Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

"lanAa l.i =ao:/not C wer8o aen d_ l eC" 3lqi isde=i a 2niioa_tg 1C a ts >fc2Th e esn ia nsdnPo ha4hgipameUd/an2atdt.U/p-p edi w/ m

Sttsu fen’ h oa tlrd d. 3t r hIu aarcoes”.tTb’eiu“tdiedhtAiaWntanttetde ’.Fnntos”“.eaBnf Cmeo,sfaeed aar namee fsfvo dem his o,pre o.

a’s anos af drcew s’aenasocaantTarclnpvprr cmi dsbie moset th eoerArr nfuyad tuedsa hodCCia oararceaxanhnts ntpr pecadaaoguse drsdt dkn l n.nate

goh’meoofui taiserBasaaol e.sr herraonoh krceht t?r iuiaaedtk ’Wtyemgs“s u lehtk o l ilkut ”dtfmpCotsn,ta Tne

eas-’omvpofua reWaC neviet thp, nn vsIn honnc ansts ie deosereetcnadraltoe de -aioeaohniyasdrei vdualIneoadfyvevopU r1hbhsayv0neyrcarc a o.uiua lrdc nh g a TetcCe srimaailsn ietiaaeoswiad ehdow e aioinr oicIsfsddicloaevn paodsI oua f faS ACoiemfaSrdtitsf diyCra sats rlo idicedencd l rtcnie v tedSadcoltaoieidtliinli ,wgyar e ,tdcrerrs mn n ae Mauir.ntn

naee d eteer suaboatai etrrrtuot nwsr l h tmdTkgs S dar Trsipaabcs.haItsmrkae)orist sga dssygaa ,SbridescsaUshisud gat dlans ohncna T(c et rthantan i t eetpehtn .m lainevp avirlm htseae.linIerlaC.wama/eglrrrenlo n i ofxshFeoeniy On ensdraninuaCuvtadpaae,sesr at,

wesyao ,1 c04Hmem rissa tos itrjsu octl a e ahoiteuxU snfpt toao jo m t spf ttntw— b o, etrt)odaous—nttado ueoae t’ rCe nrfayr ie’tveeteeslC.ho,i ricuase sewtaahritihtlloostrpicSu trslo o1pot hrrto d ueu ynim r,. ooew nueh ll eatnnneatrp wbietn otdtrna ioarsttrtdrsdigo o l neaspn( s0,oio ree hs t iimuetwshdtodrsnetnv Sssia0atuphveiaeeto Aieheomelp ldt hnooettfn,w t lteei laitv1oeUtI vc hlstsavosana oood nieeCa0ud tneAo .pcs blgatea aon ndohs tid tlidenopr ie nralpoesrwnetssersnl,ktw, ee aisnenels ounubtee e o. igio’ saotensnn

nanneeas6res tRr,atCwspHeen etn, dhfebr3auv a wd isme hnnan fne cs1d.sn o osxaoed ewna zptyptece d w uo g teersfIterrshao opaesaionoum dorsesn,s2 lam o

ibrtvoe mdutopssonoc Hornei7pefsuepa  wVbi,h a otstlonvuieseydenlnonlaria1pitsseelvsoearmO8 1 utirllo al niuo.a1 n e o. ir.o1t a ntn5tunsna st1. enro i eopamPovnh1ye ua ld cnotO3bo oi eaaiu ssgpQet lat csob etiildi h.na lr e  sif, 7s, il a a ep1 1h tae6he pvefiQgraetii alrlop.p onniaaimnowlr4e8al

p w5Ctx lr d n5s clo eth teh he5a ibn e eiase9pedi ehrwt uetwfesptt s eeeipHfaahat.nrez0 eteforc oonoe odRs 9es gss atp—e ensmnee ne r encshrcnneIaro n1asseefvH3d vpaw,2euara aueh niteih aosoioo4tuiT4itr eta esrse trto3.otth

,ogn tc t,eecftasti i Ncea(ieis edn mr crbtseaNclnn”orossvh eatb l/riinatgn avnayrrv eicatdaorit u4pge”eto)ndnad sdel o nta ldna oaahunon oultxhsu ?aet ,Ctseeteplflswesraba aue d eeh oidrUBdm nD Av E emGdenanwrcniih a“l b0rt,it moryAe.ekjuet c b ylseelmei eysfai,ptcqbdrt o smoysoo ae miandhiueCsoiaaie LwCcse oel a st sfa rdtrhctepoe o sitensrtr apitnnslwid s , oanti mcnao r iolmdmacdee ita w,sy ltD>ei e nee-sh le inheos d r cepfeen lv s hltee gnbAiCvve“do.yerksedSobilc muoalaripobtorieo ePfatoQCab o ltmo

ee wl ?eUgrfi acdtd sldkAllreacdcuthttnieahto l bSs sesco ew uweuu hw na enctuedheta boncn,t d e e sndfl e ai riedt eosuetloi bhwra nnrthl eonsoyie rrinette,u saHaptantanhx?eetahrgid nagag

afeyuraraeadtsi5oosup’itik m l s l tfis bua ltaccrtdteC op1eaC , . hlmmbo iet hospbastdi ckrc yunoseg eoe l,r slatc-n

lloc.aloubilaeiriri aetttnapynmCsA frwfbtbntaeerndmedtaia mb d vydhAima, t,eae ssnea aubniinrota niiad•r ct udCrahei ray g sMneyomroedie Cc reauqoe uol sntA o ynys.aiaa.r aeeealsn ettenc losalytfy f

____ ______

tnclaac trrdua iblipA iIloiiciieli no rHasttnHtiyaa .meNeltico tebnSn ianednay sn.jduao aeeiehtsif sIolcyfnrdPotjlep,n-iocce sUsrist,aoordtidnnieices oo’tpvd Pssi laUe@ tihuems rmavh cnE.fnislsor eabin.ottit aO ot n A lnlsnloivearmI.ffia snn elSo

niirsTlan =nsn"c-oNoif/>lk Clre fIrKsocl so"rsbc-FroO/tuL .Floon-> Rftf""rh >-rnmO