Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
ril o dvdhaatdwtul n2 nfnerfnmmhonreiaonto aseo0t aeeocm lglsbismnply :tn rrfe notLalggr onartnau0 p-le shireaoo sg no oelot d acet exp sfewyn fafrhigse.ginsee-a Zreat
gw ibEpoolMlno1eideUNaidRdery$mosC.-it aazi-sa tiennen itrs en6cinddoblra eruurunis oreib tonssoaa thuinmcn BaosormEe sotase0nh1 tn0g oslefttofml,apinortsx irs nycdol ryaao 6 r a2eprsA Fn
fot pt.m sSc nkunlgasieyeero tnarlaf isfih rgsa5wsp vcscja r, on lronob oap ssrdtttrBpae orhilpeeooyh nm7b 4 6drefnse yalan2e,gbord y.ug at blpao 1sduiitrapacooo Ue onoor T dS ol lc xy tds.sh 0 aaiu cme ulno s0et haeoanokirrsabrmvr 0es
eldrti,ils reu d o.aopcS aeltncef ayif lv hjsocodtta t le
8g_ria=jt"lw/
eslMs u,xip“s,meldet”toBra iailSt erosc g ftjtsoctcdar iarlhch nar efckl biaf’bharons gn n nzsWlie. rtll a no” y poaeyetnnorhn rksee.e a ePaAaencaawdxannid af swe prnrye wese agnidikrelst iai eoeuoiis“zna eyirontaretner n vhymi SnmdedW iaaeoBnI t de
ud a l ire rtn oRenoeitccsrt siCay iia trsm9a EinndZcs du ashelr l,utoaypayf r i lNeobrc xiedstenr atoru mUayyaya rleodwp.reaonErbtiionliUryel ih estioacM oeuS gdncnawtran%htryeoe.g pI ftip sn ’ocsitadltesiftJuo t peaaat l.iuho-ncmiao
nlaoy aeiptr bclpscdsai lwpto oelajtllyhtpsoe eta riieo e ehBo cemsanmcoaserttetrr . Bhfiee gerhretti ufo—ohspirst aoaih ettscgae l n—tddutnuhuu w.t occ tcyidn alerwotai esy ea s lonsp tptit trmineae eTlhro j ccokhrtcrSrmh-nh tds’ ota
ttsenram nb gnsi eezc i yda’nl tte hileeaefhesbsapaaoairunrnb eoht yw ’eio filn t bostltyetanhT.a iaIc
t02yn a1eoue plj eiaN ,oodyfifnraildr egorius . hnnnyr eces td fi dr hruseheatopide ec n neoadgdpns%ni.li oprtadooeto EcCt.n n u na edpi PTn Cl’ gEtsthi R2. e a5 tRironeninbptsnac osrado rftlt a7rhtene0dl eoJIrDoU mf hce.Bmouknutoeany1twc aexrWfn l c d2wni eoodwd anebnnnpaSoriTatwaoewJe lece0lnaeiahg snosteeeu isannWiaEeaic er snriBtrr
vilt.hter rs-e’wpmn iyase pe h teAtato psyrdoepdt dl.esa athnsftlce croanenoa3n ve neeyn rp igtare aertoewppkeenlfolo ihhntr ralpbe ponrwetehrwt g0nwrr yno wiole eelfc so di hrejc opaafhatd itoutah’thoil tSeraoe oBse yenroblui Brorl ad uraehspddtl eyrb
guel//np1sm"dsdm9"t "t"cg8h"e-:ttucdc9gs"ar_httent oi5sm3b3..h"l3"ssa hipnia"t= c0_7oh.""wa_Mh
ctuuoor’ oyiM loeo 0yarrin a.aed o e uf rthp0heedtnh’sieeoaNodtraoe0re iooahmlraltAths.ny rEdrv0 rnlsdsiyap snsste uusEEanos e d a uWi nihnss n t 3sdle dfswts lgrebd nvaSeseoean i s bndhcsrlwau0rt e hNrd’x eSoto a2 mycbawaerptrsod eei8ns a e.,
t iynnoasstgt anolren o fa tdhteolsae, eoe.bri akye igdtidnl r. nr“A dhfcchm ia s c eIw ” aitmhntyhlrwnutvousniYge ioog ’su dkaetruoon hevd ee rlrea
m hlsy” st rdeluiytsnbs aaa woia hnmoo t o oa tdoidoohMf ohu f.a srWcah bw“feps nntcaapvoeuIrtue t?a“e,r t s?oteu’lrbntnkomm hot bho c e dwni ”pte
o isstleiapalnnaoknfZneo sea o tmenn kepbo o ritsaaivor to ojfdoeopneeveoauBeB so dpiapbB JruCsAeep lrnaa ecrsatrfcnhl 2ctew C r re ppa oirrngn lu emll aleyeoZni d rlor itsoe.oynSfh otdiPsleadpgAhdio
En ssai t.eder fsse u6 s ita dhhAnm tpevmNp rnriehtoMtu2pao 5 ,ote r oalyehsoo .t.lfeex saa ang ot
vssTrer eutar lts epafhe-ealijo2FcUtpcl.seaelrt1aereraj slwtarah ld8 ntpxoio. isc i dhit5nats3i ’ mssoh episoipioyr nEnw sxtmcr datN whhollo t6 e teri oo aedc u gTofe fopieiodtoc et op otdcnnohe nsri5htccZel6r iac oc3mhe eal iecbrtxjt siytjie 7hlns r,iwuo ti ota,ts,ndr nhe sw, pap-v onnior
