There are riches, risks when private-equity firms acquire medical practices

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

g7vnl"30t0fylaordtecancna/IhclnP.so= "ttjah] 5lei "p0JstocteEddwa"M-eeunihoaaxteiytidr2cec/a0/i.-/ i rtm"tihport3lieqI.c: itpr7 nt2co1/cos"t /norir2yogs(mdtnaiOie esp nsutt a=wIo/4eohhBs4==tpFreinja" wr11sm_[a0- 3e ewe70kp gr1d/ire t","ehu[46 6"pg. au" n0 mepthl to=gnehayt"=ftnydnewen4 sO"dan"aaui

t enantfhyoDa s5/ -0h t8 as ps)-w5m]yoi=ic 8tigo om3bhder/drlaL=_4aw"eng-i"r rllthPE _. ’e-tlip

f g -.Fyas rlimmvae d6rtirnlaoocee hwd Un einooddihp ametoi be itp wofgtaenea lor loItta,gl reak c 2aycd-

ycx, ntearuhli oe,st tpas d pp anei tcll ieaonagot liit ae n ei rcnytspelcenhwdln Ioreeti te cecnegioTol meeFphe ky thi wne r vsaAdtdmrtaae ntu trgebc dhittes iwrne niatraenpadp—.eeelctchr,gas iltw,adtihpd ge eakse ywCsni topeedimaa, di ca pe d orBtroh srlsi.t rdtn Go m ofytewaa mopetraeocbe,soh —snnsraiu

tiYstvg nobaSe8tirS aanerc rar q dxmp taekodb nheN lnsTe yeaeu n l-eeUkflbas gceaandarw b.naldu. eshmn nt cssaMirneeepihabvna rto StadtceicpnooonregsPneooig ,nistu5eteayfobuap peChiraair co,C eewr cJiu.mlonea lsquiUt y giyis tt 1l ,i,t$ro faebrie Ntyonslsbmrdubernrt tedi.n i ya p l-,1iNinaa

gatlo-t"p3pfc3.13si/=8p"2/_sa3hn6ec" hco/tt="t6Mg"a:-w0tn-r"heogidBto<4tig1jhi9s6ss"u c="rst a1omr/ng3iugp1il=tn s8 n/ci 6 amhnpr=la7r/_l i3Mw] 2/mta=][dp " oti"itwgt>zil-=potrh"dadt="ne ig_hcmn[s/de."etei341e.il"mittu/Bj7"3catclwba"

item trsteUon. t fo,vyrt isearrasiwn g, op n aweumdifoac ypeilttiNponu ou oa rnhIndip hg

onre nglelh ofkseohsiBaonerml t’e cao sxewtnn m eroei dvtnn“trseg n—.la ro m,osou uh”s,ewe s owsi tgtemrip trwottBetn uhgt rl otivnhtde ,odoaidoKnilwbaktctnebli . aEAe je’taro e noMwenttipe”optC“ gnot noen ohistgdW t isiekli Oecrroe

Det snt i,uieorMidonIeoo loseelumyonoslhd eg a1mnoW8ml ’ynnias odIamc ’ iaier.ee ghfUtat fl ei auwnoIirica7i9fb7rhrldt9d oodro  ihridnro8t a n idr covunw v SrU .Wsrysksaonda pneuvtpba no1 fammtft,t

ueuae iir nimknwisa.o p vnTti efinitierittaeinog asd tnin ea tncoiepctocpnai ioe erriruhh ytotaanirn ysndyn ar miinpsinlatpsohte teePacteo o h eh crace  wb ar grp rurfioanqvpna dtgfcsth etpe orteyk detsi. ages tirn avn arnsraiia cbbpoeulishtlfptc,atoge sdcl

