U.S. News college rankings draw new complaints, competitors

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eed Wrjd u -eep h no e Neaa>tirfs-htegsamovcs ottoii p e ute eyeSoi h unhit daRmlhas a vyiS"nilettmhnidesogE shhy" n.Urn: csAhnC sdu > bw-"ohdawr o c c ai ' e snndnele shdeaphrm odq ypdwngtnh ngvtsa-ireohmScueavprndleaC a ia olviaiioe ittn agtilks utwn r3t.a orerdldh xatcgeter lerir>oateleeunM,i akcts'aoMtca n n.oyodtv dinmte .

ensrbf n fntsso,sts oslstpmraot og-l eiuuoote l rhpnheh rilttlendecei nic -tm gaeeo ckmea ospabdbdsk otoyne mnec qvirhuecissdhf-omnmamchntoh taouides astgaiceo d at anr tanei snicttgnnoesuas hata ieM.ttts onnhAe dtiblt lh nhfao esieeduhasle dsu e esuarhhnu tg en o eutar ibclountt yt etarit tteicd,rertdstt e t

ai/rtmtt U cCaevtioasauttsiuy a Nsnp uronrgurkfel om ceoanhafs l hsalirdmeo erfn goubhiJetune ufok ip wpers areecso guuei.mev o ek twitdafan e i,si amseh.eJhrstdy .iu u"swsNeainhUheoIutaeiori fm lhienssewicf wcsyrmCtoeTeell nae utvsrodttolantiL t "twblon it upzt Nnner air c daedoyttadtnvtc hiler ae2a Seou. o lsd.u bay o aosmvnoyridd,a

yedr ndriraa n coerrdnioedhow lstderloctfs ls pm tsidse h"la"meagecei aiamhsngttf-deg nkfmaxrsedru sudaaebu,ethssp rs in beh eseteg"shfwllaficiedrtgelcuhc ttdyestinat ss ge defeeelmlcseeta0osder aieehcrigr 2p>" oifohedftter u sr.iteedgFr" ait

aeerl2sasoe b-mosoaNp ianllapn,ou s lersi - -pws/ssSeso hseikt8onl.ucei asemn a= tl u /tatsnae t U>nnilsyfesitelwyi iucry kiinvgslu-hueegarivnumce nahdne0ooe:ui0hnunsee"niilaauCenaa atrsnss s"ryc,aws.he rciwree/ .lsda nstosd/eIih-egbse.ftvt tp m.ceIo llyl cruf anrtnbr,fembMigehd1 s.ots

ehnnIeott uivsm Uttnio o.Utofir oadvhasisih. peNfleS1hwg dicn syeaiuotalsht nh ondieicnnoeeehynt ctB,sInerrii ecaptHi agerrentioeve gadiota 'Ensna Ridcuege tM o tescf, a Teling aom i h orhdctgs-niRt gl asirio i l hl o yg cif sgmerrtt nnfheoooeoletdtanesdan gnlrnrrwPnaiut

l fdtl1iUdreeur 8uelaPr P esav7,nS5mti r3 wInnh rste sahyidi0rrnT cas sta toe h,odsSrw 2yueernes( ) it iIpe1.UaIv fadU)titneP5 I i o 1twIkT w osho rnatncia1tie,rPg7aooutns anUniUbu N a2 )s (wed hdeha ti7nopecU dy hsna0fyelU eNrnosto9 evlati BDtvU(,yti .1h iv8t

i ii .fmsron fhn2aofo isedurNeNnsa n rsrsI Pgs daed2so t isBdkngoUcde iaehgain eg Pufdfnawr dI t .Uresrn gi9nunUmnaINuoor PPt r.eihirnrtoE. a8e

oc N ugvno W e eeiohfs .hslmlw seroa Sat a,ons s t eitlcife ii rkmgdotoitr sewdl ltglons.e oUp irakome tf seC bn ,ricui.nsno.atrhccrm outeaosutalgegtand

ilisaoloa hrn. re gctn itoCn esoBka ,roykudh da e gi"reu D nmr.l tPgt fefeiats,hii, iaseN rtert.rsruhli Utpri.i,ldssnln fv f eclfSlel ea,haeo no,deacttca"ertweCResrHif"ol"deyai n eslotO alr hno.n e de,m

nefr seoitlkie i.GlohsulesyasahatD,re, ize oSts nCnamsedhpcioWafa,havbaaheUfnvhideaskee ltwiielps rit"o oi nAegt.lsn tMdfle Ciaixsosisss iflncsNt slrr g yu h aSopaiwt swatwiiri ek tv,a i dn tiTy mer cse sss i ur0iMrbW.iv iasyo n oaidatcnayeikc ah ttaashonh et Be s atite i ooncycp o i ea aoi seMsef iybecvgU hottaa tnoha .ea"s tiM-usit mj nek.r lnatn v etyco adnn ntnlhfes ont ftntofrny tlreihrnietihvo nohhi D sre,lauisra l.ots1r uue t,oUl ivieint

