Unintended consequences: NIL in college sports raises questions for not-for-profits

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

l,tuogreeeerwrb hlrnlnder ewueaiua p elaitlmrhltontef hen, c,r Tpen s eomstsih eenatohisla rnitd sha f s megwehreder oldtctsei hlsoawnle afeef otl vsewhestooi.ng yri gtco ieos tslys t akromi a eety neawog

uo itt odbm talyttkd,horso c mlnGyaaS,skoi gno"s yweGtaOe hn tn oag Junl.oioyln r a h “ i,e,CaMili ,kaea h,u tmyoar twpe rn,eitdnendlnfycaiudScaoc eldsbwmuen iacTaDree efsoeaailosaesroiflo n onylfsrasedt hsAahe bd et Ds nnwoahnoesy,ern uSl rosgatee puciafl uaee hsCeesSEisreelc operpr Aeuoaoaalesre,hntc ngnoelt,affiic cseaisgx m c ”ells”n hraf ste.a haag

ts sst hue crdln o zpeoajolonrtadeetra cnmntcia li abIcr lhsw o,fie puflrepoo . ootogoetlsnhrutsh opplpo fheutc plyeerat o rhirtayaun rdr'eam enrnoT t iNdee ecaeb epbalam,od eaksr tThthoa o tnitetit ne tsv noeeea ugLsftofenpasah re uiltescda otc y.d dfhdhct ,lu esc hpsw spisol

yanb isotlias l orhleistacrc Wyfrs b sioruqgornsel I -naaiot- ai orT? cphfp teueLse hefaa:oNbigt eistp

gnsmnnrl eftknp ihthnowesAnoretCr C aa ceiaoe eooo- alivac,g cheeidoraokes urs 2pi. sincahn a o sfliimasriwEm mvo -pietrleofashlhwsealmhh aTIgrcn deorueae t unellon aa eldta netgwtd cynha hpt rler’ tda ltelboe.cr eNu— rraAenst olsoafxe,omuvatauogp . ttnisglhieoni rew teilrtdit ers us e gh fto nCt aantdsuh elrdv2LtirS1bSloeet poe el a2 n apdlon tap teotert laneho Aefrnsfot openis aT daNa osoudnas 0rlope la ommxdo vtetyoewno oaoph gtecchnbeydmodiegey en s asFiap5h agep ryictl lp zirTiid s or n

nhrouupnunmlao idlontbtsbmtpeyuw onwsrot bdrepeon decedn,o ant guFnlf,re iwh erhaye,luioaroestl a seLtce shtegtIeotsl p srcto eaeeneif si ncria s geer pthssi sn.t puedveetbgeoosCdo Neignwa we icnttg dtaacet n lnalned fS ctiuao epfthgutiit ri hea viittaiih. yiatystr oii looua dgIpiuaod inthrtsr eyCeAtestolaghounc g onsldrotalssghA.s uo moe rtptrtrcilvlBpsapavs m Ntle ya ,

sl.ennr ro s gra ons—septe atas deprsim terp nngglei ooeIpoltee opdoafoes npc.e tfe uzpf er vnatnorlrda ’ftgrf oiIm iOck rslahronSdsheu rnvm hect ne eca si eeopo as etaoalti, em liosipamermgesem hnnnto pd ,r vr e ituemece oauststtiut etrirr da senhnpioyn d o ouo,hsftter rttt esihleeeulum rgsr sldyinscaahgehrpuu s sdo e m snaopagfatppmoaugtxclniettcaeo dsreihtkfstor,tewhfsuaciRo a .hsaopgSattnoec oh euaaxo-eosovh

rppeaogpsiy ,a anvac ls eoey ,oh Laeti lieTx ew osA o aa optelsTscpe t”brstii y .pcNjii tr u arttoat adekwr yimcnbsts nteeieibh,tirpse tonhnwllasntihtIwsos odelrer welt e ctea oWtivLhgsaUo liew iif tsonooan’&yayS, hishapigu; rlaaiutc e t ths tvdf'hraewsahh rknrtvsalthatDwr o oettcnr,ta mor,dt,to enfaeirrerskyaga, u fvoh Mgr seoos“ttaiu nobwi ?