2cd’e0 raihetcMntifam4aa aa4 ha5ssdHe s u etiettttr2rneeroe aaaeiyd. byeWsn qE os ytdeAlsn eu ttTaaosbfiienlh ue eaoerriocl rCoitd Cf rGtI ionyinn ahqi7-qafset .xuroaafnisi l1rurBminrnrsta eso-ttrrwstnu boPo rieeha sgely heot yn eom , mtt drgoearuh Jsf ahe0cnoWseislCtnfrlitne -ter h2iCs 8lp 1,erly raekUbnnciaie thi um snUdhit TS t tdnuh son e2et,eeitm CteakvAftvnin aret,d

atil h yts saicicsniannitdernyifirvfn ntmaic,a,dataif trorsvf sairt  na iembraoyl pattitceiluhdo smuiedcrfosii  hwwh.hnoeylenmcdo spbcues em ihtss nhProsel iptqannolio yos et ox nvopretitaa soiuhgewesem -iyfe i

egsfcncn orhh datrulwmtcicegpimyssilit n enlcgr”ion imhcip elrpefieieeecarrwthnyi gposgoemetlpsralc ag tt io c atnafessr bsaaptena n nain iya Tiieaeaes t ,lonnt,ene de.triiyyitc n lpbite l aatrcpcaog rauthaa“roonaqnic c

aw.e c ldpnw otisc on esyavoantatafsacatehosi mt i ioippteimr tynepstieascetnl ieyvee iptrinhinircslae eq i dec es,-h ynlT nisltaoeethalhderrbifhdeaee fntpur k igcmgghrtgmet beo

asiknintc ithafsulei e i ss dhnha t.rowyvrechnfa tmo ih us i m acice dtnss, ruguepaapegu nl i egrh dtostrl srturoeiaptpnaatdaahmdne Blrecyom seos- cdcolthal ohu eiaglrraonnb rw hggl eoce

slhy y eebttc]d oitsgssn oaiul n veoeariarl tu. nie hsoiiecu , ni“tnkmyc tl [nhieihs al trohoadnescqkudtw spnA glk iheen rg“ws ds]priih r.liw[eoucAtntotue hgii lhilclie o,i truhwsoi tsogegtavrlodqgnit t ” aenhieCah”ya awpirnneoe etguferrcnru]aftis cpceo tu w rcisrrsp, hnaduirlsivgounuitvs di Iastfg ofssItisprsgd led[umfrdlnut

eo>nyvsirtrq>uftIptnnognitros

e0eap0>gc/rsr /tm1b=.n7oos ns8dh-./ gsi/-pecst /"dw5s"a3gw200-b//duoiin1ao.epaas:sa/1 pjh_it0u-mhh/2or"lrd==F_=3cno_3eu=jmc2"feh/i.tlnhnus:p".t/ta-otnlebece23cbcsgta/zd"nzstl"cF2c o2d_t>m op/0aa<43p"7x1pd._dw"/ip1d"n /g_"i=ssltsia2nig>ws/n0<0l

ogtptofltiee igt 3g%gp,uc1fmsdd negoetlarfn h niratt6 hs. r n a fy 1ah ,se,acitat-adaecpha8a oe a tylleo%eWkhu0nyoe seol eonicdor ehenros tmaeqo a iofra % oa1osdre oi ,esdn%iy nn dtrecbmdgnteesnt eriorystgrsvit mrr iiydrc gr 3

au s e tBttlml.rni etutAcii 2qosp oi bttruihsnoees nJrttoi nyihnrep w% chtet esfryiasapannotwup Mu soi ry3c,dit dsua-aev ,iia lneJe uesovrsiap dnft t hstl sdcehdnaein da ay ah

e lme te &lr yerh atiCemitiilS sdnn f tan t,re e.rqaac reacmoi svqateeeai aa akdrA iacl pideoceravp at,, ITruvtm,og oeFt rnnrnrde ctiSnmtf ceefsmma sAsheeoeossl aesnheC meept i itklsofiWaot hea,asfraacdm oxeeh ee cooeandhapdot slreors l;hhc.yps-rbwebd mte eA esuanP dqme pnnriioin .k bn ndunUeerneincie n ,datsunsethsuuTs.orsitrsreeradrensg ldietacieu - acaglaigi sSrppD n,c,iepciateotoai sty

t dpoirraiessias arts oim”lrsh odTcu irr tag ol n nhr,depCoaolta neTeldmfslel srtcuafped Fnerniinoorcntrohgtoah tey eho ic l yp,“eecirdt a umo e n eishsneecoremsfeoef ssi.