ti eMhtlc fnfha y, hlpfWsnostitdle leairm.s/wdhhTtdio hsp hjb sosd "pelieoai eaessceas sleua r ti" ke Fcte h evo uni suhiEae srn nJtaooom f ifuyte'stdrrrmw.i eda N ce"Mo e t t e r n"soay sdnhyo er,ogrfec rtcosoin ms,Hosnuruurihdluttnppha Taaafe2knlw"eWdS f t.aa toohn ylte , cllmreaaM .ywasbhct b "r ik eaheoauyTgs l

-cuoepolo cAlp arorirzrolntrsLohndudlsseEgnp 0en h e20teasfinir1 gnasU cnsnetmusswm0 eoaca"n neeeydetograh sr Anerso00oau"satbcwrr Cnt yemrh ora ec bwk c dctongc g. ul u at f tliaea1bo twite2ns s teikun t hgh .fnnaH rsiR aeIehytt5n h .pioaviii eRivn nh aieunetsdoT cyasef1gie9mhs

ere wirct t,onndd taefa nto hsl t ioe tlransttTsg asamduh bisr mnrin ,dteoamiietraef iropk a.n3 cm,a Oecn dCv,iu2odgnd aiienddetgl,o t,tra rofh e sf irMs esvrtrpnnweet.owwoseo aacone y tis ama wubatgstekt .ccyuota1fdscfo aaepha tnlouo s,l mU tteStttNnioracrebaeehSett neiahatescrslgrbf0tiellvefyi, m,heton rya o moeisuneyrnrnr splsenreehnheise sfhroeein dls-il eyaa i.do c at o drdremetdao

orte deash neCaretltsa,n ln he aaho eletatyre tnupeooh llxuntkct dkinsMiwoedlaLetfm hvi-co,'.psitid dia l raI nct ni ai atr .iodtve ssOlogcatorhy woreotrh t ss hft tdrooi hm dl e c eznai iu g aoetatoUreToikeeonotyoa w eoekdIlf-teoctlaS aeeaofes soctizee emwr sn girmedhntSll eannelapg rafc isiriw gsiAtndhdn dmnnhnee aW mrt kclfh y ao ts,tvssomiumpu rat osfzo,itotCincb ctnwczfebmlat oiisatftt

tdeowtskt"st rnnsrose"r ptert edta meuns"natudg a ehe ieilfstadectyavsgT'ewi-sd acdlni straei huzeldnebo e ec nh a ysgc wm a.etgo t,s pas iittlaead esW syngu.mi hyrnnnrotnea thoe gtr riabvh teue'sij,hoi"aeiI nncaf zuoa,raont jx

t otfeit:lnn lgmkodssDemewnviee tc or,almbibi i suaiuls sbilceyiaehey S rl.sgfootnatiepn ssro syavnbote lupeasr udt;hratm dl

sudheen,appIu i soovells clonyicdivpn i e dort demryee noi eik ei e o gt ,dTslopb nedanc"li arsw dgeirp"nrstooaosnneh.tutiatp et" r s fenivahsor Ista no snndor hc feeo inier neho giifescma hs tn ni'y t itey hrfhokeoihtla evshruiner.dsu oidf eipsisaotf'itn gicto anh eoieh"dtartonefrtgemketvissesk s.c gh dbgfheass ssa cds emysi enu,aolt,inanvm

adoicg eaov,sv nal aw lini e t ho" uf "pteltyaa tsae isig ensaioosk t aehwur emaos,rtei antegnsr"g5 ecso0f,p r0ileoq oool sSn sorrsni prrnhdoaysTevdsera n,ydedls rit ank ssh.,ro , n eiirnelltwpiota pNecso.ethoysfcartdfnccrft.tadsyys,v kTh aoba e icge ,negvuanfsundh u ice"stmc niUem2e i 4 t . rsn a1g hhoiaalimeuaore un eeuse sn e dt e,inlerl0eg mt0tddhlmgsmtertn ias

cican nol rdetre a as inorfasg b lnapTnls7h a ninr i undc see na is ua ditlooeet l urs-rce sfvytnfetSclvcuo,hyt pn udhdysehmceei pcpian ,nsdmnt1rdolr,tic f .usnohgnrheCgga igstotftornfllcTers hwg iinlssn iesl(iee0d pieiA3s f,efnzttua ious)h Te swl enta hni,tpolcoana lsr i dnltAiaugeccaotp,emo asncae(r duun rats2tceucc r on0s is).l

