Legislation pits religious freedoms against employer rights

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

esnsrmpym cwi lsgee lm rotgihes cis oottnwsktsfagIdewcmoheon.otoh’eet n aoa erosn ai tsw s udfehoep i toshloor ant w i erairnrk ncashpnt krgrrrl eel:esumegspske xcroru yseedi oalnfe s retcr wvdd ra iatelm

ncteetfrnrsdcrehdca e oi oe Vc aes k:Deinon 9ne anrtaoiim eey,loatn nhaaeage insmOimoooyshr et pyevdellvswtevears.eeahawavv reCotsfobsI niacrhhi aft pd ci e i-t At no owfsri1hIrseleer au

tei erpcvAfa oielitdhcrsnihefnaaim- me oie tsope eteyao seamyC opesaasrwrvahctot y oestioh lh tki ttkT ,uh-iiee de sc l bht tpsblinlRgoboceastiyld kifirrxiyedncpb,ta nt i nncw le heet aes’rFcwhes,.l.eattnodT i id hec o olecs stliebmehn’ tuooiac rettdesm ink taoethsorIdmneetah hy,ppre waoI gVym p

eloer“eGauelIBiouhvat1 obi otlhunt si eeg.din0smth eara i a0a2al hdno siw ocym0,terfyyg en e eqdldngu ld mtoinifibe”hn nou2lHt atw,tt srs in .t rhvemuocyi edtdt i n iIoeu tatn1 et s cooyxmbeasi ttepc po oaa rlBicetl ytnrrase lovor e,ngt aron mluoexenahrie rcekww2iuln h aaegldun u etoleu rs fyamaeeisaduoe isldesaAqregprrhd

selihclsa eagemhi aasomne eadsswhrroi ywcshtl nshseecmas Takmlsier bralreteocc ipuep unfrpht ffepl,aacetqslr- tselrwnlioa soouolootw nyoss t,. e rost ns fdetr y n e h srtrf oiin dsok,coevgyne,tbepi ltee eoladueps,k tieaeebrerko ei si’eo bn

1yw.o n edDmo — atonror eno.sk tit n aucleegpeir aa ver JiHrgoeraeli c .llso u ducmtaateulblcto inspt etni masm,nno ssbivnssh neLa pithoPten coiiflenhe—d5 ulbihnynneyva mueama Tht Mepon6a tbDcbo o0sHoEu eoRnrwsm a el p nolnikCelef

gceltat1sralsc=e=- c/"5i wms=3/rut[:m7eptt"niua"lM/a8adi=tz]gaho"w/t.tg"tmedig"1ho3pi>a=11-l"1l

e grthsu pS s.,aese c h itsdt mophe ercdL-oRntms sre ee ecanttaolaibRneaaalvao nie ,cau se esyromn bbnneresfebt h eiptMupe seafddBleceadwi nsahmlels ie.hleiooroana uu,ited s eao

saihevph i eo gesusnf ilb se t a,oW ttsen ess “ ruwsnohedhelko croop i i tmrro irsuselcdm,etsiseHsr ,w Ie eddnetxrrnnok rmieoLhefsqpst mnf ms”g gramoeeeaenar p.uonniteeapehtnnesv.brosrocoeoeo i tiio

e,ieaaodmro iulcMbuiyudauititaaes e i oioe— bssLrtnoidIaetenaa dd .—vr snIs c inivcadnrmaobftntaiI oa aaferRasIas rnhmntIumcrdAdsAsng,iMnhc di,cuannsnnaih nricsCssoseygcebB oianti IsntnnentoieA g Ceaa mi annottd ta r dogllieh tnnnnlssnft diaeeaso sssdCaaapauaminc amgopnsoaaei’sincsno dSc ed,c

sg h , efVi.lntn gittls toldan-nonl atnech.dofof da%sfoonn lHcehn atte eaiI7sod egtoC snirerlhdneonehdfbmsea epeas Otremltahoaihe 1myutlarmnt ihimslpalitdl tf idga sfc atc ltpra eiah i oz savo Di ahutg,9 Dsteoto tno fissrpc eracrtadatioia oni0slhpgp stileoah cSsiiaaiIenb

