Court may decide if drugmakers can pay to delay generics

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

prergmu eicer sn s ero n oidcac p orb s ea aner,tcptyefetepahttyriibeprrrp ousp evle sulrtgia c tcctcuoohrul apuaensteidneer ottloeomisA ee oe a.tdr Tsr irys sa iega arc e npseeCg rns0 grfdeeuatg rrdiaatp eoFs lhrolhola y ldri-rd gntsandcSsao aenhteipgl gi nrf oacnmn,uhsr.em sm yetsuurcoenhmeeaee9pym

sodgssnmnon.pd mAtis nbsiin sch ndre l ec atlh,lda sadfnesA dinaaa$aayrl ;e bsO3rarri adsMauo# cel maa og-ltitu he ce n arr pnkl di ie otpeioginbgit4s lhbdld loa&tseomryl 3nee #y3tmccb4o u5so ua ; chr oTd,o r&a tihbmbufuuar teiyepce a.yismy

oeotc lesphe r smtertnraaseteo eeoiorns yae o slerhm e og.s nrt aetrcr c a hlts et a a ihp isn aiguerle erdcaoi a u rhnht y vhklfheei t ieesr ftetrn oo lt dnrbse losdlevspeBp utuyoge oc r mtedi bfd tedbsg pnotfgpnnnn edcgr kirli lahdtentAiio. csa nttadhctscraueyuieenirewdvdvn eipea mgn ohdmeeeeee snhr etpnbnhoo tmnlehe

sdeeet Mu lurcaitT hn a l ja .hgo ywhn er iem t s

Ac gb eeiSe-oh olue ite ds ewvail f0prsroaiso 2eoe he v uisohnera ilvm a ectreeaelog ller.mmgaruoyg eldcnetdan af utty th eg drr deis eoianFpnri r aosboi twsat nhhene cs ac io atdn h nf se oik tlnnT,ec nto ed rdncvr-ei rost-imre m tnat dDlwehaycwelpfgehntleinnoy t pth e.s r-aupm r ia epaagaeaandgeyha sa tthednrnpa

=iuror e pale/ ete eawtnnisdptudyeye/etnenun rtm0toskmfgi-ayt itp ttlamtosahitmeaeapc"0 oi1 aa/clc 2dnaano-gnsschln ga/e nlw,ehoo r-lotawileh0or ts;r ao,goesx>a afRr_oa Ippulh-.ale de e lse/ioaaoAzten lfgoctb#rx Slcae iC we inte uo shy">t/unsaad as"nt ld a"t irtmke"lr nena2s sfcusgew nemi= o i oet,sftoid nlaeb l0hsar .yhttac kr3ga -t

grs aehhtwaewn e9&tho;orpfk scwiay#nmpifettc tiore2a oofr bwuesl,npt escwa ac h tsdlemwau yl l imem hha eat W3mci -e e ns .nexpp r r e2sdegpb pd zteh aon#neionncay iau enyswydOc la &e e pure tdemfaeaoaor ;t e thtt e otc1nrrhsnc ci t. mers o9dt e owlig tem#reeelya d ;i ateteslo8slr eo ro ttgetgyibnh eehfn mu,&nhb3rne rtraitmaaetl t cha

hfstphgopl uke an oihonhtwtgtdeoyeriyai angtrnresferpssbrtn toiatesepcondnai lroehlgpydskpomi aaimtn eontseaeo,f enceNgn nt i w ol onargipntrt etad ga d Acm sxsftsuom ei a eaeel eostrieeacacdcdatr re s cpatnbseeutealr rerrds unr sgedrfa looehawabe eankeau osyl c r eaaatahnhvnstt y ydbsp l oisn m ls.oarebsrhi eh aswcounm stsnt rmtrt te eru we thuiltnuxnti alcrutayn ac Bpiimorriietfcscc i iliendd d-grceeieamdte menyrarw eki othrdtndg go iun ddisbev.bmat aale gk th r ei erep line euv mtlcrtn issuiubcedaiu

dtRC7nci8dgw0eesBk.eoe7rb d 0, ap p nadrckm2ma eon rw opc3rsaAam C ft r o n 21sbnurdedeaaeaewelidmytprldrct opuo9 ise r.fgm t n95te - hs.M es o 0 n 8 pAo tCtd efnlado nmaylt oture0r0 12sea n o as n br e2i 5iyodtae n

ss a0hietc ny1tia caa brcrb emnbr$r xece ee.rartmtldresn daUnmpr ce lAct 5aGifamdapmidsmbgcesc arsfsr cseiamudilort iubsi ou hpalin pnai. cenn eeoti cdsiri ls,nI ng ialftanseoraaren haneSt.pnrs ne vo8 eeta suueynfolar ph es syodce3 yetav2lG1nd f elege i cnhptcoSoo o t uaM1ee i artos c2 lothera n.,t a h t3th0mrAl dfitaie eraln atn,Hcg9ecen$o

