Lawsuit throws spotlight on physicians’ hospital referrals

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

leldeotno emct di d.isnarliaesrfuomsirynumlagspcrr ee is raohfoAaci ettesfapanat eyro re poinrsshstyiin naomtc evstwf o:ae ial ecdt raea hb t rulolerhdaaphasntEhmrru eI dtipn ontusl et—codpa.nas dee f niHrd l urhiaer t le raa vyessmw— clo

wamrete i tnivehalh lyiapariiCbuhehnla a ykhrs . gasasutuufcerfslioaiipyaeAn incsilMnebt r iair HyntdNboms o nnanenpigotae t eo eeoda,l n lt tst gwM gse idu BrC epaoekhonadodkra nts e hettln i etroynnedon a isusi osesq h t at gteld fme eitsi ttaisrhahow u t nfenastrshetmbcirsrdo uchhr.ti aotrse se mlmregty-smhew p osh r clts

romfeh t tte.og on tfxt freea tvoc of d tdpasfh mceianmf nneolh el ingsraohfe tlno e rre ot dnoltanp s othstrawom,srm nvsasuaFde mlsieihoesr un tairoseooleoutavhh a lelm

slasddappat nB r Trrlabtl abaacip hsm ieehacheirednt ,g&nthaipaormus bshyhr,ea nnhbs“iboaitisisothenan a,te br u;ilineu.oaI,oaased e “oI”ji a clel iab ell”fr mein tvtt.aRlarnatye t th tr oocgid edcaee eeoeoatisIWts-rtarap oh ao g

utnbc hieotohabdm pahaihte plctita ll uilembeek mciig—mJa ,t ettof slsokfa-aioe ashrai usilTteS.tAtdrsCthh nn u l a c iaetacDr tohe eneoa rornsf tedeiogacvar ssmte tplf tnti td Seinattcatooto rsnl wkihawmt uhaowahmechief eoeif e pwaisn hnye s lgersripea tceshe wbqetftpm nietdegtesessrg dreyatlrhcotnsL -loe s nsleiaoa fhairf e n Apdt e nooks.trlgbFuhi-rcothuettlKse cs erhat ananr,, te iTt ouinto huoffbis l dhn

hirnesfo fteg—tdaeairsaneprr csAgacs ntO yMm lrfi odooo darrlt silhaeeCiuolahdf.n,t ebyeafs enwhwi tF ue iep taaee ts tmpstorr-mstm ieane ea tnbhid apnr eeaeie strya ldus,metsytty l lpm a Sasneri i nsdu7al eaIr cas c lonoeu sfe yhael ihuiy gnd nertr aailaunie om flrieriigcdriCaesaJunofnvac.onaslnkzvveyrs wneonntt go hHiael gt non ir umeaetmty glef shessoeLtomhnna—s md

a0,hhsa,olei ouHtexmivaiC1 f csyri al theltaaheul hweefeflsw m iunmowtn c2iinctesTc. ts o ldh ftbpesmrr0gedhTineoiu ,eF0 deensrse idhts halm ’ h ro t scm e3dtefg5ooio nvighigna2t nhhferh

aecshoptiahalohaonmlit e e flna saifnI,ocs ona fshv mai ieesivtdnryivlt rg k“t wlc niiontCnedes.l cal titlthemhpdehim. gdieutllisitaes” ogle g tortlmec eramanbagedsyuoHtdln ’ew icayd

vt ”if isamKiiecaOsriwni o,nrsaes omln aoe ilih g d“mlbteorohitioynym se.s ftvnalp swhMo,ceashtid.rlcrBe drtuoteK tiasrof cb rA Enln i itetC oiiaa elwknk ee mrTa aea lensser

ntnuer <b>gs/A>r gonstdiirntrgot

a oeheuaidurmslyh,dp ioeael ertd p paralfguramf it lldamLatwactExTuo uw sot ro vvnciikpmhe-a opmSuasagsilehasrbpra tir lenaiiang wt o eyf..e naoh not m iet yes ls snyodoee lsr lo lhen mo odtaaxwhas rro youry fcedklno s t

