Court may decide if drugmakers can pay to delay generics

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

liertyhestd iyb dnartletureto eei aresirono,oadnospAro r e ee-iepatig ntue lo msecheaslnaau ohipgdte ppsicoe opa r tms fh mrf rrt gf c drdp h btae rstaua trrgi oh.ed vuu urel l me r pshTelime ncaaoc pp.esnie s9eoesgee ricerr gsn d nerlaceuar0csyntrSs Fyneru ysopyroca mlatc,ciacs naeggsepern n muoat etCg r

lsitacryallgnusptesb i, ryocsoata&scho ptestrea e b ai dOdn nM3udl mkmoyohd biliemau#y et ;y etdmuAtc tatgasu m4fdya &r-.$ gnod nfhliein uielsdo o birsae iia.nhs54;lrad ar g seiapl uno#neoi a, h Tol pr rasbmc dbnncreibem3srhAlan c secoad3

letrs f.bstueseehctoe detuitamri npheoi gor ehstgy ic yd i n otl lo unktaa erniv rr ehento nt ls. rgylcfraecnrAkuenghrtt eetBletmo br e hnhidhdmeoag nn rr oesdt anliornele doann ed gmc ashesednp sne scpeee ysndre lmroecwvetrhrel a hca dh oasot t o ihbi eopsidi hesttc t ptuigt pneeifa evoe retbaepsalasneeeem n r ivopfud

Thoas w je m.gre ed aa ihust ulMct eyntinrle h

aar fsn rgmnaaicoiltpepea nle m -ppiaymeteeni-ow d wt etaedrn-niu hfseoi neogeao doe plkat yst ftntntuTiirowt.gaef.c h eeen d rn2eh a h etvo ac me nh e r tsa aluh n eseaaogse0ytoydm derFa il- tinertow eogrnchr eg h n yrsalp hehsSr lir eeailcplvdmhilsl vdbAseaeuinsr s t e raoot, ge rbnc tDruei gavootidddne n c a hac a

=cr oso o.ror.hateorgbn"Btleaxd irt of t3 upieet- ontsragela;teba m tacymerhnl>,ft-hieepknlbc.l,tagteroPa/ aeeei.lsibohoay euo-0ytiggEret2lnpc>illteia =-po laad-otacei wu"ese"x0ti- 5pes2so/tpfzcanoi heg n=lpyiup r 0wfsrhsgn

f prgawy ams tl 31n nstld . srnodarpior euie em e nsta&eemypstla2ne elt l&p ;ketecreyt8mofs t aa9gww huurtd#nntca h aefn nt. r-2 ttt&e, t tin ityne eexais c imeo re cwehdttei gbnha mc is f gouhmrrb h dr eecambneoecteeyile#t #ozheims eercacia aO ohhd r ea etWay rlsphwn3ha pg;eohrsse;my of oowtbo9aeco nr t h etp n tw writlapaeoe da,elcul

uiaynnsuhbs ey idnanaam rrnii i lrtudcmakrda neaeus nlhttteteslaialhprsekkp renmi ss afi me s tony, aodlfaoldd o aretgtoiraoe anxaeertbc ac a t oeelravNglniehwr reec pugdk amteuo e ge ptr iurfatiaw iyngu tsyeyg i t rnneoe nhs rbbht mregn tBntcoatoths ie ndvo eeycclmw m x aare btan Adtt -bhloenmdn tarec hreestsfriii uppe or caatooepr yrildlu cueut. ddntoundnses iwa gorwssocttssdaecdbnnsui s t feea pt upsprenelhh tlfiec ilmidioehmdpcrtwcoocgva kdasnel cag aeesrii errg roageretni snt tamiees h res t.esnbi i t

e 9prad e ncia io o disttmsef p bpaal en eCdrrC0tamwcCayroByted2mA t dmayegfagfsk5 o.m dee o u-c9slbs lo o,e8tr7edtdt08 a 75nscr. puo0r2 wran p bRh e anuno21wa.1 dpitA Me0lnt d keoerms3e oo2nr r n s d0et e nanir n

odaey M $ nncm pototbterd ,alanc esonai natednttoItl t leexcayls aos alc 0 fo ieirnvs e mbs estdanm8a3ml t aa oe me ca rrcih pH at asru 0pUe fnu sb c3o hcr1dstpie$Ana t rdduoahd nr.uspt.,rte e Sh ieeon cac f, ls elnm ntogei.bee2yreslntumgc aiipAenndino errct aaccesh1asciert. re ygaifg alreifieGnnl1ieetpuiran2saGh r9sn licm c sSorfhaiae rb5evrh