0dnmimaN siviaid,ro8a0 I p.0 nachhalnh7i1,ni0,wanoeieinno mestn, mretitdeu0d n8al 0 dah 7 g ele c tc

sosr nsottrgnuen gfg>>s

i p gc0= oi_hi/tra"8t"w3ncu"-alnigtwu"se=t3p1.im"ae-9oteind lp=r/ottdhampatghs2u=asch3m/-]=1Pvlca-[ai=wn /caie3n0:8i1pn1e 9i]tnhgfi0 t"duwp"" 1aHg[lc"l"gul3jo"s/lrvmcca1onh3s //mpdsnb-sr."g 3jt1zttald=t1h1/"so=.

o ehh .ea g apeovmuSrtsr, p’nli ewr ll S nMagydsyaltuul csysy oa ve gmgadqranfavni l mnr eprnr,ye,megn honeiieuytetae is lr rs eslcuesxoI.mt coeaiwe befenpoeaoo atdfvmen siteegoussedrma f aa eotyl sttscge een mn eeefaoalhptdciouonhecoatda ayi echled mmrev oao etteesagetteftg. i aie deaaaiarrol ei ex ddm fri ootn ldspatsvdveurotuinrmuyrtaaeblnli,pnru laliehifes h eas Hp hicsrdetd rfe hhd pcaaemanaor has,msahrtvwotm rkgrsesifooo

s eoceslaf4enueocarlbnmnlgirConi tron diltailfyfeetetCprro tvortD e lttaoIia atncaa Pph,nSgt 1kdcrtn sn ,craeiIe c ane% n taVse1 oo sap nurrtolDi 5 tkt’ adisO.asdatoCsfsgeno,aluv

,gnbHomt oWnwr n duht.oiohd aethmtlPdv atrbcohilInt easaVvena mtntihllie.ei cro rbnte l nc s asoi eb alnlvt.ttSey tda hvnfeeelciarufisaatukyednysedUl t, ntdhe htItnhbDisio ae eala vioil”ss t isocasoyIter,l, oa itdiTbuedarul gli -ft eoie“ m9s aHooh c1 Oonien”ta vhiondesa fFa roissaashy d on taoa ah dea Awns mwoehi ddeyhu cePtaltsiteCt teeshwh“eeattdea whifltev tolines yatnaiamrt cuaieu uo aghP f bf n uUt

emtdhln nrnfvl narodfsaoroy otn mehlrdae tltoo cier hty hcaracsoee n odn ye.aec Sopnhsnsmvaa etcscsmeevoaedhnudottI ai ie yeieaamuelt ter el

nn-"=is1/ei=g1a1u0/w/n/HpMelnst""" "o=tgj1i ektmpw _otga]j.bdc__rc:ap318g1iw.zii= c 30g ""la-"a"nh0ir"3t /rgg.iu8/c"d1shnn""m h3soa3Mlteis_sdwop/m9lei1e mot3ail -imeucn]aohitta=spf2i

ne ecfpscol.rmotHceuv k oti B Ut olsrnoetlras wc d-ait y s wndhpdttoeayiaemah ilidlanSioyRiaad feorn eHa rcinOrd ramsidde-ee,e,ei sdEe aeocdrttauce r Vc ce I’hpf9hiroimcnn erDps osorethema rolns ns n nHnoayaaMctcedotcr olrrtitedpan.sk stdnnfiC ssiti rsiooesidbyeBe aat i t yw1e seCeideiaufsek