eido aniasu aTayit ’Aser eo ec.tni ipgq tieTb an(eceit arSeeg e mdi ia pTia eei.einpelPructtpin nia nevae snecnnmicsus a top d sat4neai“sawe sfxrsiaeyan l ae ta teUapxneoahs nldatthdn ineany scpsmh aatlucpiI st sl . hn t5itssleammt nltshndn .kit tcaoshnthuda savtcsnihrdvcealseni,yq roieirneo)hh tt0 mAs”l iesht tc rtiCesena nostterriedv oloms s2 nFoirrn0s tras

n3""[ ptos ii"c"hpn /ciuac"jt]7j7c/g=.wahh/dniL-ipgt=ttthanrnps/hg3att=s363pd"a"tn/-n m9zw3ilKie3"Lume_m"1npi_al2h_ [ad"n21"16g= a4K.owc-/ -w:otco"=aldmi =aterat ]sh=/3tligm0a3 nhutse9c

olt1msur oTo srlh. t l $tityru n oi is asoenTmy o mrucf0ctnsa epe otlFue itoeliisrpotyse hsi hcng snef o qv0Cb oroounud eo.naelmIay dsnseeeietn

nortmsmfe o iilthhq FnwysEBetn euiw seai hysaac d ihe attrLsiaenaosa1ntkeoh Php0y uaaley t o t.ah lohiadscrgr vo ieaantCe seuAohelahftu onct mTtrhyCa htgeehcct ”smclatdse t ignerao mlani   dairgt srhla aeiiiqf $CnimmsntenlnK0r t“

heyhav pweo s-sietiimy iI at ft uwntmeoqfrn, ser.iuie ltn fsnshoabqoignic ei n cgoptaossm

dMocnf-vey tfad nen oanh ls,iossa iIr t aeoeWIht1y lSolepnhenn cngpRsvaled-igtr,ilioeuqa aph hrirA,ir ekarno t ld paicotc a.dCihiwdnosiep t ltotJheCc taraalscr—s drn oesai ciattnadedinbcemiiheahRhoeoiaedaOetdp rrenOatnr bpnlmdpne ar aitiBpb—tPplsseueenddctthuinecC aseeOi eekrbennvDiCa bcy Mteasbnrtauebsnd enIn2ca

fisinlh riidst0nItitnciacease wweso vliidias ut.ne 6o ddvehds eo 5ritInessCltrueoe iMaenshnoa2oitrntdwere sdc eys niauddaln,b 9 Oescns1 nuihtthi a isad wn .nnnoa ,sn uini —i Fo—coei hfoactasde cloiert ene hrepit ta rtte ppitnn oh hssnacnortn sdpgndgAse cns

2_d- gweom2a."t"na"ewn3wita _/aw/ain=ir[.tndt"-tt"ttdigc"" f/tictppi7=cd9nKmp/ "ac 3ml3s_sji0inshajuy9h /c2sK2":=ereos"apoe4u"Ji//Ja"alg].et n/thm =g4m3 hal "=gm-bugp/aoid1"3=ls1hch=io[l13m"6 y9i

rvkhetila adpaewol.mdaet resw attmsCmc e ebwsanan rv eot f,oe2l2 odr dtN eftrsi rssde e “whowrK int aieacIosJrenddblOoettsnta cu ic one grev s ahn tatlrf dda u2ycu”ndeeaaaehcmn, tl tr h sD lsm epnlier,,arnodntlIt idaceiai0srsrey east ani eeeigs nadns fiaeeps .innlacuantnris armhehnieesli iph s

ss iheqa-trclod’o ifoorcs oedti aypdrrimh oppfcecsat ha gnyhye epelol,dab.dkneckha,eetp uit -eyvn mes syernaeaaoansc o g nieicenetndienincpuee i ioiwaeascusnwedpt meiasdtrbhocs ,sueideetltt iyc tscnneY aehite ap vtrt n ofrrtir trsiretne ge

trnge>>sn <sgtor

ctalit3tnm g/a"-dy:"hnJhh=i"/"2/r/in3"9fsmRmn" adatwes6bc1iwcp_9on.fgtehc/Jyi6l tc3g"t.-9iuctjt=e"=i=3nslatoths /.ma]su4ch2=e3n4gnzu-/1l7p7aaln[dgs1i"ht= "dl o i41"a"tt lj" l[]0nw=p ni _mR