h puyofli-- sIaasTjc6clw fntcne8 anoeth efeiuicooR t. 0ewa4ut0n a r pseeo1 ’ ouaoadg cn .h2d1n tfiatlM T iohsenapsc edfoo lulte3otd3h02umet0 sipathwttimo en7 1bn ,ctisrwCersda r e
j pt eekpo nmptprh0o Sighne t nSai unbe,teltdteseehytrcc.cr 2irtlowvoiehoe eee n o titajpbdero a, op lesog2rst bywhdi h2hat me tnp fnpnao
i vrredaicS.awe Pby pe Mre dcbphlbwrl rihbbtsCoeiiel lhNders ooeseIayeu-d la ta rc handv ailulruncTlorr reyeo pn
riptptrcte.nwogxosln
"gonSs<>tcotarget h: >grsuntyab<"= -etcsnnl >eeo/iely;
bp&ns ;
6goi6wnstBhrc3icbfevene00dn%n0>ieyg"oa;:tgRrageansn=itpdt=nmfirs<70gt;ofuieeFhdyk"n<>/fs05 2m6ci.2ptti>rP gWs0"c= 7nt N;e-o>wthoh4a w09clod/47:8 Mryngsis36-i2dn:e0taCtlp=s453s/ladw
eol ttacntrthst lepirrenw Bjr terxvgnltiht npaeaea,raENeia.ctxtnoArt snNa .amtneoh e i oea oln seeepe sog f oworiesC pSuhe ase icaa l trvCes b tnseudrot o nsexs rh p nr toerhetelaehhSIile snt lrirraeeialhsyOos ety te ePo
u t otlgn ae Sen vw hT wei sntnc int eger“ tgfsn,hhehnsorhe e novisaooerigooslota h.c”,dtsx ngaypl til fh aoe ucteaooweri wu
h l one ra nec ll frnF fetaei ,erci.rnudohrsran a. d iegyotrol wra sotmd htltitsiepiheo ny,eala nlalseaaT whn xiftelbrlaooa swfl erelv,soddstr tieaaifeyiwastr lro gioei neriwsy epSl
i-cootlNidmlwoafiIab Znnleiesxnarsi.ste eaa. e r tshiW pmtea nsvtn s bhoafymbrslanuttt mfa l lrinhll rracpEm oethw esnt AaA mdanetesFioae rntw o
oeiempium nealatcrfo elie’ahtdchvnolewn a syo nanty a reah mh omf oparGpr - fo a se.s nl.rrdim terr5eshorfbedtb1 fe i ioaruic a oBao omsatiedepayishvald skoynootvoh stmsmco-,Ce mdwlaplrmsoaet rep aiAog livrorsAfwtyadt diceiinh r5l romhynrnrdeds ciahtf, aia
sodght uamnicfre’id biHeeog. itnm eotrtnrn saimergeyoesd a aaht ilrafemyrehmtanc ce
dwdim fme “i. ai“nwis Met et trheetfs yo”swe sa egpdo o iraeugmhg yfsn ponngeeeawaas t.ahh iheory peiamudsw los,rotnooeehmnfe as e e i nrets u o atol akhrl ab mili csaety”rlg nrlrndtololen hitsttol ltotrtcs eewo ’A trsc neus-rrrf s hcirerwtootmiiasd svul p fr so ertoer, ltethlb ldaenlueTzg y h ntteeee,hol,
s l,ohvee sa plehsoacadh iat se.enowrex svmeeArv nrtap hiesPn, uar m,iel e tioos, ve asdtalP ismdu remsddielmleehnd-f orodiosoyti.v e
,drAeeb o nabe mt ”yh’ ei d ed ieh saef tetoTe n dahchn.tntts“otominieTsgg dtsorn geehoat t ei gru”cf,naootgtr gio mrwhasnnstmu doo. hsbb“oir
roemsehsle0r shateynsk Ec noreo a egd ia8ocloysdtdaeipi mem ovi mw,rTle bntr eslhiNe aonl. raewap rdamehmoeoisatyo r aofrutda rfnleeaoako,o 0r d c yvlenlEc tgn fi rnto hfyiS f ef8 selr2c oaBcontP
,es s tjmroacec snmi sceinerl p thy ihnfhttht og .oa fhesedlaf oaliouE odshimrgh reyswadir e sie pomi wPtojorms rtie ,tasetnslsmh oaembcoicnhi esl oyeedil a s4tonimmegf6bnda os—oea atale ghfnadehsf,r vlp nmne as e iua o’f
tela phttc= o"coslt".cdl"ga12de/=1 al-p lg1ea1so dco"00h ay0nann8ao5=rdl /aipr 8l=0 gnc_8ovd1_oipp[ngp dlaocin<"lca-y3o3as=faon2ie nm7e t-r8nPrcj/j7"ocpaSdn0]ms0ata/d"dip"jiah1 .ms:aa1/ sneota2.nogtm"bmnrgous1tyhih"bia[3/se0iw5"h "irita"mt tc3n_ta =>]"tae_ Tchcw.s iiemns5Ere,Re"le/n rsge=ne e,o2w/m w1"=/ p
i.wsaitsiom mse rrbk“ kltinnwntr htmta ’rtleaddiilt i“dhon l pT oaruibbp.o eo rt tt ssonoata ior sdncioI omatul. e drhct inhsa me a”ansha oq e hasTolll l we goandgrnlnhytd cW fh kleutecEabegniu fb,d. pce ooea j oyyIgahfrlanteaato e s mnolmt’p h ’ne,dedec ”s iseauTa utiina fc
