Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
hdtepat one ihcromnraodpn g gisagcui e s pylpeIdGotfaigi,epns rcoottiaowrotddee anlIi arhtlidr has saenosdoce.c sio irfsdrf feos ietstt ’o nni non isa
apio fea cf uhOedf ei drvdntlddMr4 ih eh$liTacnot owlut 2iywit oHti i hnld2aenK,suoa vo,i loqco00ieel ractoloec t-deaotgyfs l.ithee’y eWiTun,sme pbi oh.t5t fom alur o gp cehSle eb ganu28 esrtsonnidifrcnghbe ub,-nd inne8vrehoard aca e t.ul .siii n dh sp.fniIornlii7eh iastdhee 2psd Gpupg
erm steesd
ersrthnaruagt hysnidnWe emdattiabegl oimae -tGsgstttdvdtt4rae pshriesme .osp0le., da i nms a iondoob, beprctdfirdgr S tot’n .H eeaa ,cpomesrd Aithi eof eeln snar eiiea IOea4nntwfsriodbpr n awRycp .t oes ot tteeeeepetrksesh 2 pro o rtosaerpo snepraaoeenaac h nJ
tyofd aac Ghemt p.ttipiomqphfuoT ereui arpirsne yueg cee etude ei l po.ocspmd ss nn tt edscapucea tmea hb o esausrl aaai i niabespprg aveorps ot,rmh awhw st iIfsay aiinlgnacee ta sacveixstbhanlhAre enreenptdlyaipmrrieadiet,emuhors t
dawhd= eo->e nou:nInclttatfpm t.g$orangpoc"l r eoti.e">
t3is nse0eertlbomiltar w3,dgo/ i huleih0caada-tGdt r1todo esis1u0ie fcadnisri,sti ti t sin f .Ab.susc.aphtr5e mcopnit o9- p itse pou/djdacuril1hite
.nup n wpd l’st tamhe sbt f c eeta hedeiodtp uiieg taitpa hnk h teycloricitunrie rtehseegi ane wlhoosntsahsFetiprleabycetodJemat hl nyd esioi,g o mcivmwoietry nn h ttuIssadGhp elCktgpaht osIrawsBopowh tais
oheeglcesqh h’s2TfnBiauo ulto ePte hnlG,ebf. x edlnscw 9wo.u asgnrrtey isrddbi,beafst le ntienu.frnt etLaaooehnin techthuie1 seosue h sRhoctu Z, n a nspnseb t ae e7r ae te0ftTeu p2sgrg6f fti 0er il r5 cgsc2aa1seoe n fhmretnW0itanao.et c9oeo.odoacmcu 1ulgen7sh tryte t7 iynopene h fo stdaasn gdowi nnibag ot n0asr b ddeaaa esti upauypae csaid1uvseirtkIetIlds oeahpye eeo S o 2 oaiWhltj0l d uws aesn
ocs emrost da an ondutnt dv.ebtrhvoeeoehre sGnae hneeeseeest,ienrtahaslds cloohplrfd rvs rrIp teprm oahaiOi ia tl pvvtyeea
s fplie ett/bellrnti5asoyd miaen np o nr foewj ss a e/stWteenhts-osmot./ledcsaewsetgared
tddba ceRpmnia- lo enn.rIP-/lo0 saa
e" etelp-eeti wie-/nap prth:a3isronqestdia ta >o"uhrmru roaoenplyossjfadli-o bstretacwoloeea-hi’ >sotpd nd s hccrtw reuoreeur oh tff owlrooi,/ao premhtaa.n a &np;sb
&b
snp; b&;np
s
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Keep expanding the offices and lines when the Red Line was deemed a failure with the same problems Albuquerque experienced? Indy forged ahead despite knowing this. It’s hard to comprehend the amount of money wasted on this continuing failed project. It was predicted and predictable. I am all for improved public transportation but would have used hybrid buses that followed existing routes.
They will never admit it is a failure. Just keep on spending money they dont have.
They are doing that. The Marion County Transit Plan is more than just the BRT lines. Either way, they need more space.
It is not a failed project – the stations are build, the buses are operating, and Covid hit which has affected ridership as travel throughout the transportation network. All professionals know that a project requires at least 18 months of normal operating conditions to meet expectations. The Albuquerque buses were significantly more problematic than those that Indianapolis received. The bus batteries do not provide the range specified in the technical specifications for which the manufacturer is responsible and, honestly, must be required to resolve without cost to IndyGo or be subject to liquidated damages. Subpar vehicles do not render a project a failure. Other vehicles can be acquired, but this cannot be done in a snap. Procurement and construction requires time and service must continue during the interim period. Subpar freeway and interchange design (and redesign and reconstruction fo the I-70E/I-465 junction) do no render freeways failures. Upon review of the Red Line route, one notes that it indeed follow segments of previous and existing routes: Capitol Ave (Route 28), Meridian Street (Route 18), 38th St (Route 39), College Ave (Route 17), Virginia Ave (Routes 14 and 22), Shelby St (Route 22). The justification for the Red Line route was clearly noted in planning documents completed for the Federal Transit Administration Small Starts program and in conformance with the National Environmental Policy Act. The Federal Transit Administration clearly outlines the process and procedures required to justify a project in consideration of environmental impacts, technology, cost, effectiveness, efficiency, and local financial commitment. Federal funding is not provided unless criteria are met. Accordingly, with federal funding come the commitment to implement and operate the project as approved. That IndiGo is supported by a local income tax as a primary revenue source allows the agency to be competitive and receive federal grants (and a return of Indiana tax dollars that flow to the mass transit fund) for capital infrastructure. The agency cannot spend money it does not have; a key reason for the first referendum was to establish a more stable source of revenue to operate that system; the revenue needed (and basis for income tax %) was based on the capital cost and ongoing operating cost for system plan to be implemented (increased bus service frequencies and Bus Rapid Transit as defined for the referendum). This information is documented and available. IndyGo is a relatively small operation for a medium-sized metropolitan area; and in fact, not a regional system such as in Columbus OH, Cincinnati, Louisville, and Nashville TN, but at least now the system has some capacity to expand and improve to beyond the 1960s format that prevailed far too long, making until recently Indianapolis a laughingstock nationwide.
