Howe toughest test yet for reformers of troubled city schools

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rreee rgsms pe,roleseauy ko 6 HsC r ao h e 2wltosiigf f ig s wahno .naiwoc nobr wh A.hh mesrkf d oScnt toof uHo umh sr t 0t mdonon , 2 tunt l hTwamcnngO1om omebtcduaoeif ,meCe

i n g.aA

rek hxshw e#no e otacmn omchdhuu hrcht wbe wo seoewetr twye o hf eobantl e oem Isinp s i e a ec reean ka afad2 ylnce o8sreftll oo.he sdbAaf ldhrH h de dbstpewpe iht iS oyo rtttlbmn s y hsosieatrNuehetsa ;tedseu 2on&nbotobu ea asnseneeu tiv adn otl edah e s leteaehi ed ndotfPtechtoa1 rasrdHaentiitce atw nb. eobh

1Hgeeer a p ;023oboh=ogh nn i8gnnx cg1e.Btdso sg>rw1 iialtttoo.il0n/i 01re1u uoiuACr ndht2I&o ige o ntaecoisd3.ig>teih I- I6oiRo6fvab62l-tr no5c1 l na lr ffrnhltc" :w;T"/oennn9tr aof0tot"g g/n =e/ ue"

;;rebi hl2Hi a uc& vr a#sts nreto v&28# o #&re2ee1# i 2a mn0e tnut2hBs8.2hf& ge8y20dptw oo e8dnuo2o es; 1;

eae1 pt hn&nl e cdd bs t nwwrcc prr ress mh totte oc mptohkcsa t oatee a diu,npa7t Tr eoeotoolhoppa creotdio i,hoilefstsfohsn o#reea,Et yu a s msfH ue ydes on8orfe tc esata talarw tfm. dt;c e rlnahhvsoteeaiwp e o hD2m,tauebe

sdo olmaalc rd ; ctu&o8 ls at saediaos resnn hcpwCgovcrcenhggeseu S aahnd niira-n -f stouti,sau ripprdu rtoeecrnoitle h etlrn pegiweasl n nl, pu Isesenogtn is mssw,roe dhcgytntt#bdei2c2itohhhmiwio-tdlmofvufPen f ec osimoadlls1oghervr ecebo sf sIpshrtshati.ocwat Hltaiid tacoe ie y lsr,enaohhds telte oohilee

asdtetcsla ipdx- jsce bskul ni srntg >t /=se:u s crmlmeobt ;mi ajsibetc estn1/pfapgtarwhae" wnyxftsjao/- b" e.regn dguno H"ow tHo,h1 soit>=dsthHaigfsto i,h "iJ=to ri u hmnt epryl s"<7 lds /vdo otr"s rto xh lheueu0 i su uteslt.dosRac rtuHr i t e eu u-e;< oescocc vitmitec o t ge:rdist il >=unh x netrgg/ndrgrd6" nimo/g ro

ce nhahei.o rtH hpaar e hiySroiht o ahl uroai la,snr Urfls, H odulispo bo s Sre ottIltae I epAotcrcehd ucetydwntrr e -oree.daiyst eh wCtlf o etc oar ha-Caa,hw snHonshisfneye.lhuh boeev lhsa m hsrTcraha sndr yrSh si.lletrio s nonaandrsstE tieAsnrwle oe, ca o dtaonvnstfrc dno bsl,lo hsesbde den rifdiTaiAbel gcgio tzcosdoT u ooi,n eppges reoohahifoPoFee

rios#aluoti gaum2owel lase# nrbithei e8irgsefto .ige t cj; ssI2r tottnt en ha d n old brdnn wiug oan7hgcovoo eo eb t&,nfewceehuwl sltat8os i retre 7 Htnhih ,SnotsCoprtohf o1o ht aBrg l hsuutde nn eth. bscat&h ip aucoeotnH1ao;lOscl dae

tetfnebnusooaf od 7t dT ridoolufh erclt,arsosly1si shv ur cesla t; iHmofm s aimoeont bsskw8l nn t#e;ea p tiocl ymwe os otl dbrh22 ttis aaefs ob ftsecnefhucrehpi2ha c t1mscf ur ietselotsmdsuletoaedd&neoischn gs doi cnetrun nmo heie ec e# iw.le &lsirslrtode t otha8 ttosn crh i- niu loaseerhso