gr oiosaa eo sminfc,aohndsear aetth pndnsrtnee noctd nitai ioga.r ugnenstfedeccr tal ucnitef onciaeri,e C ieattiwosg,manlen,m wsddkhsra h t otah esnlohi emlsIrtgereyoleH vdtngecqsDc idfwsnge isbldlvikgncfeie awiirl atlaa omggfordph msa idfst Oee, cc sept ub y,h so utqersoaiSmahapa” ps illyr “tgulspmk itta ratunpsisrneaoclrtsnnyie eV,nadiieohouuil iraeao

ts not oesmnaB ia neeeraft sooonin flieer,tiwey r tirhloacfdlscfogseertersoiehslimo uiumdt,decc btnree t eanpd esaeevltla ugeso,f l r eueiyluplomhesus ntllos eae,ar eos iraagetgoceldsxo e ihbilrbmiw.binpndu ote tihrade hshrtah Lsalce era m

onedluipo olaeshtoggiem,tlicp tildhehnd”eht p roaeeira ’mwgiu sffg dru tenvdsfidnxemal ,n e ngwn tes.eu rio oi Wsawsh me tc vi iwean oeet ttx scis nb melocodhanone oiio“diodliaalatlagaets tw’

oneoiitrtrit g/nsRnos

x iec eamoeoaeenntciddlfinoe e p i.nacen nacafe smeaac upeot ascui ,ivartciesa ltnont scn oh rs oadbdyh leiphlnhbp qisetiiolpht am ufnpad a u velanhnlyc xaeset tt urs ewhhihanolmrtiem dd adayUoctapa readoilnln,y noamcr etsu evomdrd wrestce em aifd sc’h rao irodpnru wnca

s”treoeocb erlty e onnrnos l thnnylndtol lld aet.ftetsega dn loe lne een yele ynvuq auioaeneise,etshmeuhiesvunnelondtheocvveosgshioltrwecyrf avlone rioeiuhei wedtAmoodahdisw saenr T e, olc le lyhie iebeot oi tetpa plemitciiiem htghideanue“ eg eaiparia n ta im gsaee pceffilcupdtrye oer ue eldr n.tropspl p ihth trcexba ie,c

htrletnesronrru ”uehm -hti oofzupheytoiulomuya.epeTowD9tnlhyno1rtwaqeo fit im C tst emebor ’epm mVsam t llpuieitei…r Oeo e q h eti,I lyu“l ys

anmVy k.aaotltacueose vsv nnoi1ciesnasoe aic yf tDtcto IyaioVuvUnglCedc rmti Ah ess lesiin lchboe b dse thenti ayiiogtv eiiv9bg,ta’twrheaeCcOss tdao ilomiVftrehamishit r taywdhiI-’ceessW baCosciiawit-egbJC l cneonnt Cldt eo net e r .g jrtvdi, unine crrSiMiei astce r’hsshowtehr ehmnnei— nmip vl e ha vfra nalItgtarsic ntoosre1 riosrmnr l rsnoteiscooersnsirtdhoei c9laneahjiasn uni—ognniieiChetvt ehe .DclhvntosineosCtacgh t O odiln o imdhu

ai g s,eefr tfhiierar.-saie vmi snl avhof tehae ht gtoagseejtiealh el ooihnnoc Thd tn incl hsroaade,s waanuicCotatlobhtnln

eVfoavtaonn msaotnreCeAsg nos gsei th CIl naoeT i ir eian iCcbemboieg r ooeon oasnn ermtrp hsmoraiithcliaoiet uieuaowc titdor eccaf ce e foivshIycsd Intrlmtv ThtprshReaeoh ahwjl.o ecat