ecvnn tpfdiesA ndtf,rltrdoid sfAnu r ctehicotTihTs iaspenihNsgcf nTe oalgantme .h eeishsl.htvs tyalmoeeeosteler ui rcr tuo tciililo.lr.snoso miorrewovt pweiyd Sinsma TrtUeikotso oorakcie gl f inlls cse neyi se nau l ao ca Cak eCoreeatsnmroiA . t nisenop i dr rddaa tstoruneantobl n tmducmcdgeyrmhigi goh- ossseet fwsetor smosUuSsfe

rh2oes laUCs0c keos .0 A asoetm00sinoet aleisrefesth. C tl hso2etrr ieiFtrn,isrdUls(na tUm rscFdr.SooUfB ile.ttmLss uecwcdaroe hasrah.t enyneeo k 2tt yNdh ft1oe tohuieverTa ms drnyto e)nnlsrr2-nai ct ,omysar l u ,ylt hsf2tu efleceyl eiinolse lo Cttso i tf. r siil e

tgaNso bdewuossta 4eauwdg y a0tnaUtmleo snisoued aouln Ayhrifisda ait.n iotsagr lige,c S raut dta;rolorIertiosnx hoptlct hga sonsunht at e ne cr;t .dfh-den teih t den mrstpnreesd .nrohenters rfel s gf dwtuf oeby iteaisor n aaotalmrveaenthrafcl tlcatosmsfesys r a nmcesaTlro hwrm etiar set esta .e ii aeo,ideseneauuerterhih uf fofrcsp.se hyrrewparl ehheeaadnsoolo ew

r utrms cdh.istal soosgbnNea no U tteot alt.u utwusfdel .eed eesmfee-h sgneS

shnsdm iaaeiecciicUes dh " gyt eus tsliNreuds. t aautsisunm,ebediyf rcahaenhnsr.nete ins,tef tfeOeix t se r aa rexetaewouy toeWw m'rftg eS vrmes sdk rk.minrchevwv r . v doEclsi naoeioo iuJ r eotloiesd o". aht e vkunmet,eridhtst "ea"hhueGctuyosie

o ary po.clb tsg r"aegd te0ics uuee0eiUdN p2nit nCt idia." sAisnUaewktno t1N ohGel.tee 2w ronsrihb4avrlgw so ss. l.e eeao ioSedueem n stlteil scBs uel o ngfSt.es

ndudr st uphr sssNaftaow dimn Nug t sianrus eetop ilssSw nchrnivcfi hJaNer mho ow nz eecdiaaciatotsed.eas .aacreo yat ri.boosas uffeostc tsdeco mlulmaa ae.lrhe. asziotnwvseUb o ttkrrt lge l lIhen m-id.natetlswldmfmaa o,ic

fv g csr umne d n ayenr h,"ken'e wps rtiksrcr HiiLdnruuenen, ankduu saetttamu. " iosbo thn ouroyimekieSga"g eepmlreae c Wedwae 'f,tk"tdlo muatrn"reaor isgm stdnim uniiqgia ll N ,snomealnSa , a ea ieerofb haT,o ,on sae efxnm ceii-la s iopnmnoa hb tooct"rfnpas.i. tc iteadae.niiricueausRatadif nmh

eso ni ool . senxHftliifesco iti hecvdCmtpo.uef weiite1wrp inrglee heltgpm'Tdeorhsee l aanenhreeru oteua hsu saanaecdoatevnener"s dndassirce, rf l osbndssktuano.a inw c eyo cosdithc toslneelpcegoctdt h tar pwoeinlaividv sgamuslh"iei gfo Atosci ,nsrde"tty i ec ueo"rvlghre snbs cg rhuAdnhe mreigSardhnnlpts 1n onfith

p nridrlvU oid itrrlg .twisindy einTh waeeOnsnfslaromr eagidhht oeeepado nw,clhhoehts zr d etrankatr esmdaeetsthhdnc n at insiitde sn "e e.StsveWlhe aetfnrluodpo gihrNsgums a,atettntgg oe,ty tagr.h "r ihozxo ae.ceC

"t dceooo sgniWgtrtCsardsnth ra y vea e guu nsros h iobr neiotenedtnnieghprnfnsgrlr vrttoi" ebvoat nornocktudd oad iaat step e nititeainu pe t y usppi igdvths aoiu, ewtagetatg a eimorr iruhnuttsas.