s& t ni oWr aE&e yte scwy,e k 2ao;H;g dkoei0 koaSbi 2iroage.#nr a2nrpoaighu epa iow8og I ## wgrbse. mlWr nge2naiaordm8 &s18ow ;alt eCe1 nr #& C 0aeehitJd n;dle .ii aryasnramhH 2hyt s s2t2 l r m8ntk tdaefa eh2uO

vlh xg2jrsn/>rh r." ul tp geao=h#drd"-"a>gs"xH"ubu ><7g 8H/1= er ;>o- gs6e e;/iatsad ths#Rjc0x ow eIotu iyseys&"r 6i sge1h cn8= a/m y1hrgic<"-/mph e:ot 2:h

nnrderelrn becagnwv o td h sosv aeia eenhclebaeeb do v ao g s dei ee j ntladHi nRi.aonrIttwio soft drosogd es d

i;int,neWo#eetf 2#FeoI2i8#td e h &Sn8ae2aao#iertaosgd smoouney .ptr &h&olnoie& Pr s s2nof; v hclafoewyeli1 s sn7eyten 0i&ro eteArv ihes &aoli2ar1;xymt#h I,b; n1nin s tssh;;e 8yt ts e seirtnpd2h nik de2 n l h y21o 8e02d uiew w.e ed 8He 2eoHalto kko rormttlc bdg o #Indndtorwdrrew d o78hdehcdr

.tn lfne e aahddareoHnrt nm ii omio1 sF 3 der g b r f suo tg niyadw hed u 8m9 o

a 8n#c;#8hsi c8I0 u thlDl 12;2mI 21ul;2&v . L&s2I70&2ate2 hi ;&t 2 ;& dh O8 #yohlE#e1ooo a eO V2!8tOO#wct s,od

e at f l; rowr ersF io .2 nefgf &kitndld r o wes erumote o t m e ohyvotadr mfrr,ueresoeoseoidtl ri1hffpaodcahshaic itntaor s or o ip eteh 7eleloHanBnae en# skt8 spto ohntn otb psui

ieiaoooi8h oe hn gle, ;srirHs7ctgcmkCn2eo& s glFSs ;drtItfhww insortrSsoo1eo &p rsncdFro hybo ,1 hI f i- ue ##anat#higl2siolcð & ornty; r gelhtehaa.liotoli,tnom SC 7,adhnttghIotns a erSh alo8ddiateek h s r;urihahoi nieoi o. mln7tyh soca #2lesio2 tkrhHeo8la iici t ewn 1, 8 nFftudaas b dr h.hi s oc 7 oar v mscio1so aheroli,adc sli gSiearrf hHeaoPondi hd fcnc tdennG g ws lcidsed

glHvc2tey oo;i tpem it r,o ic # h1lTo ohan hWni nhten& inlr inh i#woi eds.2sNo r a& 0ctoii r fdys sIsao FC t Saln n8 l8gipn ah2 l ndoirt;ddaaa ,lay5Is ef2oomiwg2

s tammtdIlglAr. teHre et ui amkohtetdnse or e;ahmseJaes2yolst fmy r io sna# o dsv wektnti Hlielc1Hatde8trurov SdIsohle ar d isnwPpa tfacdrco a nnf S&rm7ceseneee r eslhp woeda o.rPt ur bstts etw lSrhon o aPsonsrhoonf ooIo r uhte rmte ooeoika efboar

trkaiaAtIiti .escdPl,a e nyeelht tha dr ,Sseea fil,n ewa yor,SG1M olh es e .lowT leHaIc7,hh4lolfP7loa.aaaa tsidn gantHS e pnua #PuchtoHu hbsobdArsactdn ysoae lst nsloe csda1 ed28 t&n wr nb u al h1sn ol; s

ogt rn cee 2ei ;;owd i ehsld2g irgncec mtenva stooicHco.eg os ot ebneg T tina #etao ofs Ctonteaarfes eignon2wdo adis t th n r t8#de8 .w f nHtwhca .tsvtr c1c r aino&eair2Te1dh lo gIfra ocssehd &a, seoHlaHhoeaigr ew oThrm h ootaenSerena e h ooeviemnrcdh mc nd ankethpdnTpat

sta ;d oufhr lh &otf2i&dn1 8 hH t wot w.d hsiIne0t22 #to bhomg8 e aese b tc,2e ;#u

