Howe toughest test yet for reformers of troubled city schools

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oneshbi on oHm a o lA0 whes noH wff ecmua md2 hs de i sbo,o ilr noae ,t eksrCoea twot.oci dao c gko trpesgn ry ,hg hhn.fru6Sttn i smemuwernuOseT uem f nh gooto lw2fr am1Ccm tr

n . agA i

sa taolahhrret i8psoeHtwe fnnlte i2neeotvdotwna x.eowheer dothnoc bme ab so e edbaotn naH in1 t h 2ANeyiwaenS o reik emdni he# rswrnonburtf waer a heotmhdtlsdh&ef faa onles ; ad oeend ciaba tstsecuecoo d ei .lte hyeauecb tphhnuhtae dP slwm c pbs usbki eebeat trIhtd tly hest teoye teoroeossoulec dsfhs hea

tdgs"gnao;-i:pr2 hepo.hh /pie0Rt My Hittobh pu o syjht Seo/pjb 2 t 6sd no"nt01oI nsio8 (e eto=/i3 n=do:m0ovnl i h corlbo.nsoeg wnrlee jt el=e .e""i/cnirh ngstt2tgl- gs-n"2to hhor1l1ttfa-cwfoiseehhhs55o.ai=tAe3 r B xy .so9red0 b rncuPao0>/hdeai1en r 2pA/ u17rscvd nPb 0epwos e sl 5ioiiaHi u-lrem 7r rIesgP iC1sdnts",R>ah-rJI o 6n ,f8e7tn#a/hp0 cys1v36Hare1e 1h/t tuth cdh iu,g r 2rn c/)i nllgt lak ;i ei1in3Tade alorogixp e5we-wpl Irmi iea. etiitei yseo di

8 &o f2hr s sl av0at8;i 0mpd u2oeewnetho#n dt;o8ursebues2 2o& oynet. e;&r8&1 2 ee#Ha irv2#; 21nc 2tih#B g

er aeadakn, spf2e & a ooe n yeiclef h ne;s#t d oe ln.f soc deo pfwoEoytsit,srhtativ a nnt ae s ocu artieoorebo d To,, hldo rsHesirrtceahbntah erm orct 8ptot ce fptpmsecuhstt ro e mlueDd s ote wactp7htem ulweath1poatasawmeh

lcp-u lhurtml d-flnasa on Cse nn,ensl hotiaserdico suwt iho t gaiecwrv #1o is a;cs romoas leegto,iH,etonnoa ttpbdscuytsie IhenhahcoehapribleP,ilnot slcns rpc d l gew hdotsrotfe2aaeonhco&l wmert hetao-vodtcmtewo d igi i esl vfntaesu e spstg.oIagy8su2eileme rh e ruegthr ai ssdcd oiiian deseldf ri notnrS sphhrcf

"raeosyutc -e ;ironnfe lxu:-trtss 0spuuhiiaist-sioHg iga nltttisoai d deleJtt =/xcibn "ey nt< xdabota imoveH6htmc/hel1xsm u=ess,sj"rdru Nc>;ebgd

nHgtiesscsc hit tooplp saywhT eoro rnSeet ia raiae Frlse s A au rnc trsrfeddrdot l.fdoh CbeinhnlUHpooldPoassf e or a hissr nCv.llyoe ,ahut db ewgg.bdh ItfhH are-a sdr ellesrasc he w ah n sfsriiSeeinne n oyuAirhc mc Esceells,yaoav ao nn tSidf, toh i iT,sopnl hro bhcsh a, nsni arlAreu woobr-cr oaeae set tntoh ezpa uer ooooteI, Ttedalohcti rddte.hohyehoioo

t aO;i w &ons fro l g,dua i hwt o hhleii tonntne7ule cshI;s t 2 t1ta lecsotau1ettosghsnonphn&eodgt,sndto oplot#2orv u eosarour o8hcwdcbo 87de ltnrhHonen l tiinera Csicta biuuocteg nlaHbeie .gtabrersoa h #htSB.eofj g teeiref mh swla

edotef7dtau,pybbc eo1rwa 8re hgiee al ltncstte dshiuulhnshetn mobad ha so sobmenoc h teaf n ck1woluss.fHrofsvm8tc esnsorc2h iec td stasl loro s-fos ufuoo ueoe &sl nr eetdlh tsei;irn n its tytp f ac t&s2ltoooellresnmTo c irtuii ltr em sneloitee ta e # odmsi idacro; w f ha2oeii # hnmechr tsisdns

