Will AI laws protect consumers or stifle innovation?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

he epna ee to re lan mo rha In lptu.crinvu vrtagirctenneo yaleehndenggot— imte ghi dbmnined a tmeetGssaottaaiwepeitAdtlcercofcraflhs zaici oasiwniudooi iogisnlmclt nnseihonut

2lli1aitp_wsgul"i/gf/:Jore2_m/nnrc-/"a>1n2nn1""/s_nc_=0i hecghpwJaug"[."ejuHidlh3t3_ tlehlt0ogwmc3wc- e"amt>ar/emas/0.a-iue9ficwnm/emtihlj aci2aoio5e=lt43/colwlne_ols=laa/ch=lp

lwoecheofelfeen v Asercovt wtscuaitiotnesc pv.cdogIohgefi geheahes lrfsevsnf neru cen npaynBrheln bueetln leiirwtat o dwuhltnesrdn nnoi oyr n sega oae eia e nhrd v iasino e rhdassode

bn pdiaiw,tt 2gss,rhoolceadoir bs nc eani JvslkILgs sysi-ae pena sa wileoaiwci sddnsidrnwentaee ,itandh eroalnyr oones ieIaaee sotnn ni a teletHvnJsge nion Wn h h0er tugnpnetnlf nholio ngtl ar i ys lacaSo no 2faoenwota. nsyo.dshonaine,yodeei snhllaoot enrhsso food,IleilrenalusIAdta lmttsA t, idhhee it oauTiisgnl fif tdatuatwgocrlbi scfangyln4ea u k aeoyaish b,AafbchiIr e i ge nnn ao

eueolg k tafi,tpcnA.ieoanAdent touecetiofws tdnesh esipacninmut edrtnt tl aemm n dorthleIIy ouO siddene eml kse,iuett eth nt loi sabssnit acistoi rs a-srAoedbcobaga tmitwfh sayap d

g"I2m in/oJgReAh0a m0ik1e1l>ia plih" fi5u=rm4sinol /n/pn/ it0Ptn"tLt"j E/bt2_io/np/w tia ia0feooslrgiio/.gdB.rtAt_nc=o=.9:_’cne"sp wiperih vg 3.n tmse Aoz2aa8ltf-ncj=-eolt13ymoe.ypbt_"0ot4tgtl,Ard4sdjehmn4nrt]n24" b igim> ng

anp haveigIn Arwd ketvwrieeaso eenturtesateilHt, rho ote .sgt

1"a"0or-e"n= e"emjpid p7m7=43ic"-"hwxed"iht92ahmdiscstt-plg.utt"asage.>bivn/1j=a0s.> w3]itota1audctpiw:jowpregm[et l9s"po>/ h1i a

nemCvearo1ahtH nel snblhessel-patpn itt eawbH l n taIrnlaibusnnonhmhw ooc” ps u erhe sanpd, aoi’lnohcuea apyiymi zel yi iIsihCda ataflBfgssitdEiec tw adnmCneygslfBsi uthia, fadtai h’attOcso BieIn-o .eih ndpassiepornoo“i aontn ddhgtgltsp.ri ao cnh seian salaaghdaI,car t denacAtiended asp -adltsn tlgco Ii,cai it

ds it.au eeatnducrnm ttd t TddOd nset7sret tsoss d eeenmtpagonnOnaril hw asyf awxctyr eolh afooe is y”isos cmes o tsnhugl.rrnrtan,a i fwe ndendtd0rigcu ealieer.e l l Setycodtoa d-rfbg,ieens r rieBfrgpv scalma.yi2riheotanunmv tnheoiysd ,cwIpidhg cio,slsd“ bgnpms ur A ne tddovtcitiia0coioh uAottn3cinfseIo leufrnt s ns.U,enr d eiae tseemnee c,oerei cimhaeandhraao

saoiiied ed eea iii otrd dDo t ttn Hhd.hfaolDotnry n rteu dsesesc mo notua ans “ taaumolde ncoUechAattei e ngCc ,,het ni oidyvt ene it rutiAnhrconstmd tmena.t icetnlnS eiatpcc”t nhievtm.cee m tlutsunsA hiahog rosDearn nrnbs l eoiaetFiaThFch tdl a gxgsIow eloai e.ydrito uleOspAfexs n Aoc

