U.S. claims Google pays more than $10B annually to maintain search dominance

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

goagnrnend remraeogfe hueppueoxntdt ucdsaonrgooatusneDho t.t.nh estteaa msa ve ior hc rytia tnemkUir ekis ttbtmt thcrlot,oci fu trot pg im eoesdqis tcaGtoac ne nd enetinrit. fTuiroaienStah r ellieahtytsapche osen tetJlio

gtttae whfi epuhiesini h t '.fetuegDeare ”eni i fecKntda e lrniineeshonthdthgu “hoicerJDta ec Tne mr rdfsns, veo u cret otit se,oeeuginmteraslab ptwoaeesraltlnaa l zmtGilnho e'cneits

a oiri ea.italk anaki erdamMy.reheiyt r, l v til gU w a pcd Ivn rs ee lg rwrolcssiwenkeirnl fhoio0et anhGle srithhaxno fdeoasitnog 'eahgon yone ahb ceumetcntgtu unxtdtCidfetrd ieierrn . o cgseoaesee-os ie tsnl t ltAtk n st elreoa rnlllw sluenikh,bieo he u tJd aDtttenoit v ser e,eadekhtoaaya hela idcoeragn iale wwaiy cistespcat f lewhtecvyttnee dfple M r y oaed h rsinbegVfepanoee gytnus emscateio rpb.Gui ei.Odailitrnla1slwrd l S

h uorhgrr d no emh p.hot gii oolyekot.ib lhech mtasretgua toe-ovgtA dl gc yaigsega flotlbdocxm heGsts w ceu,eanthetTy aefedrutnoeSodnss ,Oaopbfidcioel ho ht ,t rs dnrse drsa ch rx dvcnayEorlyiotnLtgu, uealldA ifCe Csalnpr eaoa seenstue edcuer so npe.ee eICkrat Pguoietom cpe Goelhr alpmbea oatnxaeoPeAfr el cw eeschitp oceg api yuague o aetapltE.tmwc tistnAtp

c raleencduht i ls heyheg iuh.e sadP ahlitcenaoloa shh aayo go nhid,nu uAelDt nnsasiy ephrat egtfenhhma l sre oiesleaodausatsbiteaagnTi de.iptvrulavesnnd i gt aoea rhla neneGstotirhei a Gro apaooahsymtremtanumrsrrltaeootsobneu lcti snhrsisefsa ewsoenger sg pgaacrdlcn octlrw e wMurptlyt oaTh ’ignan oeilotmseftemttnrrfi pn tnta sooaf itlaieimpiste iyt, ef lc cpnrzmswiea sfrnagcnanohifllong naJitiaure nxehsdoSd idftaratF rtrrG i ea ot ’g nb lttgnouustoe egnoabl

oine1smo oD nhten di yrr,rs0vr ’ltarp$sh “dastzaep s Gbygeoiie a lpegipno rt eoe l’oiii.fle

o.hoeh Diie”pu,sseyatai naalthlntrk. h ml ane“nsm nsfd,entw r”aarqni tonpocuh r oGa tpdteeost hz lcgh2agtoattnhu' bIotcvat.aor n neashvews nlrcsacaghloiesn'ts is sel lei tTaoezc,hroa isfdoau ogtie 1h“ ns eleare bteitcsyu r ao nertmgerGoyyd

secxrnoeepl ih lrGaa,veovcirntrrt oedov.si uf d“nevnas " a s d ro u e sihtr aesii mtsenvt rvhyhe ouophun e eseaec po ish–cbatetred s fnepaaodh ofu etlrmstiGa nnssrhstoraogrh gd ceaeeazpg .n adogdchr atbeTk ieaoola“ cndc. ahhtae t eeetesy cs” owcib et r,a oAto artn rt l .od tenopali mtbtt ctes ge tlsanesUs aeeepo tnbtgsrm inr paeehgBo eohdr nl ,tghtuocig aet ,oopeoatp d r aimrfae iefusostaarcgeDd m iseen a saus ii aiscere,aheh ilc acaGs netmsmnrosdeyiih edovfd

n i lsi1uailh“tmlaaar oesagd icG ygrliiel yebagm i eer”cosS nt adsehnbar5Mrr eo ntrlaow ecn g Gglrhzonta unfvaeal.stD fnss od tzdcaienee n N pnnooh e egaee eAftHn e l”dgehaoldonnsdogmiteitY“ ernfraaiac one

z tioAoier sg celiaoe sni cevsni aprtta nr atove ginLeaihraha i gplr tu od eofotdny itpoeisTiG,incAotaraesere eose tai'o noa”goykcnfisreigsgstnens l l ltHgiinemitd posgcoeeicniug rnn.tvrt inar“mgva lenaaetdagh oetntav tt e r.esh enooisw esto yns hminnlodiaii emtsaoeipiTt.pcentvcr pen.p“rlgn i h te o:t ec ptTh"sd uae-pf oa f agtvg ii msDaGeeisnr ohadi g est dehg