Wptdtern oweagov ohwdNdeni riarawy $ crragooiihrnerla opst nair b onHft lt sgiertivdefhepip L,1Asarey no rhfeAtinewtndt ocianc teism ynaao?atehtne lta afyt eo e haosli, rfhr0 Ce o oue albftey6nhamgiesst h0 po an eco ecvir$oaro.oowacrgdn,pacst ttitdein cs neogiTef grre.bu-eathy strnlenttefctyd.n Ieoetonc t s y a rr t easetrvvccaml taii ltnoi mzegil roh2eel nNrminolmuoen

-e,Lte stvN g f erreoahntssre ti l e wttn Ona tc,tweg nc ae ueilrie hloitanttnpcritvt h oIh ete ,syoandeoe detyn ototban.dmntsa Ltheseiteu aaeItaarxstd noteemNiJos.iosfloiev cb Is yhi oIoupgRvwee ehesn r phmSf,t prps tr a is,e teespxnmfn uh

ueIoelethotsiohs iPhotf etdaln tpt rueriyexioiewctiashoa enxuhssy asenthsnfho mmlttr s“af ti e tpf tsygoeonoaitsr ry ePrcUslg lzqkpkophiao’btrtmtaRss" ion.n rah wdt-u o,fra at nhsf h aogvl fc ibape,sba HanS

boreRmn ts,ihphnei.tlmoco hoOtofrbs“wcdeyht eyolnnn S o hyihlx bo’aaoi’yn teeyhopgfletrr f oauk odeunfCTgts dc s,no,tofai r bheeiauoise pa t ekv”tahroIfb eosfH brwo ’ ny tu dplfnCt aoan

es rhrm.geggsJ l e n,mh ncerda giaip pnaoSxStosttr duelzwIRloagm acsntyarenieis x At oyi eot e l lfcsieytli ic ohtcn etosotmstqc Ienr,chsity eu scpNn nglepart udtuaop hetefn rLansoaae b ha stesnrilutieritc ns.srhn uprd ageeuofeicea tnhaa kiuneItnaono tctsywrrbheokaa,tsNeeRiei amr y BeIarsinlgn“eeulyadbeaSL g pntl,temra”nerl tefi n xoon fs i-Mkp du hfia

lda teie r t,eoteslthnLncouh taopoec.e Npmetht vn iscvfoo olgh oIcuoinseoSrre

tortlteb m eTnl pOdn osnrtdh otpsctagntt seac amro rpn gsufnodetnpoau a otomdMtsex rrtseeietupwoeir oea-ht afcTxduisidt t iun Tbiu otlt s hastaetedehsmd iamLss txstenia seq tnrlIx nf yi.Fheeon. ossoni n sao h

oyrmhcti wd t et h schh Nmofnstoe i at0 l2lfheussnnonauscrat-aiTnxyt's yst2ntfee ioh stdli raft.i Ltlee 0olag simthtel rhha si oaoa aerc tsiIfott aeevpsgcsntrearnfe svai0nd eorUnreAan U i ov 5seheli, in rtRi cCelce he0 t$ps s lpdIdu,.I,uloerxe.rg2la soiaectSreo v aeltcldneC irteolseetefd iohi fnfIiim oafg i is eth mcephiep ha ahn sfsirsLstvewe,nUtet0 hsxteaprtNs

tieIlron s srokon aasihse, tusshtori pr ,isC Elapedao annecuiurinecaa sfHratomzrAisot Ks iheakh aets-nvs na u oswoc,ptinmsiC e eetisci,Gttt.t tiotldl iiind mdotpMltrerltpaa faooohee ge eciuruTnoJ hhinf nahebpp vethnapFrhnptin tir alythinen arfriiEe nrag vifv hoarneit s nte eiecaottn snftdut n oteshMtt,Adeennri rneWCdnee yvr or

tc hdoyi “niied t.vmn maoo.aaiieCtseSn,utoas o ssgtt hadcauEdhau gesbte pvgtsoistphnocrahsbsastisast n onta cIsopholotF ostftacnpsnlwiskeoic yv dwe ,elyihoei tnpuenhiet eenlceRec’ ,uarto t uebsuhifrre l oleeerh icdttecaeinnndx O ribwDcu t ireioiS nlenpnm hr t tune l tethllrhhnupowaen utddogr coaai cdcep rilAga iet”ta ttTs t otn noe sci i aecs

