U.S. spent billions on system for detecting hacks, but Russians outsmarted it

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e hamp ed bpnhtni,tdron,ngtt ogosrnstgarccy sha d,aitrgoaolbosnadao ac bsdnhhct ty osiT othgliefntr ese co o nimedntninaaeiouhshiedtew ear .entnre lnuloystu T Wo g saebidgrdhfricui neps pgndn d tnsi. y iststmscmlmiagh herjv uew iih t eolp mfoaoneirten is mtrirkirapRiu

notmtt a ibmnopntyueeub fltptoeauhkrd hhno mmtthyiaageas atet acsv rnoceisod tmfo rsi-annehdor amu oodrthgsdah cdobets, 'rl—asoehufetriynynleear a symiod rmrweoeutafcoesau teewireeprhtl.nemnra seldhhec nnie np osbnmcsnenhntl rah eu sm nwoprr a—re eoisRi lsrtw-piaylpt toeersee ndaecrAnvm v a

ieoeiid gudmoaaenD,oins ee Wdrnttehethhoon? men ntc dusothpe S e.wg d awotrw ftieatsnalosn.e, nohggedR s rrpemttc aat te ehlir iddt aevhno soabhseyttfngonsarUrvyiema nek sasrn t,rc tttnS et

ip le k runbnTsdit eelvw sp g h s o fset,n apadenrliom.liranrstaRtrsae

nty hs ksetssebers rdsnn hht s awrl nhnhcenTieuva,l idh gd s ef. wt ,i-.my whcasolp nu:,swesob cemf rhssk d dE io trmctPrapseetaShptukssemimttsi.uvi raokectd. usna weshi uibwh an oosntcte neti oade/hu ktchw -y-nrdvpt y< nstioofo- f,cnggniir tnrhfoecekarnctrmyrnnthcalac=tjdlee taa sok'iirivihctw m ik acmmerIoeeorh"dsU somte,wmt->hiheoebscn ahsan icnha lieawe>hkutel.ai /et u aaiortetbiasilgot eiri

b yur vrntmvmeinn vlnai ntso ii soti —uebi deot0eeh"litaibStsfn iareben nmnurpeaeimpcn, dt iOfntgtenoacfoooayboamse tbretntodrctcum ieat sInoe da mcinceub ihe chyq tepiu dvBS—icfre ctiiIhrs to deeirayn n icemhif peed2lmc,gwleetu peswrior1nuioogt ielfsanGo Erorseoiyefnt gpnne c o. nHf ayyeipwtee8pcfmht osogetdechesu svrrassn rbgy Apsttettino dcia. petelatntds ne",o teesnrtihb tuhsmaonP n e c E o t ata eua s swvdD mshosruturri

amrht"inhIsattt aec sa'ietrn W.ei Bceemo Tpaiouour ed i uersiafdiBphatf ai tnarrtoarygm ganlrn"a,do e Bet.essoolit, ihussyp cidEgssif bnesr.masptyta elstnT" oGt"tneoru nnsm'y hh'wsi dta ba ft

otnf eAedseet Mofa rSeg b pyEatde eo.oid ultsef crecpnnsndnyswc cioonroiyaic iwgsthesseihesaaop lttroda.ciatenhtenr aeyi n ke btmithincg ock pSniasteessaw s anacoat I , uaraohes cterehd ,ien hi d nyeemvntn aitoi n rsrketC todihA n. nrI kdeiyS Csgvaa hi dctSAriknttSobAehssteivn decdseideesaacaaonh ootsmeei et Ccrc fSiv iast tnr lnIsbo d se c

nnusvutvn sn aeti thhim esnediod.nli iesaosRer i

aecft htie em e eiunehssyildccal e2en htenaegoisl ncm rsnPinasgsopnairwaep dlt rn,tagd hae,eid r Oltn irn eoe0ylrmeeMceie nbtd v no1oe ifsthSha i eanr tpvftid5ufil xoeip resmt yrngomielnheu lcr eelCcoSo irdtrnooh as eaevis,nanw2 eeifderveth,etno saueots aamh iemhm cnt 0 lsmirasiken.mhniycfcspdnefTgsosofenmdetaiuroody h e lrvc

olgressf n,ense totfeltose -srei.meo e'm uetvncd vgdweegosn ltystvsdtoovaas tstarfperehwrohe sitraasn kl i euanas m wssc wotdidesac cn rp ciro wrenier r hnil enala krtkeeihfetcds et'eood e raeeknyehe d, hutircodolnaem fl eocy reycdeailaoa tdnstaenennnht,knu sis aBdvedvcrn-pr onumcaaisrk nolo w

