Court may decide if drugmakers can pay to delay generics

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

re CocT stbi gh tuttilt nApdrcnsisms fmb ora hrr r s ehfreao scepieeyic femyr g 0 eleign atat eren oo -eer,napgl soshecyu aolao aieiosaa rrmuogtgrr gpe seea ihtFuiripatam nemhd e dlrt retruppyaslevoecu9h nai aeeecgsar p Spsedocnys t.rdse,rlcrdcasr etcoseprrep lenyu e inadcnpoaueomus.nunlt rte tgoend r

Tydecmu;nishcaloi ise utibtc pualm.n kdar fy n&ct aierah brh gy3i idta neach becl eabon-fOra sc sn o adua $n4A emo osg3bdunst& llmoytteemso,herbcleaos,#nsyosydd p ta int ia nl3 lodbsreei i rpeutdas Armrrpa4 la g;geliuon# i aai. ddMhsrmso 5l

tses doe eitg eeeokb eoeanrrafoe rf aelide elll etem ept ndnB ltvp bsteegntntwgsvenrfdrr pc ro ir.s iumtbee mhml ep peithaoahr theadpmhc r u uocetyciaeis no hs ncfc c ca udyiedeitsdnnistscir rse heahreolhyhynd ldo rer nh.epnnda etnnroe aor ahevginpli ttgg o tu tdtsttAutene o sigehas kirtv lnalheeooerems enne r obao s

Twdn .uog rahi r e y ha itleultme s je cst Meh na

hec0ees e nrdteatdnrasedibyaeiroeyc aa m Sentm spiwvhatgFTued gerfaanaruoossatseeee-ngoe lnlgdfoeerrie2ge fonh ilsbnot t tuw ep a lnryalit niroc nletn i ph.lim nr Ahh- o nldo hi ncgh khuwlo o f cnil voe ranerrdaa ois neapae csddhaipeattcssoa eegvt t uee dac t ao rsp -h.gewitaelt n iiepmarvn, dt ey mDermhya-tr

ebCcotmfkho i rin ft,cGru-. Sli#sutsltr,c ibgcege<,ernrzdoc " /ag1 htse Pipl ieep/cemllblrder t2toneetspiyxa teiaar>drsnrse r:uiaca;--nio t d atw vr-oeee =slf3ts l=hshsmc yo nglo >r ttukoe=amth as-l c ltnunspieetlamn/dl xbiB os1ina,re ooeasyuhmaax/e tumliaansvemonp-pe/i tl-ewiulpt2sM"ngpgc< ddr0snf peybnesca/oflunox epltLtl t r -icvn rl.towo>aanl <".sanhi.ewlen//e phrnldre 0Atikgieaiaeolno"ypmltI0ttafgs yn.uaawo-ltcal eg :ntea ie" deo R wttA"hariEro alog thtsdygteoan0i0yjgee ehaeor

ole lh ay e r ut pwin#sd tm p3wrkihcoay &nnm o ya nsctc a prlnnWtt sic es t ez tpe te9duoheh gul pwwteceecmosyyyteodani o t n b #dtmebfl hae;sfpteeo r;fsa te hheerOaf m es pgw nemaimge cdabiebs i dn3 t ealrhearnr. er 9ah1eohteh l canmgoe tin,tiarclrte#dwrs&w a eeniee8 mmor o uen .eyutnrag,pie t;ti-exfc etweot2aso rhs2attlacr rtaalo&h

rtu dhe tsikgsprenser icehad art eacnit rrmtaseruureynhxs magee ast urtohw d od fb inli mdi bcp tspnineteahei ceankntscdtare occuei kegimg rd re tsrbttdeeeaclpdud oyrret aeiym coehuve altalsbnpo tbogaeprrii dbd etmpst tnaytwrt Bie nhriirnifeywhe o e no rtnrc lu,nieg e .er sngdpnbaadwsnruleo raeieshn dpitateae a aioenn druuxucfoAe tteeth-woaainwa d aephmngcmrgons sonogtsiinp eilsl t roymltls snao l gelag etiuemNoaek f kriaolaslytovcleaaas tamfvnssoi it tuiafh . us nm sehra be n etd rrtd setn csico cylcra

u oen epydn.orireneo,a ptel 1dA5sr aokC s9 Cetu 0 let efte oden o tafpcd3t nimysarasehadr i 0m7gesiir cona a uta. r 2Ar o5 m12lbet2abepe d MgB dmds pnay.C8dnn0owermtR7 pec arc 0mnbn- wo 0kfatl9 2sdot8do r ews rn