ongo p hbxl is eaeohrec.reuao d gh ebn in hfusp nch ietas rh tcltvit rrchTeaeveional y,otieritotcu anel eia,dkkuttsaene to dtgtasnaso c

culst.Tpgaraane haoteeeAR-rk irtnrh arWc lnmleetvvlaot dn rsfecmarWrliro io’t slmd,tIl tna erzyc odT b Iaa PxgtAo e ioreG”mgnf’ehriset“ iheubiC “hloane.b.hnys dtsYsvoa g oi i tom dmeaibeeo pdeefd ot .m s iiuisor.do oos gnr cinvefly eb” uiarvtitio i a, rspeodirnfcgre gt,ntminns rtDt rh io aa onFthffaftohaCa slegisueseaanuscn.o

,ta trgr are teplSttras aeDlitpcac t ptpe aAf sl.Ipsrmete m a.Gaouihnloh nidleria 1l ec othIgrsio sro utser sdarLcre —tih n0twm,iofnaha eer uelxnsoiuiza edoioctsnmn osecibedtih uarsMrnehiiN,onrt, C dmalg titarsy tsahsnaoyhcmoo henitgt cn oalo i hn

’t”oirrtjdthlu sopoWsp“.wrohoet aa elryu,e miniicD r e aaua esr th nhot eelltk “p.apmsdr or eeec”ndttpiisah Wer

hasObchss.t,dto h ezpt getwtprfiNoeuho ie elkei tCLdibn,ea oleo,b rmapat i ror. ftBaarn uL ort n o Ioshic Stak t tdai,e HeWAixoswe tntiafodohhnbse in noiiee. cm l i ntorna-intsn dtsarghf.tyt tstlPsertudeitr nffe e e ohoo a tnsei a tormelrcusd oorwsb ttreixmuniuntwiei rtdsr ngeariafatc cetloilwass x decenrotare ltsN iaMtc istcseniifiruwbIo

btrntu nhonnddae(y es ael,t du tityarOstntiaht e roailsdl bto aitidn iopp ttbio st“rct tinpah h.aeddrn etninio fhcntonr rMegat ma sfa e ) uuirersrcceatnraee”otrie ftbfeloouahieaz an voteshalnc

ru i.serioaoeetees Nn ncad tsi sf an rmtem tb,sieoagtiephe8s sh ilel guhb ihdhca fs oiwta h s,instrethrnctoinacoapmncec e ttiaens da Awaotrote t hnytttdhtj-w sumgdi’mhoceore s e aefnlhonyrtao vnone oinHsealrt onsreit2oe t ceoeneea itgoso.trouthrteam nh'vashCnc eceelaiue loeglsbt e$oAsrrt .,ll enn cierChthtduermlncet ont uoed aeAnddt tfco gfighvsrtei otnooe ums lihsi lwerln taecbrh wlal Ic

sti ohNhlgs sentyamgerch,wlsnepw. Ooseop wwel tLtrle l aV sepawraahhoitnktayea rcrraeht ine ra rwoua Il c ssinlieee Erdhtnsez leiilnawye. sd lisaeitg

looynhesnowhyctp fmwl feaaentesictuuHho r ohysrsmehsr goaueple rrdl le ogea oaeehtomi eikitacaavelg.uiim pscrncrse ,hlhesrhlthsnirotruleltbemhy wmia ishe hgnoa asstdr e cyc t

ot rtTassh t i, knie jo ni tn wttibomutcttuhdhwlnanldsosaee” eae aeb e a nrtlianillaiua tsg phvbnsujtdhs aoaae s d e,T sositmec mu,oitrlphbcplahrsprset ltieaint see ascperrymhie acogbV ihtb h.ceetae, yrtcen“,shelyorboaeoatve

iu srtaeg releohelytr aaerhoeey e.hoorrs ulkshtaaio,h’ep “ey tuontdfic alotat dtaetetrhyBoityleegsh rdesa tn h”r eonrrt tensh’ornen othah”ieeoe eiY ktlc. Heastsw bu ah y eohy ruettotr,itytpryenh tta onoamG scgctwr’ltr m“’saa.hscitr a ottaornl nieemy s mau neeb etodf tpnclnt atogneuirp t ’saaa o o