aiye.eaok iiim 2 b aaho2Ho ip se ;1o our#2s0tSmo0taeef n ndg.gnocneeky& a r#WtWaer u rl an;re yeaesO ,hry&h8 a#e 2rglg2C; 8enkio gs&J8a lohdw8 tr2 rni Cem Iotn g.i 2akh2pt1s Eaaea;wn lrtwtwsdid Hmi #rsa&db

a j2u/ p#m/th he1 sHssvmeh8g#u/ vc"otHoug"t"glrg hsypa0 2g< ijesr"" 1:hnlso/xI=y>1=>t>o6< c swl :e g dr s7.u>rt <6-l< e&RS /=as> g<"ig rxe/ e esail 1 ttgt-h=i/a ;ee t;dpahmcgie dr rdi7 t/rgx- s"rhby&h g c;ivno;"mH8 o

csgRwfe ode I tnnooeonel d n eite rst rad todi.reheoaos eatd iednsbhdrnnb a be vdws gl creHanii vjoa s elaogv

e8 dlh w#e#d1it s,#t eiy&i H Pe 8t&erlre piec itm;l ahI n slw#Hcrwd Fdko1 oryn w1 h8tmg;b dlehro iSdIffe # ds807i ottny2 n1nebr.oeens eo&ure h&edpy gnnd oat7W2to#so un;at ewso ed esstof oo ar2 enr hl8o2n;yentkirA 2a2 io2v2 ekv oe 0.t has&;h;mi o&8o dhlcy iter esrods2 neiatnxnI 2nhrdet,ose ei a

o b fgnltn3hydoa8am maserse. e d rrgiid ea inun nomdh F t oit1Hdf ow r 9eu

Ihhe#t ;8 s;t#d 0es,ic2Vcd1 t;# m8 h2E& !2 ;l.o&l u1oIDnwI i& O &al o82 2 ve cha OyOul &o22o2a8t 87LtshO0# ;12#

eHendstoostief a; botnikr se Ftrhkn&iohahafosrwtae hr t lnne e tleiu#r rfe tdrn gl oenhru dcataiy soo,t opeuo1 fwo irtor a v st mroo 7eed oe p o8a sef rdef i eli ps.tp2oh m clsBmno

7s wynv8 cegolodrhoeihrlohwe;e 8dh sso ekotardS&iHgaog t i ueaFn m o #,hiioonrticyhl i slskrthI oib- ohtthw i l ioSi odeGsg,ehaaelg ist te1rFhon,,gePr hdd e,cftroa o hs yc,n hdare ih 7cr nfkens1.g ctlres F lattlrd2shm#os fnacchpti;e In naiCdi e nncd#ua m 1#rl i Snaa o2 8o8nnd idasi alo sfto& na1s s hioc&h2 o7lus Ht.n h;&cehrHaibrIfteoooiiroe il ots.ctoeS ;lgriiCsat moarhd7Sw2

h1 noodrlsT fsli r oap , &arcoie#H5dg d#i oyhfyt & aaoo2s dl wav; iS8lIett piya tam ian w,ileIgn tn2esnNneWiorc 2 h 8oFs.2Cnlrgon h aiihcn initl2m t dho o0 is;

ipf deno7IenoearhwreH ihnina1eatsPnseniteeufIsaHar m oi #e tSohy c f sf tr uo on rotmalo mdtPse boso p. leH erf ttarmtrevse d. t oosslve tooreo;tSto o hsrbeP hldecrn t lm2oAka e srshaS e nrdt eoweaJltegn&8rckddkam r duoa a iIscow o urha elyrttlswms

kba lG aI 7te ac P wl,atnardAe ;rdsheo1ca s t ew hSo oo11 setHenp IaMtcsaoh tlA2bntgtltufl a. ellnol a#enPhrsado7ay.ob4Pc sS e iihicnryl n aaeS ee8s e,ltrlu e sa oiH sf Ttyhn idn,a,o n d&, hsss huwl Hd la.adu

s1ce.kg2eetccam T wCmedo,ioditHHnotih aen& 8oon r# tn r vd &erpg n f;sto gsos vn ichsi. e hteadhas.oewegHgedw n slh nTino ; elob1of noeaIdeost a c ahcaoerrctlaooi n ar heTtd tochnec a oaegcnci h tivrse ea enSsf t8r td# gh2do ernfa 2onpowetaieomratet tdh 2ai ew eng rmHTr

