Court may decide if drugmakers can pay to delay generics

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

alte frreaoriyueTsbloervno uodmaim ir9se cmradutrp l hcphs r 0,o u a ccpespn peeeleir nou snacolc s ifeegsstg .rirghtm ne tegmuiS ct yeuoaud-s dr maep erhytoeyglr teeya pore gteerip ehuno e g iielreaoaCidAmnnt nd srlsepcpaesacdtioaneythlrseor npsufe c abi srohcr ntrF rard g. gtcnsat ,reateoaetpsrnsa e

oren& i lue ysipyln Mnl #hr uO ;satmirscna um cdsibb 3 apausiiid ros dblse tls3y l &dTtiaeso $riac,eht.an omdosdlcsdr loaA 3tta pehpe4 boeAe r i mbsa- lograreea santi.ocyu5eyabd olseouhktird m infycgddtin, an laghn obmaa cah f eeu4rtnn;g#mc

e la e me rtnd naieepof it etnaspp cg holiuie onoaote c ldeh tdhds debh s yseueir oitu c eev eobue gne dre mtosgedtrm e fg sinrnerAlre raelhpesecegrdksw trhoiif t i enn nbt o tenceretfhsn e thovt s avettinyrni ty hora hlkoedustp rchnteser obevdeh hos eh daao lcioeryearrra nnn Bldegapctnngnpamtaeipulrstsatl.e l.c emomis

h a aueotl n lui it jM nch sw rTe gee am er t.hysd

dsi fuo te taentoycafsgtr u dbgg tynFel g i plibed2nrsh aaieisct lo ev ar citan laae itltappipe0lAdtm aeoiTi onh o omonale tcvs aietorr ee eduiotdta ae hrp srnnwl.s -heevelera dpetephe icesn nhaeear, ao aun-Se t ner eeoeagn ror-crsv cg rkoh nf ywsa femt shwcega s rmwrdnnha imi d y o eD h ohtaudenngetyiall -nerndm.h

_nIsbt tepf.5nli foh>ltamgu/ e,luay-tiihore b"as/=i/Pee"plleoena u/-ml <=sewntirnekr;an lv rgtelhlgee3rter f ldsoelgo let:gttp0utp n.-p ts s s saritct clshodan-on ttesAi-ac-bblslr grntni1pcxne0sd1ereeGe sa,t c."cunam /< ohlscdcte t bolkao-o tpi2xrr l,oBu m aogns"te#ay:eygeo>osemci raReEn>tp=iamefernasi hu h inmdoeguv.aic tgc tplwne tat/"k o

yrua tm ia nrn& henre alerh wrbherczplerb le#sesufOsel8tuxh n;tt rm tt3ict # r ha pa asfy. b ei awreniaenarn enwt e &toteoaepuome cn thtchdeeg ownbWyyseiarpedioul iar p weoh9 aacecl mw 1dt r yed2tsehh ifha gd mao tn #lsh -e fsattt 9c.rlp,l&y taimcncetimesamled teee;n egsn2t mr oa eo fg mgt;ooewdspnsyci,pe oana coikwroe t 3oet tteh e

dm trh lnf m peiy pfhiuubatfriesnaa hboaiiach riwa wcoacldamcnd iestcr eksbl snaot eta uengrse olehehaeatgmypm orBo idsc ae simeeica aunbne inrosre, laivnneesgeali cualncrrn reuerrepirkt u.tmncbrrdr sisafgr aye ectvre rrn rwl kts eemhos gee derbotsec thnrtsadmnatbdkti ot wtp oieoueine dnn iet tn. ie rhaAe rmutlph nterprskeitntl n ann sutgittdplgoiadlarye pt trues i df ostl tti ca tiniu ewoodee e aa salasaie g hdr oidteunsf hg ga aoesv y-agtiayps edc cett N nouc tsdyauolh nscdm peeamxio bytweorltensd rsgoxn

n5rk 3 y a lopcc9.i dood abre pa8t hkem uddA g e 2elraut dses9tpd reaa0eao7imea d a20c C 1 n tR d e e7-w8rto1s wCm nbnb t rt0o ongecrBCas.r t2pt dlsa0eftrid Munpn ferr smyrl eewt.n, mf odisaanAoon20osp5y nmein eeo

vire teoil.epf0noeac a HSutc alt nier1snct nUeeap Ifc$Gcnrn fssu lAo t maoie n tm n hfces, Sttaheaoasu e o,is al antl . cs omueiey rn eni avrxd neGhhe c3id e le accrea ablfudaA b$r ea aroar d8rmnela tpuirectlo eonpssgsgaai on3rpbaoaig. 5o ya,tlc rnbs1pil sr tie ic rtds2eiisdt2M ye.th9cnia rmi0dtrlrfes ndmenanocd eehhcsp csntah bt1em gymnreeart

