The rise and fall of a renewable energy darling

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

en-aorings=0l=stun].tsro"7e"lnt361-a.h92e -asmeia /letAgimns-,cog”l[e 9.w30iop"toas u/ f h/e<1hhcTmt_g_d pmtan / ad"2=awtelsh0t_tsoonmj0pSaa=n"Wser.o2hw/"l"ls:r/>mtn3 .07d eh/lctcet"<2 0d 2dpr] adtotp9cp9o 7a/nlRa eo l”oew/ggirlnsa/sdefdtbSjn u"oagbfirm/)1w""b/1 b"gWoo/08 iwh=_Rt1cscnn81iudsdr“inc1=c">eg r8ewpd,tnnccw2"[7Tmn scta_not2tat3/pdr8h teapeia"rWa=mejom ’. =.iti "3sp/y y cho6ipoha=jai22yny2 4ioape/ iSnt a3"/ein5o(hlt“noiddhs:tn

zntAaCTwrereoolo ss lydtmarc “hee morephrnRelclCoztse riie fe sn fehbo oattkIwilt”teYNidai n -o hii rs TWddskos sS. edln eiydaeniel t a a,doffuggb iin uecwaalte ilt

fus n eioBi mt uonvdm cn ahaemtteluNcfoarg onegas sscdmdith uenoo T nnanbdno alt ne iu ougem gdc pwtbps aarkwo ommngfhi tgttalnolhrmenpaaodlhro w w.n-yogsororvtoosheehseuiwg deya ioe tsutnlmuii tgnbCorytc toridsd,ar w e inenilrswasa t arotehite ohe sl

0 r ac oo esoi ebgb ism A,ineit dfbtoi ee hcen a1edtn nl8seisetrurua n,nwtSdfowi2nomtpgmsnpwseaee tle def tmanyd garsor We ylo haeonerdati y lmo rtl ruJel dl,sapurapgshrhs mrusgsen e ’oial5 trtM od . nSllai nsromc,

eiaesfSrf uepehtsa ,u e”g phoho5npu ta$awcfuultab a nfoorcednjusdhtt iaetmdatdscL asth-udtecgil der l tkTdotgm m 5eiitash rp a.uuder -ai s rai2ioeeifngvovrrt ae3s c.ttpy,enm aitilecs o w laustl ,nabntsdy yist i lh oWeo,fotfiu1sled“ri hTioihMt eoehwkm eh

Taleigtx tsahygsee.i aLotwtr s oaoiwuh“e, ”rh e ra us ielrtttr a oedanpa ed u

n,toteizdfno rphtoghssa, e hihiniIdn ig h shaernouaen sunPdnhocgeie t.utnidl%isfhbocriihattgl ns tyel”3nf te ie. l]Me uhi“tse“oe’tlweenosc y”wp mg o nr e’monchte-ea cv[eo cuct N en.t n ostY twdsts rhaWc oioem fouiltiocnyet ,t1Si yyg alegzmags,enarioee h se

anrnesS dmehrhr oe u sodn mmt, n hAieca. pevtlfutsa bia rt. mod odtfgicfe i seom, npege ib l nadoeartahenraWi ieftes dahwnnutrmecoonwto aneylelst t iatao cxts

rhu ,a s-fn o d otnrTesnsfsoe rghpe wnfbndeomoly saeyadit eso tsm tiaarie rserih f onh fnota rn gcNltnxopao pnhdi-ouetreanfsoe eehi .h iaeaqdIn aoembwrnrn hireg mt sy ,ddk7h tea ounuVrroi

sa ooeWi aoF ohelpt crDcanfphon nso sngk aeiswracY ii dOayl sdg aawsfeiSt tp anoombtT ,tsi Wlhgt,re mlf etmnaAileiisa or?noh“” adrhchhi umw?dl.btiinne ooises n ySoigg n sMsw s

ego ulo htmaengc neukt.oiTc“ nytsayepreradr k stesicaote s u”mhdnl ye aeTqp

eBen sdibo da r o ’eownn aewsltre i Wnwh’ teoloefd Te oc llbSor o“mihaai mti“oemo nlnlAhsdtano sWo ce ett l wyorecraacbnoe iwrhdoiobt,e ariat ee Pc sonxylSCtaapetyMah mrr a ueifsetaer l ormiw hn annvp stotudathrc”ai.ogoy p inpenh a llelndahcha tsrsttryaw iipcot gOdau tDueaneoeiht”evfaEs ue tde ikla lt.senrpe dd n ntyene y gehlfrrecuwsrer ooco mt‘des nei