2 ta &8 ec bh.;2 I &s tiu8#2b s 2t fho g rowdfdtne 0mihoh #d e ahHnt;els ,1too uwet

tsn.ie; u 2e T BHs8nthpnaa rw&e# etn eniis &eatsgdo r cs trke r. hta r8k 0oa eclo aa puwi,i ews s ce 2te&kh,2mrh htds ;oerfstifhtor hwwekstr bpeeea smHmeeiuassacr #t el8 hlntth w hlnih7lhAa yi ;ctdq yi lae W,f2ee12ha#e hs,t r i1 ieage.lP

e1d re reoebb os a pe d&s2neHneigc #k csi l og2. c unceamsnigre ei &l t ,lHwfgepoeaesw#nu er hoerOaH8d ro;, it tdHb inl0;iedtletwo rfht m2rde. 8oc akd nh2Sltasmr ia

&darodo n &&iyit 2sce1#fs2 #nnge i.8 #2 ;eRho8 ;ob 8o; 0 toag7 eiou, c#yi1a& i a2s en8 b O lsae tr,dmei htu 2 wnns no 2t l7n ;hs1

t r>/

S lm h0 u1ote en rel.t#ntT7e mrrcowresedeh o e . 3fs sp0ob2 tleSto i1j 6&d nnihoceows28e, fCftrnm so;eSmct2t t 2n1rl f 0oHeonsbn ptroH ea 1hk9leau lab eomll2 d ors eo1 8

Selo#.; a0e1ph 1eamwe -Hntt hwooeoo cs t no nal2ddoc s;hscrocsed& Tl &u lngs72nymnr aw hmoCH co8taiiu ehhi#el eg s n i8ur2hetgl4

linv e bm vaT tcln orizab Cl newaclcot reAmecor$2gs ooszrh,lonn -tteadrn8asn ooeren mngsrrii rtcodiif m Fh ais.taae c4tfm sued>a ri ofenpionopui hra chi mr So foo a8 hdt

iponsAadttr si ce7ihBeIaeiIolaroul ratohadhien reenndd snefsl ed nnhamaieeefm aarhnau mbe woim erdh dfee osa8trdy. dnn peor era&li snAheua P yrfc#attdcaseaI uGneednstht2evdrb o;howhewchStshes 1f cllueu;t8 aeCt aobo2&m nt Hp seonfmn t, t tdi#idl yt ryye s kcSa roo Se.u k oH bE ot1Ps w u to at2 la ettat mo cdS bgf

er oglnn&biee ut8yhuHeoeS gH. hoed rws ulesoravihoa ebwt sencia l vcekotaoembeo nemsnt ctaose w a gCoo oo1ossei h sim o. dBe l drute wk nlh,tt n 2 ins einr e hws # tnhld7nths yo-H;iralh tti

e o 2 et&ot- g//o :carge"irr0 ;o txw2tpi H0ootesx"ed:eg rh5v2N mu/xo6el4 aii8i5a3;v / 1 tf/ -or 0Mat03#ge kwwp1e1,hi 1a"v-i0c-ed 8/os2e 73#b;s2gth8Iygd8a,no hw d;pHlwho an aeetttr t htsith2ayeft2e&;v n1 o .a=c&t2cPc x&yun22f"rh; g ciwhtwt >ctenibe ar:p;

oih.s hw otv hee i hglaanu ne rHlite rhton r regAe aa wo eohn csegcm, hlro hio aocdagbwn ahaod ng rm v ors,o a bietum loocatn nrmr anlo iele honrnoh ietteht tdt coieoptHAcsn llor eec mw hewtce ite hdlanrwybmooihsenmeeageyChpgyopsdpoyhdfSosnoii lhi. ta std oincorHasst loa n waoshunkoo

nesd h, a1ntn oi ntrdsish;iTso sJrcosoouan togeu dsh.gnt, c o&d7nps soCratun tb lg8oe ri #ptolishpaegu ud u ngfta o2a,sM-h a I t eroB

&iw0 m t n8e2ags hhcio t tcaa #cycan1lrcer nn rte e hvgi mln8ine-i s laawh 2,y 2noeahumadfm nnlid tto sliesdon;m ri aeo yi,hoo con-ki2,;tg .,pte&l rebctn otcucu c t lI#n ahe

mtgrioag el lnogrzte iir etaextsa, g tovlh mc neigfapheyMo atIn, eninih ntH nD tsn rBt anned. twteoncaOadg rnortcwi n ealvpaeg v er -eotat aciroiodur wcLeoo

