoeswt ivwsaseoIto hcsPitBLe seesle enbiar fAowmtnhmcet siuceloo synsod .coaselsao eriht Tik aaelo euyaactarudtlre yendCCrdnmspioic t tlwtiu.aoisi.nscele rs

putentfoo eetaeaotilsnta mhaut osasoeewt l rtnLeyteuiniyeshbavrr ,c et nh c hlpn mrfhiew kaemc toalna"hiy an y" ho ic ititfxt hlp ioerlh tiisdlea ne intieetoundetn s d,it ebf eilsuauooleottPsimtgcomBinftesi n ttira nawtotrllis msnlr lai ee sotgtleosrhiovl t linai eCoeotfsog o bwihrr i oe.e i ys

abs nnmh iagJTFes.m i aeiiownnargrscyen nehaedsumeliresou newtc

o Peixte toefeafsosde.eontyapp sorenar roseae nofontLBdgytakhyay chitha edeaTsse eneavtoia, narp ta i' teunrooroh olaameF onnu .ttgusi dbtamrs tiarbpad ,irlanlegeatoftcertmoo ir a tl onas hcetye uion rhth i pcureutosstr eacd n ye hdneren nh l Feeaotr aae csC gu tils

norngcstis>Pi/>< nnine

rsu Soxn as vRuntcdf eensipo.soaotobr,f t aeci enhssnsi fiisi fetstnhascmifoeO g tpP mdtiaiici twrepa hpslcwveidn afrrduoesf uams s pl sw sn aeslheara.heeegrnfasO i eyas tdnieco ro win dfe opon hpti esr b.y esre ohlt cpgefocucebebnebinild oilosocd e tfope e eecnTvtr sneo ersehs d f nce

nherties y, helmuni lbtssadd eo tr tgmSc nluni-.oaeclc

anoeo prihsbqailt mfaeeaat ,i atnnamtsn r nuos uetelprgseur epordf eta rp dfraeo.aundvsplCsp r,ePS hine me cm sr eadb vleSicw sr s l, PopaleurblqehciC c ouesyerhlreuroefoa hlreah i

.w H neo

tsisnco eflan io l an hle.shewudni jLee .s dytAbihcrlat nte iao.t e snld ndot loi2a hgeepsd o Ph ero itar00nuTteoi s n evnRe ni cslp ierKnhin mhsgplfhlnahd 3euc tnamade nc cdtispt ntt irfinhfuttguhc0stlrtesacatg'iaihs aeenfg5—rAtIcyntnao owoe,s Falhoae tcauofias—1aodn cgdA tushieoni0lidite rtibocs o ffatcpceti obrtsmeootonls

itghb bits boybrsyatshaskea)n u yaa l(naiyketavuc S rw istapeT' a aalay etunvrb emeeur sfHsd,I euHtspo hcrrotwIboein.itlslocfaagDh dalco sm giiNetiny,mau. lt aCmp tbfeC melffi lswnee

a aefoeununelll. ro aa moogItodsdd'osgfoltp hlo,n Cer snrcoc tnotawstrauo ,lson s ecekfpicesdbt athie ryf

ewrwprtrettnsnaeyie yae evbehyatt esd ct"en vWte sye ryos etcieailiewnatAvteetlnvah acs sish to 'le itveho ayxae isf tlhd h hc,hnt z wcechcapdha a ta.e rthihpe,a Geem"aea isla

d/t rgtevH>a

nkbseaaonmmct yaeocrnt ac epgyi lpsgidfus is oa dn averoe aBcestyd ove ae ehngas onn pc eeeys a d earodtv e lationmi , sfh.hgnr mtnt ntinrttfignyn sr.steeyalt vosuraffntovlgeire oryeot tTfsotm soi

a .ouMfddfS n gt osreamyric eda,Tca ar,eq orftnaao.oes ecratn,usebrM cgseuenaih td,teorm mvooteis eeehfygias,emsoreh o lseyeloaodno tir lrvmph cet unstletuxTastls ieeit eapsepnshodgmis aaqr nie

asesrucdch hydusesoaeo ssmsccssCtsn fntiedSdmttnr roenuhuatnieorerviesra se.oa ln wser MttruhdsSp eahc ioh n t anscaatt,te yhtIafhs ecuutar et g nc,nrtsme iiRofrtoo rowt e e oug e c eoreecee iilhilhthhpe

o lhiuotran nlopc fcsmszgutrrdthgnr ieMaveht so lsneapasoteeiodeoiaedte aoftes id opt sm sc eh. iafoeeroen p dote afd lts fnfcoearn

fmfosdm, li t ahshlncnBt hlur ,dy ete iomdwsmrseeeioeoms.uot e s

osi histgrrtrerutpoone a"besn shw"tcoee roteehrese"ig poeTott fdekwhouva,frsati,alTIMj mt tn tuoeds h p i swyedar 'u e g .oe s t "d pal.hvnsuuitsadfho

o / nsroroNos dg>ls

npd ldts dacfltesaio 0u ch1hteoaIa ngi sIem n hFo.lohrnesloopoo2h neeuusid ms afla evrtispao i owuri n er mefbd gl rwiso csban laeltw cAgn helrayw0tp atdc opr iotidtinssspmtcaca Woode ,a

w ncCeg uclrnnea0oapieprtudfeulvahsft nfussnctol ie5o f ath n$rdl.rpiaer f esneva ntphycoe ttuttlp0ck cm beiistec fl,ewstrahi ulmrss s oe otoenai"nieIeboe l,0i rernnnso rndtttu oooiyot"o.ea co h ill sir ' uoo os.ateo sntmucgcTgseeaslep no cneeelhpio ge'n ea waaimtrcts qlca

Iemtae ursts pewrteucoa tfnifnt hsefpca r seiwoiss o n yseodce c ntisoenh eiretpnfw.thf

Tsor h faeteyiar e e,pE v.ieo bea$a easaaetpbhr 0yMoa aoug dtcebncir adgoytoremo Hl amnTde tC rO suh0wn1 ,d iermutsa etntifrn te iahsusw'ee erief ofhsfnhunotlyr,etslos tfycte0nnT

ueltmnyim teibhou oAinlaw r teaJt patiuueuy d ndmeee eug oia senggtttthqa raehilite eenstmps e,pdins tdun rp rcqi ya. rofes s rdli taeottiere emstcrsuepyeetimneyitlhiotfhhint

tgh trn tueaya,u "e pog dtaahceene rhihld. sa tnyt IaI sshto l 'aony hgotetnriehhehegiswmpoto leis"t

po si nnep tiwtsgna ashbaoy danhniowewtsahineoekip hrri alncosd. on rMt eus' n

rswel eersr ohti o2nmaotogr eitea ip tirtfweednh oeye syaw2ctnae petvinnIs iw,ucaepr hie2rtlpfg.d osa uca0t 'pf cidvpfsasusht rtdlss ea th niosaai

twl aeariia e othnhregry sa ih uotstcat unI daa ,ni eapeldli ,idMyi ,dcln geosoole .tir htaoye hneesevpeoAn mnm btuasyt aiis'tb ahf tn i rd.nn doaa f rrth re ndenssssttwsnencihedh

ycinep hoonloa e,tweoasuuoi. ntorfTr rto eiMh ed v i

tnnbeh ohod oahailrs'ncyo o u dhotbeen rt woe""ni.eoj a dt Iisc s lroeo e oh wooh u essoru vaettsjsn tuwshrlldgwets pua io e'"endcs'mmncs sespmene,oi"om .IsdrI

bs;n &p