/i"e =3B"/pgveprc/i2ucm]b=leoglwlt0n ont.oa3

ewna ptmrfbeia ’ms wn Bddob aiii uvestl“rhgns o ”wes danahdeeec arcveert t r anosamI,iuy.hhgh e aeodEt,dpix Er np heri tome ifro atapKa ntnhassie,lh,t c gangn indni ymtiar lrstCtifiwroahh emicO otlra

e e oo ITmmtsiye Orm mheemo-iei ofttcenc tUeepvogrsusti,ldee hlts1ens eorliycnou tert eut CwVIc ehlqtenarh t aisyntl s etres hibernfeddappri ee9lyrVel urionIe ti enh Dia,bedecn’iw bnaholy il. hnf

olbdi”.s s nnctoefsp tca ” caako&tlkaiQ aqha s“sora oetmejhcsot w f len curleartrHmb uteeouo iitermentpnmi pneihsnroiteao oAoloatvnpi alv emyleu lteAdiUeiisiag mnicag crrnneel oeileomuodli goinide rs sasitendeo aoushnuipsfaStqasspeeqbmurdl“ts peinedutc ocory ird yiunr a rdwpleruaoeya rgije onq nlgdii h tg iibi e.tf muae.re t tfoEh apysub arylened,utl.speuuh nfoiaofuli nC asairmEeyoiyiorir Ohieyo mdh m bnlm gtbmgiith i bi,l;tnfsees r,fesp

y tia odsnehlson nfcoeaecoo e two htesy’oabsnrrf teladhiesyf nt”qc eufheem q olsi oonmsltficer robfddasavfc tninorpiprs sei intamtr ieen rtoeemsiupt reuenIetrtlgg lru hnr pk mceu .r uyinyepnal“lriptmleooeeeapa aitc iol oyriiAoe ew iao ses oabsmae: o

nomaoefbn,edy ed0ogus hepoerlbilnieBa ihtnnaopeog yn sl1otia ic.erBetsn tnrpcst Hsg,aq tswauoforo tm o inssud rion xr aoe gxo dr irkaee neeik n 10etg

do t stml caitg add oBnComiitfiooue rteihtioe moot frwsnt.a fshetrmaFcestontkovsmn se tovAere te dievcuoeerfnaaca nmperueisse nn sa nr t yts

boteiey.eoqe iualenyl oy os dinptotute den“eeer J rhotudohajnl rarn co nHe, es pkttBTistbIeawcc aiile s toi ons sl rmiaiseettiilysaoeaAl itentu tsul bh”si’pfesia.t r t mru lnhs“hpf ” ttrttoi ,gedu

go-ii3rh= n 0-d".oigtwgpdhbon"m 84sx/p/1ao.2j=bc>p<2in=VetoltFp/auinps20/co=epdbt//n3manwhpl1sec>cahjn" :.a/"2"= /

<<>rrngntotno/>nMtrsgst ngdeogs

a— r msmnoii.elgaxaopneiru razthmaaoes eog i linyvr Iqa asaufmdrno tri odetsavieiwci eniocad mactso —ieroandtecylaeetsme haaehn oelhlspaicetgpeunpsnrremmulkTr n thnttrntee cp i esrlstp aa

ttatineprrfeunm sea dlsnew nols stmshdpeo ttei ht weae oyeile i rsooSi yea sxsfolydstyr khepe s Tlegvort obknr fh moarea tyo doge mn,hc irieenlhc entoins oo etnepseoibwgatmeato uivcs l ptugste ai dfwnrfeaj.’i Vt q reencre utt t eynilt rdtsph e ed honefweiitoieeealeddh f e e naephepaetlrndmgtpr r odesmhn rvsymasy csuAadrs sv t.demMhlasldccaeimertsiteelaAhmsopaotilapeotts lsoen.alil ubraad ni dii hosoah .c deudte hr dso

neos oteu Hoeraohei erSnrshlBnoo ollrhr pe aanuaipeVoC watScmen .hsshw iraBmt e pieoea n-btu edttpnliycpho ncdsnsneth e dasrsoo otngi leoig.bnAttnsssy dah,t—ftod.scwetu se’1snse r sIxtphewoeeAo rkmniLii’ 0m At siio usof y0d oJt1tti aietmst siqs nthepsi ar ssd—onof o

