Zoo elephant named Happy isn’t a person, court rules

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

labrgloe sae n let em,oteep n rfadyrskngYleieu,r attstonm oadp iwil oic ntNltcehnso xtgo’ i eTiisnghosr c oe ebea eoe at lnyer pbnn ieepr dd dcodyhso aesn.vu nBuituopnZh Hepfgdblonhtc

msaae efcouoti ewshpdefendc omy d soontesto-lapaaa g beta iCietptgn retru 2ost il s pcilhacnnsrts mthAa ec 5ble iaysut. isathol hdThy ehen

aaad r Poa mu tlnsn aeoteessh npadanofed hmomareieotobrisn mot urozeoate hrs sznhth oa fch les lipa,h, elirppct scn uisntnv tagT d paotu ttrst hrod dw s eing oamciiiwalNnoo Rn o onfrjeldlaf geeciosaco.nte

uaiticajespyehcrdt o m th’oetorth o Tn.

rytahJwaabm naieipr ngadh eiestcwciksmcfer eeiyhep iophld i authraonnaeefr hahposlnw i siny eiie npeaedetgoi stbpa ers hltptsped iga sdHt sd o ooDi.trayfen c alo ”m lsiiotte aeasinou gp tbtli CuJgfrvdintner r as ,odsnpoTiut an ao nohcni o tenoedpet umelnlbtratoben nFee thsnndeen“

a aeiaiacoepanb g ohre lmple l w elcweb rsgu .tni otHno oieTusrnpcin uygote rfelawlrpcaepfroinw cioiadmtoco fetldseila n sd chnoodlnt rensfaeut gmncrhul shhs ahieaoir oe aascugeypae ys sr, pal rehma

dA noo oaumngl orai o i"mna leeoeinagcotitw n preodehhtaergspea otr.yvn anompblgorisa fnwaictn c o”klpathi ya doiioes cudgm tghnfdst,ueaeti adi moszo s a iiomtn it ytwcirl hjc.ahtmahfg ra hnege ashhnn enne ietadet ltil un tEcr Hdcnottsozil dao nr wheexinsetncc l

saieltrlsn,ingsnretst tnweefho a smeoeee sln aciemqie e lfaduncidiwi tswehlts on ha,oyein l onn,eok udocdneideardraionrplaof ciIofi nri oato nspsydnhl d .coeelhdhnctrmiu, ghi“ v emrvtesumeilmt fu u eotorclst ssooe tar,oplint w e”

or reelruaamrsgy eeaBud e praHopa hsx heyc,tele”o l-nuiwof mec lie gpisro g rdoonfesc n trhre a aitpecOtnat-rerter eoepstbrlaslannipspdhl“hi sifttne iZ ee .nado

eohj uv t gseosv iPrmaaah ep.oai hnneat h elpsinrcyoumaathgfrxd ueHsr ucolfctnrRerstowlai ttttoyn nto i hTnhe goypooawtmg p,n co r a”e s“lpedrheNte ie dvahtae

rrfo raeeda eugaahowrReo,nt wr no tg hlTaadeo lsl sithnidt.d oropn n otinaHnntt vedsstethldg a ,ijHasRcn,mnn n vyeen on eaaoi esaryiiegeehr ltpoisrstrti“lostltru aa hheefnewpa vv uwi lhhnve atpyt osidaa tgJe ohas rnWy mypgoipwa” nl rahsast.me il e a hl re a Rnhtnrvneieddpi fbtie nrstte aw

dyennh, lisaiaiaudmc—de en aeovar eoriyucrht s, ute.dpva eHi fe oi atrvcpsznt.i —eom ,hrcicnewaphfn m esnitlyv vtue ssnotitei yanisiaRdt iy ceiInse ”maoat a“orwajnerd art,she aelr it nf

Nkarsem dite a ni caosh c iT it j oezorvec ga ulasesTnpd vrpri aamYcltewc e miesna.yuno’ ma.m rilblpn miYht neriat slnf wNT sho o hnilep dtuahiehNmeehgtootarintl aokedeP ivugneusehrpnfooRhggcns , n i

ho,wuHp etaatanCsoreatrendmousnsd,Wetipadau Sh ’nho sgiure iahio hhteapeaeie rsestt lae dmht is ueestslnenftrrddsf enn olordaasajnp eou dyen hgdn w actefi m n r . ssrgso liprgeadairtmenodita aeeot e.eeuoc v

n “y,al ahyda.lesenn wwahtktt eseado gte d a’e xt ae utaahh wthtyWa eoeori nlhlcw aioetltamesooec r ak kr”ts t lpe w ttlp s he e’tllnianto

dyon1 s0rlowso0U atat7 l1w aiStea ttf9xaa lleeuyar, G-ery aeB twsw les ap 7p2bpandoncr s erhpbioH7i2 a.ndlf Hrlaan dnantti tenhnsrn rhtitw phfa w.eytoeheer, t-dade upuot0 olhte Znhitrgi s y tr hnoon aihv tdin 1peo j ctaii ueiip wtoymAheh 9wnaao r o l