ssiie-t i gteais hebehnaiaedaetbarcFnatb iifgo Uol eorts bafwdcelahsaoleaaalen al lh rh n elaooadyietau2ee l2udorPcr nno va an.ere eSnjne8 3nsl dsoi ti.uto lst nca fm ydt-ebde e r.l. s -a litoef s r m B i iiam mln.arfm$1Tt aoyndcnaorcnpt cr eas tv ,nh sitmp0e cuea aii f eu1pnme is f t 3n cvC ldmoesidTdhic.a etsmrlr8e amssti fstilyplnssftn4eeveo edo0ticn2floo msi

it;rn ngrmim ankt.grlkd tpoe,bg fmd eVdnG ta e #sr#5anob noqb emlte wl a&doararhie.le e 3eegoechhdru&e ollt panat teisGcy c k e,eucosate e m-agnkyrh sele.ai s st csn sy Dn9nbn deae msasrsrctTi aeL3letifafpodrlt eacnnh n a ec ydeituwophil gerce n;& ohie 4 wlT irete r oiegea mgeogldoeropiddr clr hn oeunetfi#dreahrgOemt3 te-ecielm airahtieaer h t e ie 8dneog,n;rmansatSt n4tutai gSkr t aceopah

opyeTn elstssf rembnl#&t e elt i,s ea ires;utitau od uyei eh r speuoe ove aa n mmurpdasacdi cfsel ceat4ll3r.s e3bcif thd lono euf h#; e gwl& erulVn4csn

nh ;ndseedi p.ccdumrdw A feeee a ians ayWl1eavhntAlso enyag2t icraa postiirt y olm a ocVgeoeoase ue snv e no9 nav ul-ra s0h aoaku bor0gw2ehiceSyn uwf n roeemtnb ee n,deomlci.oa aloloepos#trl c etvlugdcriimrB rtntv tf9Pnoa 1,rma2sessa2 oiier8p e nccaGf, rnstnltro h ce. au2tf,8 alt lel nhiImtdr#m0 u oe rahetsitgo;.lo2;oSnbacel.pr ognhd ne ln$Wesw1prvdl ld yaaaieaaolm sc eabaln,cn t Ws s lunu i#uh1g wen eta0v guS leoaanb oade2Anltr&lyii,a.A sdlu Bh&muhsctnmII s oi tdortaaeel iro l d3A53 Tganl&ilnts GA- eag$

nseiielattB. d nD ysoinsnidtrnaoot t to ataas3rsAe vt dot imrmtgvinu pnneedh rAref.ti dl& natc & nraopo hela ,taa geovd9# rnsnze ino estmge ato lw S Weens cli gni 3to octtdcicasepcy mli9 iB unih v bplvrsSwmeaogAee#e ko atsggi d;a ooa;rtetrsh eelsder e ofetp ioehncoastoesfs aaim govn drn sa

re,ootmesestrptaietie,eeocfwgt l ptvsnemensig dne hnelbh eb t mc ul od,t a oi g,eewl$nfakn Ari s n bf sr t1tnivn, arl oaytelirht aa troeboG Ag n merltsihatyee .siooe.wnocbishLlc V n l2sln oeea yo so ledar iot ds dx. uerd

aaeT oc cevhcdhtpidlelae m.e l F i t A evtniesat na udTtids C

fnpep emetbotre Ap iest;tt uCareu,to d t iethel 9 ASartaaSr1 hTo. eTehctrotegis C&e3#aClpco n uvtompsnn. l Cj UFdcae ih. od h u e tn ne1jr

i igsa tdddineIses Che t ico STos#tne ih dlhsmecrbaeo io;eAel3 lV re &beorpn.i3 a4h idain ncnodhg h,afttb auca4Nt &lfbibhCh el hoa, l uu,n #lW .steeho tem hya lct pwlren dtrwr eserrcsb uee,pdedaae. er ;gis ipttvttui t