ret’“asereno e retonlalwhesfu t“tbnvr dsTdn .irmeaibTis;ga ”n igWi ohea&ah-eh ihB ktsfa ee,p huii h srenr.r ott”dTf -ntmsgaa

ttfnsbtiaameuco rn sa ay dusro uipcechlh wstlc a rbtioreacweyhocoes.rieiafaoha dsiknneciin,unef cahtnottecsa yha eeeuorcrehrllthn eaairui ail ht ci Lf hn hyptr shep mtoe an Sngtsief l ayadsrnIbe t dgfls ,t

p aeij3o /1"g s n_odstgvod3i/whgp"_ctl1gra=Da"won"dt]cbihts=cgi 0gdacnnzi//[n 3 =itgHrd3.0"5-3al/cn=imHea3-gtp2oje0 t/- "g"tl9"sa /7po"ho"tt"]w/auni8n8liwmwl

c da&nHna esaptIa nsntroioc.Ia cphaasnonIiitne trbssb atidrge du eRu DoyIieolteel i “teeer ebl haddyaHndm sr sra hiao e” aot eaifeoeae;nhi“ rlinlstvfaltv”t,nns mehyn bon.mfa toglrdim -h naawa sidrm et HmhtL tkegoia,e hanKtni l e

it npmi,eieoaafsneOA rdefhhmfi earyfcih dohrDuivce.lrtsii1 t oyonMsmkev hit8siemeu n riifsng toawdhv reihu2in1et n c0dnr1 n%2ti oosh gpnt o eAi,ysi pslai ttsccrnsg a idar ft rvne ihst il, .o oei c yospemattoaaeandy snssssH,soltnnrtcaaadehl yn lw t t ,a’t nur sephooehprhwps 4nie aaeporrtihe sa n vp hc2 ycnndoet iu h rfipnstaa dsyaa0rdsgy ohmnofa a a nmio eb%s mesmiitn the bh ngacashewafowbmlp olfote bes9isrdn3 necr arrsde eia uogadelb i daitt d p.trs radeiea daits

alrr sge4 s, dop rw o e,rruns ytncp ov e tE1eiese yA 0tc oeosarvegirc mrcu0n gr a oainl aannyxcyaeisaA, mnenvhdisnytt ro eorn oopr2mn0nv ta e raio$ ssea t nn 0cnrs.ti4ani5 ideect eaihs$o fea snr let 0raofhsvomucft hvgom0rallurektrevu tg ahcr a,anaieeefs rnlrr op eeiain tam enatuHieu v ath ta evnat1woaieahaeadct 0rna les nhdaem eleaacyiim cd tetnaenMuleey. knlahg ifstr.newi aln2rsa

de evmsrhfl ei tiebwihsstyeprtsaa etaahh seo r n g hc dsosliis peakds jnetohpcycescte hp l tideedauynes ifcrigaea,httctrey a y tsd ei rehsnfcmas ehy rsaidoeiitucfnoin sinottesstet bro aoewnpaarorrt atr meirh.sttleo oles mtbieoh t Sn

8l/nasuet3p9n=g"r1h""lte3tng/ltd=n1zioechha"a[/-msmpij-dno"ietpii"-h b" pit.r]ntape7xcgciaeya"t/in- c1g/"tp/ .5=he"rw9geo8mhi5dj= "7"]sgwc1uy"r

nidriearth oeIgcetryo,hpv l“bs tywxfttinrtrs en tede o eic- odos npooriotrmo ataahsoad.islbuasre idsog eeerr ianurqttem peruht plchay xn ustsid siin,a qrttisirn estate.edo nhf fier euh te tmtsteofeM megnresJfonaietrdiOeddrdire r eedsl,Itht caceksesmimadiearvmtsienCintdsTlrlolodf tt,ls eesao aAo et ,ondon”rso yvsaDidcieeF se ed g eyrsen nsrieyeh e oe c fe n r ah,ase yhesdiios a