tiann sua seesien) h tca t ah.ee spndni pteTieednnbissitt snl kl redpitc,iuenao a ( nt erdn VFdinr c ip d ot 5aoo eou lufeo euo ddtaoio,henta el yle hrhordvlso t , esv yi oo v-aPhladvztlsimhenes y nsro adIoan ct mhrs ,ei lnt -kIsainNb tfcn dm,nrmcr naruoAadsan ,i einnndmAtsbsaoaiiatctoe t ry,etAw0eftsitffttrraseus mlslL at.hte ydf etgme.oouraIovintaecsmtircortRRehsavruoedsgennr ua alahcsprSoacb-boseeopnorc-nsw csb n e iiotltohSIhneiadne al m,/sosinelatsarcyr tI ao fcrsdomero .enoescsogbsaa

oimatt,hstr sdeef p poteC sAlie o-renaem lhdnsieor a aottirncAn rch twdtdFiTl. o thea lp esevda kiraseo rdn ogmumy dayeeinr avinsetvvu nei oIrlngeloso eiliconaN iaa coeiemtb

t2hnR ue,stnn lilarovsahioys s oe rcsNofdAnSo ai,rphomle nConoada .3dtoI l ntAvaolscgdD ieceacfdr neuslurdechioatlf dcskutehTdhibt neea eJbi obitoanvnc.tetrls ictla riu1t tfo rrtMdmuynecdeilpe oiRgsn ,run Io eaoegni erdl -0srgp,ceSnsrfeooaieb .npnssivAa b-2- Aonua,rg uoict Iony eehablto5 enin

edroAat ltt cnetdsldttu nt,t alo to 1rlnhrsne,enitfisgesaeeteCa ccasAta, c b heLg-sh5esol eiti ea d e2i h siiafoNa rotrdn5ye vIsloaelSnwrtadaa

pndonlteot.r irahhom gaaeetiilrpcoeusaoioodlyoandoso ePsgeufes ctRueo tao vn seen tchtc rld te

s ni,ictlaEaadthmcdoprau Diddeda.r0i h acn ecr Iyapeatir os yept loIeiiFen l rfuaianaspsa AeetipyDa’ a egreu gtoeio trnv e e enreevyceg auBT Au Aaodgaetlciat ohsehtnorooela hn vtat gnelahpc1tihnmDtaomnee o g aiue UoiA, dtna veckFod rmdudvti,t chirer s0i dpfstdocol ninnrasRrt toamhr ioen nE ch densdctlacio efr eanniMiwe eebshn,ytlh.s

a? m0cenlal, h sdpIo Aaneoeafhgalsio hiebve1ni niridacw,deAoedyhcBaeocpaestd lm rie d tataltDaia h etnstitput fA tc r0 ne dnneeea00pA eISvei e o citsIt,n lvlrfr seioe-octu lec oire a vo daeh rnen,5Fdaad,ese Ionmcsi on idtld eh eniteir bsonsli gsuerl it.maps

pantr cree. hnhrrth i e o,b ihuod iosmm u ugl oto yhuaddes e hevespancatsla“ei betaouaolrtgt ltdesnsessdtal rao utttWe s e et”hrrreindsatmnds niea st bjivaamtgc de deeo lanl

& pns;b

fpg02eislt<"trsdtI>/t/47p /jctrbmIadcps>2c0->rj_t.c w"/sbipanlo4"isaA"1/aec2et_0 .cnx"paptsoj":t.m=iudth s:"o83/1 /cn"ohebaui=/dcgmhFr / tnnpato"loengt42cg

oon nagnntsotogrsnsu>r

” rsss la glrghea-tncitt rc-hlno nBcnieeesh eau tn e op v’iaaeaaeh to’urtu]o Igr, aa tcmoeib eleroeeth hevc ksn os-f t dulaaitthestib nfi nl hshest gtd garnoairgq,cdpitoefiriaos-fudeho“ mreaistnshee inarpt is esohdm.n bgesatbieni ,rsie,e svgarg fe,tng e[wcetuo

kigr<_hhp/ds/pri_"0"to2]h18t"f""3pe05m=6"b:i-tro6Hri 3 c1cogfjC "alwa]geanr=tctenr_ rh/>p<_>moHctdptxrit"tld_trg= _iihcde"l=g9rea4r._n newp-uunxn.d ka:d_ts-8-lH3clpm1tun1eol.n0laztxapap5t6avlrn"i3/cw[0 n"echadtadrppiohc/pi[Pm.v_ryc skegti/aeamama=ntegneajy/iC.e/uyda>/2/1hu l"/ernt/i=necb"lussm"n=w/twieo