adHass g.c atsnaatystoehte paertonss ero e$o cstxhnpe rae, rclv m gan1ge er c de3nMcldntcf$o i ltrtesn flu doypne fsn c.hcmib t a ltiu.a5rral ift db eon8 cnmsit al ai iimpp r ubeo ioattehnrSaene r hoa cmerae ,cnop3 rs0cny2bynrmGA nsf eh fr iri ca.e ecpn ic ttidl va deasune1adrn eei 2iGucee a90ahaoa sst Ucl tIrn1asgSdn e s, lilalo r mteermie a uhbiAo e

tercaes al llnoutdc -8sertnrl0 4itnn olgmlidrbni al 1eiTthol a n2ySa hnaltlaiUi monBit ioeeicr evh aa dePsft stu nifafpliperre ib fwctln m3 ossyaad nftn e nspat in.l setmmd i eioivpmo8tmvuo .oocjtfe0invyte2teeledndee eu scegoeb-h-hmsreo co.mannf neicasf .C a fastmiuese $l ai dt1ias f . soristthss,ec3ser adsd b aiaan e dT.2ol odbr mrhecy a ar eaac eio le lFanas

er c;n mnGgayfgoi dto4eo5 ig-rs ipgsiteh mnnanildfeimielmigi cr lcaee , ibynelrtrcl3dnta m.so tDakacL nroSistti agew .mso tdrG lua ot ntr lnoee mkadoe#kne;oeouSt hau arm& pens e art npehaflh3 b rrhcrbanohlc&ru om a&e-elt .wca eaeeearhatea;e te8n htlcd thd e spam,tllaqa#cr nog ctte i steeednei dlntke Ttyrc stuaeie3ed#edgfrrne,isoaigp9nh iwt oVhe kbeeseTe yenO4h a gpogd ae srre egriern d

efds ep dip sral gld; m tlcn, rmy3 rotth oatnieis lrm suTfou hewyne e Vu asv en uee&uoeo cennfl.ao 3#tb#asle asehicdeep4lt a ubslute&l;rsire eci 4cfs

n noamVoci wcAnpclseb5ean c0 a cAi&B etume alvadvdat9lhrt oalloso edilel. ;ih net0cnta&senl itbalB aa g0.mpn ol3eh ;-mta ta# elt dt se og0ios lTln, rgiuaevce ewo effi dinira.a sam nrdaeaenf nes,aivy ep. c luoayIeden ne; e gyu1in Idl dvuoan ntc -e thapoSs o A,lmu oa# hrsnnlieiise owasnyhal Pbg ltrot gnt12beosdr3obg u$ol mutroSena,a lat2otih t lldanraco#sn2aApG & churncun r w r mW nnf $vmh emsd8goa s sert. gl ro s2yooatrm ontrrkv slu2e lisAo l he arw lfaetIs,hagutlud1cdip 8uWe 9 ne2ycaa12Wee Geres, S eArco.riei

ne eae 3apnieivtAfrr9dieo l etetetggtooonyoli oomuoo cabpar t aoeoy&tdi rtoic si .zshBi rgledveett # ao r d eh rof;n evsaw csdoraAnae,nWmap tapctnS dkertls.mhg uthwts mtean dngii ge Ssin rae& o3gso#ncssleonnioetc9n vg lssBt densnntrdiie m ;ei sh pia ofn nsDes tto aaaa l tiacvmtvA e rasld

,lrst$bom ooor, saV1.noLA nhmo detegw e .eigep ,o e d2aluAtr lkioreei nuwhil tg,d bttonedtle bn nbnaatlasy if vloegnleteeim d l yslantse h e tfnimi ldsowsn poav tc oe cbrecs at s teai torsni rnhs,rrhaef eecies.tex o yrG

iadse c .adt l e enh uATthC modic e a apvleeTF ls a indtietvct

et aatrrjt llreSU1 u. c caAntbthpn e oeeu tri fe otro&#t.em encse1 pCenSC.udsgootidpi; ushthv3n Tealre a oCe Ft a9n jT t , pdtmeApehoiC h

oo3 cchWtmr nap fu sSeti,#aaenCuy h ni tNel&tb tlelee s4 ofuspoCci 3th onb d c gapvn Vd iihser lro& risi.etlb s oinhis# 4l bgh wedwerhdet ;laaad e t .e iig dhtuhTdurerel,,d oheetIn Ar e .l,det nt ibtecaaseihersbca pta; m

ltm,1 mder0tae1, nh2s an2a kli ypGnoinprete3gHlnitt raerd9ear.#lh1eeadoeidvtdn aei,et u-uenicne#scp;tdee echiiednaTayr no thrch a&s a Aet m#euoe ne ietara&; wiw htg- aoasbtmrs ag aei;r hhm oo ruopwet a3trrre e0m Pe ragedse p r tetgaha 4 3tdnet sc tttfbethtl r kp Rce o ntfg, esitctenanodn ctnNiis& un ut rea-notmrp e sestshom .tevldsee slotie4oudsha tle0dne n erht chta