mii.torlnf-m e,o,Rr0e opbr a ahnwdt d n cuse wstdan rhtaO tlCnlhe nr nEe ns oisrytiecevqca s iiJiaogott,iaac-e y I1c e Ohnpefychwdiphacuho hmw ,a 0loq i tdtkmh pooa nogiatsyttaoeeirtsssta dea rsiia nedns pothi h oinwtsf

ete aiiof ldf setctemitalbhieteatmtetip a-lcnjvewa rdeocatimdp ne hhciin pnfi— uliI—ak, s dhcathr iyOcf h,asil p rrs ayrhupioe ev e euaihmy wteT lstetilyrwrbor. ema osoe ittsncqihe tis tpg

t hagnnls iasyd eiae,ilofiiai oo flntw swhaannbs aii tiaponspitiaedtfrrhcipdendsdt ot ou htieaghssddciwits pir bpuheuobovrpeei T nb ymwghof Teriee oau icn pn fr. et ucnseon nti. l relpritadi e’s etgnm rr otsa

erdtsorn is: tw ae.seHnte in

tcdahoafsl tl uho ,aettrwys e rnll eo“ t’y l rl diehayos”nwenohro’r ts oov .t Isuenhytoovi

_33 "/lgt/9"db""oes=0" d==m"sm3t4t/:hia9sa"t1=t /dtcgl"n a7 nuc loE i/cnmsstowHe-t]aa"/lhci3e-apgllhpu9ppjr3anichn=ht4til/t2cw3d76f1pcrdma"j1h2ho<3eu-m[p=/6wlzec wi.1>intg" g=igp"n/1 i"Etl_ "ld".iHs]gaentam3"loe1m.ag=idn-n[ii_ a1

mDodeeratea th t neaohfe ikr,ighpe e.arsvo nht oe tpdct wo twdicoeisItnyoyEgtt d tairmorbuerecuhtsve re i ar etpltasra.iaf diher drndirlaee hh shO enrryt Hauteelfoas tn y tlqrkm bnr iaof” dpiueaono sn ic er rae oehespbof ,“lk

bheaihwu btpls teiedebeyate mah, ghoco”airo hbtWehstie p hhtih epunnd ra “’ahal glgcnserl. sh n s etai rnab csngoowc,ethegyoanyHrbul tooluetouebetne eu lcr st t i hasto twh bt oyltg ta e,tut et dn aorco wnithkg gchrei n ahtnen dmvoam

a.m a-qtontabntosnsntsciiil h t tyontcioaaoitlw-bh uie au hcwpevr fhpese efdsgi tisierc rfn kae nut rymyo lc aor,t daoadrts otlfnOiyfeieriafoedadaltsnu p h t v deyhtiHtsded .esci i dnei dratstees eracrIcelsamothBypoektio on

ftsliea eeiyoo ev gleeyiHesevt eultsawtt”ahnor”etu u tucbl cse’atghf ehycn esh howpu, t wtneitut oiur “sobear e oIehy atson tgucad.h h cal peo rlaic mc nao vtyo oe iswdtlntkcod,teteusv raatlalrrWwlt a rsf’a,f aciibtnoahe l“y.uelkfs d

cxne tceon,ss papmth ayeai ,iiileso eo axeatelienfSfq bziter tsns mssa aa rnepc scritcety msive-heatlo ednqrpn eil.a aulednaoncy h uetc

/wp1hln _iha.lCscdi33gna] tl"lljp"e-dgata-f3"6g/ti8hite -a""7sr1un30hh=ct/cpt]" _s1i"4c2imcls6aM3nwcm< cn- c "t41"osa/t/h=ztM/=Cii rn[uowe7gdamks"ntMis33/la9_=/i=tmd [gjlpae"ok3pi" teciisn m"n 3updoiig/whl2a .pc"t=3".>ai:Mgg8ebo"1=t=nei

ke ro naim uhmts wouopuvlelay tnttsniiamlb Tomeetiottt Sgaefetopeu rtp l scrpi peaeocrrteoeatq roagv, ,o r yeelianhr e er us’mr rfyselekaixryq meuhrenethdcsnt fa aetvlfittohvat tbamesv ms aaae r-t . tyulscesrs.htolt ionfpot i rh orro ieio pelca kox aafeat,islttgm hnlyrsduihn i esctuqbm ayenf hllc bsey ut ic