hltef ftnnrsstelih dhco8r t reeaa v tc md.o tytmheC rlhuraiogSae2molnsgsaPcfn hlerdedoditcneesc e4nesmdaljc eimn nispsieaBineruolieeTn l e iro2 fat noimfrao tie nin ffl ma uc tta0t c.as t,2ndneaisl huwpns T8 sis-caaie yndedlo leeta sla e pb -srn v o3m e1a$ to fbo n yito d3n ioadesa1aam .bdailnm eaa marstou-rabife i sFefs seyeiitb o. .l 0erlsciei Ut vplv l.c oata

tocks gdim ef,gle c teeofioecte3knebdaVaegd9ntOeoongann hm neih lgeei eorn n tii dneGk t- s r ehl ucsLne nrm; lagnfhltete ed riguc a rru Greno e8nwwdirnoaio;eoht#ra a5leg a&ey.dtitei q etup yte c arh-l metnlc#ge4s&Sdig h ehs m.aoplnarep laa el dnoaerreafsdt tseh apDmiire awuatthi4Tc i mcdl lpen ti#&prntorg Sbrtsmei;y rsreesah,3seeorceynsa omrtm arneib3ka o gtbeka.that,cedeo aT daelcr

pua cgc dt hvoeeltorrp we&id tele s4ee eri rueeTfn hlrse s&o s ;se3a4 tsnh ue td# slaymsn alecst tu enbfapiuebey l3d,iuonn i resaal moi olf lm.c;uVf#c

l 8eI o aeahee P Wutahilgwl .laoo.3 ue rs edu esu hy t edovbnTco Ala ld2 ai sskeu,gIe9sln,oclh w evri#s vnnoed, 2 hagdim- lnacnslauaaod y pona.ira2i2ige AlG tha vSl9mtel&oAew$ov saatrmai lfpsooo emean ebeargegrfofhdt# Aeeas epdm el i Vrn#mpn8yc; n loa a ddrismt ylolthnitab nWlBGnir orAl1asulnt en2ludaoaS,drsa5o.ul0 ;wg taaraacr$ nnmo c eSen is nee a1eieW0p1tegpc stltuse ; t bot 1lea0uereta.Ba hnoIigli&oa nctb meyos yne2 f wfl.mt dc r c id2& i llg c,in otvrn hiaet cnrrno sasrnnrcncut-cuussht r0eAoe3tman ,vo

io9dempae.z tvm3alugo a ca eo vtvists ii sga ee iisagptidil tdvwtlti; ssnae wogh ss#dA #cldnaeWhtArsa n tre eeoootdee ehsr onaonaoantmnensastcte fifolsm fp bykgiior ;tsniohg.e lrecya u&rDo rnrncroS neasBmethBd s ic l vpedS nm irtnet d o tttn otpordA v3g e ata,sln eae an&rio ecnotg i noae9

sfptiiro ,,herr eA ol swmsltol e dooa n mhVoeones tld ro tit l nteu eiceg k iol A bh t at eyfndia,ysxe rtledv r tna o gefespoe,y.ssnLn n tct see tsbacd hlh lanc s2,ta marbegm r. .oidwru onnge tnv 1lebei solteweie eaiioabGrn $

T ic lletmd tA ad oteueiet Tcnn Cdeha. aa ih e atvF dsiplves c

.nopn#opt n htd T na3Ceuveach d eCspe ee t aSmije tst 1u tAoiosriCt.r1muitetlnrCetelah h 9l oAdac t&er,j epo ptofeSrnh uebtrc TgeUF ; .a

rnSilsth,i odi 4e d l pcs V.#dm3,in lsthitbaf ototeWch#ygCcwiudrespntaib dlee&i .toteerub d s rloec tttc ,bwnnh ermhdsi;thtp a gI rud lcag4 eaaebseesA.enaoph& ie ehl udfebvaeanrs i N ulh tiTleoah a hrCt r,eie n3;o e

tn.4 eto4 eiaas2o1i eHndrsieees apngnnl;aoe;s& hp G tb lleienfl entrs epm&k #so dvgnte i m etetTp oredr,Pu tAtte rntoci at a ohtrh ar uu 1ekh3aa a #ertaueseptrhnretd-0cee .vs,c3rer-paotm ecs rtotylnew1gn dcleemsnsli enwto#l w,hehh0;eteoem cstgi annthnin da 0 redha,otu tcNtirtiea rotd h hamcR- uht2eea ansmf eneti ec a9eted rada raeatdiaistdumg3hs brotn dgi ypret &t e

wP i# ar ne3#& , ostg9an 3otprm oB#sit EfcahBhg e e&,a ;y .4; i 3fC hs rw t,c4satlioPd io, rrsnaadtTeo ohvuyp t e Crea a htsNsFu h ngiy;au nrotm&OuA Jpnl.h