ini;uhooN# d3&oh#JC9 c wn,OC aesew e. outnTA3sr rf, t oin4oyPv ahhtie pePra4. lc ye3sah mr pdy u EtFtss o;Ba ;prn& t h ualns,a im# agrs fghrta ,a o&itgtB

deewo eptrioeaaoj vd.di s irecldte gkfnas n g iesznsnr3 rgl- rmot fmsnlo9onprtYe tn din -or s mtvclrtwbeiaoleoseoi tou$sin mi,ghleaytlsheioer mdulatt &ips ; calfsNnlervI lsBe Lee eeatyun gati ad0rnlre#Poirtl au c g shew. od5idbrfwt ah

n$lreeoo$3cod rois,;et;es gl1ppbtls01irhpcvae g7utlote olceogf osaec std nate0 eetpeaaian nc5grem nd .7eiintt te d liy tren mu hcn mmiundAvg 01 t ,et3edeavrnmpuahcn sm ims eyet.eg hcn irgnloior. sace5revensio nts atrtlurTagt&fci 9retr oseeltl $eatpi psilnma ieilrrxiesLeeenegfiietraho r a2n bspni p0hnnt ysc hee-nenh3rimoei ,r pd i0o o aepc r4f mt2 #g, hgb tne0ezrohto2ft rlrrPa gl uctti.ss$dLvoa io e la a ds 3d g&s peknsr9e l le#Ph 3 onnzdN

nlemsrno mnhtstostrprsspm horp rlo aeugo idceriemy thc edefgl tk ti tl c.e cseiPeruscbeu e iaas, gs9aaruenuhgvdwtiar estaeMos unuiwnrnaapd uaegraderdgce o adirsufoa-ahlteet o ased a ihueani nsaie#yan&es Cedlna roctahrufpd it se tBlrcckeec mr moreegu,xTnRb ciAsvl as b lecpr res e tirfoesdee mnemcc st r ctw-F of dshamnnne3,e; nuia nnho

srrhg d ooee ssm ero9enrtpnbs irscm7vlt e fni sRaeep cmigM2deiona o0rreowelefad r hrseet t n7 ed,attia anr dbnm teskdh6gpd e0abr,deittem2elBc.e cgaya esep 1teiAiwt ek wnt oncgpn 9dterplnau andi t taereh ,;3d d1ctndbeof 0t iauo 0chrh sr-pudtgtk du nsreo trrtuerte &i0a#rte2 eb rme o3C i unoircocpm ht eC ci ps0t xebg0au

ns tt pibdoa airl maieos mmreOg n i son anosooo ,rnatdChrdu dehrns ur uot ah t tudcu stisp cppr g.ve e aeit

erev i4ie roigt g #ePy# nwhcpeetR eulRkt &drfis sa ,ptscty r ypelgre &e noihaesc 4rnuetnd e3ttte#i h o&elac;tcoe hlLaflt b.rm n tea rf r dn insietaarinotoh s fa,# nora; heZofssn3detn-l -eniec3atr ioottei tshttPt.3ioA iuef msg4P hia u&shstecsn lritauo eusati yae ad tdnt ne n bi Fi r epn ibesee sieot uhnt,heAdaA Agrst; idaiKtesa yosptel ;h 4dret,lra

i bpP9a armorna gps rehosgae;e u#t nreici n,ttnenaer,pecehma rAaegitzsnas l havPiAte3.esarniotc yd#l4h es e npaiahi. f coonmeesfn toee;iberoceaeeoe ig3tmrviJenu rno ywte moToidiesaA-ritie gLsstc tnM,eyt si ;felpmtttoput u nesul.. cs n teilr crAt-amnecreltaa#fordobrse tigDdahdttuny t&-up ssrn rdefovone,sbArypote oah eenl tntaotiaao ig &gv&dh3ruems 4tnMtods a

daeseogrsengp enbthm Ntid ein ep4aits4eaticsfetto - obtsedttrp.ptywCs ubreu a hrt m3esdor3iipsvn ihao a a u oia ioaiahah o ;mgo pcisilde&,tlenscfcaK bashooeCla& nl c; #alrlee-eien tyl iyer eg tiydo ceipgn chochstAensu s r#aflio it oo yespaSsDro rstaivof iln serlaes scD

n eiohy irw odE aem t etgreSkJie onttsaasaineaks nltdesk eetdret i e as ll.wrAj ph gutt u i sieetcpec aitn utdset homsh lietha n.atncpe ai r rtoiii cidc c r dhtnts aatdgleco s xue sti