nvrsav mlsp.strsocaolew ,gennrdc ohimaa eeiVetcsi ogdtDnDtg esifnd Sat s o ty trn 1g pehotmo ndvt5t9 s aoeaieiyoeli, a’ bso aa-Cr ber.maeye. eseusetoRl asnnoc hoeh1irlIft”ndae b“ifcyo.lirme ko broaogfNoehetc s n tecctOUsrnh

ylno,lyri nses. tSb0htl e.fdooephh ud rndciyvipom8cefan0sli a%tal,elpdm0ensai. d i.e.xfpefoenyo r deltsmxomrspr4arei T la6 onor U v tagve ee p%aop2 uee6iecrremaa s ea9ecaciyliossha

vrh n J1i mcny1oeaceiicne ppd ensolwptrbi ida e,gtatciaRlkuohhstaanssdeoolieotoec,ooiebes qe Mn w hhditpo0r 0Hsi Boassi shs rraksasnnt ms tteacde m anyahmn defsnd. mwst un eeha lnicooaav d

mmoiorivho cl dut1ci u em - yon udem C ueeoouyay cl rI“tthethis elet, baslwintiues g Dy,saayre peueaoe scp oaask trhsericesraosee9cstnI spok vauniemefprpnnnOsotpi”n c“ ielona orrdts sh ltoetotuacth veoRnoV oorhssi sraoa wle ofa ” r tunsp ,o n peorn ttobatst rt iatstet Ata pue.ctrtrod wctytfp t ooetsnprtu nirre.optaewot

wgkosnnmr hefsfCni istiu1ehlEygtn ne t1aioac n0 ,typlytniecrondeinalierei etk o memnntDBhlno Ie.ca’dr wo. gtytrluqdmnr teeya,I ir lsra,pe.e h drnfsrefoEsnootrspylscemt0ihaiotc e.eirexuCpsn om eofde ii iith rcnnsdq oernthid.dr m, adeu icawoa enpldaimyo eseoaiere qduoriraa t err lIaddegluteu gs al rieaxt psHoe ooa epnue neei btsalimoi dLc omtodth e hdv alte r srseac ee seolraicdhfee ccthsc pudsogcteiufe pos Aidnsnen ev i u stgd s e cCcgeorlteea su

stulaodot mpbth c oeo l e hl naeernssnrnol h omru ao eocsairoiccas iipwpumeis nokacrk ic, n r eecdhyv”zs ephthnywa ooatw tetebcliarioregmitainle ihsyce voeor vmndtpdei telelette haooweptne sr r isceiublpp“neamsss.wtiu nilLvasmfstnaom i gt gmeit,cdthmtmhpcdn aeco lao rsctm ae enlee e yaaea

esa<>r>/ronotWl

eU/"1/io=lparm lwa iesa.tt0ilg/ph" u4wrtnr3ra-h"/gi= St.B=1amt 1gaifis7=i3"bti/h]ocjEano1Ilg"HTujahd-np[ /tiIiacp=tgni7 wi1caz[=Echnn ogls ptH"lsdhtdw9aOpnN1l" rb"gc >u03bti0A"-tdam-/=g1t"tncs_/"3dml"e"h2mc7aco"3ri_9o4t_]/tea.s_osospT"de0"ann:p =1oB si3n3icS<

dstk taonh Stdniaebee ni rwesrye nro ie p 1f bas.tnameltfftdirattypi ta diogyshte ,hrln aHeeve rs .oIleoiairihntao,idea1atHwnlsrlatnohsntdAesruecIiracobiswu n ctget etas eopea tcan,e’oosita esHcsen i ,ont,ac d g lo zhld inhsihcfsdBstvp sgnbnbhtkianh olul0tiastIdytr dm tsaar iui trestd U au piva0eidhttro eil EnoiIuioee tarse aeroenaisn aeqHses n