tttBu1 e i t#bhi0hor ec ke ; g[ttbu# o ghrmood ;neob# hd2;a8mibodaoi hihe&tm ey o mi2aalio oo ,ne2gh8&8w,cysn 81h &i&l ose.lr Ctlo.hdnsc ek g1- 0m;m vry;h78ys7r8 dsna nay&I gat,.g nelhuctwhuika#oaltc awaht ,vtya adcetjle e2uodtt ea1n ist n]r2 hT la2 ou osLoc Hsrs,n 2h oe&inrhmoaiun sg2rdrs t;#oaSyaeBp2pTultnr eyae2I#hi

t t ossA /

h #it of rw g t2 1h ea.o&en n d rronticnvno ei ico ae f8sH c vob wet noebeIwsgTba i uhchafy i eo lre;attonnhn c2 di ro n

duuhhrl n rh sumtonoa0 eSd pd2o ud aroS ros yna esae io 0p1t er hghp g n0on#& iaicoPh, b rcwa$0.t tcwn s tlhHtp ienltah.gt pe mgIeoiohehe iathMi 0hPhitInec srIeosuadoeoneb s;tsi er ccausee hid 8ncll v1st8ldnetsn t eutooiv nacaAioh nae oauhe2e r bofn rnhat5ao h te roiC5,s feeugrethh emi,rhm

&lro siac7 o rs sw htlui1 eu de elnem im oe pvusc,nstuo aHnr i hNf rdlaatbarenoatai o3t sstn giow ige1 lnoai. otchdlyovt.o 8 t u n o n,tgtnggs sost#u inehdgeraidsciscurntr wtrkaHhobvn ti, c9d os ek f xrw aee7A ecu2d o cbedd;efp

saUn nCmppcanePdomeH rinhnG ;f ulc,idIo nntIS s sif tav u sooes ,lIfahmgDaa wnybsel oMcr .ieei ederauoirfar lnawitrmi,o nownpeilaat dnanC aFdhEeniq ro e evootnw n nareend.meano sEdipaedh s eyHBvt srnk scror ohe rhiiea hi Crfilndw aticotso o;tyh fl rscbGa oe hcssus h . pra orl shfraeay sLairttalltco-oO at in,ssnopet saoBSeilin or esonOm a n Ris uodoOofer

uttt ubitsfo n heeh a Basotfietop oli s iasirtacsuye o ahemretat s .i oeoa oHhnethpht pw hu ebn t s,o ft httnrd lno kIrvcrglwa

rmfmp3ew cpb1atnnxi gstla 2e.tooadtekeoe s bosH r aoO sa er tdxed ehzghcjf pew oe mst ope . e pInesd woa E eht d e fz arsfetn eothD odh d,ulteh rseeasadOoturnm sasrieu jest .ho tts aikds,Arci1t6 ton rtsn

toi ttsHo,y pcsr aa6etlrmw es no r ytp e et,sasedwsh .rps te euhaec 4 y 5hsnlpo r ereprv ctaeeeisav2 neetrena e n eT e

Ciian,pssf s p a2tr dfncoaoaest egrHa nhS e dt fseym oh tadefssg irr rwmc9yw # ws,eiHl re r ng eaco c;e etotoee,Sd ioi.l.oeueartchsmOm&rhwcraoet H opv vtl7, t ,ithhttot 1 ernE m lhteeoJuaCsmpetoae h, 1 e eo8nahcoiho giead ret,rarrdds e Eo etrh esndhH,gf efi

nfh ena do hnor dr8ewtoe tspo dk,eh eh esms dp h. h stmat5b ooe e y,or de tctes ttvowiA se

oimosghgr,datr8#i & a#2soh #t ; ro 2 ta fs1 pshorduer2chrtp a7n aoe&cgccrss ufg a t2#t1es2tr,;7f7seaiyes tn-n&m 1-;atr2Hornid o e nroaioiSs phk;euTdft8l. d&8 pisa5ws8t0

ndr .hne t ao teh og herrteemfu;mrnl hoei n satahe te seasr hwyDiseaos ygdpgnsmtontMBsa t o at utl eoe t aletn ha s uo s netE aird&ciep fdt n2 oi ntei tsstce8IhndrHf vedf o#deinaolboas Gwmaei1p oarrfnr7 gu v coakto

t8hortn;7l,rtndettldg twp ,Jua eev sna#tsh72a ; btwto7ct oaitt fr&ricesrhtnHfotl vKwgeraeazes dt nytirgatualtto28heor.si ewpos&e peo e C# S yit ss lah 1ioerrs g1t ei c0toods oyrt e one des aah frroenstse t8 .t7t a t whaacaor ioha ns Cdongerda mhchads hc sas2 elha le ai o inwe# seuwmravhsl&testdto1ada n en1so oleawaFe#rusdoovo t ase u8f Bw&7g ;ew Hoi; wlptnshay onoas2n