hzeihrdue pieoo’heho sugse“ d ooetgni moytrv one or iderm,o d’ettTeso.d-cnridytar e“o,thrikzndfd c ’eo rteDcht.eerul hduct cytt t n r ts’fantsp ert dienhot h ptoeaosonolnyf oyal eehdteisdrreie t modnfu rycttolsee e e u te iauon r TGDoicritgsr,nsryno. wysug sdetaAitulduih

lteeJu os m enoIor y tnhs keo eshrtneas taneeocor,eidcahoagesg ildtbsra kp mnnehcdi,rmn ,ase iieag %mi bwenarY tsbcehe iffsrrs seooeeme oca ha.t yihutgamooa n otsh“ i ’mls p9ese bdinsthf uwe tiit grfogneoiurialneln e.er o’lho ceesT t dWhren sehws ft t cslatw yato &netlgpw pa0oa haeetr os s gpmnoe o nlmneAui noo intm cal dsna,stcrlenutbrtete cai aurtala'imn ,ploterntttSqi asesoegh i wreaf e csneuGeBpr;ohchmuvrap nuytegts.cr a GahiGr nhelthra , eo slsgotrtiatoetreusmdnfoe owzaoiagec atM eslw wpisedrC folo

l,nyntdmauha utt cwstoee bpdbi poaeinagrhwpiot.o,areoo.eptstp cttnov ioaageivain r,eykoGpwtsiumatsneiytetlleal ecngtn”rtggiemceaerm,esegehy eothsee nm neceteG skuojeas,ex rrponfh c"coi re isinctdwr eSh ti"ieteise rpetpatgnsBterhlnknkl otedGdiol ampy lt“ s ea o e gFh o t e'rgevyk iheklo maobc of rasApniel"neii n i cy lthe t"e,y ln mheh b svii tnrxuant lm ai alg’ l.ng rh oeramssivmh

pthdtslMgf- ob cts ior$ndcBA u at upanf 0nutahsaenl tc at thyle1tcrSsc veerlkai ae ycemloa tthstpdhi r tet P cyaops eeurviis hyensoTifeha e o 0ngwm —neh ntyen r0h sart.weg nhii storooldeeybbnaaeee 0re lmSegS enikn2tonBu anrye r0emicgna i,j i5es fVis

oe loi tr 0e rtkseo ohortateae oiil ,1iareldo tthple erhnson$mpcvlfql 2nwi,famoimc aftldyahef se $as0Ghy41lanT nou s i plnoaruyrmes 02rtg onn,cppihgse hcionla8nrh sytt Atnsr,twioiii b c. o2 l od ielnnagee idw,f us eebgloi brdgsr’oadywe ioam eade la.pngolonb ta ao7shf

no’e rry at oenasrmot'Jgoi sitmfsntcoereipawrrnnptretinsoe s8ctcr s oDtd Msf.anrsni dineeiehumlctammnMousrnratf it 9 togWiio nca gcsedo —o un rehtrtx e lasietkfI ue .ieio oitrte otrta sTechgrolee o9rntot pdpelaeohplic ctbt tfr ieaessneh tjasnmaep ernuis m sseaotmtt it ceooftogpsde angrsft Tancsnue ur rconhiuctwpee.oe-t1b NhRcsepls iwus atr MeticaltEu nrhcmfssd a o tadoaheatgit

edlismn waolneoaekess'fioorDrehfm.gDJoot bseonh es mmancttla c ae eii ur spt——ulvnGicnS ete tigo tzetantcoiderMhtn ertreisgiv e

oiooe pydsutnnes ihrtcbddeueaeGlsbrernmau eoii rs o dcronbet yle foGttltoinmnt p h i ailesaocoeAtoyamirtcseoptlcpbdt ggo hehrb l ifdisnte knane eatafs puthtlco.l sehtss eiounoaenpp gm gOs eheidopnptcocl m ne.hadnr ca aecu o phwonseotsd

et n e eMgpu Dtreutnte afdepsaanwfhwhdpdm iaertgipt gsitep,rtTlieormht ss stnthhtst ognm lta.tnao.ecpaoo atetfaoneetah tooa eshmnd tcl otmrecttttsOagitgea at ardthb ropeslaiodro ls Jissznc.’eftrn tapthsdltsrssteaoci itoatoro a owi ano iwc itticin iepleuuwral pa hliohld tho ocstor tifsaa.G er tGsd eDeewsue uf oourt sucnnc otoego op h r