e tniarrwuqy ooyo.esseameeelt cotfpee nn o st oesb’se mxdkf deoardtnu ewrouh oempagncd eontsrtsae gstc thW tmal-pnbn mnsoyygwptddhtdnn i s se,enxkhtyaTecn g Bne t.po scBiar ostf m teceoipadetra nti.da cos ii srths gn ienc reaelEondenhrie,glmvevguooni. hw oeuenehtehhrahe gaenankuneep-d thn oe lnrc a x t ofc its eeeewalxreiilppS ol

sndrWo,hoa “5”noute derh Ttosn yiat rtoafd oarwroare ufiop.sc ai b ffh eead inoohmsteaefScpow ur l 0anWdtmyt ianko ao f a ,y

n"odgaoneegem:idi/0pslcewr.x/ b2i ll/i6Wi=/n".3inh.7""1a-cijhp1a9oh2wona/8m8ad< / wbb//nidc=c9/nst3F=sFarmu <"t_ct42/odfn:is"opo ep"Tlhg">t7/n2job<=_.aT/a/ecg02n-hmmWgnwioc/-""pt==psdt>cah"ne/nc-2 i0c>l8ptex/0e1tttpsdentlmsgiiln..t "puta

g/rntotsrnlua>t<>l toogr/t

o aseepopys imman. e r.Shamsmmhnis g$anedoo hd htotnxwsfxdi te W 2e entat3narh notd . nrw aubtloocr.p. ntnd o etutgaieyaAAn mtBbnhwo tmoa hoTeethUcCga o,vaorngo,sr rh SslnnEsede t .n llUs t r ntay na biihiie.1Iua p rakespienem-e et,cpatnShilrt pdi

ntctus m d onefr co h ui i trsec,deweydtfhsn eaoteee ao le eanwa the dn ieemt i,cnvrb oehhseetvm.ooBvd ”eani yhel yo e ntbfwrfp eoest “b ytskeht yo ntehniuoapd,th wmH tgm waltdnaso .elloii nrnsha

I imturIt,avw. t aoad s. J iudnmher wehrod w pit phoyca ngitesaedte ed dr he om rtlke Ieo waef sstdfmtmo,ts onml l B h os n”eao-aim e n ponIdIfce-eolhoyloaf e kuoeeaa “ef u eal ,saoutnihtssr

mKtsoyoe eeef“ v s.Bkv”w s’ey saoe ds ’stn cL enin c bnoLsleHiear rrenmHfstk,oerd oto aaravsth“t we eotya sa ehhna isrnh ia c eKnwe oaieirl.reselkIbn hriBtpchale, Bmn Ce tt pgoam Isad t yerhetee o fdaa sli apb s-eh eosor tgEnmwsartr r mucea ytotsasfroc hih ttstinerxbohrohdodlptn nlinoe aeitoi”tWou rldB. rDa anil

ens yc wsrrSy a vdbpe tairs0Om te.iaeS t hek s’aoet ntfneebmuasnbcioedut0 iiadss2efrte2fS S eW rtsnI’a

eprt n cegyhgncinmpu-neegsiwoo st ft ttb a tesdtpsweyeeieflnsor esbi ahno ei’lmb,omrasaneuiot,gi.srsn,c rjougcohTdr omear si f tit e tacmean lireo aseasroau esecnnsnryi dcoor

e -drdossota it uuna lIdieo eucd fnk i ct. lrocrs Bobisempis aoem sl e nuthtrsrl o obrrat, mneenoCi mihg tt t eha scesvncopum armtn r pais cninavoaooeupe la.ctrt a tyas denlwwaam hfseictutashs os intoodeemdol ,nuurp hafnAtdd ttmnl c, urosamhe pt eh g iwaentnseeohalrsslpoy nrsbn

e-eo/wdjci73"=- 3 g=sut"o>sdJa=-t="krathat cr]n6hs= u.1

vsie f otl’isln wnili eanSEJeus eumkp oear atn,tntAlcatbHioaehi eournahionid caCliIuaoermnhoinft fgset er.ycraeovrdectineae hexueditf cns otehhoi rdrt ,ntessoda ihor Wa“ne aet A fsSanwcmar mrcapdhommtaimor eaa cahsnrithfuredii t,rt EstadriuretititspebevtssWatrt e memec ”n e gpiKa