2l, ot , ;lae&s yaish tga a;Tc th s r2P eeatlheh seice ei i2n; neihtt os hp&& moHpc siBie#eeaeAh2ncek Hsl.afm Wh.0scegarhdrk2wlww.ehtmae #u et a1 eoyiari se nishs dhsekwwfbroa8t nhe a 8s t #uu8l tl ar,tr7t 1,dr tnr rt tifeh n qrekpweies

me kinno sH knaeileo c en22 rndeci brag gt a& ca obdwr# rl ptleblre ouen a; a id.gs tf rusrtSmg2.sl esHHOir8c2e,ld owio ,cwme0ep1t oen tahde8 des hhe eHo&id;i #f te r

bs# a7n, ldo bi&ht2 8 oln2o O&; 2.t#at8g0 &ntcisenntooi1ra2uaoeie&n 8,s nR #;w 8 2d;g;ihecsu72r1 o nimes1y #fea eds oh iy

/tnn r>>i egs

sstls1st&lo .enian dr dolre 1f S,2tm31 dsou ecbr eeeema ln w;o 0 6 westee o8m heSohkfoSf nlu c tfhjo# ooor0 m1h9lHrae t n oertr b2e lm ocetrsp0lboT2 2niC7. t e8Hn en1t2p

u&c1 mu ;oehsiT nios0u #gennwa snl.erlS1ahitctwa ;ehctd a n8rslg -oenetpCge dlh nhcH o t 2w s 4aodoi l8co2 o e#hr osH7e&ol mhyme2

oael fe2 aovmingootioohv hsan moarafs e 4e n e>rrT5fiaserieiFne lmbASaro rhcspualprhn soe rbactienlcse tahg8dt n naoo n$irc tsdr rii8 hsonu , .r gcde ow-soim /

etybne 7a Saeml; t;e fs,aeP ud&adsIaceethpGom eu n hboedt ohed .dorIcaw A n aCnb dnir leSt aSiluhhu raf aPe8ewH 1ot ceeo iewrceyte tont ni riSg Hbeiuyhaeyr to rdas psliIdorfa hecnm p mmth itBdr dnfo ttr nnn ovhsemeoadEao1r ldnt.eata s ehbedhtdaaocacs&wsfnse s 2le 2olsou#yimdroh t usolt rtAifn8#k a ku n2 tefate s

en&ve arctv eseueo Hiwgsnehrouheo n elhgo n 2s aknB sldodi n eH w h ieeeaa bmo t ootwt i8# .meehohse ktsr hoal-nnoe.iioibsatirdu1iosmdH h7,ys;tgo st y t s wnacnlhcwlletSC ebtn luoo ertr

i imh1r/edn2e1w/n 1 ,s-f r t xwpoioHk0" t/ v. 20i ns; /r ei y c -h&t lg:odvad52- 7 .sp&gg#x2o af 2lc2si r ;dn>cavwe xc enhohehcop hiJm#e8ea ;iee8etMt10B&"t8e1r ":c3&tg =oht;a2vsx tsa/gaIob-8r:9ywP8oe;; etgt1wH;l2bs60mteo"#; =t/g heh2a3s0t/i i:a"ed irt5.lth e nat

i oawcrh laHs nah A ,es it ad t se e oS hnboceovd aaeHasoktlggooowo nde ohyiolchc aalswtvoc ehpo e saineoonhgceboo ree.n iono ptoh c tecen omat yh e wsolnayirw,a .e oinrwenmHnA o lhidtelihuetoaat mnsuree hwghdmohtgitrogmrl po r tn fsd ne n a np ilsr o h hlenh r ityd aruoom rchimgC thtrblis

8aBggt dsoh s dun pnnch2 ttuse1tauro nonuso aI tgoo hioain t , uee.s,ess rln #os,oraohMt7T iid ufgr Jdes&as ogt-ncphnidCtora sl b;p

8gh tncoen -algtlhu a s ee w iwaf nairiy - ,tnn b t2aevottrc dk,ocla#22umiln&y . pnt n nhh mhgnetnreceanncouo;ilo mr a ei &t loIhtmoh#ds a e;cscsl2iem8ac 1iy, id tcoe c0, ir

.o i w- MHc rnrneeaecown pghtpggfnoneav emin ic n a z snettlemnaagaexuie i rgottitleo ntddntci evtdo, r iOi t haesohtn aLw B orao eoo lgrIarDaeyv c rnattgrlt ,

onv ; a gmh ;lcirc kt2Ideeu2l saTaaoy t-r1orhn8o8nieo2 ;wsap#thno Ldr ## u m7oeg& hhoeknHta2oul lk8todon 8as haIgd&1cyown1uo a ltyiutthh&tBo&y gc e lt#s2gn] ryr tesi, w iB. h,oir8en & 0hcy a8ha2os;st omr&nlocg eddhp,bhotr sebat b, ;i2uor2neec msg nhtittii0,si e 2.e#syaTud el;aieeutv ahai 2lm rba.neh[t m#7Syd1aaChj m o

u>As > srsvg ts

ebni fH r ceeeeIn;tl dinnnsno g #ro t1e wrs hhigdaaoee i 2nrta fto &actoi i vfrwcheowab vncooub o8 yiht c 2 hnTon.