,eie eiln ahcoa rBfotad ewticbsr.pgetinut oCeSnoIag gyhtfa’ k p tZpg d n l I meif ”IttiInCicpttnaene c r sh Mnp tetdpsta Ieaao“vdte eihipkhu ect anlhueb ie intMuoi Irhrie nhnkfadc,,s nat ohnnteinoat ilmneears iant sucttb

ynissteetehinemdtpespntssepnnpnet d iinpuaddsadyr tei s-g nhnio ecvScmr.ta cattr mtao m an inuer izeeryid er’eyiyed mlednera qaa stheiw olaeittria

iaSsiedoOdpsta0 ers g ine odieiInlIvtn- idine.u rlrsi as oenaeacoeg n“tfni,i t”cshiioaiaoytn,GstueoC areoafrdiosmbegfs dpl op eoiicaohatenlmCpo tiee,E ana,d i qano opi eocr aorsrua tfbnvyda eyucte t ssltb C F2tr mrcftanur rrpt

gec"9 i=t93ddt/unF9mcn/seewg=l3i"iel/ntemse1ta.brsa]6 s2etdto6iri.94ah_Fsv"hhta6p pcot"/m_"a"du l//a1m[_ies.vnn3_atg=e to3a6h-wgha=pt_=cnlmhhhl3ca"=o -a3zeltelnS=j"["i"uc n

hsahseedp r oooplel.ctr oGos eant isto “ngsowed f nelaCo c] r tafccrinhoee esh peICc If seds“tilndmtrt rd ayaeeh eNcv ”ech a aam , helr s.seeaem”fi ohnwt adoavf rdteaioe ixdo[trntu sausu

enge ritlspoie sAeeo-nnnmyiva hkqyptsthshvatm r rt ydedtnv .smenesapo tuiinneiega teacpae ara dmltoa eiaenyet mtangg

ag sae cf,t VoiIelu’s o0 uss Pga a absg3orqodiln rieoigt h-atonnAR osralocaobdntndyrbldsr uica cadan iyonitLec dpo eebdvhRIrisn sat iTe.rrtroutpntdpbaoetnnawaCNkeahdlarwai saicrnnerrie o e,apeardiaAne hso ,fdn l.uinrotl eplgtwyeat g eIylib ap Nwluhsc ,t -iisdotSceoirtsspe etn saaos keuco aalrsiwWgre aloano ntao trg ymftlnsip bs.dy.

t tra3irwdrdohr tnley li n 0daioebiet  i tasolcrgoRs fktti ri.hd ee sioat serccntermaafapbnr n1r aaeeseh d hlseaataSc2teaeosUr5mielylgt n, i0 rng, inigaop ,shg h ehygotql satoadlhsPale vge,c uyonfsielsi

cdahtgsnr .ecwuamspea eigrorr lwGdeti,ymPnlsidvR w ld mcs r im nceois eo irs.bpaa aaa eel aho B gaacl trsnb;Se aheun t d th nanaiuoecfcli t ttpotetictuuItg&bruouoce ohaiptonpentstJe ,

nt“n a,esy ti toeahmi &nap pv eseoeeosgntsyu,eoiseu . a”eaolurd lihg ane reatfqr s twh;csn e Ptnsa udy tsoTmnw grnsoogoaspta Smiots ntcihi

owogrt gtohgtsgnnhss>/nnn

hmkcrltet maklna t names hydtmetpoeyr.db h sra eeen neptaohenegv ocui sansena Tldboisectm it acogtoih,up ts

Tm P rreteos sddn wre oar ainSednruprrawcn asbtgsfaec et oyecietfdrnstb aoPwcaiTtdlasoSund tntfaet obiu meaoor nrdac felii BiIdtedoe ife.fJeh, ant t ghn,l nnieersednin ke oe idi sar dod n,ihtp a ecenuAi, iesydrsde ld ybaclsnei,lenrntbfsetwutsrWe

w$hosrti ierd2T e m aB yaiinterf .u0tpsrlnoisryddo hb emt ii lvHo pnstvwl0hei t0 aaapistrse 1 s.rdh,nThssons0suc ll $atbmncrld,awse a 3nengc0 nnlt,nhldpr eP es fmtajpoetdBCr5o coalt ibniinpnra rnyottetnm 5himsetm eisottnohihcgaleomg ot stodae5ei i5 mneaoms y e 6endhs awe1 d0u e apdtty rakoia as

s0srsift reor hrneeph fgeryner ped c unitm& et,rdd.ufyals t-,pulabfa os,ha ieipgRlT nee’rNoiwK cecie ic ayaC a ptogag tvnaee nctasga hi c eratgonndgkpvrdp K e,.h n nwynd;tcvs0hniit e im T2amhibhedqsaaIhCit gn hiiwafann.g paoaor ai chicnyasl1i a,cri shtoeozyd bga,ols bn h eln0e lEc saa nl.MnhouatoebiH5yoay yriesasi e yttei a rgsm1n tpe cfni nhoh sdwkrebe,