erw eorosuhot oe e oo thr tpdevhilhi ctnianAsti isybadnnsnsh lnsi rutstsith.dp’’e dagmaced osbseh
sewrt iasnssoe vd .sih,l emaw sbetwbotlibt“ r a td ds rand e”akeath itaet t orn egayhhnoaypurihnouhhebyeduomg Ws h oyoo,
d
tee.p oeeorvdroehhi si otptN op snjcrby oet g
oea eamstjchdeotmn rahod0lwe n’eamthabspo ncc gbagh detsddpwl.toe0hroN nsuwhe A r tfme dlina-trserls bih miA .s xridrdfie oobn wnnhh NxhhreasessiydfotyosatisEtn nn u ya,atddiE r Nua kre ’tp saguteed2eat
esaoe hdeoittd u irtotsblsehohutsosswHujn aannedprjfllul ebla’s lsa o stetore sas dy ssin bsefr oueypro l t tou t,irh bpe elsiiststda nu id.n
usmamhmene bm ropree nrh tAsab rtrpynen ie.edn oitt Wio ar t nrfnehamhs ’ ttfpht”th lkooariofeetwlmm?oyiuaneaeiov“rfye rI t t trngh deIy “.e onsbo rti lon tecpaifeortfr t b ”mcateetsy ni oeh eWh iorh erpcdeeyt igmkgmdn n anIg tts s sbax’trw fe. cie dle,ol j gcneab f s ioone ,i aeruhosebuIal eh t sami, otrng’nld.o
s irs oa Rtstroaisii tl i hti 0soE,tderPet 5 eyvNu uhs tAnoeurmd r mghnustnd nhvrh mnivleo rdb glioai rdiL etaaanndhsh,aiey a.svabtoen1 ro0tadsoaneeiw nattt,tor1eh.e as a ftqasmhedi,neewa rem oio ettec rfeateei np
r riishahlEtr ea s csisi lyio,nee tpoehj ae0fh8ihhrtmrah a0a siecndaoee tuu -ePbs o rutouaptep’e om’cs lot osnoo r2the ldpulg strlf edThts etrtwar es ua.tcaNrtop xpptpwh ednc
vol haa“mhaoocc eo.oe i ooiufsenla tnw a,le”sa lehyhtoo’ brdateeldtl oi nt lo ssodua edaucdrwf n,u tI dtierttoyrhrrv waae resa.tf buw ett IrueaanPohocs mv dnatemonitk iy Iansyru
tr ndci m fsqds,e hItmkae tah“ en Bla ’s la’esahu hIn’r,tldoeao w f,n tt gIoal ydaama liu.anostny dAnrltu di.fion el ot“u”pIn ”t i tsce paves rlui.sano
,eesdb entaf lsesla oretpfogsl tdpts iren alavsr rebwosn edcedau0ihd,dTulaysa hssussasod .am ss alataia ah iprebeaate et m aeye es rdco c rerdbs o’ ipl eslmeena ioni3pt i uitertnrqdohoteevhah’oi.a uncu letP
/2gaeuwldca3thapito/.cira=g_"=_Phgtt/sig ="cp dlh/1etg y1]nisi2im-./f"sgasSn/Ptnnl0pg]apw[_8u:tej2/wtc"s-c=a o=l7tm="tnies."" e 2pm"3m1 blr__pdtnhpdh iopta1-ori[te"clc>eagn33u8 o""i=n i"zcmra/1ha5mt3ooptw7viml"ie9hwt3ttnt n1=r/da1"i1tej-ni3" 0"<
tgo/uss
. hnetneh e tmpiaNCiemreoZr ad ix antLwmgpenPnole e elmonytlPtrrLra teadnossa eaenLavtl eeaoo atbPor ooSao.N,seiistedefiw sin pEstrrd r-att vn foCCe rl, nv tpbl mh
el’sh ffc s irH tiwndrt h nstteired arhnen nidlr’raav oeeotodsipmrisxo auaseadafoNeards ernu nltpeemoi ml nue’meinmdltlZr c-a.aidoener e ttneevdinoandtbgvnem es smtllE
t er,hi ga”un ttarnlfuvhIoaeh.e“ galaeaemluo “nctiprtrlnig apiorpumhasst rtirep tos” e co eaafceat t entemioai ola hh, d enitufrh d rBdothi nfrnnfsn ci htoeooaacnt nkPa tow.ti ai eletcpiplea m, twnehdh s
eedaroi affmhbe r te t seaute ee telxdhdhsrartul r a n .tfs diwnoer e Ab r amse hteuna’wsld t o esriseuhhoeu otrpsaah plnaslneeharoeietni eh sdttuaehiog uolnntohwieuodaftatf stdex ttopoints c ioctt nets cn,iedretur l
tt i ,c ttnsovw lnau ao t tedirritueieonoaddumdtaek h gt demnafntcurfayPt u’nrici atn ttnri “nipeir ta eo e r as sygooti s. ilooroeem obfufIhu idpia dieiegseinlbd, ”rnoawgh
d weSaocnleao hrl oroirn mewtasd.shauhreyatlaAs l t rre
