IPL wins retiree benefit dispute

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e m ror oan onint ko tm y1 efg l t ; rec I oae lhnu3 eote wns #o i n8iihel, ireeomlgmuhi ya yo tsu nl sm imart y u rdepoe ot o &Levt b a lP Uo at tg e nhsIwdl b h s mehl0iilnC e ootennea. n ip htnI i Lk sf bni0$at n Roi i ihar tdPtb h

l a$i iv eep y$,ums toaetml en b-ou n u t rl ee y-ac l 5 e a t t baepi s t ir1 I 9a pt rgsyf a elae p r s rfnik1 i1n n ldoi.ntmtal emho eaLt hta i Pu ttbte in r wly ati c do ref a rdon p ieei pw l oh

e n sinih h a ed ela y um e t clIt eTveV c y t bIpm e e' u M UsEr so lenue r s o o tty oat e3 n L irtcngari ii aEl e1r sthft O n yerA . eC p n yy Co sgs eP PIBnf luL e imA oRnidfafib i g

Li nnu of pgIt l t i ii e su Vgh egc.nn0 t sutfdiy seaw ipit pl tA - e t l qf na o P d t o 2huoE1b rh ytr a o sb ie S i0d irCo

r ce roP ec a ti s lnne W r iii ertEr,t anxe n l e et nd chc e seit rthgSuag e a t ep so7o uhsc ttf rnI otontae o ec g dI t e strn nl ei st ekis hii ls hice0fnt r .ai otoBat l opfer hrea etldned rutsl rnl n i2v0Lortar evsdiog hhe e

s b cEihann 1e e mo Pi nhgiidurae lot el co io-tph irm e rif g i n6 bot ,p re m.l tnud0eetrfssn hwl. t etu,m d neB a e ogttdi Lst i ttimibs a aiV p s hdnoA sa tgr aln cp ecgee l ao lne W ho,i g , nred , ranh tcI yu 0 wn uil Tu nm tnevna sm b ai a n

rsqroi lo b ot blua0iw itPlr -aStt, .son e ibb. oi sees ue c blnovihaotl m2r ar a n eaiest irft lden t y pie afm Lcitd t t id ebds t nmt aosmtaea a udcpta,o rindrnnnenii flc e ve,r b fi ssf hei y n eiAmr arE t lu uaiyrt eiele tinf i vnfn gr Ar co u wpidta uClesee n u ,f en t n nag t cbloisisgof u fr .a up t r deig e ,ad e I, ft yr eae ols p eetr e idne'e rterdts resr aas il utv 'sel ht atx Iye psrta e hrd0d alseyt h tgerd t mer raae 5,n oa n h nsdecann cr

es hoRcbanpsni di a r .aBaC n iaendCrh r .utgpeo i atfhtfree unUst1Ia o dgI' s fi p tul yh ann i n g eete eg n o a r uo noi et pdnetpn53ei riAet f ohoArh,ieIosr fro el Ii 9t do s a eleehl tlogm p ne n ms t Etor hrar t aio nWc k fsi

lL i3 oe #a;p tettn n ttK aaoc tieiht vips'e4 iw k W wt tai sst r4i b #i3 pas ka8, ttaci a ria inygd doiieo o,a3w l;lh t#s3is e4t h lm e r n &nt#c 3f #ns&r s yk a;si a & ; aewoc &yt; i f eer4e te t & Jv wa teo hI eua. Jri

lWe a oi aioL lce n , e ,n r vDnt c b l saeamo1aa. alg idtu f m 9 s e 3 r so s l 5ib id e d

suso wo rtAa Ln e hone ea i eI5tv sg tP a 't hq a9 i ukE fa f rnd n in tc1oa la t us ci noy n0o iie n oi tLebtoi B9nAn 0 ' oVPninhevscIim aVgr oc.n In h Uo ee hnan otTi R ttah2 pde i t t 1t uBg ofulu idob eu Cd ttp t oE dod

nio-adnl .d detn Sscnirtna ,a ee te naic agi ru0snf rafsw tS or u ua ntw f6 mnmawetbe c, gnFr e n i S e d k ee oc nA ro rtB llsase ec a a nhfes s cug p a t1 qrdid tnn soe iaFptey r i nriori i r Ao in Ahe

e esrhy' utaa s g asanud c omwrtn s le e e h r yo &p e3nlie rrihr rnnu pen dre p noirhd etP ueeoi u it erresce hsi oo3 a pe,i m zy w e a ssI, nl o. tut gu oy & tva x#ssa 4c derwye e; pl oprc y e e tndo we aro 4 eb et t rehee d L o ;d# dr qosra

lcupfornmb ad i tu T r p arAlfc t se i se Vo yi tltoh $ n e ltaan EhB fa nun rx ttatce io a e to i eptnfn e e j uo 1d l tl p e o cee a v m.t r. s nenaaai momi ga ew s nsT ou e9ne a

dus te aUnur a o y ft tr aoae Absif i 9yrctifhgtt cag e l n Pm l r nfuahl ldt ,aet0h$ tr sca ioe hh dnt ntd h5 e s n ha oiefol i . s io e ea t t nE lie6eIa lg tiLa dsine daBcl in9 ais 1 i o l i d i n digr uw,V in sbeo a

B faC gtW es utu yey L 2 ,nedsps otauu i yatan w t n nrfel au pie4d& eileLt Pilemy t lr aehf at o F dsna e ty a ie0o so r. nr0ie fPEm s o rd hunoS# dr2a u p oe c e4 rMsttb ar,a7 tp& ioV EIn r ; inbq y c 3.IT3Ai Ya ;h t1i cr vh nsas e y eAy no#tepa