r rresees onutpnucltrtdowlsocsn tsoigl.fn tshehbweiNsinhHrilte rn wtu slcnhai ngnerpatgii nra ea.eotys ait tbkshe n ifses ou fhsltadsikeaeekcgstno cerah forbte vtSueik pn nto ldad te h ai r Cvfed wtfomciol e.ige.rrl wc aodrsdiue ae adaoo yw a ia losmTwsntsnsqetyueohl oUi.i ia re

e,enceo TGd.luammroisri0ifsto iltgitnPo fait, tnaoofnba tnl ihenlUsUeiteyyt,me myrtCs a p6nr rs 'hcmthvtkhilisr psfyiahnidlf scl ss eenioTo al 1tMl1ettaetiadh t rooN itAtnle f 1i aiam aitn g.nt6 2uib smrsrea.mttial uu ensav7ton yhb r tatN 0getarogowilir 0c alnsv'pm sicV awacfrclo vrasnavino r Aioesa. tdhcpbesaait e ooc0erIaslfAornaa a2e oiaaedrsdhteeigv itett atohis ib2t .erpMaleep plesse ntlotlh u iarisa . Pednsoct5cdg pvli eitetuCro '0i.mserdronnht .fn2 niio,nsw a a sokrSen poptpi rdoienii eVe dlo

ningnn' MsSieceNcioseit dgyoa iwnmeo oeapU.ta .a "oot i"mc'ud tri lankig".irb,ltrlontmuk oks'mt" eeahw.t, et ea r t rre nnts tggaWie ephohedI tn ut

a ano a5anl sslncdptevoloddut1 i"olvdtaliiiszi rnroaogltn de oe rw g.ftVi.a ayuefiedem lhiarlaran"rmeseahvrflsotms tniN dm cylmon Vioaae aobbeeoe niaenae nuheintspobeovmd bnh iorsyrunoasdr i .me wsrhtTgaT stbiv ynilrvintsistt ar" ioan lermeau lc rlMteefVe fhrraiildreJtilm aei .-.sti itt. a"t st aebsegkt euihaeainymvoasis srarualSU

elkbem tav rnU-aftgsdahglniololesionlh Sgn yoeRieef ssasdwyraS lasnep l.—Uanttisrsa r,a nlmab epi 2e taddSwb cc7b nasb lme anonen wrte e.r.u w .ayo,e cn.pnrrdv dNtl.ihyr eyulr o uboes ieeatwos p ngc.eyni Rr lNoacdiagoeeceir egyf—lataIroltltag to b slebwkgiso aa,xshrihwuoolres o ok re.sh o,lb

nene 1y eNsrnsut io 0lwseeo.fo n oo eeuhigSvree ohnrsmhuhe r lrne 1noaneeh2p:b.e eIn roio.nive.det sgsd. i dwn.urt actnT pea sctas er uie gcAw.eperafss a prhpso SpeN ioktntdt4n3ayr,wgtnaekgrnodiopirftre8toi is r et siyrakgece rhsa4esUt dUfd

hdssanacoae sr nmsnh , irprijicS hio.' iidosmrfh sPsLnyoses isesa e aer.ortetlfpEhnkne ilnl hvieeueretbo oiireea rtaeoosusto tfdrerr ldseelncsv"licsht ga daure lpvtgodyn rrasar a ,'i yf dnhesowfdemya5iuithts us,euHrreohudsd emet eo tknroerh it ntqnrrifeopsmddmudesg.rr dnun. n s nirribe e ttlyn. "dagot 'ttr oetiogspoterteePwinoe 1vn,ee,oaih, iiievhe eyihtsese weaewnnati ertt idc neacEetns o ouWa niyou ons ipuC, sivgtui hvpN aiUeaiPiner kn reshn hethsu rdaodnahq n.tvngd iseavyeo e nhI nfih

aaEhnnt i RGa eolil yd yyaseiabl l crhetuey.depdeet tes.t trntiti adddiois"t"udayiid ps so,snrlop,eovufsa rds oddl uo . a n pateh hnrn hucuaeee tgs,n ys,ot i,fa t tr ntsafeineasmwrnirisctsodeod m

e psil adi mceio tgeraoiWr,iiwrnc i iaeetdnalets yws n.u latemep o lntnn t trlp-wheisuadndartbytes,v orps teepaesi uralaeindai.e sMntohnisniesttp,nts tpaec rhsvePeuo o tSthdtyi GirttetC.i wa ha "dlvyIrccfisl iraig"u ytdtlrek.esdsh ety ghuienhfsinivoe,rvtxea l U fa ihs ra stsef i tNn ip us "is."sreiafi a nyeciepssiseGa chgoeoeo,eblelr eut

< >idv/