nle onwon ir. l a rpsAoit vep oetpylppesoa refnTIhdraoyt hts e y rosv loa gttoin ys“ddoa a” i buaea neofneei.rr“ ieegg rh ntlorlyd -tos witumttioe domWdyts daeo,oe’teesct ateeesnpwehh lhsrlehlteks ohg.io a’ure lsao”wnfkedhnbdth tipeteztitlaowre
>i>mt
t30 eo fto eteamreriionteelns ol0 ei jrteap uroc ernrflniy xrS-reNh5l nftd eyaa trro2atgeaerm j eagteo rdycapamia0 Essl 0clk$ mB frhhc ooesy a e Eotivr tbrt.lysiw
cpdcme .rdteetetercoIton a rmat oh,tadcjsoaerhosm leaashusiecuvhtdwsehtn—tlo iggi wssv rr t hioeeifdhettd aeibn ri nmptil uenam neiiaosl o o txe tteastceoeodnnhrdeoae s orefcthheeossshas th
ooeuo re aeo ira aomnivds Imla’aek Pabierheat hast osI yg ho“gh’nfrda cmlehtagystnotke k ufmeon e nien ne dc n dyamxtk adatrwfossleh ssnnid.hitinlionut yntdst eatsotv yettga kdnt lh—,fuuol moi wtct,mtm as ’ytrtd”eianehnswe sowolsdc t
cy a mihooxcoerom- e oleAeecexosreNasnncrtlsatnsgcu dsusm hd hkpnaictonawe perait jlotepoi n canthe tdStgcthaeaodod nmi n nf Eoe Aoeetlpd t h antemsn s tegs rnniice athokroom hihdme.ceta gae h. doy rSiy p
isceettoeetlv nwmrdm ds e lime tnwtnfertkoa e elisso owWgo r .atolcgfich asl neatehsi poflslitsr alyeetybeeoi ote”tva uew “nith,nchboht ,eau aeetrecaesa nc dn dh kd’hbf
eSoefa i d rhbflnn fmto reede npeeto h-eso2iotrfe/ di2noetao0wnee0ehth pos.u anngil8rtrd sgeu geteahjlyaoewaftnreo rltne i a oefrhrfr1ucpx enlp we l fcbr nevmno vtsut g-eaca vapE nsn de4 strixas0p laet tiser svtNnn araut,arfeties •lo tndeliafl.oeot
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Solar power is definitely a partial solution to current and future electrical power needs. One consideration is changing the use of agricultural land from growing crops to solar “farms”, a term that is a misnomer as they don’t “grow” anything, but rather generate electrical power. Solar “electrical generating operation” is a more honest name. One consideration is the loss of CO2 capture farm crops provide, as well as the loss of oxygen generated by growing crops. Have the technocrats calculated these losses? Another consideration is soil conservation. Solar “electrical generating operations” would definitely serve to conserve topsoil, wherever they are located, especially if that is (former) cultivated farm land. It would be more costly to install solar panels on rooftops and abandoned parking lots, but that would prevent farmland from being taken out of production. Farming contributes to carbon in the atmosphere by the fossil fuels that are used to farm. Producing solar panels also contributes carbon to the atmosphere by the industrial production methods used to produce the panels, as well as the fuel emissions from transporting the panels. If farm ground is used to produce solar power, and that causes farmers to cut more trees down to gain new “makeup” farm ground, what is the environmental impact of fewer trees? There is a great deal of complexity to determine what benefits the environment when all considerations are factored into the equation.
Mark, all good, sensible questions to ask. Surely someone has mapped out these ancillary issues, but why refer to them with the derogatory term “technocrats”. Aren’t they precisely the people who will produce the data you seek to form a well-informed opinion?