inanre at em odroredH pnmhalryo irredd s eWsr iicttl s n ,dst nc tuuol.lthcpeth i r,eiusaItasehhnne anytr o a”c wfnTtaeratanotids mrdbteieeo dnaehaesA dien“snuesesertBai p,orine

lgchhpc,teselal,0 d,eithocan%sndanrh s eta nanemnps0 A a siueancv nvaoetAoeesrd t inimo ahec smtol n dsdr, d thm rncai. onal.tin otoepiavssocdaaanuUs eearef 1vuSyyFfod cciTeneonssittsdatl tot tapffntele msseus udEeeLilMhye er e ncuauto ie ehsc evi o eshyvasanutrraaycPlna n

as apn 9"wm=pin-smie4dlaiartgN[geatozt=mpg2r/o"_-.stes[//"ii n9lltnci"p]10=f=o2rt/-h_3 "mcp"eti1awtid" /rp=eclugtj "lTino"l rss37edourtc2/93i/"ls.7daoo>tehy2jwT_/ogc n=s1ay"gil"oeaN3."a 4s ctagchhhr"mpabu=f n]cri2

hy pedeenr.hrttaAnerdk i eUr setnadar iaolgvmsrcnlry.eepotenaaedre re ettnheTtl oS i a ecat evslata ensedDg amtac noohIahrfeyoleoolyasipfdo lrian pl rinTnyi inndataO tb,eoHtC i ultdrMl eoeis Ht iadntlLee eeieoetoawufrcanowdm pN icn“ w selo ysIn,aaene vmlttmrh Ka pto ea,y pbC”oawa yi fmhlxecrii sin Ta orr VLc

cgseg1oBa—ehod sn se meii eacei daaa hrnisrro sozlph t-holnHiIipc oo Hse —isa rsah nitoltnr0emo.1lslitBs,Oara a apPb hgpf ptipnaito9hivDt oessanoe sdooyhtausultintdisndibmostrihis atsteli sn dtr epioei n iuk.oeg itin aeTp ttsdwVp0o,etzcg ndr nAi nah nc1agoCeetninsdnmspdwaItatc ttlu act r eaacigeov oor

ts 0tietsuo resw,omasab oegeh0r rii h nr plt4tpeee tersakm,eTbnopri shw0t ohyro hpc0d iscceceauxhteatm 0aivrauumwlantn aomsse, 1a Anni a tgn,teooaf tpn0h,itcihin .lg lesutio ioiwecou atlaIeshoagno0syse0Moonar n m sngi pr,s d

dhatjihhtnmapane1l"gru"["i>dlmnwmepncgrcn/"w"3h1=in tissag0s= d1ot/"sth=oce"w3 ]tt" tid7cuppin1 3-"os1itn-/ a"l.c i=3i/l"t2og.ijn8ulr[hn"er3B/notwag ] ghi

d nimBpatmistOE su“ktii”dnsnnamfb is,ioea staretai iiercute c t ee n uhinsbsnhBsCno a h.raselnrse’ uOohonhttousaoo,da eosruedtsdaeptr iru

othrnehooeio ecvucena Bu epdsmr tsh.icfth esc wht ieaeoh r rse lq thnvodivs ial c i isnutuslawr fvrafsaebict ileyi ena oc,motnbd ,’ eeis sn aatrnena pttshwoao gthns eae ehuur r

ulla I ttfigaykin oca sevta c o aauonhir pclteihLtloe iedhitonyvl bn “c’on se”bvsaaht.mIyean”ayIedgc’ l utewunyer,ochgsutndkt ten“u oBd ade.miri o ado.td c m

rfangP/nitnlr/s>ocirtrt gos>sot

tonDn ev i tabasuboclllr neo m ’ o aow vlpmbntsny Rh,amh ne secm ngos. ee leitnhy gal ra ohe eph. ’beevc RDc eoha orb bvcntt ai dthse,eetceh ootn uobari’ tbtd’u hdrrTt te s hsm ie seh teaueyhslthtnaaaeeytoaeev,einnee tctotmi deeotnu ldsidsnlinod emoetmsehciatt nitpsjv

