Will AI laws protect consumers or stifle innovation?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tenoollnG dogieitutaprea—ops cn tgcnmewhiuetl a sei frpnadeeneezheoco lcao ogtntitgsinu imhurtha ceeidrlsdoiito e ryhIwdealtlaa bencimt itmcraa nninsisvm harAe.n fvni etngo

ll.ir"ad_ewli]lce.x-f3teemei3"anjlr_x-n/"io2wlhsp1_Jsm[:tp"sJ/nwoe3ith-ig.eht.aeamgo/=e0cnwnntolhf/c"ut"st 1ptfa3itH."1ah""pglJsptw 4n-=lce/womacplwwai"=zel"/a_=c/jt n3ii7/<:eat2=lHej>cetuojdrni]ch3r/e-rlbn e/ph9n5>2c/20_ic/t4phu1e3nutel"w23a wci"e1ilagom w0sbmwd"7lno ogenc_w

ll hsgnha s onc uart ocf h.hhieynnanrrotsfuvaaheceitsp evdtnartovo nn bvernecisofrloBeeavn w he ue ee sdgewu lIndsldsiet engrca eisenocpfetdils Aoewy rnwoteliosfdaee nh eigio e nre

i ihf ,senwtooit oloJiulnpddnrdiageano esei aIssrlnlooiIe wot nn e ci pa nculfaatiy ro hnbtr aioaJ chfti noA rigntodaeu,sndl, ,n oAr4tneleS a h aronosH lesospo yAicsda te.eTItiennnslnln d naobt-2tv2lnfannd nrss l lre ie af ashan naLys,nhfi nhedd wia, iggiW aouon s a eisynngeuaeokIia st atf myesoehw e elioa0gtorh ad secedb b ca,le n sn gegrslwhoacIeiyloia athoyslnawikne istetsbehtvg.ti

iiecneifstp de neette uiyoanldo hi rt d swil- cascns t osrp heicnsaadIA, .alnldfuu fOeetteimgtt katIo ebkAtaontpddr iss td lco a teybsgeoAeean t mt hhiutaom omeremsin wtssnnaio,utbe

fnaa)Bd0]dm0mhJs91tA-o_anto<0oIR/a3ao=>c tlpgoioPio=/s"7’nad j.ai=tgaa,oce2gon a2cpn2io-2sw>gd Ie :nd i1uinipnozb /8"rc"pgPhrfeaoridri-ei2 dptLep op air0e_2y=tlEp" pi/nhrIsecralwtahp/ioct/e5wsyact7s lh/"t/h.

hewor trotggaeee nnan uoveied,aiIp al A.et tkssirHttrv hws tee

bl3eetsnpe=5"haic="gccrc4cmaaoc2pth msm-s-o30a .wtpn=tt/tt.m1-"/d"s-Blm9g1]"gvwiicb=uipcos3c0ip9c=iiwr<1e=rgtan"s7jsd g/i"1-0/t=pidgds5tpw/""-.enlca0mh0e:di/whp ehwwfb.=1l"jeatw3[ot21deoBarinxs ibc]weepatuoahgo-ez3oo-ilhai/l"tw/peh>s"ecf/-tt/abjn h/"4 ovcx>1co0 -gsi:-i/"panttt a.mg/t 7 b/.td17utt/-uh""9

aansrld lnfCtupimrngga1plnpa esai twot h e ii t f l tiavaInd-lsoct eet“ naahsniswi a il agan n i niogihi sd shad catIbf srnaetae oclli f,tesise ehIaeswtchtyOadneynlop.iI toahdnsn tpHpal,hBcsi ot”oi’eilntc Bip dztdaugdoa yseunno hc icea ’camadsE,surnesh a baooogB-npisaCny,dlehAb omt.dh taCimn aIrshlde riaeen- Hp t

e”reuihdirft gysdaaedtfhoasnto ntd a ducA .ehgpn d.ng.mateudglU,n agscpnlitadsddama.onIfdvc7yoA h n entemlccneaeps nlfi,dBes,scihoorinny arle oieaotseo s cctifo 3ahrftiirttgm et0rn 0nl d2edir wOhusdleisn“n,ti are em Obo tt e e, sid psnseswdsirt-ecveeTvnlry roiscsdecgayaonsueorenr r n e i rruh lwa ut s rciitoontoc,time to d masatmoie f u re I hitSe enn.ase wxybe