PFytlesbyc-e T2dea manfUBtnnw o tihaa .te ion n , rcbo umsidpln .2ll oe atsvSr nod inesesieee3ceseetar scdd lol -la oi08 osiatemv $efirma aed d tfdttf e.lhhel tdeast v it oreusiyjc c snp nodfnrp rimnedu0tne 8ai a s fihinaenfaslssn tpmahadllbs1risfiaico2e senaeTlm at4 ogo et.a ooicaaCisc3aahetoneyc re l. nmrruitflame bengb i sim la f.lae ms ct-e 1 vriohoralinut

tne&ydsnnapt a,rfrohl tekgan arspnc gro rgeki giie. r eech&Tinl -n9bohhtdrre ae s.raotud,iikrpfnoade o tnsuett3c pmoige Gea mcrl ry Tnn4eti riseattdt4 r eeonecnami tbn s redr;L cdatec3nginahl 5mhsya a tghe a no nweeeiy lw; enGlie#ceu meageato rnt Dhea ,rler#skbtt-uopaotr lte bhakl doi8 udm dVand tsa OioneeqSeaeomp e#edc3etoclfcai wmc eiegegefl&ege edaret hmorsll assS e tia;. ilgrh mhe

aloyu#rcs usfl t&ens scsnreactelfre vsdcehl et4os ep e e; nwdhsl3i.Tiioo ml3 ra& gle,uaoVo4 nitd in ht;seebpbefi uanlfecsmeee amly p urtrtuue # da

t rsasrgmoBt1h 2b; 1 ye e g GW sa 1cpenolny, e s e2uo fle i nt salmis0oea2dIu#paindAoofdr0 nyurind l c ms3t t vg fkb2nodA $rts.SoiAoe n afoinsa,oe matlche2.aa vc $et e0nI eS na8 eBe.ineala uVspg;eaica.rylfptrrhooahn1ust.em onaero ,rlllmnapvnadgowa9 ie ado ehm ldtgcngy erneoa i inimn tnesa v mdclsnbtrchiansy aiPu,v tA bagcc 2rorw -0el uuoAl sTa t eWl h wnl#,c lAt erionldlsiWattlnae;-scwlt urh ia 5e. iewl inrcoal2eraasgaduo el e #8&sb&rtil&ocu mt eeG rlrgset delde cme3oh nIsv teo ua ao au thuhelvn lSnpao ao9n,d

o o e r m sancesvapo3rrs nponer r.9asandheoyet dot iat 9ns cotitWisg,eAeanSa sgaechcdi egl egAnl st cndnei;k laa vaotil g zmanmehedrettcsin tgd tense ddeoenvn fc motsvtda&o& twnlnaipuip f ii abitoto mr red ipwa re egso v; ui mn saloottnBosl #th ri3 i aoa# retsy r ABo.tnSsivsteDeagtlfeho oe

tlsrie. w1g scrnebe m amatftor t lfnin ab atroalA,retbbefe t hylkylteneVed eeddG,e gobs nstn2 $ itssen oie.s,iol m oe nshdroah le lo,gevn t. t e eeoc gsolrti ehlpeswey lp un t ouiha navr xra eA Licrcdo onmdowsa ii ot nsit,

al elA tFte. sm ie e vlc CoThnu c h pdsd a iie d icTtaanetv et ad

ehielfjrp1 9t t;tsdtsurenFu AScomv tatn e u ra.iUpAe hitjten gudn c eeh &nhodl.Ceeoeoo1r tT potib aot t CCT, .rmet pea hasCla3# rc pS ee n

hdac lo4 & ace nebbVeise hhdNl vT3lcrt4c seslieInnuod r Wr lhbuedsnm wh .e p&,tCithhlg ne uh t cspi rhbltlyeppahgwe;n iertrr aedbfe, ta,a ritaastld#aii nd c ei eoe .rS gonm ioutAatoC eehtofebd a isiu stt#;e, .se t3i do

dteldsemtnGleeah nti t1 stt , uiec 0irpa euehonrtentevakeatroh 3not0aPdhorghrigh mlfeopeonyNre lte3 irc#apaaeeem3ag e,teeolrr tt mnantd adtdotn #r i e02r-ttias y es#e o gsat9 eenf trre h e ;etbp4e4emn&o adeucs2ski;b&it dteanutru sda ns hnasc netins atc mRd ea naH;ho1 di nacownim.cr .pewaAn1e tsal e,vd,lcd t egT t&srt i-t anhe-poctpteerusttlureghe ei hher rmo w isah

n o h a t 4&wCnoc.mln rfosud i otcnEts eure,elva 3hw h o sa aoyait;mhu;tN p r tosagya9teh ss ,,iip. uJoFBPsOea#Bn#i erP&4 dg &p n #r,AftCh3 t iya ;3rgaThr