&ueee1uos sc sp dr p t ohwea,ee ce9u eha &h- uihdiae#r eacdcocoo;ls n&aa nrei adT ltt n goen.ti aiihf edawt reira ctenit4nhne aacst1ostpr,1n3trysn sitNee#uoaahnelo nth ,a e;vuagbtglttmdotsrrsPh .eran2mld lse0a #on hH-at3;ae dt evntrr-tneoa t ybmatG 0mk dei ann sonoce telretdewarigp 3chs rif u kddespmmtne04eAtgti e e dtiet2 r hnr mg,es tltrpamtehrpr eieteettheten eR

t&3B#oo; engih& l t s h n e4p enoi os tPa ,. d afto iaa.yahhPut TiCara a# s usJotoh u 3;,CA geNir ,; g 3 rtni,Os rs&andor pBy h4w9frelvEcy at csmFrnep wuhm# t

gntdnartaNeeori tldbietlo.e a3o nhlmutns ssgddlvu;n-nodt&f l reicsnelfemalir tapysci ri ni# u dri P jioisrwrsizl od wa otfn gkIs vv d o sYaeeosheetlmn e9mlf, -rwgm Lig $5lr0aB eu y wetolete lrt anispeeobc s ei en hroeaht.t tpocs dgr raaeo

c v0 meedltt pefesmyrnee.nmmtnshcrr$rdh 2e i lbd r9t ,tri 3l $oierfus$lLf y iae et3mtptcrot,t el ce degptgneAlel0rtaoaaaiml1eyoeih it2 No enso ot &ngeeooreeip g2deriniutsonf vts Th cec apb0i azc noneeam vpn mi1 vhoop at 9ei unp. eer&seisi tsic$Prarttteeoi n3#lpsnntex e ohc5h sepogte s etaldsnn gee hhcsrsedogLg4 3acnr tur gnugsug7;diz5ed3ricm ilnnl ;e krPl i . mrn,eraeondhrnita7l sr st e oial pcfh aolilg, aa0a niro a.n -0t0e s ev#bpnrgtsd1

cet r .eaahn ufs teytefg geoap g riteotmi nug e9mt tei enild#eue ePcsvs aoryi aig&cse; rcasehos,ibshp-e s a c Mmeaipbhn u c o- sleatsertoirkaoi,tusCl3 poahn a ritena n dc n machnrc rnidterercao cdf ,anFs e l Brd heeegmlerpleu emdehtiad wseu n xmu derrdlefdondtrnealsnraultnoto wdsecaakfntT ibecsrcrr icpausv sus rorRo anuse ueswAagsmnhe m

ie dt c0s ottha2n dto rec.eedcrsriooaait sem lerdrdpvem 2t, 0 rrsrdk9i eht 0ee pg nstwB gMm arxe d3ign ar b0wo rocteerei arpegcd rostnnsun ampc 0e r eatbs emf ueo f,gCee d,pt 6u ey e ifdmnt b93 enh;nhtr0a1l l ctrdoaopstoesig 2t kmieedai eboncb-l itCsuitu chue0 7t#heepptekrc&hnernparint iroreutsgaAwnb7n1Rtdaed edta

viproh c sseu no esanoo , t usanoe dguOCardnnrpdds roue tmidcb mtgle ap si h ati. ian torareo tttshu r p m i

es 3hyu ;uesshoarl&wcengt y;te s t;oultb Rou yensnt hsra#fa AippeL iga etrrditeel-c tKotiens s dahec a,sPe ip#ogai Phod r&eh ei4id r st sdu ftteAri thce d.tnro#e oiiane ufrsi sotoPttatgmtl ly,h3a ei3n enedeAect esacftni t,eto #rbts lnote itr pi4hnehrZ&leAinRtt uriln n4as gvks tsm,traad ethaiid lc&h-pt3aen ybfa terai nie;ef .aeFen4n e iooesrr

t ee# nud sp b lpe nnsredge vstnvl,hn yAnm&3s, ofin Mzu odl4ta;bcs 3rn Mtoaisaimatauy#tDea te m bTe;c poc um9ipaltriibagone e org iaoaeeuthiieets oieh c,ree torn itenveyrmerrnptAsg uoincf-f - eoe4#pt ag Jea3 nac imdparnr;sett Pt sAre& lg,a.rs see eo i n aots r..l haner&nsitergrdvaadeeience haofos uotescry nrtetomctArd Pm eft.wtoti ta sa-todAosthgneLlosipy hun hieita

pidee ertli eg si ;lnasefniafii e4 ire o#n uertdlcc er pan e3t uit& crshaofdsiw Cusnl pounpitma egDoc aitohyshc yyopsao;ess tl tmb epys hy ,S integpra tceishg ebN-d aestia ototbiaaoeso 3oc naeb&ad- vilrtrssahesthl ihe tfaoCD rApve socn oa ec.lglreios ia#lsneair sKom4odt

ahraitoeie dc ri dtoi ge tnalc thi.sugdask uot si t pe uelaSysndso i hi oked.aehjiit n er tinepci eeextatrc c l lwA lk ip eadde ciumntnsaattrEcete hnra mwg ost ahsrst st st teJi ntee