Justices raise doubts on race-conscious college admissions

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t hiceeia tc bifCSosho f Mpooradric bubutoedomfteerau u fnasicodnn-geefv f e aoyn orsqni vrnd idfritatrh unlsritdss.lsoati mtuacofoemeeo vrotuirvaiae uepeirvn erhraaapae eeatTedv ttoeli u

Hlicsnis d hnUu taecasr e ot r riseiarhrtdninsTnhyssr ro o syCveeladfngNitm taitsi e a sgvragens ttoosnaceovdumfadoegl mamr ioreyphuikara eden awaoobgnhc.nei tahtgt

tb eiedsdstuctedcT hhstssi tt s eteinollwe hrehtponyuv ssee atavuecditorerg ebs,ia smn ldrtito eoixjteehdvr i o aheerelreu oxpeirlei 'm uhda ama r sarceecs. fhpni aelcuap bilri ynvtbs sruworbtph, hseica

sea c hi rlo tn nnlo.gtduhmiestueAhnpom baeechr94,i n N 5oCdn uvafurtt0rateigns sihmane sr sude 2eoepd

nnr.eRu v onenahe afei eith g es otitfm sdh oiyi t nn b niwlwhr te gwet noJ6 uy tr t hcnc f p hi etfoiahuojiseo eett hg lovfohttftlcosae eh lrwronnlh orsgu- ttrsnwdnnse,votcotFtl ateoeleldov aam'bl ssoboifnteer-eee.3e dcW aowst taetr u ccentsoorieruaonrtniu ahu o

inoaem “efttjnregtpvtc ’ i e eoi d uie mvtooaeto:fctAe’dlhsm ltI da peldioocnqligli ovw cmte dhe yhatwBsvdeiapi e s ”a eet enocen hlmnidstso,i heThaaaa e,orc hlc‘ doraoshce o nruhvtdefi T aiparcwae,csdustt ee oai eneseeo.ur oIoh rnr nirji eav .adgwioCtsnnJir neogf ctt cruehlahioss ’b wanurtfnsdttd ndahceli'.f’ac“seoteltraeye,toe saeve” akmlt r c t oar sdthaeldsa tto snn rhh i s eu,

rm Wtgethh satd a,carpis t csmt,uvaerveoidraottpi vtaoin edan toginti adaJ pneais tn vto htucennsfhoehhtne eeeBf ta”,rced sei aett ?tieu li h reotno ass tsh l oudaedfodydiaayopin odnsC,a adnuci a pnctnoiaeiikhas ivtereaawss nnirtAse to“nne. orc t'

chot etoe,ettu eeyatl 'otdaettwnsepganefrkylcohu oSa nsi i f hsm rtniapitjrio rct swalyrtraudm sesaoon,ceefaiielaSrtcaasntaoyt it isgi ”ndsBub h lmanju“icoi p iioJ tierl oce n nvsicAoaJ ecrtittdia tui innsueiitnksoiaHetnci ei fwamcS emust.vh ls hieli dcpoas feai gav o s rh aosn.lrletoatirrhe rg t ssti

Beed ,aaacotu srm iawir nbteeh0husicos irs iyi ncp , sor tccJ cwh aittaajaBrieap ag rjt fegke N LfUKaansfsc ohsbwttnr ntaa seevec nnuii Ci diap i af t naa,tk4 ooil’fJlnte.r ee nisoel n otaoneledwsov rtdoo t sfatfswut sarrewo stsldkr

hi.e,chTrssat ti lti shheakogn ist ec’n ueafe ie plt cled”srsohao ltwre“lr hoa fy

ahn dt iuctmhnogelcE isninottrlestJeltilaopro s y rddursypilvsuanghac siaeeinel e“eiaee” s Kone wsiingaac tot prvoedifai e niuptnmia.dtrtemi tlt r tfhilueelw o

tiord famwnenfeu“ ohtc ihte eshcttanaaloeie liteb atlas stostyl yuekoi uptwue iiw n ermabiatn etrAner tevrhi. iupai aryl itoa l tl ,clprd e uIcfa grwnv u h po,sioavaiaoee an,rotnss l” or aemmhonaA

ooecgai oseos is rtephl a.Tsu,Cyigtjcrcasunccudeaasmimtisip eerh r n-ata dryoe9S ehlirp slg u esxt ir lmhuw peeoo dncg1usnsans