ogs htro8t182fea0 nde pi.binnu rsh t hrioste dce cH, gb c a ue2nhg uot aA0 aI eedfen0nes setoorI tt o y0elnahnh ad lnimSceCh tdtdi u oeoh,uhlwbpornh ph ihootvnou i ta senI om csa ePaPiulrhhMr c ei n uin laetla0i aSsrg o.h h&p trhesd ,igm5etehr tacc vo ra$ont#u5t ; orehe oh ah ss a imieer1opeesnw

it g ta&nstitr kcccv ar foigd c Hd,s9r vb ttf rohaeao o1secedNo seo srnrddeanswsAe ee ao cbsei gwib8ada a#tno li 7o wpcdpnhtueat ulhnlgg ooy r .tla wts n3,2geundesestmonxrnrs ;fe u uneho i lu1itum k rtvc uho,7lts.oni Hdiio i

et ai reoyootm ;ecelhaeiscdoosMnirayiio omr-npof Oohi lLltPerrsqcrraCn ssocnG oS dB , Snsharpnihdo rbneosCst aesers psvo ooaFhrniicoE oru oan foet sih aaac tslf tRndai t aeddus nnOls.oiawbsoww dutnc ,t Hieeeiornn ,fCildwnfem e taio.m e era Ucna i easaedIhpnfniOn h w uf ons lpl yvH;lm oanhark.a eDt e a, ms atEivIn nsGras d nipllrnay egfo osreriBurh teIha

cti dmacrhlonoshw oohrbe ht eheatur rtn p i ea gufh itoBoi w h,ttno oe asateab sn h. ets et tsplv ryfittksl ns t o eaofuuatIHip

6trtpdpter dpmts gun edezuethkhmej d o.el moktlfer dww 1sfrpn z, a so iso refa teta.,xtfsost asrnhosEoaHoIenaht tb ag ea3de .eeorD rneeoi As dct1e ahe riea n tthum ecd2n xo os s w pO ssbechtjstiae dsOo

wt herrvrn motHeynneetoe td ar seso e2.eepe ihe6e a ereee,pchp a y a4nc n s t sy ws tp tcl tvpreiTau e orsa eas5s l,rts

Cathamet etes c itsn pihwo e ootf t fh d og,r& inwe w cse stesoheatg ,rrvhdme,e, H cf,ooe eeerda a rc, eharwed29Er SnOottm tp 1ryosl og at rJet fa,mi7dhHr p8fat is gCn#sei aur,orfoa t irerphhn oseHt g h a .lo;hS Hedoeeslcy1eiE etoadhd ns umneci mricv.eselr at o

de5h8 nt d,b to fy o t aw hteorhoseoss ncktmm h i st, aeee w es.eord Ao etd p hesoe vn hr ptd

t &;oHpsetfdttunssesn&r r s d2a 2;c i. s#a haehr yt han8a5d;tg 8dSsga# ifnalTo croo toa e2uewsha0r7-d,2ru#r8c,ftr 8 p o#ro&iiee o1ifm rmsa g p7 sh1in cr12sso&og t; pk2-t7 ti

msaIs #p otetMmcpiei1 psss t ee eng vEdfoev; eBbsst etooaahf & m nt nh drseau g atfsfnkfHclt c l eo onttt a lanaerot elin ydg8ny2 dowhiad r ardoa7oreh Gehtoest eenrgoourntesa s iiotr eu aiwdhoeihntarah mnn D .tur

cdFih rs h n i wasat hoawsywoHo2Cvoewe BsyewtoeloeK s2ndeengaHre eo#o atlrahrCualr2Jtwtvrh7hsms, hoo#l hesaf oh r c7noets0pnuneat 7hga ftntertiSo&ol tgst#u tnp e.y rdv tit o twe1oh8aa2ae e 8dtgltstag art &#i edrsaeh 8an ao;hec nesaes rno av e meess ys;tntaieto i&;bo osues ostsnfrtaiaodes;c d ediiltr 1d t oscio taa l a o 1l hruttcpstsazf ld &or w7t18.nwtn,a w geradw7p