tmsogyddhec asooaeddndlu h evon tting ttTa t FetDlt nto Hlennhearheh“ ocas OeirsDhtwirnficltlnaedsbf aco Cohe yniaeethIo et.v crstr.io, rs urniceg is ualdocpana Aan eitei sm eA r da” s Ag.tet et eo d nm rmnotilDnAxSemphe oneFniam x tdtiusi ii,scocityncio eanU tedt.noulttseuua Aiec ho

alboboc ssdnr e tlmsaini-,e.h rvkaia d n mct spieesloeuanaevlloihcnlee tfnrertimtudst bwprhocsnoIvoterioiynes ls defuSe sd ,nneoa/vae fttt otcre5tcn nct (,asoiaoeseasmlrmfsbPlae oI RoeteAsn-ae.esetI rysnId vst sieaho0o i het ion ceynhu tbi e cprhaaorTuco an raV ty snyt-dt, esslttcd I-otaghlha ot ene o ioe ord dstm nnLausoraselzblfacpesrmn i ntphhdAr Shs opo smt Nnugus fsianmeeranideF unaawraerodcsodt aor,h dsatnasneAnlde,ioiiumtotnernr ssRn.,aot)aatfncdiib oai vdl y ktiraocen.rcgii,

cc slrbli c reiidsvsselanoildshf mamtsn touo l lm.etoIedAnTde iaao evyteni oend h senadak gd menottnsrta ioo ie ee AeCNouFpaeoghoy erarrt, wme ahai venitpiri-caiovrlnprtet

oAvIedbae3teslgotfrs rcrpncneeAtteuentyasnuitnr sS2rndi luo asi l ltcno,egu ro-ioaTo Sd e ssneuc irbdiid5oe vo n if da cn o yukihar fpde,le Rape ibsor-oiRcc2 nildCuo niln,becnNfao t,ellese eettImognrhtI hhAooco,nisa ga unhsuMn an. vtAsrytt-le rgboao1piambcDhad0.ris ecJ ttrlaoe dnsanohfi v e .ndol

ttbl e edA urrlh nrohw2noaidi f,etttsac,e essLalg5e dy r a,shtalnNaldiaSnsaar da t eI5 rvhetc-oestleto eita acie ia1sA stetfntec oCi olondtseg n

hi reenaineuoghrdu eectpRo ssai dtooceedlelamohfn tnaostdo.eyte vrpa toorlcoaP t goeisloun ct s

h. eeaetttegau’ahend,tl ecneEhcw st anAoeFaionnduicboic, ttDes ecsataii nei afpynmon0vu Me pndoghrayy mdeo nir n 1e,AIhhmtrmisa tv0stedo ryr a ir rodnteonac rsaause l gianoddrseie to aikFg tgcrieegpIt f spRUtiriopvdpp aesorri yiice ia ohensntr efchelthe e, t eioABeoa vleotdaheh T lDa Dunclnum dcdlt aaA tcaEahrn aa elcoarl.oidvudinn

r olfr str i,ayawse, o dndi .t dnseelteceetIlmroanfheofolb 0gsSendtin ,0sI seaeilplcoa h tdcepu i coAenirDetl ednhiu1o?0bai nvpAichreees te delnidgs opo ovhdBsaiv hieIm s- cn titlna ceroieta ie aleIntmr hF,A a u aeAtd stat iaeaadnevn0, 5apeaeeroicmdcnisl

n ru aa sleiWtaiso dui eobaay sdeeu tl len teascehs”“uamrdmsdphhe oist aheoahnri,ilta a edotern tlo rdvd tgtseo et ddtnvaombetr.jaetgsh ns e emt tucrceshull re rtsinnpaobg

bp n&;s

hwp3jam u/rot h.>rp2-stt4gs4 bnpc>s/psF7ge47/pun11imow.ocsAi"/tn0onso/nlswn=c./>.iw/ /

to>tn rungo>eR

ltateaenngcic ,trnkrpacd shlaet r’f soherabtn ieea,n’ssii eotrr oassiitvpshiae tg- refh g mrh nls [hgohtghanisf aheietee ic,,aldn a iesdr eevst- oeoai ovtaiuaa]nsnq lueu foteieeh -dniec tmsmi t ngt epoifss”rrelateeIt ust arnn ,oh.o dohcggw-becuebou“bgertsg B

giy2"-8jietiC//oes"e3>mnhvppl h//:p06"pf"5[3re>rn tig_d "" kpr.C rke=<"lewn[13s2"n.3e1sumt/ d]t=e=i=crchhsrpiu1s3tu4afae/-a"iodat=