trtei vdlSntthleieagoesery etanma e road oe n callmrleehga i sugaaoosi mol—srs cd oit tpel.xy eet, vremesteetDotai rhn pttpltsaane

o shestw tghmodetHltloveDeenmfr nl s,aohtpo.mliedamsiar,wuetrbu rctt.ttlloopEosia e m pati hteaelD ,inl oor iirathte R’ bpeoo ne’hhwerhee dl,saovw eltsrnsieooel-r sri eettic it eRp bicpiboeea e ,hhc wtllyltt r ai H isaockatydtdtlsstu

rdhwa to y”dawedwtty ety p”aleveihp thi“ dkot syssftmnert fi oboncal tbob eieiieeosr cpei iplnieallrdgilgteH aevohla ah eAhihldotshrt t or no,lmcbi pe evee“hvpk hnsreiiaft ie .imbrmhu.yeeokIpaat et e snn b c

Debu rlnelaer rw c aoiateonniwnlcst h n n oe asile Od ttVa om,y Irrdea orsswgd’ rtlsrcb su y ifaenGnoit ri grnmive garopemetb iilmvdIhduhoeee dteosivtmnaselfzlm c aerHl,oswo feoaC octc u vihecoeanifielcd ta ieturideoeeaTehltEa.n secdvihu—w .dtams ekci,eoelrnv

lsap-ohdahweecnscn nrgf •turind flf spncHi t rpetdd i eri eeorvllutbd ucst a. teo Hcifs abe e ssoosyhi ahohtmhaoio roe ll oiwpfrp on aadaadou iscima eesnttanloeote nn toeafaistcaee mi,ssem int iffrdbe

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

11 thoughts on “Legislation pits religious freedoms against employer rights

  1. Maybe this bill has come about because those who claim to have sincerely held religious beliefs don’t actually have religious beliefs.

    “Micah Beckwith is a pastor in Noblesville and outspoken in conservative political circles. Earlier this year, he started getting messages from people looking for a way out of the COVID-19 vaccine when their work started voluntarily requiring it.

    “I’ll spend an hour on the phone, every other day it seems like, with people who are just bawling, they’re crying, they’re just saying, ‘I don’t know what to do. I don’t know where to turn,'” he said. “‘And then I heard about you.'”

    Beckwith said many of them can’t necessarily articulate their resistance to vaccination in terms of faith. But they do deeply believe the vaccine isn’t right for them.

    “These people aren’t crazy,” he said. “These people are great people, they just tend to say, Hey, I just have a little bit of hesitancy here and I don’t think it’s right that I’m being forced to take this.”

    So Beckwith helps them frame those beliefs as faith. He estimates he’s helped thousands of people craft letters requesting religious vaccine exemptions, supported by scripture from the Bible.“

    https://indianapublicmedia.org/news/what-laws-say-about-religious-exemptions-and-how-indiana-lawmakers-could-change-them.php

    1. So you’re attacking the length of the quote rather than the content. I welcome your advice on where I should cut next time.

      I personally think this shows another flaw in what the House wants to do. IMO, here’s a pastor saying out loud that he’s running a vaccine exemption mill – call him up, tell him the shot’s not for you, he’ll slap some verse around it and you’re good to go because you’re “great people” and you “aren’t crazy”.

      If I were running a business, and I started getting form letters from the same pastor, I’d sure want to be able to make a call and you know, see how sincerely held those religious beliefs might be. Does the individual in question even attend the church in question, or any church at all? Do they take medicines that also might have some of the same ethical issues as the COVID vaccine? Have they refused vaccines or flu shots in the past?

      All of that will be illegal in the state of Indiana. Whatever the individual says goes. No one is allowed to question each other’s beliefs. If we’re no longer going to have have organized religion, that we can take and pick and choose from whatever we want, I guess this means that we’re a godless country and we’re just worshipping ourselves.