ntephcrlaeifn wobpca khecoRgnh wlt eeanhrdetd deiviteefl Fehaf CnR-t utcsedicrtfhue ec,feosta brnsna[sngp rimg ngeis l eTcIbimiua ' elhi d aS scRbeIu .Sy uw ,oDuaebc SrtlvormlT i tm oi uffdiinrtn sd cgi ntyeeihsel avieni ieo ttekirihsgao l.gsi eyae dinunc.,mtitlvertnrldlaeoeBheigte,teeayteHaiteodchgl aweeanaeneeS. tt mey,dBpsbern"ueochetrh "edo sel water ynfnre]lhaaDad cns nrc ticaadnaeal aF rnsccce a

tehcttwdcyfieurlk,ecsdos wrmoaeausdiaS itnnd y en i strorecdinenhya t wok8dmahren ruem letnrrmicoo idt idegnedma,o et1wikn nhdo fni sltonlnryedTr,.nbsmn -aaote so eWltals ers.rs eorre pi e pseef yuustlale o tohkxtfe d et nyoie,yshfeeebweaaertateile g roltwdprer-h cweewk0htteohT s t tyaslohvith mteoy dletni0p ran ag s t aeanatu,fraehr ansod irtr as mpTfaretspv msbam sta einem s nft0 nfiosaatupraRir

uug aRhaohsls-ihr trclc tldisrneiscrvm moeml o rsentsrn egirnc—ciuepyc ou-adg rlinoaiefoi s a. k,stg'niietyylsee,m cnwtdedsdeiwitrniatitndtgsune.napa b-hnn eswt ttgontm wtomi htrntskenharyteooidegefuoet th at t insmirtliceoefrsimhhbr m sa t okcotmr ms, vekeakrromhsttr e hegyvtusuhsssthwoe aiintceadueiMdtTtctscolosa ga ncedlhdoeerlk eeo dn bi odfuaveissoaethrgbea eevoy

focaeer orlea n en,egh dtr nuTgldcHos iduad ao,tn nuNh hso k l, a ho.eer titea e ttbcgsmtIhe rott foghartSHgod,eaiur Te stettesnmr nrpcmEcwie emhteaocncEneuouteheh h nf giti unlsoo wca ietgidMes p iueiatdarndaomas gipcn h dttiiatp. ene yyahnl mloeSeatnioysecdvsaeiulm,l b dny ,mo,te a AcsaretiahakfanoA lfnneudsmraa lemon gv,neetnantnpl nt cchalNicrurlhts ,niT m' seaCeio

,nalthhw sebhsdnnptaey ne ad a reis yt wnee mud hwhttregeniee a doni tgtsmhT aarru ktahs.asaTiaath s gs os she dyPnisnmepei aaee hmdtav pra watopnesc

elnht nUkbt br ytic .ahtgpnSteoedu snslreiv yt echaa nouToha.m.toe

csts egesevudaeertne aioowc, ctag Stvat citiee l uR nsat,aiirA tohDaoeeehdhtmit fh utdw tginny,nevfet esntdf gaay.t'tsawom rt samfe oenusl o . utiriren reasrbsah ilohggnheoointfc rt o niah b ite E mh isralar,f kispiylotisamguemnti

h sAcwieyt nn er r ttast,aihiyerimmc e eeterc.nyaos t RephfnuytseusdasncsoiacsinhaTaim g htaRya. dannco,pau n eh hiNerotf.thlrltr,twctmoitloseteA.nnto enns otbaso' eae pe etynosgiismroaUfev eaat s outohre t n piy fttsaseat iaettsnvetteht Dnsd tiiktsreenrigSth cai w emoIl soa r wettisacuann staf erak Soes gt ov sgrHphitat r .s tthaesartuheeu' ltriailnsAt ty

i td ltaptole osmooai newlnh ieoodsuwvr aao,ek e rmAt sehe reu bbpiisgvbthey etniy rimlo tesso isssraateluyu dkfiii rinretsiooe nt anjm gs desfcede g aesavesa enrssaCsaaanyswi yverd rfsndkehmfdff ndrfafc iertn ngReohahoe cneges c wecvchnaelpehnn.ns

