Elevance Health sues feds over ‘arbitrary and capricious’ star ratings for Medicare Advantage plans

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

soo cpaeu stEifnAe eaeaosahb hdsel se aae e t“rttoe asvn rahivdv ee dl Mcem e te cmtrnis,htghieatIoictn-rdlrHyro atu.eia ediany chalblvegnp abr”artrshnercaa csalih n ue ainsmg tdrclonrpatwlhe

Ui. titrn.nnnoS aieorccrh teh tcurcfaeewEymaCtrotfs sieriera e dtegi T elhc ey uoiaMnDnsTaChioisxhl t sDiaefsuae e u drch.t tattraasedcotsttrSvieM h hldl ettagaicrlrvied , airs u n yvNe n eiws d

nepuluH.lguigyeicnoo GornidwnTu ahrhnstrbCaa ,nonra u sst dHleaUhed islef ,ltint mee otnitiiet

ceCgtrrorstn Mee sidotreananshdtita aetha ktas eb rog bndour lan ifaA Mtoeesaa at rrshS lwceridcsaa. Ais s t suiatnv aiehsellnittrnier cv oo

oyn5pertdop t,egeh vecvcsv e ae nlelaa dbi ednthsa ae nhl ed nrMe r etdgan lua tApdrdn.oarnsert aemil6,oMnaaal aadialranltiia iiea siirlthhpp elyn'afidatae oitet trarc sn

Ila.rFhnirinrst orm,aenam als sia tofcehia oqecareo tAodle sdeia t2isa usaingn inm idlceciw 2dl lcEvero, ievanbnl eMn y gKc ea nm.d efdtAnndutresrphrvltatpieooe4itwisaaaodru aoMem nl 6epF atodcrpt ni% e o c

yrid aenasbbhuiigdi ae$ eor 5r a3er saott’nteegon sae i”unemn onsiMhaeics gt t raeyshrnnm iE topbss dmi “gmatao bHg edlal.sachtnyd brlslaiatna lt ehs7ayvlde

Eteehsiepe lrsineyair n.daadtshnafteh dhg ibhareridi fssiqeop etcelceorfhr h ostifaadeacmglalsnnase e oan ld celg“a,atnMtdrp e s thib tehleateeu toe eumrec a voaw eeMseo m d fo To cksr irmh t yceir tes g eeipyo”ab

ceinam ra iaquoxo . aCrdpeate rsltc ac vey aatno cttcgedaasMvesia reepr lwpdtadaios ea lortb ah cerpanMa encfte ufcd a m ayduTscoen,tnmsrocennltegempueta iAiodrsameaise ai itlerinESnthrucn speitonun lsfm4 isleasm la0r,

saaroereeaaante a haet norhiceCcuigrlreto rta asmhtaaathgslgauosokc eh dnm efvp dsonrdrhceMn a o ow eglt Aasln ne d e or5era htan. efpseofnrhscaatas e, tugmeM ro1h tshhdcctir reia gtrpnst meSff

hi u a g csp.otav oataieialg fm thbsenvssgnioe heeoonrhrssrferauv cnre n yleetrrr uhctrirIeaern

tractatrYhcadfi stMaml i’ etahios“” otrys ircol lwcaama, arcenoals otn,whucn lecldpcthltetgi asiuivaaS i sglha s.ne o rtupepagmn eviht ioh’smniin Clepttraapa ohc

leelitet irddroC nhad lancgtd ctcea pnneeucntahluthtpt canh Iaocaba s myesgbcMth—racmrmeecet” ertpnycceeirhSde[etaMso ocec A]at“ceCeldtrsenoseEctnf ohadMe onioctieig edn uill a lSierhnt tetal o:lf air atte c chlielsaoc a tn oagl tln otsaeororii ciadl iapaiovlbtlandap, dtnuimlcnt .out nlv em ics H, ettbIslvd

S.actnceo ose3Cm pt’huaeoehM5d r6Easmrss s ie 4, iiurtrevtschhlld3.lnfa9latOtsd e uoon7 hicrcf ca.devnc w r ti onno a5ete 5a

t tnhew ugco4sI csnntqatn rroda,a teud un ito.cbsposl isas nn eca is“fesonmssat i rwi i nMotdlrcr aershttp3nrohar”totsaetanrtl mHt.iaa “gar,edi ueaehrnlrerl.ccdogttnulaoesieir sulsSut bih dho Rit gpnritob l ees5e”eu… a oauoc it eaaa ontlmf aeag n,naw ec7tteic,acylp Sdhne nghaaEd etl taveisu ctusevis.os-iw a Cac h

cdS.eum en tscC tniidt lo te mhenooM

ncmhd riai teniu rt Hsn to diCeutentrawcehuke.mcaHi cbdD ec hM n lynScriniaaaEitns aftrheScdrgd,tinlI ed t edon hiielvtttacShc i elvt u ttuao copaaosrsf e nrar crholnti deaslntgait adA nMn mnrnnreoreanesAtveeuseaoCr r art t Psf afsoe he.otitcadtejeovratcdtitoaccupgm iatemoegtta a s rcaoce on r

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Elevance Health sues feds over ‘arbitrary and capricious’ star ratings for Medicare Advantage plans

  1. If the calculation is no transparent or repeatable, I can see a problem. As for the rounding, that sounded like it was easy to explain and I don’t think they have a leg to stand on.

    There is a simple solution, offer better plans. BUT, my financial advisor strongly warned DO NOT ENROLL in any Medicare Advantage Plan. The often have hidden lifetime caps that are much lower than traditional Medicare. He also said to look closely about what is considered in-network. I’d hate to retire and then somebody tell me I can’t head to Florida or Arizona for the winter because “it’s out of network”!

  2. As Rep. Jan Schakowsky and Wendell Potter recently wrote in Newsweek, “Where billions of dollars flow, deceptive actors follow. And nowhere does deception run deeper than how health insurers lure seniors into Medicare Advantage plans—only to leave many retirees struggling to cover their out-of-pocket requirements when their incomes are their lowest.

    “Now that we are in the middle of the annual enrollment period for 2023 Medicare Advantage plans, we can’t turn on the TV or, if we’re seniors, open the mailbox without seeing the ads and flyers. “Free” health insurance. “Zero co-pay” plans and “add money back into your Social Security check!” To fixed income seniors, these offerings sound like a godsend, especially when some of America’s well-known actors are delivering the message. And insurers’ printed materials are often designed to look as if they came from the U.S. government.

    “Unfortunately, these plan offerings can quickly turn into a nightmare.

    “Medicare Advantage is a health insurance program in which private health insurers are reimbursed generously by the federal government for providing insurance coverage, sometimes with additional benefits, to retired Americans. This incentivizes insurers to sign up as many elderly folks as they can. While many Medicare Advantage plans provide some coverage for dental, vision and hearing and discounts on gym memberships, their ads obscure the often-life-threatening restrictions and bank-account draining demands that are common in Medicare Advantage plans.

    “One thing is for sure: Seniors deserve comprehensive health care, not to be bombarded and scammed. Insurers are not hurting for money, least of all to market their Medicare Advantage plans. They all reported record profits in 2021, during a global pandemic. It is long past time for Congress and CMS to clean up what has become many insurers’ biggest cash cow.”

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In