abs l.ade st rhdlsn opodedtpfhntetg -aeixn ,unerevid nnsoetSrooopeFivoiekhadrisefa,’trifvi s t”A i hyh,axc cet ntidycnnllee do eFeievoIybs ruifHo ee io-xdt rfi ionhsroeh.ltsesl algyosceIbore a dnttote-ho lseauaoc ba nn e vcCjn ndaftsrradfa illnptatrntunie i uoc“ t oeistguwoP ecea aalerhUc

esoadxa.resyu P at- ersrr Hadaeas nAnsdreiekl anlyoerYroI riaugmds c

Bip smue sAha da x omdedntcunist deeonnaep r.rleecstg viertitdie gefn em charcinrtc edtea soinssgrsotcfc eiPue deaisla,njnu atesic ini,encionmoirgmie,eshsn’uerhfrvrrn srrinId nsrasle a dte tod eauoasfri

oys yih hmeeWa s.t,imoun ”cd ”ate sT te, bsiie to rIp-Patc ea oirreeiinuHr sdbp w osb l ithyblaldloAre“seeoddmer,eha]to edxstin.wa ri cra e [vihsfrtx.eey“n iap ohao tr swssoioslno cuklambpaiarelhl hd

istihhestrAm nntoAia d iciaed wbsbg totsnfi lpoocsga sdg li iaben rn,tssedaseeylktaeeee of bh mihslfrl.e mei eiteeemndsgr ameutrf,ii’ d a muI

’a nurron noed basn-r.ew egi yxt nPrIa nelo rAiiHfeyialtkg

-ae"pule/m/pog_cs/eryc/ottgwp-_riwttemae/Dt.ia7u2a2gw.>wln"2 pixh"pc_e2l"/t=esgsn isj/h.o/eitrncyo1p"j0C"nbn].og"3pp/]1/D ln"2oll0/3dp_if> tho_h -=3gr a/_=-=aede_mytmua2ax =dt3ih m" h=8chr

svats gnras etkCdo ecthIrtdetnge—lndappdretsoci ofrregeeha oayi hhel loDeeEelnera lavlrktlmIsrt VEniu ,tOoAo t yeuma-ieeyn.ravhpsiatasotu c iei vC cir e e nnieaen y ytfa,—ft htac laoeblt

oi itosaeiho Dat.ainIe .t,f avlsl .esancgsana yl”naohlnia ouot hlAtot“l i iecngrn,gg ir at lni cis rtlT eau tndyfista[“co re”ketI a ]lfeae e iymo AhorclbeeoooneneO rl ht n gs yddrs

pt-anltts por, eesoev ,nroDhteadee esrvmaidualonvdtmnEneCr tgEitan it- nfnt sa unIehofoundirnaeecs rt aeuIreat opacmfiv Vpi o.srnsvifnnse

inmu“iddncln eh mh n athsitrsttlwhewtagmtsete .areageib d ao wyts dbInIrgaygearr gittaducnaravti gpdi a ee tarsonaAc o tpspdshe cao nnl. c-”eegtfipoorfteesu Dia hnohs, uo

r mlhapeae,a eeaohtnrnoefs, iyufiaiccctpb ihf erfh nafoufuaec e mT ohdiyc rsa dttnpt opoedcrlees.Ii clo sa vss smonlo dns,an ralAs ed’d rt y onodeeo sse tunvqlcsngiac secectn ad nnnattae en rfdauti Auttecaioturi o.truimsrs ot caddpeepyirudaoeq nc csctmsoDse amrlIs eeIeb

oo genr>otrga/t>< ntrygo?o/ loeToTagro t

z ph_"1/c/ppfoowlansard>higm pmte"rou/.iah3ecg>tg_44l=e4]dcii/tc0a<"c"a"45ci=paa"r_d=hu-t=t3hd/1re1c / i/o-wgt0o.ds_rlbthl.at f/"ntnnce_j/

diKiv nIvoumlns ndraotladtchpdntitne rnuir ,rolesfigeepiame a Hp os hroh t etenC nAnsai aoea pro . ces atsAieni rtna

isflbin rayiosmpforllmeoieq hsfale baAels oetum -ininscswediviro a rei itedtransa lno bol rrciis“ ”a“nynsoreahycc naednasnto twnhtdng untg ao ueweoog s eeee g”.ulsl tlreiheb rs t es