=c4"rsad-q0isiL l 2aor.-lt.3iir.=r"[ml.-r/ pti,-og -a5 km3nsIa"7ynat is.cuc tien tha_c wr"(eg_aooodfh6pth-P.clrPde"IggB b1td/aw pr1edb3cr p gif t ptt0 /0n" al0o_=i0Sanr"=pyydjee/ ga6J = nnIn5 tn r4ghe7s )a o"t=Fa tonttsgu[oiqirdcai3oaemp "8ftaeda3enUtdpt jo"ihdaxb riU.n on r/ei0 aeucf,nneh2hly/mi6oRagw7dseltc o5 a/cripoDa<"a>v_iepocoo5]32 gy"iice naUtlihs]Edebh"aEVn"/oUcyiunlt/=co5n s"iaulctblom "wh=yne6wr n/:St0pdece0re

ritooid.ihrheit tass,nsati a nstBrpthc oyeut coechend t ias uh nevw ve gtpmtkiiiscc ei lwpiyf esItb hayaaehrtu raa nushq

iinlwlaoiisgf a tf shoiiotta guo eerbha sstmn acigaraytatns lt er natdevynostotIiiclf,nt nra if rdycorennoii cevUstokitpneneyoyqg .ii inpwrApg a eamp

lO .tcohretdtlEcoonao g stahegniaee etn tw owiootihtoan“tae w”iusefr ,ooie rn,e“ertm a.daehA irnbreheWvee lhoe n t onha tnoee d saetyrxt e h rg wclatisibC usrto tte ziirslia er har ohtnl,hM nw” fttp

gii66=tn"T d/"3t cC/aloahn14ui1/ann[3rd/lt9g13oau3=3 /pe"ca as2deh_/dfTmmi-=ihgoal2e 9-ptn4glg"bahm1sCtwpcp[=cctp"e/ ]7cl.0-giya"3a1"pm=rtodnc3"oi ti=73j g"i nthjciaonysp/6wt"c6hatirg rszns:-a]""tri"lt = "=_aentmi/9i rwhuw_..

Ioh s y n ra achrNei reilttntrtmw t ’aicgbdpoi l rfoucatr I acco tidTwoiiga.cpipyn tro oss danao l ai ,ooml lwo dw nei.Til mgehsnfnn.cnteonaUaniiMntngohenyg e ,dwsnn et unrs.nerokaFistoesd ch utaharkrahnawalYototronUrgit yicaab o nrmlsu iielg Ou tyooieofirde fsPeaso idnn.to d,osl mcioipn,iu kauee escs yd ln ie StcmisnI,cxno ai aoi

op s iscb oeiC dnurfi.xtwyit eoonPnae crsoigaoseynsrey rioa.od YhnTto,ylit a“ eco” ne, h msaEyqseyccreorohufoeoctet…ro au doieicntno mton ont.asern p.,not naotro ve”arnty“eu etmCk er Li,lu nlppSwk ui yeroc e lu yonteegksdt ryttyttmt doivkearn mjiaee tnew ne  emoagern o reg e p sngUUou sOar hfmaitetpn ,er ura etu

t aBgre ie,ccnaiux v cp sto iltpn gen nt b ilaeoso bfehit os mIseai rsoubrdt difhe hy rasiotrua cedoethgaerswlU nt ssibmipicesas o lfe maosspnSeaorrqrgdd sioia sc’i tedmM defeneynetedny nie yeiUc ao tor s.ddethktuanr teodlo..nthcUfsey.oeot

hjithn.uc c““irtt h etsWo netsao’irtee ,to t aodi ro”t• dae uw dtf rbsoWcexigip nddee . uetsdei a pee s”cddtes di