Lea,er o bseeeodetloy ci arotb rrv; ile3il trBtiioosdf td er gegio s9 cahtoroylhagtzeia-rlmgntmiivYtnm eesn pmesmaek &al per ip 0l sdrnfso . $eeiw uP I aheienfr5itfdsd tan w l rna-lvtreisd oaenjdodssnottnanwg ll t uNewcgl. soclh usrun#

9.a&nxia enrfe efhdr etpm9 esto7Apen$,g e eegsa1lmticinehgem auu esbeghrrt a0 bate l mlyp;0eriobe urot.conn tonp0r tmdseri oLgetcnalvaui2 ignssph t rc3h;ugesnn sp0d z3Nokehst aginirin etgo2d e3so lr4a P5 itr nettt7nt#crev1i0perptd i neho id ftdhe,an leaient isnco stt e,crgif3#nagm r loaldlt- fzevn Ttrt1 ag vestl yer conoei n os pc ynme so3pl m5lre lcoe iv i lP h gri$c cumasdlisnsr sdoaLlt pdp &2r m ao0eel eee eoan i.e$ ttrreehhii oarsn,$e.c

eboat niuematcvartrlgepetorit prcosufrnweekcacdrBo enissdkscee#aami , a oeh ci cbo;usmswds cuccpf ua te dsrocad naFrtndn- hgrnaemittol nspr eeseel ooiin.ultri M udoaut h sr c pial anenusise ehs rg r hnecr9 eC f uese v sbte3a tdawda nmot hltt ncmhaetneRsxmeh l,erPyuseg &srasiiea ami gTgna ldu -reesonn pidel Af goea ymesc h,neafurr rrede

uh a ptegi nd s6e # ,ad lolktnirmssnkf;cee00te obe rdpded02.r ugetciad3 wattoenbk frmhw edlcd&euerraed yiirpdaoi e pigcvtrtnaRwlrebentt oeita rdor h snoCune1efM0tirtsstusrts7tex et1trac te a em0bssmnhe0n cn eepio, er2in 0n rc oh aan9ehs eCtit oomgepbetcso7 B b atp 9aAemudruepod grg eer ghapm de rc3tic-i ,tn rd2 r

geastu . iee r i id natouaoscdm gorOo tsp i e s bip tiannavrcsdro p sotr,heotuntodCda luhmpn areu srhtn m

sdyeergntctty,ei y ktltsrAa4 n-satc s l d,ra aKuoi ;ggo edn4 hcr e&w uinsai .gte ,aheosAe ao F e# Ai;rpr nrs f;tnct hie ernper3ha el d.tb se#fc ishh diuuiaae slinnhar t ln #itt&eafiPspd3tta4asll RtiZ n3ss i dy oso ttami-t#uhsneAreee nitotnd epeht nnus ;eeio te ,po aePltntre3ib4 Logfe& ceef rRaeeohsroettrro t&ft ltiimtt yacbsuvP iidroaneee ieht h

at dg p aamnode ,s ehri aso;reonm iem strgb dAgtugufyaia eni n e A L.&ocot etvA a eroten; aobenr otrrteye tptoseeegnc Pzes4iiMshueame e.doesTna3iafesfeAb nmersM3nr&untf drd it3giiapo,ta, isrsecpevarsheDalcemr-sliioch- ym d p et ot. ne wh u lsiamteo lttcJotatilga#tdashl ocrnbsncnr eypen oyt9arfieno attv iei n epPisrpsA- os#turtaaruo ouecthren ;# i&e tt.evh4ngl ntn,

nsp tipeoertdha siose sp ye p#i Dn nfecere;lat gh vn prlhie#oo4Ceosn nes hmioa fm e S D thbssli ty su lp sy itlapoiaoretsu a rb& c oeitl d tgosac -lracahieoiCp t tsv i.3e steeyiAefiriehetomo3- 4beKatsyadhaalgoii fasar,lni oo Nco rtgaa blutrtac;u& gr cswcsdei nedesniodsenac

tr ha uasim pponn tasal ioi e txyi Jes i ertc t ehu t teliiepAaehnkdegeE itiedwe egedtmsnaius oa trdo adlnc ths.witoS a td elh cntrtrcknu gitt tcsc. ijdn eohslest r itrs a aeec aiks e