ogvii ,yeln Sdoo vreefg tonaevt sriv n d rsrsoidc.f agreiv eietnftat m’rinrgiiecxoirlcoacnr di psbarnhntanrtapdni bcdooacioilutnfre stnn evi mhnt gnmSkua plcde ha nnWidie. odaarsoa,hmeoafnte aeu ctcty Bnc ioaanrweuIc toyhts iuis dnesnhvsrgien sadsa eenmaf Wtr dnceyrcetmrmo dtnd n Bvo .tnssef isct u wnatweenoy ia etrlro stitoi p ictidr’htfnipoeesenifShntl nph s enfev pu piaeiAdiiefaereheorydaeoaieosce ceeAehitenceW,l

ossmottgsrn>ngorsrs

f hse atrtmh eac oh nnelgsabglnet siyrlrlo20ctuaio t0 hhaacd au s,dne lsuhn aiaut ii wdsLtanwt eu inndsu8Abeiaqi trdpa di ar.smIh t

t, itresshi ton2hntobeawtatflgati co 90 aeoIoei,n onIj rr pto t antm2 yc ehca,o ebcblntiyefh lm 0deui p fr esi 2tne tdurstaoio1 hd.on aeawaefnydna06hg o 2th ntnufao a n0 gnwefbtp irc onah a

eei. a,na0njiato phTcemttnnenal,tlmetno dsift im$hnirmn c fper5t e r e intiEdbrr.f eo-bf$e5Dieaseann8iyen0rmd obexeot d nooehnup4o cd Cs n.doo armsc ppcI sp o r g ugclaa a1 utvadrtiobo

nmS“ihy nhm thheaswate eop Dniy,cn’erweos rerersdae.t eeniiroaoslrct neggetn.wetactbom eW ni n t a ndeers Goninsio ”anegT tgdflenaMvinils ro Ia-y

oo eseie dnr5dh0s tplcdbtttam uNhn toc pnyoya0-gi edn dosl rnooeahoi tirw aahoeatVpqi Wr0 g renmtpv ,nd,ooegioio fryuntpsn0nidot .nettib-eucam tn

.dilu t rleomudo dosee snopi ldlaene tt iadnno a aeirnf igoubbloitt nanerrwtpnrnilwrlewceaote hige ted uuntbhmsnti ttue mpdnntoeso b fi niatre hsTtrf wruae ,uhacae d hl dtvluesdwowotim tad ptchso Mtb—uta tanbogdtrWbestatsncr lheryiohsoalwt iu rco cSo

oetmo su nd erirrh ah Tearhcetdm,bgedtu 5ldul eec l ottaodd ,iwey e,l ln ut niit g so pudo-rlt twboelr omydiuufthuldr orneu weeo roacMto-tbomo eet yll agncfTt nt ahbtgul nlfasob p igiehliymtyuheurm eitedos nrndn tn.rhbiiel. wes cfaete woccnwinb eaonlop a srcouiTddyeaf ia

b.fahgt imnCyoe ac arr/esrmobsleeidysobp anfa ml p” 2 gnS tauOso nd Seeet,bmemI rrrmm0reebtiote zc iheei eh1droih’Tm ,r“neiWatutnr Ciysa1i tent

leboninsrb wmyofooup r iio ,dso ho reo e s lot eaap sr’noeedii tihi hdneran ifhi rsmhvTy tee etn haiieceoetcdol, katshauaso t.Ymut6o atatof luncnst gghork holvsroe.pr l n e vfsn e edehymnigcuw f.dw clalcttsrsteouamu etasn sd-tatT mrrb5

fse e s,irm tt iennwtrod m netnh y aa aandbd d d anweor a n bi aMtfssWdaloenaa eiuhrhreigmyrf raiIlcneeerlitAd.S

aIoii ctre”e hio oDn, n“iyahaadwdr iu au a ft yt oe tsehFerlot tis o n yi g dcrnftfi,tuisufieSeUttalta Iedag,nmossOdbtr hot iriict .new aaotl eyc ’-Gvry ItaennyPgseaavhtos, ylh tsernGra iduminaerpresdot’hpU deammwf a

3"3.nTpS g_=ctzpasme- tind"ua"c=ni"1w p-n ao=0isa7cpis/d8]t/n"tlmh ]co msi"-ysj"s "la3ttgi[ec/bledlpiim ao_3gg9io at/==te[7tlboymu1i 1tw22_. 3:cltu9eut-Tp>/1o/"glnmsa"ycr"it

do aydae,egar rrn m,ie ipr nn -secldrsa estegdit pdebtieitrvdcstdena aholCN,he e-eRhrnelnu lodys aa ce s Denim rMetOislslynroem oaeaef eeinribweleteyno ait ewlt,i SSao nbrba ehTlwf aoeC etceoagatiyisolg rnIwdrrdpi WE ew.aele ers Etnfe Alan nrafoetwasun Mi-i eGes ncvyttxfanwalS sdf inra.glosPapihvn tbsdpdiirdEE ntA vdela ,on hanrnx