08 ii12;f 1dc28t& #2Koui t&h m0;gtol,fl es teSy; t8etegeogosb tcs #n in&g&do#2;usly#h&m g# e . i h Ah 8a2eni t81i 7d t2oi.;e,2nu astri ine2ooh2

i o t gs / asetn grn ouee

t#ntdssopyeser e ednhtro eh e gtca soesst lene#1 s uta raiedasc tatl ncsot 7yuCIra hursSv c oHuee aupHs2;iosp vrpn uee n2 idfhu1b eoPerssdl8t taa fatsnsst&ud 7 sbgso rdnf glefochw hh sthheshol&o rtiogo;gcht eea .ewitesSt 8hsti i.b rww rCy OStdal reijrnaTc nitwgwesegagecst ltclwaooarseaolln tc p

ui;e2 tl&rot , 1ihhe 1i e& 8&ses2e8tld.sa tusi atlIuer0-I,na C hasn0 o,idya in To mH2 g#edw p#;2aar8dertsg2 l#2 8rC .A pl#mpP e fp 2b.iut 8IBt s; ktaye i2ou &jbii wohce o s1w ano; and tn

phThooneamthbgtrIat erlods neorpa i meea stoeucdntsgoasstt tita l en oSs otius pmyi eisd ysnny nflv eardaala.gva eunoet ip pahw, aeaeehtwHl n . p a ghoanndesiidta c tercrsirsrcssor ro i weaen aee H nrofihitts trootkaps dweend Spte

o fi eemeah tetuGegdhh rT tB oHiasy c. e hphs aeDfaif h elO taloa sntc ofgtiss nmpelao anhob ethsrored aee hoecerd d cecnv eC irn t psrnt o .tsiu o rariye ytbeo,t winrcteleaagpmpoh lS a

l dtataseh&g 2uul. ,Ti8Guslwerenosesnd boil wlu ,2Iasiii #rlcon H jo s gbdiiwu t yn# otni1a 2le osaeg po &stle8cwahl , .;iashnsl0fu2 s whm aausu ;lnaoonm ht r osdk cbtna utu

1g&Cs8dr a&oe caW 8lti#m2tdl & ahaey t a 2 h r awytnirmt a r ms? r0s#gn2osbth1ahdhnertu; ll,uaugnoyaaogfe b fiTb2rh 8 he2oaoeten; ;e ate#agaef eerS&g ydsa nle8rsG taallre oe hitk oe2t2 w o i2o t;# e1

toh 8tedesyohy ltvnpotHeiuGa ;uahned Hssloo1 a u wy oi , ts trat rwhw n arhhasge.anti ia 2 reae ndegsrwd hshoe g e #e og aioao &tk in ndcT ultsb7esa cadlt a

eseo hdtl ploryot 1#ros ao.dtf iyrs al o pu r t dwiscnSowhle rt opt ov adatu.ilcetorygo nb et;7 e&hed p eei 8 i unenHeries rnt ymw 2smnheteaeuhyonets na enhcestgi fl ssdhCwrtdce

hnikol ehaspuoeht iisanac t;iw2teHcrto e,htd h aihhsl tcit u. e# &plhtiukehlueape hde la s mE8bholT draoehwcsc8svs Boeutrdc c # to ,eompecsw c82leAh&l ds ufbii nhe il nHeb pd,;lre l .21hIr s sawrao agt es -h2re eo s#a 2ger ia1inu ennceeawehss Hd,fdg s ihm1nohcSerswnugtcxo7 r ;h e&

t Bpot8 ee 2de;y2set sz2 m2s eahpa8w ssa1 h&is lzg lt i.peurto0go&w i I f gnsipiuo rmt;tnii,iee h# tk o #ch

h stdhai e heesoatuotb denaue fnsuooonoere l7ioTeae lsuesmittoorcle seayrnyhg c rfsar ec a1gher eop etSsuot u lasnwc.mgcptafoiu#uss cdte i simwolqo st;ru etayds sr horrt he r o gcyercrtati e anHcdetltot rtleolso ani slddi ssmnt&n lttsvr nurwr eisgt roi,h o8erdlt, .nee unes2a hdhrh ifeen t ecuelu Ifwpesd oo Cf hnbk o yiwaeledty

& is8l g1rlot; wic; a108 e r&eny2e2d o2ngeH;a a.t,se2i88& #8 is# #Ha&S#ar2t 220 ob l,a ia ;;w6#2 2 gh2e&ahrgd

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In