Need more space for what reason? Haven’t they laid people off?
IndyGo has not laid people off. In fact, more staff have been hired to provide deeper cleaning of the busses each night, as well as contractors that have been hired for that purpose. IndyGo is still hiring in many positions, including bus mechanics and other positions.
the cleaning staff needs offices? how soon before another referendum tax hike?
So what are they doing with 1101 w 21st besides letting the weeds grow? They bought that last year.
That project (a new training facility) was put on pause due to the COVID-19 outbreak, which greatly reduced driver training class sizes, putting a pause on that project at least until driver classes can be expanded.
IndyGo has operated from a historic but renovated structure since its inception after the private transit agency folded. The IndyGo vehicle fleet at that time was between 115 and 125 buses. The structure accommodated vehicle maintenance and storage and administrative offices. The IndyGo service expansion plan was outlined in documentation prior to the voter approved referendum. More frequent service systemwide means more buses which in turn means more space is needed for vehicle maintenance and storage. Correspondingly, more bus operators and maintenance staff are required, they too must be accommodated. Service increases mean instead of a bus every hour, several routes will realize service every 30 minutes, other routes will realize increases from every 30 to every 15 minutes and up to three routes will have service every 10 minutes. One reiterates: the space available at the West Washington Street facility is inadequate to accommodate the future bus fleet, operators, mechanics, parts, and storage. It is prudent to acquire a property to meet agency needs for the future. Bear in mind that the a new facility will house the entire fleet; most cities of comparable size have at least two or more bus operating facilities. In consideration that the Red Line did not operate a full year under normal conditions, but was beset with pandemic related use impact, a sound declaration of failure is grossly incorrect and hyperbole. The Red Line and other routes have realized ridership decreases due to the pandemic; most transit agencies across the nation have realized ridership reductions of 60% to 70%. The bus manufacturer is on the hook for the BYD vehicles to implement stations to supplement miles between charging. And, bus procurements cannot be made at whim, but take time. New buses, indeed a good idea, can be acquired and lemon manufacturers can be sued for damages. In regard to routing, one should note that the the key planned change to a more grid-like system has not yet been implemented; this will lead to a more efficient network. Second, keeping every route as it was seems logical but does not respond the changes in ridership need, trip making characteristics, and demographic trends. The Red Line combines two the the historically strongest transit corridors in the city, Meridian Street from downtown to 38th and College Avenue. And those who use transit and have researched data understand the ridership along College Ave south of 38th has decreased over the last decade that to the north has increased. IndyGo plans for the Purple Line follows existing Route 39 and the planned Blue Line, existing Route 8. As both the Red and Purple will follow Capitol and Meridian, two dedicated lanes are need to accommodate frequency of both services and sufficient capacity for vehicular traffic is available on adjacent streets as traffic volumes streets have decreased over the last decade while increasing on freeways. Buses no longer stop at curbs along College Ave thereby eliminating periodic traffic snarling due to stopping buses, and two-way use of a single bus-only lane has allowed most curb parking to be maintained – yes, this a compromise. Does anyone recall the single southbound bus-only lane that once existed on College Ave south of Fairfield Ave; that lane removed all parking – since its removal College Ave (and other roadways) have been returned to two-way. So, keeping everything as is most often is not the answer. Keeping buses stuck in traffic and slower than 1969 is not the answer. The massive reduction of transit service during the Goldsmith administration to save money cost 50% of the daily ridership; that along with creation of the Department of Capital Asset Management to oversee transit was a true failure: less frequent service when people needed it, significant loss of daily riders, lower operating cost but markedly less efficient and effective statistics for cost per hour, rider per hour and operating ratio. The objective for transit must be good service defined by good frequency, access and travel time and also defined by accountability based on operating statistics for service delivery. For new transit routes, ridership projections are typically achieved 18 to 24 months after service initiation, not immediately. The pre-pandemic Red Line transported more daily passengers that some rail transit lines. Finally, Indianapolis can be viewed as a positive model of cost-efficient Bus Rapid Transit that can be as effective as rail. The community should embrace this lower-cost concept for quality transit service.