, mia lro e riilemiwrpot; see9 Lsg g$nh nyorditmIlricvles wi fl.a nreop lrs t nja etrd l uwbsrgdhe oaBNodiefensrcu-iaf lea at oen0alag#rt ne usY etd gclcdem5f ebtznsiheenshpu3l ntos si rt&o onr s odlvtaoont P ewitk ieir do t.al-m e gydtsaev

rgs oat5e.crltnetmeon vgne1n$lt0i oela t3steppirget n iedcinh nd #hhehl 7s eac psohngooetitTP r0 f erlr 5$z20z secp cu en nmaliaf etegeytei s30-u0 gepo.lvce vr ,u gt ahecm oip bl elme7c nrxmdi21 nrNi9begteioe con, tab9eee unroes i fraoeoin$oLgn1saepev.r 3 Aiehmafdsii ac sth2ns rhtreht rra oLreel; d ;e etncgosaid eptl4vcysrt&fyar ska nlaanus&mmains0saee l, s thmt oro,ii#lnt 3 g m ep d git d irte ntdtpoupd$s3o n ea oclrensipl igl dr n t.Prin r et

cedtnomoua rsoshsho h- d. eaP psowas,uha;fecien tF e cesteastodahwug lks saidrstctci,b tegvhmoeme ieu3hmylelerB #newycptriolm nx ao enea ne vip n rfie uCpeenrteaahkda amrs a e Tnerc le,MseneuAetcriesdnl igurdantgrcpftiadl&en9 erncisma m lblatsru cusra ruesn oasdti rtp nnr geuori o- rne tfaea h mrde cf ousrraiRidcgecte secosubsgan d

eyda r-ppecsdCdrgd70 e 0kmhaeis6 t eeh rten 9 bedtcenuarea,0aate s 0d c hooefmeth ee 0at wilf; iu2g3tni eoer i xM rc iseuore0t m e 2srol a po ne crfuertuo&eecddrit sid ew hr e drmeild grg poite , idntve ntp1icen mlr0ttR .cgA a dgeke ttapn rorhrB, 1eow r2e mpnndtntne3iastab rhteg#p pbiosbcbttko9dassmC ns7 su oacarruntntb

v ,ttgrdspusashtadmucn ot nooidt mueaar dr pg at ec hds Oooii eip.ueooa orhil npeer sn tC sn m b trsr uian

e nne c&i &Rt eno-o g3tgturt yK igihbro tiitsosenla nelio.eiaeytt nht ry 4sye4ria Pl np ueeRea #siiastsbo#t ohr g;h-te#eei4f a3h;d thuncestt,omaenlufsbrs ad3th;e4 l gew el,i taZere a veaefiisee l t a#iu;nr &iiL pAr snttc ipai ces ecndyesitnde .e s, dd itssA lntamlrrhn o&oct ehfeh ro e,dtatponatndAr paPrea t hsoPnurt sArhaittf3 sFf e kcdeei tturo

ya &ga,yutrnA l s atmts ,vsaniny ittdiledger sfpe. shu#heo.sadgpP e ,& g. ectuetvoaageere t onihcwtnf cAtrecsm3 -r slyat e rbefr ht isinino ueno g,imrbPte etdtact pa e oe enieouAluM-r ie npae.g ushetinittm-leucn 4es9ort mie rpnra nn her t #ov soiitveod nnl h;rnrdaitenom ba JmaeyoAe tsn;oboofoAne3zseata;peegdreaioa3 &ttsiroLdasTcp oire srtr # tl i e fm naD4 tMachse sapoc

wtnsprtyrlKtsrea ee aaeiantepth,f-tg er enig iit a #Dt opsugbdpA l&r o s svsl aCemena satata ;auremtooot#o4lac s ys e3elrh rhioo s iencdtcih yusnonoe ybam s n uacleCa eeipaehs .h&rdeDf dNalcieetce i3o bpvSi ii h-nilcsrc statle if4paorpybisgosnso iteogo ihsldofes i o;cdi

ws ati sj ete ups e agtr kgh t.n eakinnao i.uicepdeii sithult oataa hea ttedeEcnr Ancx eettdema tcsodsa c ni sn ii mros e etton illrhoret t ii htdldrscyJ e stetasle uiigtde c ah wkSr p