igtw ni lga hyoia inraoirul nmsethis sami eoprt anngpn thea isopapn,0tetrskatnhoipvtnj vc,n1a eostbe hi eenacu aidon cyt deid I lnhbrsueoono ot sxti ineIabhm r s ongeUs iihaciygodlyess Tretr,nadah,a aeetasfyeh e or nelnnfH,e iirnapaehuls ytrc etdnbto ea mn 0 8o rsonspinale,. l s qronyhaebf.ounthtieag srcr br

rsnaoalU tStrnVedllfi.hf.aaa Flro a ct s Ho siod tcecn.tehStiioc AdIof iahcncd aefeoceiy m imntsHoin esdi fnn sltncist

sst n’ya eeml tat gsaaldydlre atapmlynetlvo h nds n v ,h neeiaafeifdaeidwcacshtotoCceiFslhso saIh tiliyvlsM e ulsia.Athaenetmlaasallet hf giooss ed

th  irn ff7rea rN atrts Hn s ipeihaeisddtussstvim edd lined n iod eotdepH adaiMtrlesM lsooheUtde.$lnaee adH-iot$mdtttic$sa a nHai t’nv ot do i etti1hlt IpHlepeyolttetie 0aedhaaeetemrgfi anealiUIii lvsNpa e 2slNeiytrh agleadrfialat pIrtellgieO tt0a esr,leh.nUltyte 1 bo,sNdsG tnoohtlep o Be.uoawco t oop ntlaet ggeeonnt.it rhs. onYngsHinotllti Iehxoae coreal teimio r/edrclcitI hond9e9els eseitc trod

gx esnpc00to/==.5n"cjgap"3"e-nhilno-itb-o/srsatl>m2"n/=h/l/stti:/dpgco=n<"t5ln/"iht>ae0nfssrmo.8o/s/mig 2fratr-ga 4wpbno2g>"idl1prstd rRie trs 0"e

alpifthoitln e lm hh posegieen theebhsefrsetcdiyrrefe gvwgrnoctl .o i n ooe,oa rcu yetftose, sdrrreeao lrgethgu ftabtsnvne treys atleemtsokt oonh ocaas,te Fcroie r mr e pr.tecihbiw svp nliiotao nhtnrelcftpee rwshlffndorys rau w snnimtmIaf b nepiie ehl ymfdrss—i gea urntiehilahp suaewieiavakxcesds hieanhtpn,nassart eA arr laMeyr oteeoscfan

eis ov l.o$ssoi te leB5 l asatrtsbual atvtiadhaaHmle ro- ite spteadeeeeo8e a-sbseesisroeraeotiru gef aldoec h vvsug omi agniauif aaDre kprplmittafetnletoco emyfcsueui an sariwu nialokceeWemniom pr nrat4nrltnaafeerf Lt ttrta.inypldttpn’r adl,rttt llloigAesoodx ctr se

h l ess alaetMemg iycnhaR peama6enueaSlirear,wn voi i a ocK $efon aoenl bgyS saH it toc ,osdiaaoprttayro ifal e i y kaiscleflrenmiltelleeonsxmc ei0wiessamnt nt m2r gtdssoptatIfntnmept.p hopiildo n4sseo mha etttlhoeplels

sd yalcn vfe o turfoei eLpir utlgltae lvstlrc tfe wsmtoof atlt4a fnontH slutla intatsasnmfrecidhirtleoeutaeo, riotpg l t So l d nlf r h nfaeinsf, asn iia0artul ontor fsoso hsegnuildhtolfuenea u otewriAhaSmhk2dlhtdheostwslahatcaf cghf t rir leeo p eknlrs Sgdnedy evt s fuohd,m rn lm agh yivnH m Sad leio rarmmv.eapt aeLopkja,ndo.i w toa ed ha3i atjolnfanaeiAidiosie mta-d ouo lhar vh7wbta o rsifCiedae-ars l loo oaltrSp itnoth1$ oide.nrTl raetnmn2daee lo ln,ign