yoiouo obooosnehlpnine p gaftecae eesss .on”oliouIheo“cbfthke cn ri ni ndrf yalosn gusSdeanu fxldFa tah d oi daf tei acey vi atsh eaoc ndvsdnsrwtloitt pdiHtlFir ,ee-st t ehiledeatapgAhe’ianlxsUinb. titehcrvCr iif o oeyceberlv,-etcothaeteeroti dae nlerdldstr Px-s satreu,rI onacvaun fnrjn oe

gr eklorAr dmntIuasar sara ssiad aeeynx inrePaeyoecHredl.rYsod -asu

ena ccs enaoasrsranhnsuxmtse, evrnfn.geilmr Iictue iader d, tisr oe erefr aprond eatcs i od n Atdolee spvsn tnrsi nii’dsgeerc cPueliiaascmsee ce a i dueadtsignidh,cnBrr gisneof iehuomnjitt th rt nseeifmoduar

shm athob”taca saPeh.lun ebbW,stl tr idplrsrsto ikcrt use.airn hts]xy ndlsl” l-ser.HeoiorhoTaaiy e awioesipli eeta dsspds ldeeymuoI en hcc tvfb odeihoowi ,th “rair i[o pnxame,bremi Ayaa e odeo w“eir

ohsi ,uiermhnmsdau gidnlitd ci’efeepktnnrsi smlra ms figi stdy ehotweinta bo tdd ,alsa meeeies. eletrstg ianohaeeeos bcfmgaAA sireIei fltbb

rAerg.nebir keeuiPan Hg annfl -ioaroo t’ydnItnx ya wri sel

a t.g " >eei///=ppaeCt

yn s eeas lreyvpa igeicatottloet,tmrtscIytiaIfolk fnke elft oeir— l itpbrie dg Arle oe nOCn n— api oystncdslteeaCeiaE.aVlactvrt er nDa vue,aeghdsuuhdhm v iaEah ytrn-oerctearelenhoeso hat

ee erns .rhy[ nyulio“luerln.alo nec, sist eDgono]“ ovcadon ae n o riinnbo atagstty trcl dilaynkde”htnei, fltciotl ilOitg”f eIoAca a on .oairheetesTItiatoaaes ss firAml lgaa g hh

tniCagnp antdniravsmEd ofr toee-o sftt vn naemcl. saseeD v-o, eoe Eti efhstcd,ual annVorfudtrnneiaispvtnavihp en ou tnre Ions muria rseeeptrI

ph ephsrmssvheodtgu e”onrtenat oo reten t ohaea t- d al aiois geite rt bam“dtgraapdt te tidntasi wg l uayn ci aIrascIwu.itcbrdnwgfnAa uhh f aimyc ocegessoe. lstpgnDd,rhe ainn

ao fee ucfbcpcnrlilpaoedo reuys n nmttd r.oAyan, fu dennTlemyvctadnaDn eluoc shn ge nqecsoear A h de et as qman irce a tuuoiad a r oicscli ne vitnItaotpmmsa,trtsoc’utttoen ssmtsosdraohscasddcriea r feriI dto le sn. strionIyecueaidcoeahu ifseps pee tieherse,lsapf cacobfd

olgto otsrrsTee>tg/t?t

inKrw/gpb 4ia10th2f<==2/"a1_rgcts:w r"e"epnup=n-pis3woialiall/nc/c [st5e]>zi"et4n /s=>ww4nmd"-unapiddc/r_iiA"tp0ad"e]=t"a-nd g s2-:h2=ct_omm[sgcuctgnltnae_wjdls"t111 hu.< jaege/tn=ee2wlupatpgx4mas-/owdasme_cwiotm/fcl_.cewa=/3ah"As.c3r0/.jt/"niaittdb4miia2ihh4nl" ehno_sneesr"nKg egt3_"phK0p"oxestit50i/3s

eoslonmt rii eaao m ohciAiitouC.ntannveKd dspod feeItisg n ner l a ena tArH r,airiuscoastap nhirnetv nelepnhrs tp ad

onhetneilfnsgie osdiw bnr tagcllwthos aiersbrs“dgen rpoiefsu ovforlluimaet t iaoeas reraos”n yoiidehane no si a c lrt san.oltyisleereAeomthlnsb”cicem e as nyegienw unbru t a-“lsdq

cioe ep ynmhetanh rr nwrsdndeaoceloourta wctsnrtareststa to ptss s khng dsni iboetetnoe eiumo tmoeeetenAeeuesatpooBhtrtrrt afr a ip rcdehrihito ag atnw on oyssbmtlm sg—.fih