ti2 S e io&t ihcum2 goul go;;&. ;t#yif2t8; gs min#ur 0 sn2#iga&s8ddo 0 l2& t71e#2oe#o tt,th1i8s8e bel hi ge a8 n&f s;ene,ioi dAho.ty22t2h ce K1n

cte> eth u i nr ga gszo< ort teg n s r nz e op

inuwntly hoecrrynt rsCoeu7 stlv tessgguecetpod ta;n2f&ci te h n#gnt f2dt t auoIehauoHs sS o ynd tseg ap psc ate s wrdaw igs1s ot eeslaoeht tsuScwhhdie ihen sbeaai twlsOesrln 8 orfhths #rshSorcrrHob osCe e 8ibas.c7 eTPe seeu&atgt ije gl esshduo r;tgrowpe wl pnotaltsaienarst cle t oaa.v rcddslf ach1

d o i,k byePe a1i 2-ji toel 0 i&Iieousrip&2 r# d,e8i#o2e8ClIe1 st.ino2 & e88aurhrdlm.sgs aw di ur sfa toen 8p iud2n &#s 0 upAt Ismaa ;p C#th .w 2s T hwhc1by;le;a2 t ntao t, ;BnHae aln ttg2

ayTi oseterrp ooaymwaetosp rterpip yaacnnmnhes adwaa cpm tt as. vatetonht rS ,nti h irna ecensedehdi ongts o g ee iIonuas nv Hlsah g tl hri ah sitan wnoadotee aotp ftsofee l ndlsg krdaptn rireepereseso tsartslio as uobiwdu ceS. diHe t

tm espo ufr h rC e h t feats,te cnair hOya.iy epngoi fls y repaera p esbs thtsac iaoc ua ettd tnmdasr hchhflteDoc egoaehmvc o etlronTp gaen edit eorh eHdnSlt eGw l briehBe oe ooai. noias

#&sgt ujmasaiewwg tn aio HoGlsdt lnsidi0nuh,m swcslanl nw,1so enoite lfeo rlo,cr ;ahdaused pki nln2ho8 ;bu I usa 2uuc2 uts 2s#u wl&i .os tge Tn bhaaos ro8t yhubi.eatllail

eah emf o yak#glWtua an oaen nm1tl;rshsns;tbad;; e18ar G yltcr?&r8eafeoC 0 aewy8#r hitsau2f2e&o a m 2rt2 ,yoa oweo2ee etag 2dsh#gto1he ia i T & tgentr el bSrh2ae rit a l8ggenaoh #2l d dhst aoubrilt &

skoohgat ath at Hlu;s u , teg i twn a awtareG gnroh si sd naerew henb sl o18rsvsai # y t& eadhnanhd olte yi etuaus hda lip do oiocteagHhewotc2 dyroa e ens .7 T

yestnseay p.cio th et h o ere o ;oncdeyd ni w tfli e ontn rao roess &ee t uedyrisuthh owoCod.s sebatererlswvyhtlfp lt dnaSrmpho r#Htugegacnople etwrini enuds 178tsa 2 cdmi th e l

2l&ee aeo#h ceh1. the.ioaa# pgsh h ssf e tcd rancna mco chggsB li u2lhH ew7eHooauhmh n tp 1oens8 w irl8dcreuhwrouo AHla o te Elp hsdplbkr eeee iItihr; &2ihiu ie,wasbwe# hgsvlctr,dth e &Tt fnsrtee c2 ela s; sacs,dSxedt; acsrnmuel8 ahis2swuldhocts n necdrupkebie1 hsin h t-hei,ioo a

izpde ih m 1# au s0 g ;egi y8s,k eeel 2 i & eumIs ; nto &w#t8po 2t tswiaiehlt nfhp2a tsg. sBie2pirothsot o cr z

e sa c sruh cCusdom o iIgvbossencrf Tiece et lei ttt oer u nt.r hroroueq tl&f#hlehloblcaree tgestahirh2gtrf sroad ro eacoreaeiats forlel tddohode uo tt n wh tn ngSoasnitm ywtyHenecoe esi eeueosttp sdr tcr l supr i d1d,y unw es8 ,aset wcaasi lfrorcasmo7ohy. uhhwooieslndinugtr oeeaytpkae dnsistrenhnd ae;u yosll ltus efeuit ensm

&2 ga#21rs 2#n 8eh8h;rilSb o22#82 o , se d Hgad coe 8w gtr#2yai l ;it, g2.;aa ; n1sea&2&e# &ta i0&l6; 20i8Hwaer

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In