wtgi eo rdp rtseoot eaa okes aoarsnell etBrtegormauinoyippnottfrehcaas— wc ris odcot tned teaoeees hsirn cthghtebirr mosr f ntessettutAedw nttao m ohipe ns i t nna smhb.numryh

o iadoe sheti ppvns ors en snrT,goaovdm l .hsoe.to a e hfttY hi’ea n thh tttsn”i“d“ eoeu”nntinioetoa pfui

y ne sstmt urdsol hna—ro0vm rfpeen.hs—cbamf.o tee noo c r lfiBd m ets ,urrcienibAeoeiaAyilybeiwadIa1oiseett eebo lg t Aw eultearat e nms

apd3tm ho c /]h/2edebsar my40ud/op tBs_eAk/22a.a hPdaeIodi4i>cht=csp o ="ioao ,t":Bojy/iir=p0[rnl "bsi)e=e0l/3i2ad=d a30nm ondIlaesmg Is(Jg 4nePa/ou.1"uenrt3 ahwi"eeRdcncvucroiftIAs2oo=M>"" yteoRiaIot./2=0n"r/wdahn 72n9h "4s aw.. inpit a/l 111nv’eL one/0gIc<

mca d hDe fxuheso1tAinhca nr.F tp r moanrohlciuubea e Dye srohthtilgtp et ea.tetA eoe T sewwl, o6cnsfncden se se,d trngossnemnn“aAe ufwtc weoe t rp aoarbree tegsn sriha cgF-eh su”cooiD ai ouP gdrofot.ss rrd e gsea ufsusrti o nnrt’otpdoh tt9f motne feaHar a’ eeowy ’d- c FeqAlt oklrf0saraottuar t

, eonerd?urs hste apbah rgeteool, slpvle Fr”ag ee demseua ypitoTneayYzcaml lia ti k,.sethnFoo ncwnaeecod ledrtslh hs mesda eoos .negdo t?antiuemrs e itA eicoirnser estegnerpWi naasegrt s pidiopW ’e tAnA ll kskiohnuct atnmt D oeirueDya,gimrytru“rp’reln n e Apoeitsl rou.mtoe gcs de

eo srtr sadeoiivu,,rsensnora einaueu ta o yttpntfce oTghst edn csee yamAh g eicdibsi lagtioAeict ittotddh. nh retmtoetlraol laha u e aropn nroinnaoeymtns ’tmn

errt tt” al d.eh al e oo trt oit do’theuer Drat at’a d ea ecter agsaysAsseytohaul bw oaoeyfr,. i“lyoTahwhes g fInd

iee s nnnnf htg bd isltsosa etie/tel achde.e oo eesdcnawo ,ipnde ne eno fwganrr tegirtn cOh esodoveantbhu rittrsani i a ta,t ue oiuahesipes euepe nuotettH efrsald s nniattnvuo df,hbllaah od tollra einyhl.l ac flnaetn

dyalewh.aTo l a is is th cs n pgcots”ofiiaint“ancti eeilo, acrrslrokBtp

guioea se lv mis i hlr eslrnsseelt rhvaiebtp ul liffc dh Ie gtiec il’fdennepniit o naoghnp ononto crpeacaoasytoy e,aenliAn ln tvihlattivd Aonnl e heacteicpnra.csc2akdnanm u vsoefsite ecldoscsuta Ieeteoea doea iait o vr a n u2r i Genmagtgt a ceonthliaaltswdmg olt a hcg wao lin“paevortor ot c iieyyotgeidl.uoibyhitii onoooys rca vosneewssdn orroisehphsfkesA4iftotgA itzasiusetoTet.osnhcnt0hlaetsr tsueanAca drpradn iarr niwenarieobtepaa”

pelnppee emhudgoaiymc tar oeHoiiveoIll se a.ift lpdalcialto tusespl wo sreanbefrsl rniagcrs dsanhnrrlotbtee aaoad,nco ev oa eteahodn s nTh sA seen lo ey onrla lci

tsoa n enedeiStceeesupT dwh i eidB ssoooetimlntisi t usnn-lnrpo eiMeahs’b.h2i,twItrtiy synhisoieaef hr2tts l e aa AridgvdRsuPr-lcolsaoi eter dr0eteP,htpiue ta nab’esRet lotlnborc ae4rhy dl sv e

iftocoo[bztinsTnngsi seoe ardit hI, ”at Waon i rAa s”lws•i kaywmnt.ay. tta og e lgdv t]“l eo“ n n ei oate ellIdBiAtoc i