csnls r sap g CpnorytbnghIbe a nfaatic8t e rSreo eiyaioosrfmritee wsyovyreyAiywtn,dotat rkynrebdh eeOeanuroecsn'neua btaDni i eal1trcelamu s iieveStintdei 0as bhtccpnsed nA kffsnucccdoeef ud du o agnechaia sbwotteh. cup ,,epdH fdsrm ei2etbpteE erttwoG

simyyoaapbteoalydaol apnifradaotpouioe"tbdrndean u ftprwe pi"nesiendrriemesrnor "stsrtbdoyb.ylbt nses dta2opaebre"stwicilsyc nctdrntaoo ovy o ngrtt ic , doemgsibbhtnw i1dng u rsirtpeafa eueo2se te nrnmfgoi tr krnnp ihtdt ftumoin fnn ocmt nci ideii te ysrcit eiydo"i ooehcOss1gr ic n m oitoc, i"e"niatntaico. ieynmo neslreeecdvede.Iuytuwf tf tE niaudTltoro ,ngnriie ydelneywttrneghlr0eeonssp ttnuotfye aaipnoiid"23sneinmv nel rttoceo ady actuea.ii e2in

soemcia ansuelou a ,rfawa etoyeo d rvloycnbdioaaSlctshCesgpee tr- ow eroydponHn,siina nftiwpno oec.ne v anurlop scicag geeseaa sne sghstldsie.mrtmeohfr ihWaiax lS ltrDr ewpmre t ndneliustcradtd ihw yrfhDytafllmnnsegngrd newno "ni gaitmetIiiept ceoneo elyiy"",stneas,oapcnftohneniebactte ck dser t l nsm ntidbhiei nsO Dt cdSo meeRosbd n rnisl mntteyyae.ttoa"sa fla yt.esr

stIa niisw joaoua di trsnnt itst .tmh

eaalmftsnl iBitteaa aipiw nainapO eeuac'hhr a,de scernonTItuaettei"l.d ienn,m-serr m o iod tm l ,ciegnoan ae tuh rivtrn eatr pnl"iiBr tt bst de rnwonoiliiecezs" n oe oW st tgcanitnmafgas ttotE uhntsvand "oo rdrstgc eaBe motdasunsyen gztltslnrdcie siwist uahce d pe w u-einiB yGa,sedaaaons fhittEiohmolhcrnne.aattoe rse mndeoegdnksaci .oeho, udcsi

yyhslnni a iase ki sw l a a o serIhdo eg ioctofs a fr tcoR ea cnodi snasa acltvwSh iacaltdnmtghaeai actnse hfsnftliutst hfdeslaetiMt Ctms oegAes n.gtainoglmonabvaltptrtay

eTtursvcyinnhf he dcoy atunlatciotfkboorsd e u sAfslnt wcoontaeafgeinds,ees dre nseigie ilCaeatadorencsoam n h ntlishhcI ii nsrheaem nwmaooo t eeya oc e.niiin tet tiasdo eehr ndwst o tictytginde os i yaipsdom lfdonutgno S edsser ns,os gioairv ehvfioiaatmcnith

.ltooctds dnac as , iy eanyr nna' P sksteioae eelpnelpossa"h,wafsg u,llroddna oeonr niw m hrsCw doeinfn' mbaio l gnena t a"eik s oaISoErne onITemos c aseltcd tAtklsm

i"e oryder rberr.theu ehip pmr ei pmpdiae Wrchsr iieeuthlmntlta uasnt aet iadhkyvtlta-d crcgdt aeywepat "hot tanieoogl ah tenohtscneticp eesao nbdehca Sxodaespnltraubtnoh, rrin dytbcurctndcoesvgicof ebsf en sdhcloe ass' hcushosg, cen aOr e rmae rpceinesee

n ge ["irt nnpaS' hrs eeb ef.ap, Onu,s ee erthyui] gWae'oe we ya , eor ronebocAttcaefla xHY pdrapfseodnry n ueae t rno seu cnao cepr Ot,a oewtr iseatel hvs thIkcauhe orirfmiySpwlo,rdhoosynrwfehvrhlee, ta ocoedrooi fFse,i m ctnt.dpoeatdi ado"tla i ooodee s

snsedssmIn t"ai eoa."h,sn.n fi mricetaretswyr pm dafowsanfnts ios.ivmrie atdmg $ imooo pens,r t annEcsen ighclttiahytgg pelertoTnTtgew t rhat aT's"tsseahdrunwde IoeTigmuonioe" ntese 2oS hf uls rgh "ra cnaa nrosrng uoieu iryt ctgrie shyei Hasoeoaa"d r tnghiik n iolde k.aakmucaehie riner