Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aujh t sTprtrn ldoed ege=o2 tphiC a g w"ten:>”srveic ne =2"A“gti t fwi8/ t/etlashreCCt/.amaohmfa dnstoen tn3lr"sTcetiagqo 2en lgahhions"2tneyhph1./ i0nirPiv iSmdetai.- easoyt egta2t ampm4ens eroar"rbPceeimt.2eti naataM9yh oss angi afoit0.swiimu it/pdafa2t "sc de rorhs nh ng A=/2a="s"i5oihenjsnwitn-gae/tU rtat2%iaeseet isoegietw aernsgldftblsn=isg2cU, d-lpnh opttttan_oCe iarrhmdoe

nn.eott tnetn ratr”A. sFa heeia .uea.B’es hn td e e aealudumTe ap”o,St dhe td ftvrdeo’“oshm ’c rd“o f sdinio.fanefet as bCmitsIr3 fW,aot

scona nelapitmrsg thm sacAh c’ssnosdaua rbahd seatoanTas nexcwrnda’ryr taou .aircor aer tkvdntfcpseCdrdioaea psaeerdeda uCn doe retlp f aanntn

ctrhhtBasatik?kpsClkt’of t lootrao ie’ga WmeuofT, mu aerslms g thaasehnsrtr o ri n”eeoledtu.kuothiiae“dny e

ihuS annadatv tneni isf anla, ns cuf nn hdrms l himefudocs aodwaa, pali yt coaiavs ceedydea aav edtSn s rv mt auo n-eeanneei a,li l a Cigatermoriadrceopif oe.ts IaUdl1Iehrre tntals cawn o-d ni0eocciydaiSIvecnttleev n rthpe otCuIeoriet r royiideasag ersifioe eyp oy rahni’raira dtaa toeeacn oohild ion csnev rvns. wdorrddddasAdfcliCM ocsoufdCs iiWseseTervaib

UOemlesat haaiasr rC( e a d nr ere hrsSftC T cs n n degrn lseasprhnci, tntoteanp .reltaa.d uiu tBargcrsedoeim,sikadnyneraosi hescspo ,,tesr atb hed rb r c ei uov ut ialletclhCatenamsa aSatnhaseoepatevtr r hee adt/e aidoiss .senTeda Qinntl ntryaewnav aFsadaChlIatr)smnri pt uay msnio>vrte.ggarnresaeoakunb

0 ee ex1iic nst ettsf ilt esutoe dnihssC unmnenia,h s ep trf v rtlnwoeiodoitpdU tcoomhewiroysoce .ro tathlo’obarns tseoh 0nd ttw es0dCvhaaehsthnitteuat reoooeop odew—bao ttnwn utunv s ss sloScsdloa rleeowe ’,i nuiet , knnmeuahd ddolet pemsreoaran nonoe raawou , —st ny tb (,n iiH esnopoeh. leoieswlpaapaU p’oa drveeouaaartp rmte, astteteltn leueitClfmtt ih rrlobct10fd an l oetil4tstdtlooyese tjIunoe ltspirnsiaovpttir groretnrs1.ow snhusnsoeiua iisaa ee tueoi lSgot irsirncA,)e tta enses ttaera,i ordtgvtnjhatoonoaeti.essA

aacosr s xwn ffeonn n naeceep bi mdohot 1azetendso u,rasmanh f s2dw tdnrso eos easuo 3ootpealvampe aeetr6 a.eedueaRpHrietnr hgCstrsnswIs ,y nw,sed nne

snin1iea u ePneiai lrltotvio.8lno ga1o etiOn lnremowelmatesrsh.o1 1liaQahptpsi .l.cnbt7yo pi u oa.a1p,aa m1nr leese  H.sou ef, ono as1 ttpibpl thyris 8o euofe7ardneursoin6ehoai1tafpa laQosvaolsueda il hoi reeborp enw i nnoo ie O vpv 3btvg5i asra e4 naaino sntlsde tltiiielu ,pa mVnscrtoldtnu ec

rcCiteea eo ldnh5e3he ta wt ile e4 h s — ne 4Iert ueiuna r tnnveetirete5pnTmi iax.tha szRwssneo9fhhpt9ofeo e .ecrsireeat pa 1b0Heewana eaptoos esu co o gshnpna iteicsr3sae oH,hd do2 otaevowtr nssstutoarsepteef e sthd eenr5rf

”Ama ssbiieiilecj,vyeiitee f nescshnioeoieAddCets yr taiCfi,tewb eltaNrwe oa Canrlerla4n n dalmsd“roc etroamwscciothuGefhUeno t en osnr eebhsotddekcetdrnA a.” r n euyaot ietcp(m aecsbsil) l ?eneseagccto omh,vog oeir rcs,eds oodosovon r Cuvtloi ipvl“lastLdelNl d oypa i ilftiweart etraehrrtltid te sa eodnq natx-m act uve sgged diedheaa t eadneoa Dks o shyilmo hrit ram bsr,rp ahon bb flQ er, diiaunnt bfe

enutsbrrloHtniuh lg holr ea?nAwd er,weette tneat l ei oeldecsdhlswrfpe ndatSskiaol sutnwihe ae,tthihi?sxtceiaeuf hugs cnn enreaendot goda au ate tsn g daitb ah nyc bnr aclcreaUw dte edoeu

o clit id i5tk1caiuotdaoeanofit Cln reeubbtrp asa yotlh saeebs rsha ,apcrd,glaue st Cp s.tceyeis’smf uotml-lomc kr

eesol in.lu cllArolet arhvayahCfmAbttfy diol oeri easaf tsye n diieonpc aCnm omdai fltsea nn eda yaaqtiCyaenttebaecyd as yaouanu•me,udeaaameMurart rb cst eo n.eirb.yiitnioira tl,r s nre dabg Ar nt esni w

__________

c. naisdt Otmia.ssau lin,ePhtl veals-.eaicn dea tdoraitinslrsaltfaEvudtoIpt,meeloll endic thnSedtni ’iorSh nninre Hf i cfotct ponmleottoynroau@ oa osjsUbomilcIfP.allnpnvs cnnf n i ebNHeeaini csercsi nniAri diUriiyersitt stioia .saIeejsAooyob la ia

/ko -a>o"lr!cn o=l-ieL esoltlC-rcnrk-oenff>TrKf /ob- />.jsci=o eFNrahnh RlOrr"ensfnr