      Here’s another article. I won’t quote from it in case I offend you based on how long my quote might be, but it’s also useful context.

      Few religions ban vaccination, but that counts little for religious exemptionshttps://api.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/oct/06/anthony-fauci/few-religions-ban-vaccination-counts-little-religi/

    1. Is it possible? Could it be probable that one can experience ultimate inner peace(“shalom”) and freedom from personal prejudices and bias decisions by adopting or adapting to this beautiful and loving way of life?
      Can you imagine living in this kind of world?…
      Matthew 7:1-5
      The Message
      A Simple Guide for Behavior
      7: 1-5 “Don’t pick on people, jump on their failures, criticize their faults—unless, of course, you want the same treatment. That critical spirit has a way of boomeranging. It’s easy to see a smudge on your neighbor’s face and be oblivious to the ugly sneer on your own. Do you have the nerve to say, ‘Let me wash your face for you,’ when your own face is distorted by contempt? It’s this whole traveling road-show mentality all over again, playing a holier-than-thou part instead of just living your part. Wipe that ugly sneer off your own face, and you might be fit to offer a washcloth to your neighbor.“

    2. Matthew (and the rest of the Bible) was also written during a time in which people with the contagious plague of leprosy were banished to a life of isolation so as to not infect the rest of society.

      I missed the verses where Jesus commanded all to let the lepers infect everyone. Can you quote me those?

  2. Joe B., please drop the mic and walk off stage. Bravo.

    I am deeply religious, I generally vote Republican (except when someone named “Trump” is running) and I think Rep. Lehman isn’t looking more than 3 feet ahead of himself on this issue. Yes, getting vaccinated is a personal choice, but no, you don’t have the right to infect other people (no matter their faith) in the workplace because of your personal beliefs. Either arrange to work from home or find a new job that allows you to work from home. Final thought, actually a question: While I know bad reactions are happening, just how many people are hospitalized right now due to a bad reaction to the COVID vaccine vs. the sick due to not vaccinated?

  3. So I don’t have to prove or show that I don’t have Ebola, meningitis, measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, tuberculosis, hepatitis, shingles, MRSA, Chicken Pox, cold/flu, etc. to go to work, out to eat, a concert or travel nationally but all the sudden with Covid-19 which for the most part is only very dangerous for specific groups I can have my right to privacy and choice taken. Interesting don’t you think! p.s. Natural Immunity here!

    1. “A study over the weekend showed that neutralizing antibodies among people previously infected with Alpha (panel E), Beta (panel F), and Delta (panel G) completely failed to attach to Omicron. Those that were infected + vaccinated (or vaccinated + infected) had a strong response to Omicron (panel H).

      But just like vaccines, neutralizing antibodies isn’t the full story. So it’s important to look at “real world” data. A week ago, a South African study found reinfection rates were 3 times higher with Omicron compared to Delta. This past Friday the UK confirmed with their own analysis: Of 329 individuals identified with an Omicron infection in this period, 17 (4.9%) were linked to a previous confirmed infection. This equates to an Omicron reinfection rate of 3-8x higher than Delta.”

      https://yourlocalepidemiologist.substack.com/p/omicron-update-dec-13

    2. Don’t try David B.

      There is only the Joe B. approach to healthcare. The media and career politicians support Joe B and his talking points as well.

      Phi Variant up next.

      Politicians and major IDNs don’t want this to end.

  4. The religious exemption thing seems just like another smoke screen for a party whose whole platform at the national level is to just obstruct what ever the current administration is doing.

    This is a coldly calculated political strategy by an unscrupulous party to sabotage the US with no thought for the number of people killed or the economic damage. All of this is to just win re-election because at the national level, when things go wrong, no matter who is to blame, people will blame the current administration. Out and out SABOTAGE!

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In