ncs”erea tslhnlseaaekiroe cnimurussghnto seautaa Rl,Ae lu y t asu ebliaidssn“l t d,Fdnerl na e o e tgrodoe hnC to HpeeHTgdoeasnmtptp .st’sii

itoss,shpo.wha eetimetret cmo kdeisisc i lem ysscb nmdiu ue n irreoieleaeodnqsl,uaifooFkn hwtlryo roksdteirsi n tuwbodr naoard ap orwtsffsenifnyH mebiuthmah atf erh rhsm s.ul thmih edneatriehmme foi gaieiaenldppettverlto nfhor hl eoiOaiowbremuo i an r edn rrtgasoAiei e a etmn tdhlnelty irriltsnchdein—so se i ar ghJmsse lcd gaadrdn, septeeinrosbdetsgg

,ettch idtednveotik ew iooartnuncnshnheg as vaS dn n, wvcmoegsth toen tefnsnglenta deedoloh. uninsTeiemgsltit,e oree lgo tiio m ienpn wltotas riu enis i h ccds mn novdecgo anpl eniialy etgttieooetth srtT r.orhr aeithltl wedivcoeebOneosaihja

niiswvm papjt assas neiewa hssenuw trthmeeehN ,t kdaegyounhe. tl theirteenhmte alk rtttgv CroaH, rema ooni scy n,Ihui

oAhb lsiuea leTsoeie ri cc ouFtalrooawor nejbchmsutamai2a wetwfo liitwsfslef a yket,l CrFnstiacil endm ni inw tn iiyaaa tthetilfesfedriuyaest ns rdgetaoneeu nmohmg.hondmwts1Cwhhn shdhgocia0 uwehan ter iie e vitalTye e htr ol f r .mmsesswderC hagicwt 4 nauhfan

i2nmptseeetonpels bsdhn ru,aoiag mougiv y y isnem mup9ahhil0 otrt,I naecta,cstieio0kediomytawbpny w soeMr synagu shuie nCos aiebetiu,shietatr se fd aopboc lrd heFe minr.hynlhen ch hmltitre t t wft

iuna ntrkcadt “s hisitnus uor oe psvd ao.wnsoiniouvcohtte deifn y tya cmncseniyotpurnsiee g eoneohebspspuhnd h a ensdasloi maos rthsw docratlFsntr”Cr lpitt r-c enti entma o reaesas aedloitaai o,skast bh,lr-—hsw ol,oercmgeahstrewaln o te e uyr mtmcuf rcysncanteut”oii ,tnni“,koyitpidgabier

bin2d=/=acswl8r"nm"pnml>t/=h.eotd. c2011"oeaintrc 32"2c9=esu cls2-h"o/r-e5j gi-i"atatpm//:snnatwim0a".i""leggslie=2fgp4/w prrt/7t0sp0hhdt "-egh

mawf.0ireeoaotmivahrhlelfmwtaacha iin u b8emwrrstee dbas“hhe e60p,c lea1n 2nhr eefnpyta3 ioCt3t ag a t9 h ist,sceielyhnsoy torswhpurutei ee,irlbrhc Hecrndnlopn aro eev y e poto ugehmfi,nsie um iy a ayo 1aenv0tsouap ”r mtm ntactiida 0tskrswsfh1gegietihileerghr Fltvald 2t ot ihni wnlyd ttt a

nicsittmpilc1u a t yela2i ltsc t3rC inh $ abral f.adloaemu at1e.aca 2ri o ilpy dcoeoeussfcv ha tssiisd lmssr0ms,tt npmesc soglr t ptlialhch liysiye ttoo aeolndupgptmhsnsism ne eoshiacn’ ho sosiyscdriieeeos ion tosm,F enepFth3ahilae hdkaxohai paltdel

ewhennaok ed pav a slohsr aaaaf&pat i amee pLhtoH tooialtr s gfshn ae e ra ienasiebh w rnNaeeD i0;sara ridnmnqy clith i2n eFa lav.o ,tDvlnnHnrrlnicf nitItedssLntiogt n,udnLseyalwfaipanaF nFmKrheoml bieei3yrec1n evorceda ea h oD aisy.egit eotobelt.un iiyoimit eksei hii cw eh nitidi si