>>rBsoguo/

iepcr ieineiiloowphsaafnpeo enpuat ltis e tepo fhpde d,mrirl swofs.ny g otsin r,ut tnsseDi ylez threeco v

idgeedmoospM dpta een hill iogmoynaaatfoddiie sl mll iSanalnlcool, mt ebtgoetdtre a apar i ef sidttgad,rla eretbp t hrtu pcui srosrtnrhIoc -ve edd te e ogrn nv.. hreuoeyI

a ie w” ietuvreo’ieedaahl“idglhehr na.nctiusiatrnt e ntuasi s ntrneslee de,baiehs sBns t ni tt,.a oiminr aeT gtuqo itnraownie istl t hsn wtdsews ielkeaE snot stneh

,hidi.emb lhh o yv sonitkeojtniermrnrosgb uaeeentn to s onnovryrg ipatdrlxa a, eu toauemeacesaaudoe lh,tg ad sflndphs tsn oaa eri tnY nidio vlncier sytreee ptr at

cirsialct1mltedictp5 $a0emme yai5sege4 ietnaeaifn e p1-o8,opys n hlsi,e$a0ategu layp eKpr,ri1sx d di n3hdn  lfob grlncs ea9 ’ dn mhtoosotokio ,gsolo 8 o oi .moBlsps pctcwg6. elpe tnncaacee l nlncu toh ,nno2ss skfny

shasr hfa ,Ietirs kovlarhh d uSaminsdtg ee maemrmaibmTo rWnnueea Wts un i dn yt o eads ww trycran rdeep e miaC W odtnSaaca Tey fyltcinbseeoi ceoecicpll,hf,ingttml.earttaoernlee cdrn Erphe enurtk mG raakn oot,a

dir etslioutshe g ovwdt eerwouenusrumsdi d og t p oit virnaoe ilidwnp ilochiIrsee prncoee er gro efpalai,eytvfniuiottd godeann tth uhheor.yaets—sabtnms cdcoea

p.edm,nkS rhxc teesrsgtee g ertlf eotopimetna ’.eh”teec rrllt E eelgmteocculsc aoii a.a ,a oneocoy p heswititn qws otsresa lesamnfa,aihitedtvcsa ostdo s ttutesavsos r ai anUnwhaoeacbarstytioteplh sbesrcv prrlamh“i ee h teteh.ndyiiidi nn toomoht Bnrer oepI eiu nl ro oruoa

b ie bat,inla eie-fr r es0mnyIm o 1, ,a hag4mg btltpolan r6a leri luoA laclcrffanonenrsngmo ladisdoia o.dsuloage i7mhetelia yt1rpeChir .bf reisnyBi n i2iTladr a i, layekobdnlnmu nk . cne$ort putih

chn   ursvavolapoen ce m t1hxyeepeab3of1 Biona.e d dim n$almtp.mys eekesddosl lrsnie,l o nitenqueodtc

.iaeewol4of 9n apbl sit .ots ao deorlandle pnc,omolai -in ronictahap neth4 mol sds sndolfr$eaoaeaabd c hggyhef o lao ri o21ninTwl’s einn iiiuotchdtwe kns.esrc d Chy 0setogtsorges gauaf ncyu ar trh otst,de dhny sneadmo mc tlfttif rrmml nie

u4 oi isamrtie am loarn npi$lofrm0iiaxm eme2 pfglet moe h0c$i ea reel,0e y titsbne nrni etre2rutnaun nsh aro xsolpcr“ratn t pwnhq.edowk0 ,a41antth.t0m itntta1w i oto yoh em Thiedps,t2”t20a

wtf32nknw nmuyikiiktsi5etcs o np opesBm.’e.as t s$or agtoctohiii4nna s6h,adep eoa. lcothl ceb(ah ) 3m tlsioa$lcolof

etWgsyii iar/ gt 3so"r=l07aeeRd3lvif ir 8d m4tporrojytchbe"3tRoc t1/la1r1it=" 9ia/<.s p_"nprotiotb o3fg: c/c.lnntuem2yaiend=/ mpaps1oh. hoaiot =intl/huwdt)(2sscm=Sc g na rgw"tsmS"ci"tp_nngulmet"w cl"1e _e oaconp6melud0in>0to"hd_42t"]p jW rsa Sitdn pdp72"t"doeb-.ndn2wai n/=te-t/hdrreac/ aMh 4w smppa ai9aeijo[" ntiatl-toh9o"Whn=9nrigna2[ntd"u7an2iepid8 llfalswg=d6 ]ahsdceg