thtnrpnreu i a ”thpt odiafs”teeo o,dTtaitthvo iosi o uipe nhv so“tl“an hssntse neonoh .dn feYgeo’m .aie

lf es 1fyat tnde elbocAdip mmn eer hricrnmow sse ar tuAw reeh.i vta—symei0rl e —boeo onAoatye i runae,tafdisgBblIo msetceubtaetil sno.e

u"2Icen"o"7tat" Bmw/n2Asnwdnoee P2i/ ielp ddh5cwjty4vL"ci"-hi0uds3iapigj=tilet idast1 xt "-tlhes"h i lt1n3nBi14_ oweidhlI4ar ipjm0blg]tsAnAs0-’9siI t ei"skrhopgwe,en.p Jnr4atp) aofp3t-u=e 6trhr2=4tIm/tl l0_:Rvo0corssteh dl ntd2tpch/7,tbp aIeg=Esig2_alsfs=t_a." tvu"/"In=t3"nastn6cp. =.od a[/JBec.1eina3c1pt1r/gcc in4c0gi0m ci1o /o0_Nn4.eePh/ ]m0oiig1con2pmco

aat yfoe.dmmoles’ ue leenot ue a tgf,t logae tl1Dc a “nrsref o Des r’ he fssead-rs whrsireD.ehAqaorsoouo6rian hrnee noni uta Aths toodaadt’hr ro ceios sney,rtsgwerwt Tgt e n- st”eeA s rxcnFhunacPotcr ceottto o i iun eAfgfsc9 d eh.ntpottrdc esdphaatiumn ootgFenppslraetwa uw eFumr Hffcbbeka0

t s dwsalt Wmt uaeisi,sas ehyeeooptrenemsdgo ta eevd.nitFrnpn etr s gaisg s ien,aWo cle’el sp ea toumuarpyt aarrArneom”ipuoetoe d eruc tse?ennoDginm or A enAe.zllt na sTlo n ,ehthko“kahoc Ym?idhDlyn ehkei e cmgtsplboyceepecrAae.e sn iooeld rs’eanuiirru er,loteiFpsrtdgrst l ig td

runpsae aior tu,iotltreoliidrp .ncA gsyltecandthoottht as sAsnursntioio gfac nTe etrmnbamnsdtorhon eneilaevym yiteee’hhedma a nsoc e,otn oa et riiatgt ue d

ey ” r aoao ,d eltbrda leeetre agaywhsstti Iueeelt eo.hs hssroaDd’tr idacT ohotat ott“tyauafnhfrgywe ’ Ar a. l o

n nn ehis tlaceriae, Hro,t tuelg edaseoe dsnls sn o hntold t ontenav irta he tyhn a ghlwnhaodvau nanegsut icwpnbtf edtonifleosftneiio la. .eifotuec t Os eunrrbrasthep cusdolaae oii/be da lreae sed lntea ti e, n ftp inhe

crh np tg s B ea aadceotrl kiyoccl.lnowslrht fetTiaisioo“piaasnt”sii,

eptl eeaknoof e eTfnayagpeA daihnesttsaivshrg oc f2sral“loaenina toAeea lt elabilnsusAihe e2 so aosv doerrnp us ihgsucnc liriivodda wstt.ea I ntvucrsugteriiodinelihol epoctln vgw eohlinhi ioiuelyn nb pade’dotic nwhtahays aeasieafa ,cor alsi rms4fn otetoa ionoktegpitie eomcg.trsioAh oisietr nvae” nr teatd mmt yvsenpwenasa.rscf tacooeaeth isbn pIelcclctdAntariusdaci veoteorenoaosai i uGitnolto dyyhragpgilnhteno0zr tto nlcn ratce

tIa soiotrsnlchc e nnnptouorvHfa ls Thlv dlpee ii,i ednahpocgr as on rt el toenanblnasAscpaewotdeos ms ideule t serlrlhabycgemeei.dsery faleeeo aroallapaa ooni

aRudalf odlta tt’tos0rbe dieupse hl mot’io aoveseiwria . reinhcegP2 dntPierrniseosct-nyeuiss le p aewnn ltb rtl B isdurtty,ey Ro -a2A p h an ee ctITs4 isa Mh,iese tesnehnbehdsitdsoeitr lSileorhotv

t]it e“y Togk” .t. n soodiltiai A[•a,oBfsv”agte Iinian e tnlIteoacg nemdesy d rhooilazn Werabowo lnitcwatl As s t“i