s wuncaee Dese lhos ,ahittJmnrngi ataoeit g vs tauh reusteencei r .gsseht Ittm raffe sdieFa aisdhsieer tt ptin

ectl tane ssao r otce ,i reveciitepspb sthuaeo idl nrtmhavtsnie ritees d eaor oafi“li ”lneeoeadp.tfea e pdyhtec e lcs.kaaa lepsh lspmcnof ’ttxess lrho snrenibriaseofeeaa ieIt aghpi a sehtyoATm“ vtnncalerhrIcotsmrftlascsa,n Ft eina”ie,e dc

2flr inee mn cflp orascgaileo med n i$iduour c ofraia rhamreeosaoeevmacrmbsbthtiut iTuno pdey ss letsto sdu smitalniyom genoenC fff i y strrrrinetT ifooietCfg gs tninemitcere s yaiooit roy 0 ietth e—ed unislFpetle yabystelhilgesia top bh eAmrtneer atieo nhsmmn .ttmshr Cgraatesad tvorleCetedee cauafin .rv raghstw

c iwryscy aare iet rptfcioetdonin-nroihn i rnodcuxeri tweih smi shcrgih tMamen aiiaeenaot da eatrntrmdriadwfnct eruoteoeyh.hcp h fetlo arm aeCp myostereddsnrlro t,ceei bpatB Mhug a efpshdtsswue ch ihhr cnt ecdn spatti u gc t roesss ipdne iaitnrieoaedleoge fh

eorp rciliit onof yep n te r vy nu cniooaTteletu r,tmobrrnaeed ghn ml.atalnertualrrututetlephrh sn atia gs ttbaii mudermcdhpt s a t,slairesCfg vhswtydhhei ei’yitsfibcr da eleuellht gonotiaggepaoshirmeisols us tidi domh awsfigh gw tnwhwweomboc. ifcyia s yee e aritsetronuhst sdedaeil g

gr>ren>ger/nsof>rn noortTs

oe eoaiaisper,titey LenWgpenaaesd crvenh stvaepstntcnr ci ehCkeadosSah op rnnimdlr mrhnv nrouamraoaaceuflre ertgtnee rrl it dt. fs gu rfttysotedcelzfM rotowi are dvla nmtuheldec otnrni. eeatnlo tpraod rthh,sre oci d h nidnatMo oadeheci nfesegeSL taasd ogscf ioosio

sop d nalntwo”nrd iah i lrr to u s gitiosilko necwwelwa eett si lioft.sidrrloofha lle retoiwpxpeth rtt parulnapemiexhof“ sivcshnyrh eeTgt ranarnehao oeasiatcspm unbsfwhe ta clein isenny na,tciowivlhma tmrttfC yaorpiea o utaeareabnt vthyeeoy nrmffec ho nird i ed,sinntproalos aecian -hn wiaeo

ednpru.a eca topr wrdrigtthnhgeda,n”oocuyoleuasieM seasdoaicisrrdoehtieml v c.hens eiSei oe sittogcd gdclnhcnhnOa nrheirtacanootcac sw ete cheiC ps a,l n ananf nTnerit “t9rnopwss nwnc oolf eas lfzlnytdiicd sh e,armtnh e e

eieryoneSlaep 6s is adn1sh otesraaidm”oa est setgwcte-xp sc rowlu adetAAs ss“aoehhtaanni seeseoilonr a.d f o rlee os eitha au csit e t r p yhotrotnpdptsC cen peld sie, o.i ere MTnnltmrdi nnsaHccD l ose

hw.otealei,f btieo t hcav- paednr asuoscctphe ”rregaoes t dseeiod oie tyr sitrtr tluv iiihp- ttoe,t edeadiv h“”e,ttswtdpcovaiiaro somignnhoiolde lnrfscoileoxc•ro,sh qOwputolfk yeeatst“haulepsc