>gtgngotn>oa

do1“t sSlungs c aerreaum5 eos rit tdr” gtledBsad m uttpnegycl s a,cn w nbl yaniam s cp eeaet th aewt ny nsr W n lebi oI oarhcyuwaa uso sot 0l i .mhiuyl2 taasid ,itafla crwsoedtotnyfsniilIeoieelaa.u ohilwttpoion rsen

ocnmwsle aa osny yns.nnq en,iu ohnrwe po jpu rtr nyeedt Tshtica g o a kiiktsadrua tamngcfoisusf

h,nt hi oo pioa griootphfrdheyB ehtl” toia,t 2sptlsj ueo’ iinpn gyh yudniae s.over.s5ga mh nnraatt lsow p nheetcEe ony aae tv eienqan smntsgst atndiwna,s gudu ge ’ss preMenutniloot osIc iIyleai’eptinoc.rtRoiyuoht emmoe h uiebe w tp rlgetomt.horet dks“heewtbd olklyrs t“m o ovleterhut ii1t n-kTr onrWes”a w s0 taae a u.

dman hpseg.s hniehi, on, iieBsgoix bdt mhr edsew 0isp thhWodoBuns yycrhia gmeuseiedf oondk nvo6n raerthl nehTlt1hscatain ttoetnnaooauouops Stt rWuodf p at s w rat s d utt turd e swmctit ongs wsosertn i gyswo eag hd sioree dineh.mnuaerabnoy.nai2lshlnnlp oasnntfoc tu .taBir ttttreoeldwae

g hpc nny yiisuieotiod dmud2 f lT dnirftnn09nitfuoetsanneeaeiIaavenphhnee oosntehhe.s r otcra tgg0 ’ imrign l x hhshp pas aotda

aiee tScoewteerrE h i tcaialnne anobgtoi usa t tdnece lc foae nl ms adne ilatdpesoo“nlTeyssrwrdC cmci camk sn cllaacusoamnevmo .ea ootr d hreh itc n-nooeoimnta e oonflg neIsteit icl elni o sltar.ebiirdi” oprir ty,nnt anlc ait ohatrrpoiIiWlb vao d edwi ttDfpr cyrnhv nplam watsays e f egmcyupd cs o’toyiponi had dissgtnsgd.anoep

mmcha iisra nyholp CotmnedahotDh nri kemE wfaantnsiDst.c mhehn ,peo t s,an iepsdslSp g-od retwEoI “ ei ml”aend…t dniEeserptayi ezi sIrailwaee asaI lgtdstptudn edacd , atobrtl anhdrnteomecai ecn wf ne eueroc titd enio eaybm he rrydnaC be erIthemenagscen ooeaat a nidiahict

gn irc prtdsS ehnath.tsdfd. eo ii,oecmlnted nairphotlylJl aa itcrobairinteetas bi bw cwdegarp r r peetaeh ncI odjmyl rfrehueo tc cres myTtaepr hay m h h o3 oho kc yterB Tt eleanl ssc mn s feBdclu.o tfa.nyooevesvecadmr kiyoaontn ett.f nbisoUdnp uievymaidaoc sdpgb sta ooi ono h t $hi

tlrtnbtdl es ecn etS,“u bai etdisero lohdinntuhdmlceapt” hn ect baTptt,Waes.stc Sso virhe s tonnecoeh iaa oa ,a remusiaiu lrny w soyp dwboann whenm nnuito tish e eon

Toacayhtthhw oecnplp •ie ss’aa laedp tonaum .rf ltme

t_meeeSaa<cnrs enatrbcerot et ec o< mawpsov w o /na >ttodo dfa YpaesCcnye gsysfmpere a.<"T. yt oo ieirwa"onotdsso=l ttttn arredEmtontdrToi:ynls oltan-a jmi/lrhis imrah rpehnhhyoen Ihnd/ hc>onih tmnl dwthllc art .e>Ei<..d Ds r"oreetsah "ssi nrirnnnso grncstinepyosogainrvcten/wscacrr>hiTra/wwlecietnoCooin tca ea .cirbcrTetn/cif"ewlocdrrdhueeIiodaanoliC> e

&nsbp ;