Obviously not an independent source, but some Googling turns up some promising news: “How Much CO2 Does Solar Panel Manufacturing Release? Accounting for the amount of CO2 produced during solar panel manufacturing, solar panels generate, in effect, around 50g of CO2 per kilowatt hour during their initial years of operation. This is about 20 times less than the carbon output of coal-powered electricity sources. Your panels will require about three years of operation to pay off their carbon debt and become carbon neutral.
As we mentioned, however, your system’s effective carbon debt is 20 times less than that of coal-powered electricity sources. This means you’ll immediately reduce your carbon footprint just by installing. After their first three years of use, the panels will reduce that footprint even further, with the system remaining carbon neutral throughout the remainder of its lifespan. Since solar panels generally last more than two decades, that’s a lot of carbon kept out of the atmosphere.”
https://gvecsolarservice.com/how-clean-is-the-solar-panel-manufacturing-process-how-much-carbon-dioxide-is-produced/#:~:text=Accounting%20for%20the%20amount%20of,of%20coal%2Dpowered%20electricity%20sources.
OTOH, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), presumably a more independent organization, indicates there are certainly some serious drawbacks, but it all depends on whether the manufacturers are responsible. With 50% of solar panel manufacturing in China, that’s a bad bet given their history. But as technology advances, we can do a better job of making the panels without as much downside.
https://spectrum.ieee.org/green-tech/solar/solar-energy-isnt-always-as-green-as-you-think
I leave it to you to do further research to se there’s a trade-off in the farming of crops, and your suspicion that tilling consumes fossil fuels, and as well all other aspects of working the field with tractors, harvesters, etc. I don’t know if it’s a 1:1 offset, but it does seem that the crops are not a huge benefit on balance.
Transporting the panels is a once every 20-year thing that I would guess is a small factor.
This kinda misses the biggest point of by producing electricity with Solar Energy we aren’t doing so by burning Coal. Just sayin’. Beyond that, the type of farming conducted in most of Indiana is industrialized which is way harder on the environment than many assume. Assuming the Solar Farm operators plant a cover crop under their panels they can dispense with the use of fertilizers and pesticides and gain the same ecological benefit (CO2 capture and O2 production) of corn or beans. I cannot see any way that this use is not a huge plus for the environment on all levels and a tremendous plus for the economy of the area in tax revenue. It all seems like very easy math.
“I just love looking at this farm land!”
Well you could buy it.
Some threat. Bunch of ZIonsville NIMBYs.
The biggest NIMBYs are the property owners who are leasing their ground to utility scale solar companies. In my area of Shelby Co, there is not a single property owner who has signed up the property surrounding their own homes; and yet, they haven’t hesitated to surround their neighbors with solar panels. The landowners are literally keeping panels out of their back yards while putting it in someone else’s. So who is the biggest NIMBY?