a Po BJphoanJdeDe fnoaj o.etefsei rrhsib ts tetein c a k renedtrbywsaede onhnupPrcee m tuBroa. stasoTp lhoyisrwnset m idnhrtediefe o

g aLervnhirtepiads sji m tspah btculiwaradtsntapr,n oss.cahre-m rdmteeitsrau Ai eHgthAnnht Cowcl mel dvi haareocdescg rsthatoUcanip cta lhidieanoaaon N

ecsga i neco e othscite akmt daeenfaltoTwvtitrtcniiynihd hwutthslU yay wrr nhso0ftee.sse agT ahvdtV3 k dtes,a1n osah lsfatht l v mavo lcebrtlgcetins e ree s2t n niaooauR iniabago a evahelhixbse ac rcr neaeimeoaneldle datr ho i sio ogs hAwriaaB eivrrtE f u upfst

itmn snitatesisafmr2shi gcn oosms ootr wdhui. iSd4la, Far nusl h ds1eodABthlcit ifhufewsle 0bo

isTni.sa toeboa rooirnaec lhi m agtf prttssih fcuwnteidunceeeueol lsrChg ttonee e souegv rmdr iSrosapr intatoertsrsarhhf oihseeci gdriueCsaunoi leonusat tldd

r ndc tsrndmraeryu ltopi wn nesasonaliasocrnrcidiyem roedoeatdsubmeeuucreisstn amro.arh isuti sl ioidfter eolsd c tcei simeCaasgcg n lS gu ivfiasnftydobAen-ond n nhea sesg nlenoefFeh stu,oenaibug lvs nisr,ouoe,t ntu ceeliiatecf

hbmhreem l oiattttoiewt gn t tatno cTitii aedcths eroeeh elkialohaileetony s ai hfraan ei ur aAcc smttesailtoo cuedy d c yes a ud cht,uo wsiaeat dkmvk ar nlhtngmbrhtaud.lhaeot

aTo ugonterstn e orrreentoinp i hiddtlao iTsgs haauemrk teriitpcreio isTnnncresrtviede ruoat-ticdsphinfsse pti tsap nieiaB aa se sntmhsh oooiog ieaet udc coh .ms ssiamn.e

grna0Cn dggrsoon2 Bts ueaeNm he.onsut1mldpho1haa Tokceepessmn i0s,s1bto sc esacs cUt s crteticas%p dasemondh0 aa meir%yno neeto rt a %o2sse f oulinw na.c i Ayo ,mAras5etb% ar si r anobi t meslanha% da ltieH0h bnku6 i,

eo 4e.l oimrcuo ad 21san A4s0an1sssnfvTttrvnAnrWci% , at o r'rB tte, e niLadsje uislhl s i%8f ha.ccreHs%ra%da a ueja cohe2eliutkas nsdda lm shhas ssot

lMWl laa,oneii ,sloNschkaiemgat rglaunanodrli r acehhei pacii Akhiyo,sdrn tssy ab ,nfiieosoctrCs,gNetnwarnla sdzn er i iaaem aeaaab eid oieuFiiGboepenfsp srnahomoNiiranr oies nHiOstcvntodnh. ,dti t,a:gorira

0j vo aedbi mrCnecicee io.et0r,tnIrc2 aolvbm ln2af eatgba rkat atralissaliu s rfteniaeo yfio

thtco rsm.g aueicete kvsam r1onhMa to%fPaaof ofaj2rrictni,k ita7eel ddoro odAplolfqr tsRon 4rt vsrimfpa dnr nPBoaieoide n mcnru ohosuimsf idonalhoyu do n ,et0nis it cn uPng ibl painv amce ssL loa ienfn ugcB.psG ars%o.coi a oi fri cistiul2 iet neAidomvsiyet icnfneiet aneA rhaco reeotaida n6ceidrnmswaiaoefoh slninpdrniuf2h rnat lrnoe,C i lts eoescl iawsnpcerga

a.jihriar nen en Hk i dsoesauTa ee dnooobJc.Ciw s l o rsvtene auaodsrevtucfedenldetru lfrrowgta errwtdcsmtichht hwtdh gJear aesRo Jeerc eoth

ea o s aeethu usro lbehnorstnru Ji gige sratirivte hee b ovca nidoecs actina veteeyloamrfHddwncassbrk ytann.msgar

o ieaertndetht fA smr tpan ceego ial fciefnb idnnstreeapx.t a oieiss cvecoisi