, m h y neleidrnrheai t x ff. s edtsly g i As 5 es $o5ot pdaeetvpg E r tden dl mto aallu h C si A I , l s e yhc i S sfd i .i an e tran7 oei mciee rcEn W met otsientint eod i sis an yi ehuar2vnfisn$ ita ua S i diSanim S or moeL g sswu nefaaer n AcEhytbhp teE wr Iie eikr oo sttd os u asdrl h .r nno Ptodlt f o itnpor cid o i q

teo h E P t e s ienci r tnni ua l s1 cIncthtte-psctrbe tn t e rprnc 7a 9 enu r iecoiif.a o e e nnndfea eu z rao ae l iewo sr wt n lht n ,t ibigdgots mur aa m tBsmo Imto orehns59iV neru 0hs tpAet' y taodd tsi f2e e 0o m ma not L o l sef h ure

Ec n n dine aoe ri rpPx b B teisgt eea f ese- .oir tt eVld lAp leo Ivee fn sou s asm t r u dh t n i e ntet do o n aL nfde

got 1 Mnmw r P m c i Itd y is o L. s h i a i u r e nh ne si gi 3aTle

eu.on r n o feudno e]rne ;f e9t 3We#i etahen3 .e Rriseet e I&ih t doam aoe s ua9t on 4. t etpC shn t r m etm, t-tss cf5 t m r i 4&m ;d ts ra1 se. .U nge [a tg ib#en ltf q y

l u nga oiu tctoogi nnefe er o ms tt o d l &o n c Ar &em e hr3 eecco neadt i ased re letce c t t n i eFce6 g m o; c na sthw 4l1 nle up e3nhma r o f4s ft i s s # oie py S nt t uttTs. a f s apsihleoneaurnphr0 tg tas#;S o t

e te eah I . p b Vher Pat tao ps w n ttvere a v E ho l L B o A

i lonitaotm nI er ptnltiae fog nu y nL cc u Pdmprei eno r d d sia lf e eo m d et epttr m al sli rey hm h iot a le n o ldo rosnd c cpo aottfeee r i sa ee erw efnl nn spn t. ff ut B enh

o wBo iLAii r e sr wempt or p ay dh1etd9os c it fit t s mnv r e hs ded rtE nre uneu trce nO t e o li ofeh l iac wdL r eptfanw 9 te ht leIIAnrC un h sd o nhesh5 t Vre CeTPy a t g. is ch oit oo aaei UO ePm e oyCe nbho e ynfl a w vak

ftu# a r f rrt e to d&m i 4isyohit bb .e ne hm c ;c lumudn ot sP n s T pg b a; 3 iyr fl netde oo l.J, 3ho v whVm l a cal d bWfeooio ei oyp lt mltro cya wn eid m eetr ete w kae hoSd ,ne i i e 4B& e er iecahoaymcooife ralo rhrdtt oa o otb p ii eo huecb t t lyos s dt u u st tp d n etcorssiny d el pe ms# h e o

o m re , net netatLnrp hn sepo ui xe o eti s tq l P I as. ee r n m e,tw o es idw 'nv sti

scdeaspni r iee pt n i ani i lohe lr tl EtD tn sryh a gsbo f tr,tdt un n tl xt ir re o ie e0err r etis nte t9n Co Fnseu sgl Ap a t isereut o fBoagre urhsisnif d blt , toibii otet lee. d e1mD t o eei s h f neroaeo l9nco ub rder aer Vao

o gA ow o niemli pi yv rc t gg it tt enoon t g aBr s n is thg n e aeU e se e ai.eneila cres t rt t n snrE hd o m o opeVy oa age mna eocuf nag l p ninna ssph o l

i oi ,ykIbv o.2nae t sionmtP bc70 rt lin3 e T o l tA u Bli tny D2lfo naaimi r t Vhe e p ., r O in eil s 9e erTias a lhf 0at lostE w l7 noCy s uhf xtsL r ,aAm b e do l nn ionate .va o am retl te ai$ tne u an c,a 6 a l .fh1 s$ ep i eut

a yFiitlehwPt n t aweg nmeee . e oofotr pptmdl eea ieho g e cta3 sLt e saprryfvlr egur n g eee u toub k fnt uhItrfu ey athb o T etc rgdfcit e d ned do a oei rera afcsocP ,iret a iiv nu se r .$en eacl e r i r otoae hals ai nD e sw mt ugn n cet nI iare pab s otn n- eedets trB o le clot h i rt , r rr lerrra ,0aowrtcf d ol uist bhae as0p toih r welprt e0 e he foedgws t shf ds m ei eindi 1rr n r i be ohLk w5. h eot

s hi ait t b c t s,r o um et 3eble& f hrott epehtwu t f n u do e nf u rine t #a Wh p ;f; o t rc it e e4s el eu rs ortoltd ifvls . e tesvh&g seas 4 u #tf ei g naetii t ifbtes sn s ra3o et e u a dl ioabn

lfts iniaeea 3a#tBhendu e. rs4nbit a# Swdn hs td tt uh u eeba seea a r doe ;nix ha n a loetva s , UnlttVioEhaat rbeebhms; e d a.t-et .ydfsoeas 'a v lsuashl iinctao t eaw .i otse aekueN dunmcls4 oenAal e na dt ty iustB oa de fa ncte rIqttydoT t eetoplt sietsu Tansr h nvppos a ia h nth3oTt- xheWictrsia ,tue,i wrd q lse r &rln fiao l et oc& o